# Acquittal: Section 306/114 IPC: Unless the accused admitted the handwriting report the expert should be examined to prove the handwriting opinion report

- Link: https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/
- Published: 2025-03-19T14:38:37+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against judgment of Hon’ble High Court](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#appeal-against-judgment-of-honble-high-court)
    - [Conviction of appellants by ADJ under sections 306 and 114 IPC](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#conviction-of-appellants-by-adj-under-sections-306-and-114-ipc)
    - [Hon’ble High Court affirmed the conviction](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#honble-high-court-affirmed-the-conviction)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#facts)
    - [FIR, Investigation and Trial](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#fir-investigation-and-trial)
    - [Trial court convicted under sections 306/114 IPC but acquitted under section 3(2)(5) PC Act](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#trial-court-convicted-under-sections-306114-ipc-but-acquitted-under-section-325-pc-act)
    - [Hon’ble High Court upheld the conviction and sentence](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#honble-high-court-upheld-the-conviction-and-sentence)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#analysis)
    - [Section306 IPC: Once suicide is carried out the offence is complete obviously such a person would be beyond the reach of law](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#section306-ipc-once-suicide-is-carried-out-the-offence-is-complete-obviously-such-a-person-would-be-beyond-the-reach-of-law)
    - [Section 107 IPC: Abetment: Explained](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#section-107-ipc-abetment-explained)
    - [Judgment analysis](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#judgment-analysis)
    - [Inconsistencies in evidence](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#inconsistencies-in-evidence)
    - [Suicide note’s credibility](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#suicide-notes-credibility)
    - [Post-mortem report](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#postmortem-report)
    - [The suicide occurred due to blackmail related to the deceased’s affair](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#the-suicide-occurred-due-to-blackmail-related-to-the-deceased8217s-affair)
    - [Handwriting expert was not examined](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#handwriting-expert-was-not-examined)
    - [Opinion of handwriting expert rarely takes place of substantive evidence](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#opinion-of-handwriting-expert-rarely-takes-place-of-substantive-evidence)
    - [Unless the accused admitted the handwriting report the expert should be examined to prove the handwriting opinion report](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report)
    - [No act is attributed to the appellants proximate to the time of suicide](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#no-act-is-attributed-to-the-appellants-proximate-to-the-time-of-suicide)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#conclusion)
    - [Cited Judgments](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#cited-judgments)
    - [Acts and Sections Involved](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#acts-and-sections-involved)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against judgment of Hon’ble High Court**

This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 17.12.2013
passed by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad (briefly ‘the High Court’ hereinafter)
in Criminal Appeal No. 626 of 2011.

##### **Conviction of appellants by ADJ under sections 306 and 114 IPC**

2. It may be mentioned that the four appellants are accused Nos. 1 to 4. They were
convicted by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Mehsana vide the judgment and
order dated 12.05.2011 in Special Atrocity Case No. 53/2009 under Sections 306 and
114 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (‘IPC’ for short) and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment(
RI) for 5 years and to pay a fine of Rs.10,000.00 each with a default stipulation.

##### **Hon’ble High Court affirmed the conviction**

3. Aggrieved by the aforesaid conviction and sentence, appellants preferred Criminal
Appeal No. 626 of 2011 before the High Court. State of Gujarat also filed Criminal
Appeal No. 796 of 2011 for enhancement of sentence. By the common judgment and order
dated 17.12.2013, the High Court dismissed the appeal of the appellants and affirmed
the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellants by the learned Additional 
Sessions Judge, Mehsana (‘trial court’ for short). The appeal filed by the State
was also dismissed.

#### **Facts**

6. Prosecution case in brief is that one Jaybalaben lodged first information before
the Mehsana Taluka police station on 14.05.2009 stating that at 08:00 AM on 25.04.2009,
she and her daughter Priyanka had gone to the Amipura water park dispensary as she
was working there. At around 01:00 PM, one Jayantibhai Kalidas, a neighbour, came
to her dispensary and told her that her mother-in-law was ill. On hearing this, 
she and her daughter came back home immediately in a rickshaw. When she reached 
her house, she saw many people had gathered there. She went inside the house and
saw her husband Dashrathbhai Karsanbhai lying on a cot with his younger and elder
brothers standing nearby. Though she tried to revive him, he did not respond; he
had already died. As she started weeping, the ladies who were present there told
her that her husband had consumed poison. Foul smell of poison was coming from his
mouth. First informant stated that her husband was taken to the village dispensary
where he was declared dead. Thereafter police came. After completion of necessary
paper works, body of her husband was taken to Mehsana Civil Hospital for postmortem
examination on completion of which the body was handed over to the family.

6.1. Jaybalaben continued with her narration. She stated that about a year ago, 
a case of misappropriation was registered against her husband Dashrathbhai Karsanbhai
in his office. She and her elder brother-in-law Jayantibhai had asked her husband
as to why he needed so much of money to which the reply of her husband was that 
one cleaning worker in his office by the name Geetaben had trapped him in a love
scandal and thereafter started blackmailing him for money. It was for this reason
that he had to withdraw money from the office to give her.

