# Acquittal based on appreciation of evidence

- Link: https://section1.in/acquittal-based-on-appreciation-of-evidence/
- Published: 2023-07-23T11:55:11+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Section 313 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/acquittal-based-on-appreciation-of-evidence/#section-313-crpc)
 * [Material contradictions](https://section1.in/acquittal-based-on-appreciation-of-evidence/#material-contradictions)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/acquittal-based-on-appreciation-of-evidence/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/acquittal-based-on-appreciation-of-evidence/#further-study)

By means of this appeal, the accused appellant has assailed the correctness of the
judgment and order of the High Court dated 06.04.2015 passed by a Division Bench
of the High Court of Chhattisgarh dismissing the Criminal Appeal No.3 of 2010 titled
Statrughan vs. State of Chhattisgarh, whereby the conviction under section 302, 
Indian Penal Code and the sentence to undergo life imprisonment along with fine 
of Rs.5,000/- passed by the IInd Additional Sessions Judge, Baloda Bazar, Dist.Raipur
in Sessions Trial No.41 of 2009 has been affirmed. The appellant is in jail and 
has already undergone almost 15 years incarceration.

##### Section 313 Cr.P.C

30. In the examination under section 313 Code of Criminal Procedure3, the entire
evidence against the appellant was put to him which he has denied. He however, stated
that he was doing his duty as Chowkidar in the Forest Department and on account 
of personal enmity he had been falsely implicated. He also states that he wants 
to examine Forest Range Officer Mr. Sinha and one Mr. Rajendra Thakur. However, 
no evidence was led on behalf of the defence.

31. The first question to be considered is as to whether any of the eye-witnesses
had actually seen the occurrence of the appellant assaulting the deceased. The answer
is ‘no’.

32. Following are the reasons for the above conclusion:

a) According to the informant (PW-1), he was the first person to arrive at the site
along with his wife upon hearing the cry for help from the deceased that Shatrughan
was assaulting him with a tabbal. When he reached the site he saw that the deceased
was lying on the road and the appellant was moving towards his house on a cycle 
along with tabbal. This is the FIR version.

b) In his deposition PW 1 states that when he rushed to the place of occurrence,
he saw the accused running away and the tabbal was lying there. The deceased had
fallen unconscious and there was deep cut on his neck with blood flowing from the
injury. Upon his call, the other neighbours and his daughter all came out from their
houses.

c) PW-14 who has stated that PW-1 only informed him that Jagat (deceased) had been
assaulted and had been taken to the hospital. PW-1 did not inform PW-14 that it 
was the appellant who had assaulted. PW-14 states that it was later on that Lakhan
and Laxman who informed about the appellant assaulting the deceased. The other eye-
witnesses whose testimonies have already been narrated above have not stated that
they saw the appellant assaulting the deceased.

d) PW-2 is the wife of PW-1, PW-3 is the widow of the deceased, PW-4 is daughter
of PW-1, are the other witnesses who reached the place of occurrence. None of them
have stated that they have seen the appellant assaulting the deceased.

e) Thus, the only evidence is of PW-1 stating that the appellant was running away
from the place of occurrence when he reached there. He has himself stated that the
deceased was already unconscious as such was not in a condition to speak.

f) There is one more aspect to be considered as to whether the cry given by the 
deceased could have been made as stated. Normally in villages nobody takes the name
of elders and especially their uncles. PW 1 Vijay Kumar is the uncle (father’s brother)
of the deceased. Under normal course the deceased would have called kaka only and
would not take his name to say that ‘kaka Vijay Singh run, Shatrughan is assaulting
me with a tabbal’.

g) In the First Information Report it is stated that when PW 1 came out he saw Shatrughan
running towards his house on a cycle along with tabbal but in the deposition before
the Trial Court it is stated that when he reached the place of occurrence the appellant
was running and the tabbal was lying there and then he states that the deceased 
had only shouted that the appellant is assaulting him.

h) Another aspect to be considered is whether after receiving the said injury the
deceased could have shouted and if he had shouted before being assaulted then the
situation would have been different. It would have been a one to one and he could
have resisted the assault. The fact is there is only one injury on the neck.

##### Material contradictions

33. In view of the above, the prosecution story as set out does not appear to be
a probable story and the supporting evidence led during trial of the witnesses of
fact also does not inspire confidence. Rather there are material contradictions.

35. From the above narration of the evidence and analysis, it is evident that the
testimony of PW 1 was not reliable and could not have formed the basis of conviction.
Apparently, he was influenced by Sarpanch Khemraj whose active participation in 
the proceedings subsequent to the incident cannot be ruled out. The medical evidence
did not support the prosecution case as the weapon of assault could not have caused
injury on the deceased as noticed in the post-mortem report. There was no motive
as to why the appellant would commit the murder of an acquaintance and a friend 
for no reason. The defence version that the deceased was under the influence of 
alcohol and could have tripped and fallen on a sharp object resulting into the ante-
mortem injury reported in the post-mortem was quite possible. The same is clearly
borne out from the record. The explanation for delayed lodging of the FIR is not
satisfactory.

36. In view of the above discussion, the prosecution had failed to establish the
charge.

37. For all the reasons explained above, the appellant would be entitled to acquittal.
The appeal is accordingly allowed. The conviction and sentence of the appellant 
are set aside. He is acquitted of all 35 the charges. The appellant is in custody.
He shall be released forthwith, if not wanted in any other case. 38. Pending applications
are disposed of.\

Appeal [**Acquitted**](https://demonew.section1.in/category/acquittal/).

##### Party

SHATRUGHAN vs. THE STATE OF CHHATTISGARH – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.437 OF 2016 – JULY
20, 2023.

[**https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2015/15420/15420_2015_12_1501_45213_Judgement_20-Jul-2023.pdf**](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2015/15420/15420_2015_12_1501_45213_Judgement_20-Jul-2023.pdf)

[**Shatrughan vs. The State of Chhattisgarh**](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Shatrughan-vs.-The-State-of-Chhattisgarh.pdf)

##### Further study

 * **[Section 482 CrPC: Only High Court has the power to direct to run sentences in two different cases concurrently](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-482-crpc-only-high-court-has-the-power-to-direct-to-run-sentences-in-two-different-cases-concurrently/)**
 * **[S.307 IPC not attracted: Reduced sentence](http://localhost:8080/section1/s-307-ipc-not-attracted-reduced-sentence/)**
 * **[Juvenile Justice act: Issue of Juvenility can be claimed even before the Hon’ble Supreme court](http://localhost:8080/section1/juvenile-justice-act-issue-of-juvenility-can-be-claimed-even-before-the-honble-supreme-court/)**
 * **[Section 6 of POCSO Act leaves no discretion to the court to impose minimum sentence](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-6-of-pocso-act-leavs-no-discretion-to-the-court-to-impose-minimum-sentence/)**
 * **[Murder case: Based on injuries in the evidence it is doubtful that deceased would have met the witnesses](http://localhost:8080/section1/murder-case-based-on-injuries-in-the-evidence-it-is-doubtful-that-deceased-would-have-met-the-witnesses/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
