# Acquittal: Section 304-B IPC: Appreciation of cross-examination necessary

- Link: https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/
- Published: 2023-02-28T11:55:01+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appreciation of acquittal judgment by high court](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/#appreciation-of-acquittal-judgment-by-high-court)
 * [How to appreciate both chief & cross (includes re-examination)](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/#how-to-appreciate-both-chief-amp-cross-includes-reexamination)
 * [Cross-examination: Nothing comes out in cross](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/#crossexamination-nothing-comes-out-in-cross)
 * [Charge framed](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/#charge-framed)
 * [Section 304-B IPC:  Sexual harassment: Mental cruelty: Ireelevant to s. 304-B IPC](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/#section-304b-ipc%c2%a0-sexual-harassment-mental-cruelty-ireelevant-to-s-304b-ipc)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-304-b-ipc-appreciation-of-cross-examination-explained/#party)

##### **Appreciation of acquittal judgment by high court**

27. We have referred to the entire evidence. The Trial Court acquitted the accused.
The jurisdiction of the Appellate Court, when it deals with such an order, is no
longer res integra and is subject matter of catena of decisions of this Court.

28. In Upendra Pradhan v. State of Orissa [(2015) 11 SCC 124], this Court took the
view that if there is benefit of doubt, it must go to the accused, and in case of
two views, the view that favours the accused, should be taken, which was more so
where the Trial Court’s decision was not manifestly illegal, perverse and did not
cause miscarriage of justice.

29. In Dilawar Singh and others v. State of Haryana [(2015) 1 SCC 737], this Court
took the view that court will not interfere with the verdict of acquittal merely
because on evaluation of evidence, a different plausible view may arise. Very substantial
and compelling reasons must exist with the Appellate Court to interfere with an 
acquittal.

[Also see: Gamini Bala Koteswara Rao and others v. State of Andhra Pradesh Through
Secretary (AIR 2010 SC 589)]

##### **How to appreciate both chief & cross (includes re-examination)**

##### **Cross-examination: Nothing comes out in cross**

49. In this case, we notice that the High Court has referred to the contents of 
the chief examination of the witnesses. Thereafter, it has been stated that the 
witnesses have been cross-examined at length but nothing has come out in evidence
which would create any doubt in his evidence. The witnesses are declared as being
found reliable and believable. We have noted the facts in this case.

50. Truth in a criminal trial is discovered by not merely going through the cross-
examination of the witnesses. There must be an analysis of the chief examination
of the witnesses in conjunction with the cross examination and the re-examination,
if any. The effect of what other witnesses have deposed must also enter into consideration
of the matter. On the one hand, the laudable object underlying Section 304B of the
IPC is not to be lost sight of. On the other hand, it is equally important that 
the Appellate Court must not be oblivious to the fact what it is duty bound to find
is whether an offence is committed or not and such a pursuit also would embrace 
the duty of the court to apply its mind to the evidence as a whole and arrive at
conclusions as to facts and inferences therefrom as well. After all, at stake for
the accused are, priceless rights to liberty, reputation and the right to life, 
not only of himself but also his family members. The Law Giver, has contemplated
that the High Court will be the final arbiter of facts and even of law. The jurisdiction
of the Apex Court was deliberately limited to the extra ordinary powers it enjoys
under Article 136 of the Constitution of India unless it be exercised under other
provisions. What we wish to emphasise is that the cause of justice and the interest
of litigants would be better subserved if the Appellate Court takes a closer look,
in particular of the cross-examination of the witnesses and analyse the same.

##### **Charge framed**

51. There is yet another important aspect in this matter. It is true that the deceased
died on 05.06.1991 which was within seven years of marriage. It is equally true 
that her death was due to burning and she committed suicide. It is not a case where
the accused stood charged under any provision except Section 304B read with Section
34 of the IPC and Section 306 read with Section 34 of the IPC. The case of abetting
suicide under Section 306 read with Section 34 of the IPC has been found unacceptable
both by the Trial court and the High Court and the appellants stand acquitted.

##### **Section 304-B IPC:  Sexual harassment: Mental cruelty: Ireelevant to s. 304-B IPC**

52. A perusal of the impugned judgment of the High Court would show, that accepting
the version of the prosecution witnesses, the High Court has been persuaded to hold
inter alia that the second accused also harassed her by asking her to provide liquor
in the glass, and after taking liquor, in the state of intoxication, he used to 
ask her to sleep with him. On her refusal, it was found that she was subjected to
mental cruelty. Reference was made to evidence of PW4-father of the deceased that
after he came back from Mumbai, he came to know that the second accused was taking
liquor and trying to commit rape and also used to harass her for television and 
VCR due to which she committed suicide.

53. The High Court was in clear error in taking into consideration the evidence 
relating to harassment by the second accused on the basis that he, in the state 
of intoxication, asked her to sleep with him, and on that basis, she was subjected
to mental cruelty. The said evidence is totally irrelevant and foreign to the scope
of a trial for the offence under Section 304B of the IPC. It does not relate, at
all, to the demand for dowry.

##### **Party**

**GIRISH SINGH vs. THE STATE OF UTTARAKHAND – (Criminal Appeal No. 1475 of 2009)–
JULY 23, 2019**

[**girish-singh-vs.-the-state-of-uttarakhand-2019**](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/girish-singh-vs.-the-state-of-uttarakhand-2019.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