6.2. When her elder brother-in-law Jayantibhai called Geetaben, her mother Jasiben,
her husband Dahyabhai and relative Babubhai Patel to return the money, they initially
agreed to do so but did not return. They also took away ornaments (jewellery).

6.3. Jaybalaben also stated that at the time of death of her husband, they found
one note of two pages from the pocket of her husband’s trouser which was shown to
her by Jayantibhai, her elder brother-in-law. She stated that from that note, it
was apparent that Geetaben and her family members were blackmailing her husband 
after taking various photographs and videos of him with her in compromising position.
She stated that her husband had also stolen ornaments (jewellery) of her daughter
and gave those to Geetaben and her family members. It was for this reason that her
husband Dashrathbhai Karsanbhai had consumed poison.

##### **FIR, Investigation and Trial**

7. The aforesaid complaint was registered as I.C.R. No. 107/2009 by the Mehsana 
Taluka police station under Sections 306/114 of IPC read with Section 3(2)(5) of
The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989(‘
the Prevention of Atrocities Act’ hereinafter). The investigating officer on conclusion
of investigation filed chargesheet against the appellants before the Court of Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Mehsana. As the case was triable by the Court of Sessions, 
it was committed to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Mehsana (trial court)
where the case was numbered as Special Atrocities Case No. 53/2009. Prosecution 
examined as many as 14 witnesses and exhibited a number of documents to prove its
case. On completion of prosecution evidence, statements of the appellants were recorded
under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.). Appellants 
denied the prosecution case and alleged false implication.

##### **Trial court convicted under sections 306/114 IPC but acquitted under section 3(2)(5) PC Act**

8. On consideration of the oral as well as documentary evidence and after hearing
the parties, trial court vide the judgment and order dated 12.05.2011 convicted 
the appellants under Sections 306/114 of IPC but acquitted them of the charge under
Section 3(2)(5) of the Prevention of Atrocities Act. Upon such conviction, the trial
court sentenced the appellants to undergo RI for 5 years and to pay fine of Rs. 
10,000.00 each with a default stipulation for the offence punishable under Sections
306/114 IPC.

9. Appellants assailed the aforesaid conviction and sentence of the trial court 
before the High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 626 of 2011. As pointed out above, 
State also filed Criminal Appeal No. 796/2011 for enhancement of sentence.

##### **Hon’ble High Court upheld the conviction and sentence**

10. High Court vide the judgment and order dated 17.12.2013 upheld the conviction
and sentence of the appellants and dismissed their appeal. High Court also did not
find any good ground to enhance the sentence. Consequently, the criminal appeal 
filed by the State was dismissed.

#### **Analysis**

13. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration
of the Court.

14. Before we proceed to advert to the evidence of the material prosecution witnesses
and to analyse the same, it would be apposite to refer to the legal provisions and
the judicial precedents relevant for adjudication of the present criminal appeal.

##### **Section306 IPC: Once suicide is carried out the offence is complete obviously such a person would be beyond the reach of law**

15. Attempt to commit suicide is an offence in India. Section 309 IPC says that 
whoever attempts to commit suicide and does any act towards such act, shall be punished
with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year or with fine or
with both. However, once suicide is carried out, the offence is complete. Considering
the nature of the offence, obviously such a person would be beyond the reach of 
the law. Therefore, question of penalising him would not arise but whoever abets
the commission of such suicide would be penalised under Section 306 IPC. Punishment
prescribed under Section 306 IPC is imprisonment of either description for a term
which may extend to 10 years and shall also be liable to fine. What Section 306 
IPC says is that if any person commits suicide, then whoever abets the commission
of such suicide shall be punished as above.

##### **Section 107 IPC: Abetment: Explained**

16. Therefore, the crucial word in Section 306 IPC is ‘abets’. ‘Abetment’ is defined
in Section 107 of IPC. As per Section 107 IPC, a person would be abetting the doing
of a thing if he instigates any person to do that thing or if he encourages with
one or more person or persons in any conspiracy for doing that thing or if he intentionally
aids by any act or illegal omission doing of that thing. There are two explanations
to Section 107. As per Explanation 1, even if a person by way of wilful misrepresentation
or concealment of a material fact which he is otherwise bound to disclose voluntarily
causes or procures or attempts to cause or procure a thing to be done, is said to
instigate the doing of that thing. Explanation 2 clarifies that whoever does anything
in order to facilitate the commission of an act, either prior to or at the time 
of commission of the act, is said to aid the doing of that act.

17. Section 114 IPC is an explanation or clarification of Section 107 IPC. What 
Section 114 IPC says is that whenever any person is absent but was present when 
the act or offence for which he would be punishable in consequence of the abetment
is committed, he shall be deemed to have committed such an act or offence and would
be liable to be punished as an abettor.

##### **Judgment analysis**

18. In Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh, this Court held that to ‘instigate’
means to goad, urge, provoke, incite or encourage to do ‘an act’. To satisfy the
requirement of ‘instigation’, it is not necessary that actual words must be used
to that effect or that the words or act should necessarily and specifically be suggestive
of the consequence. Where the accused by his act or omission or by his continued
course of conduct creates a situation that the deceased is left with no other option
except to commit suicide, then ‘instigation’ may be inferred. A word uttered in 
a fit of anger or emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow 
cannot be said to be ‘instigation’.

