# Section 138 NI Act: Accused completely rebutted in the cheque case

- Link: https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/
- Published: 2023-05-18T05:33:40+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Teo stands taken by the complainant defeats the complaint](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#teo-stands-taken-by-the-complainant-defeats-the-complaint)
 * [Defence of the accused](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#defence-of-the-accused)
 * [Rebuttal can take place in cross-examination itself](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#rebuttal-can-take-place-in-crossexamination-itself)
 * [Non-explanation of vital witness](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#nonexplanation-of-vital-witness)
 * [Non issue of reply notice to the statutory notice is not fatal](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#non-issue-of-reply-notice-to-the-statutory-notice-is-not-fatal)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/#further-study)

##### Teo stands taken by the complainant defeats the complaint

13. It is clear from the above that the petitioner had specifically come up with
two stands in the course of cross examination. The first stand is that the petitioner
had an independent transaction with Sri Sai Baba Waste Paper Company and it was 
admitted by PW.1 that in the said transaction, there was an amount due and payable
by the petitioner. This admission made by PW.1 becomes significant since from the
cheque which was marked as Ex.P.2, it is seen that the cheque has been issued by
the petitioner in his capacity as the Proprietor of Sahithya Enterprises.

##### Defence of the accused

14. The second stand that has been taken by the petitioner is that he had an independent
transaction with the said Mr.K.P.Ravindran and the cheque was given to the said 
Mr.K.P.Ravindran and that cheque has been misused in the present case.

##### Rebuttal can take place in cross-examination itself

15. It is true that the presumption u/s. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 
1881, is in favour of the complainant. The Larger Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court
in Rangappa .v. Sri Mohan reported in 2010 4 CTC 118 has held that the legally enforceable
debt or liability is also under presumption u/s.139 of the Negotiable Instruments,
Act, 1881 and the same has to be rebutted by the accused. Insofar as the rebuttal
is concerned, the standard that is adopted is the test of preponderance of probabilities.
In view of the same, the accused need not even enter into the witness box or examine
any witness on his side and such rebuttal can take place even during the course 
of cross examination of the complainant.

##### Non-explanation of vital witness

17. This Court had an occasion to deal with the effect of non-examination of vital
witness to establish the existence of legally enforceable debt and it was held that
such non-examination resulted in the burden which shifted to the complainant not
being discharged. Useful reference can be made to Mohan vs Viswanathan reported 
in 2018 (2) LW(Crl)424 .

##### Non issue of reply notice to the statutory notice is not fatal

18. There is yet another issue that has been put against the petitioner in this 
case and that is the fact that the petitioner did not give a reply notice to the
statutory notice that was issued by the complainant. The non issuance of a reply
notice need not result in an adverse interference taken against an accused person
in every case and it will depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case. 
This Court had an occasion to deal with this issue in P. Gnanambigai .v. S. Krishnasamy
and Ors. reported in 2011 1 LW (Crl)366 and it was held has follows:

> “11. Only in this legal matrix the facts of the present case is to be necessarily
> appreciated. It is true that the Petitioner raised the defence to the effect that
> the cheque in question is issued not in the circumstances as alleged in the complaint
> but under different circumstances only after the proceedings under Section 138
> is initiated such defence is for the first time raised by way of suggestion to
> PW1 in the course of his cross examination. The Petitioner has neither sent any
> reply to that effect to the statutory notice issued by the complainant nor he 
> entered into the witness box and deposed so. As far as his failure to reply the
> statutory notice, the same is sought to be highlighted on the side of the complainant
> by relying upon the judgment of our Supreme Court reported in 2010 (4) CTC 118
> and judgment of our High Court reported in 2006 (1) L.W. 433 in K.P. Chinnasamy
> V.T.B. Kennedy. It is true that in both the cases, the Supreme Court and our High
> Court have in the given circumstances attached serious importance to the failure
> on the part of the accused to reply to the statutory notice and drew adverse inference
> against the accused. However, whether despite of such failure in the instant case
> the accused is able to rebut the presumption invoked in this case or not is to
> be necessarily considered only in the light of the other materials already brought
> on record as pointed out by the accused in support of his defence”.

19. The non issuance of the reply notice in the present case does not completely
destroy the defence taken by the petitioner since the petitioner has rebutted the
legal presumption u/s. 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. Hence, the non
issuance of the reply notice cannot be considered to be fatal to the case of the
petitioner.

Accused [Acquitted](https://demonew.section1.in/category/acquittal/).

##### **Party**

**N.Gopalakrishnan S/o.Navaneethan M/s.Sahithya Enterprises No.1276-D, Periyakaruppan
Street Kamarajapuram Colony Near SCI Church Sivakasi 626 189. vs. S.Chandra Mohan(
died)Crl.R.C No: 663 of 2019 – 30.03.2023.**

**[https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis/index.php/casestatus/viewpdf/1031101](https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis/index.php/casestatus/viewpdf/1031101)**

**[n. Gopalakrishnan 138](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/n.-Gopalakrishnan-138.pdf)**

##### Further study

 * **[PMLA – ALL THE OFFENCES UNDER THE PMLA ARE COGNIZABLE AND NON-BAILABLE](http://localhost:8080/section1/all-the-offences-under-the-pmla-are-cognizable-and-non-bailable/)**
 * **[PROSECUTION HAS TO ESTABLISH THE EXISTENCE OF DEMAND AS WELL AS ACCEPTANCE BY THE PUBLIC SERVANT TO PROVE SECTIONS 7 & 13(1)(D) OF P.C ACT.](http://localhost:8080/section1/prosecution-has-to-establish-the-existence-of-demand-as-well-as-acceptance-by-the-public-servant-to-prove-sections-7-131d-of-p-c-act/)**
 * **[POCSO: Accused did not rebut the evidence against evidence of victim](http://localhost:8080/section1/pocso-accused-did-not-rebut-the-evidence-against-evidence-of-victim/)**
 * **[Section 139 N.I Act: Rebuttable presumption: Explained](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-139-n-i-act-rebuttable-presumption-explained/)**
 * **[SUGGESTIONS PUT TO THE WITNESSES ARE PART OF THE EVIDENCE. BASED ON THAT SUGGESTIONS COURT CAN CONVICT THE ACCUSED.](http://localhost:8080/section1/suggestions-put-to-the-witnesses-are-part-of-the-evidence-based-on-that-suggestions-court-can-convict-the-accused/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
