# Acquittal: Motive and circumstantial evidence explained

- Link: https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/
- Published: 2023-11-09T14:52:13+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [No eye-witness](https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/#no-eyewitness)
 * [Appreciation on circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/#appreciation-on-circumstantial-evidence)
 * [Motive plays important role in circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/#motive-plays-important-role-in-circumstantial-evidence)
 * [When motive not necessary?](https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/#when-motive-not-necessary)
 * [Motive not established by the prosecution in the present case](https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/#motive-not-established-by-the-prosecution-in-the-present-case)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/acquittal-motive-and-circumstantial-evidence-explained/#party)

1. The captioned appeals, by lifers, are directed against the self-same judgment
and order dated 12.08.2009 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench
at Nagpur in Criminal Appeal No.7 of 2004. The former appeal was filed by the second
and third appellants therein who were accused Nos.2 and 3 in Sessions Trial No.80
of 2002 on the file of Additional Sessions Judge, Bhandara. The sole appellant in
the latter appeal was the first appellant in Criminal Appeal No.7 of 2004 and he
was the first accused in Sessions Trial No.80 of 2002. During the pendency of the
trial, the fourth accused breathed his last and the first appellant in the former
appeal viz., Sri Hiralal died during its pendency. Hence, qua him the former appeal
stands abated. As per the judgment of the Trial Court the appellants were convicted
under Sections 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter,
2 ‘the IPC’) for having committed murder of one Rahul Pundlik Meshram (hereafter
referred to as ‘the deceased’). They were sentenced to suffer imprisonment for life
besides imposing a fine of Rs.500/- and in default of payment of fine they are to
suffer rigorous imprisonment for one month each. As per the impugned judgment the
conviction and sentences thus imposed by the Trial Court were confirmed. Hence, 
these appeals.

XXX

##### **No eye-witness**

3. Admittedly, there was no eye-witness in this case. Based on the circumstantial
evidence, the Trial Court found the appellants guilty and convicted and sentenced
them, as mentioned above. Aggrieved by the conviction and consequent sentence, the
surviving accused viz., accused Nos. 1 to 3 in the said Sessions Trial preferred
appeal before the High Court. After considering the 4 circumstances relied on by
the Trial Court and despite its reservation against some of the procedures followed
the High Court confirmed the conviction and sentence imposed on appellants by the
Trial Court holding that certain proven circumstances are material circumstances
and would complete the requisite chain.

##### **Appreciation on circumstantial evidence**

4. The appellants in the captioned appeals challenge the findings of conviction 
and consequential imposition of sentence raising various grounds. But, before considering
the contentions against the concurrent findings raised by the appellants, we find
it only appropriate to refer to the following decisions on the law relating circumstantial
evidence.

Sarbir Singh v. State of Punjab – 1993 SCC (Cri) 860 – paras. 5,6, & 7.
 Brijlal
Prasad Sinha v. State of Bihar – (1998) SCC (Cri) 1382. Prakash v. State of Rajasthan–(
2013) 4 SCC 668. Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra – (1984) 4 SCC 116 – 
para.153 – Five principles.

xxx

9. After noting the above five golden principles, it was held in Prakash’s case (
supra), that they would constitute the Panchsheel of the proof of a case based on
circumstantial evidence and conviction could be sustained on the basis of last seen,
motive and recovery of incriminating articles in pursuance of the information given
by the accused if those five golden principles of the proof of a case based on circumstantial
evidence are satisfied.

10. Virtually, the law laid down relating circumstantial evidence in those decisions
are unfailingly followed by this Court while dealing with the cases where conviction
is rested on circumstantial evidence.

xxx

##### **Motive plays important role in circumstantial evidence**

18. There can be no doubt with respect to the fact that in a case where the conviction
is based on circumstantial evidence, motive assumes great significance. A Three 
Judge Bench of this Court in Nandu Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (now Chhattisgarh)[
2022 SCC OnLine SC 1454] by its judgment dated 25.02.2022, after observing thus,
held as under:-

> “It is not as if motive alone becomes the crucial link in the case to be established
> by the prosecution and in its absence the case of prosecution must be discarded.
> But, at the same time, complete absence of motive assumes a different complexion
> and such absence definitely weighs in favour of the accused.”

