# Murder case discharge: High court shall not discharged the accused in a murder case without referred the charge-sheet in its entirety

- Link: https://section1.in/4076-2/
- Published: 2023-05-19T06:59:19+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [FACTS OF THE APPEAL](https://section1.in/4076-2/#facts-of-the-appeal)
 * [WHEN DISCHARGE MUST BE ALLOWED](https://section1.in/4076-2/#when-discharge-must-be-allowed)
 * [PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION TEST IS A MATERIAL PIECE OF EVIDENCE](https://section1.in/4076-2/#psychological-evaluation-test-is-a-material-piece-of-evidence)
 * [HIGH COURT HAS NOT REFERRED THE CHARGESHEET IN ITS ENTIRETY WHILE DISCHARGE THE ACCUSED](https://section1.in/4076-2/#high-court-has-not-referred-the-chargesheet-in-its-entirety-while-discharge-the-accused)

##### FACTS OF THE APPEAL

9. As it was a blind murder, the crime was investigated and chargesheet dated 09.12.2009
was filed against Hussain Mohammed Shattaf and Waheeda Hussain Shattaf (Respondent
nos. 1 and 2) and Zaanish Khan stating therein that while Respondent no.1 was staying
in Dubai for the purpose of his business, his wife respondent no.2 came in contact
with the deceased and developed friendship. They started meeting each other frequently.
The friendship turned into physical relationship. When the Respondent No.1 returned
from Dubai, he came to know about the same. To take revenge, he in connivance with
respondent no.2 and one Zaanish Khan conspired to kill the deceased through unknown
assailants.
 10. As the case was triable by Sessions, the matter was committed by
the Magistrate to the Sessions Court, Pune. Immediately thereafter Respondent Nos.
1 and 2 filed revision application for discharge. The same was dismissed by the 
Trial Court vide Order dated 21.02.2012. The High Court vide impugned order had 
set aside the order passed by the Trial Court and discharged Respondent Nos. 1 and
2. The aforesaid order is under challenge before this Court.

##### WHEN DISCHARGE MUST BE ALLOWED

11. The law on issue as to what is to be considered at the time of discharge of 
an accused is well settled. It is a case in which the Trial Court had not yet framed
the charges. Immediately after filing of chargesheet, application for discharge 
was filed. The settled proposition of law is that at the stage of hearing on the
charges entire evidence produced by the prosecution is to be believed. In case no
offence is made out then only an accused can be discharged. Truthfulness, sufficiency
and acceptability of the material produced can be done only at the stage of trial.
At the stage of charge, the Court has to satisfy that a prima facie case is made
out against the accused persons. Interference of the Court at that stage is required
only if there is strong reasons to hold that in case the trial is allowed to proceed,
the same would amount to abuse of process of the Court.

##### PSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATION TEST IS A MATERIAL PIECE OF EVIDENCE

19. Though Psychological Evaluation test report only may not be sufficient to convict
an accused but certainly a material piece of evidence. Despite this material on 
record, the High Court could not have opined that the case was not made out even
for framing of charge, for which only prima facie case is to be seen.

##### HIGH COURT HAS NOT REFERRED THE CHARGESHEET IN ITS ENTIRETY WHILE DISCHARGE THE ACCUSED

20. If the facts of the case are examined in the light of law laid down by this 
Court on the subject, it is evident that the High Court has not even referred to
the evidence collected by Investigating Agency produced along with chargesheet in
its entirety. Rather there is selective reference to the statements of some of the
persons recorded during investigation. It shows that there was total non-application
of mind. The High Court had exercised the jurisdiction in a manner which is not 
vested in it to scuttle the trial of a heinous crime.
 APPEAL ALLOWED.

PARTY: Captain Manjit Singh Virdi (Retd.) vs. Hussain Mohammed Shattaf & Ors – Criminal
Appeal No. 1399 of 2023 – May 18, 2023.

[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/43002/43002_2019_15_1502_44583_Judgement_18-May-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/43002/43002_2019_15_1502_44583_Judgement_18-May-2023.pdf)

[Captain Manjit Singh Virdi (Retd.)](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Captain-Manjit-Singh-Virdi-Retd.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