We may add here that just like complete absence of motive failure to establish motive
after attributing one, should also give a different complexion in a case based on
circumstantial evidence and it will certainly enfeeble the case of prosecution.

##### **When motive not necessary?**

20. In the decision in Shivaji Chintappa Patil v. State of Maharashtra [(2021) 5
SCC 626], after referring to the decision in Anwar Ali’s case (supra), this Court
observed thus: –

> “27. Though in a case of direct evidence, motive would not be relevant, in a case
> of circumstantial evidence, motive plays an important link to complete the chain
> of circumstances.”

##### **Motive not established by the prosecution in the present case**

21. In the case on hand, the prosecution alleged a motive. According to the prosecution
on 29.09.2001, the deceased along with his friend Parag Sukhdeve assaulted the brother
of appellant in the latter appeal (the first accused in the Sessions Trial). It 
is also the case of the prosecution that after the accused persons entered the house
of PW-8, Chintaman Giddu Gatey the first accused/the appellant in the latter appeal
hurled abuses on the deceased and asked him why he along with his friend Parag Sukhdeve
assaulted his brother. It is also the case of the prosecution that though the deceased
denied any such occurrence, the said appellant continued to say that the deceased
had done dishonesty and assaulted his brother. After alleging motive as above, prosecution
had failed to establish the same. In this context, it is to be noted that the Trial
Court made a positive finding that the prosecution had miserably failed to establish
the alleged motive. Despite the said finding of the Trial Court and despite that
issue was pointedly raised before the High Court, obviously the High Court in the
impugned judgment did not consider the said aspect at all. This failure on the part
of the High Court is a ground specifically taken in this appeal. In the light of
the decision in Anwar Ali’s case (supra) and Shivaji Chintappa Patil’s case (supra),
and also based on what we held in respect of the impact of failure to establish 
the alleged motive in a case based on circumstantial evidence it can only be held
that the said failure had weakened the case of the prosecution. This aspect should
have been given proper weight by the courts below.

29. Thus, in a nutshell the correctness of the last seen version emanating from 
PW-8-Chintaman becomes doubtful, especially against the appellants herein. As noticed
earlier, virtually, the oral testimonies of PW-8 and PW-10 are at variance about
the last seen and it becomes inconclusive for the reasons mentioned hereinbefore.
We have also found that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the alleged
motive. In such circumstance, though the deceased had met with a homicidal death
it cannot be said that the rest of the circumstantial evidence culled out by the
courts below unerringly point to the culpability of the appellants in the homicidal
death of Rahul Pundlik Meshram. Even the recovery of the weapon and the dress, at
the instance of the appellant in the latter appeal cannot, by itself, be conclusive
as admittedly, the panch witnesses for their recovery also did not support the prosecution.
In our considered view, the remaining circumstances relied on by the prosecution
and held as proved by the courts below would not unerringly point to the guilt of
the appellants.

30. Thus, in our view, it is unsafe on the aforesaid circumstances to maintain the
conviction of the appellants; we thus, extend to them the benefit of doubt. Accordingly,
we order for the acquittal of the appellants. The appeals are thus allowed, upsetting
the judgments and orders of the High Court as also that of the court of Session.
The bail bonds executed by the appellants stand discharged.

Accused [**Acquitted**](http://localhost:8080/section1/category/acquittal/).

##### **Party**

**Shankar vs The State of Maharashtra – March 15, 2023 – Criminal Appeal No. 954
of 2011.**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2009/36969/36969_2009_12_1501_42798_Judgement_15-Mar-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2009/36969/36969_2009_12_1501_42798_Judgement_15-Mar-2023.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