19. Elaborating further, this Court in Chitresh Kumar Chopra versus State (Govt.
of NCT of Delhi)2 observed that to constitute ‘instigation’, a person who instigates
another has to provoke, incite, urge or encourage the doing of an act by the other
by ‘goading’ or ‘urging forward’. This Court summed up the constituents of ‘abetment’
as under:

> (i) the accused kept on irritating or annoying the deceased by words, deeds or
> wilful omission or conduct which may even be a wilful silence until the deceased
> reacted or pushed or forced the deceased by his deeds, words or wilful omission
> or conduct to make the deceased move forward more quickly in a forward direction;
> and
> (ii) that the accused had the intention to provoke, urge or encourage the deceased
> to commit suicide while acting in the manner noted above. Undoubtedly, presence
> of mens rea is the necessary concomitant of instigation.

20. Amalendu Pal alias Jhantu versus State of West Bengal is a case where this Court
held that in a case of alleged abetment of suicide, there must be proof of direct
or indirect act(s) of incitement to the commission of suicide. Merely on the allegation
of harassment without there being any positive action proximate to the time of occurrence
on the part of the accused which led or compelled the deceased to commit suicide,
conviction in terms of Section 306 IPC would not be sustainable. Similar view has
been expressed by this Court in case of Ude Singh versus State of Haryana.

21. After considering the provisions of Sections 306 and 107 of IPC, this Court 
in Rajesh versus State of Haryana5 held that conviction under Section 306 IPC is
not sustainable on the allegation of harassment without there being any positive
action proximate to the time of occurrence on the part of the accused which led 
or compelled the person to commit suicide.

22. Abetment to commit suicide involves a mental process of instigating a person
or intentionally aiding a person in the doing of a thing. Without a positive proximate
act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction
cannot be sustained. Besides, in order to convict a person under Section 306 IPC,
there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence.

23. This Court in Amudha versus State held that there has to be an act of incitement
on the part of the accused proximate to the date on which the deceased committed
suicide. The act attributed should not only be proximate to the time of suicide 
but should also be of such a nature that the deceased was left with no alternative
but to take the drastic step of committing suicide.

24. Again, in the case of Kamaruddin Dastagir Sanadi versus State of Karnataka, 
this Court observed that discord and differences in domestic life are quite common
in society. Commission of suicide largely depends upon the mental state of the victim.
Until and unless some guilty intention on the part of the accused is established,
it is ordinarily not possible to convict the accused for an offence under Section
306 IPC.

25. Prakash versus State of Maharashtra8 is a case where this Court after analysing
various decisions on the point summed up the legal position in the following manner:

14. Section 306 read with Section 107 of IPC, has been interpreted, time and again,
and its principles are well established. To attract the offence of abetment to suicide,
it is important to establish proof of direct or indirect acts of instigation or 
incitement of suicide by the accused, which must be in close proximity to the commission
of suicide by the deceased. Such instigation or incitement should reveal a clear
mens rea to abet the commission of suicide and should put the victim in such a position
that he/she would have no other option but to commit suicide.

25.1. In the aforesaid judgment, this Court referred to its earlier decision in 
Sanju @ Sanjay Singh Sengar versus State of M.P. and held that in a given case, 
even a time gap of 48 hours between using of abusive language by the accused and
the commission of suicide would not amount to a proximate act.

26. Having surveyed the relevant legal provisions and the case laws on the subject,
let us now deal with the material prosecution witnesses.

27. PW-2 is Jayabalaben Dashrathbhai Parmar, the informant. In her evidence in chief,
she stated that the incident had occurred on the 25th of the fourth month (April).
She deposed that she worked as a clean worker in the water park, having studied 
up to 10th standard. Her husband Dashrathbhai Karsanbhai Parmar was serving in the
postal department. Her husband’s last posting was at Linch. They had 5 children,
3 girls and 2 boys. She stated that she came to know later that there was a misappropriation
case against her husband in his office.

28. Amrutbhai Karshanbhai Parmar is PW-6. Deceased was his brother. On that fateful
day, while he was having lunch at home, his niece came to him and told him that 
something had happened to her father. Then he went to the house of his brother Dashrathbhai
and found him lying motionless. He believed that he had consumed poison. When he
took his brother to the hospital, he was declared dead. At that time, his other 
brother Jayantibhai (PW-7) was also there. On searching the body of his brother,
PW-6 stated that they found one note from his pocket. In that note, the deceased
had mentioned 3-4 names further stating that they were blackmailing him; so he had
committed suicide. It was in the own handwriting of Dashrathbhai. However, he stated
that he did not know the persons whose name were mentioned in the note.

29. PW-7 is the elder brother of the deceased, Jayantibhai Karshanbhai Parmar. Narrating
about the incident, he stated that while he was at home during noon, his brother
Amrutbhai came and told him that Dashrathbhai was lying unconscious. They rushed
to Dashrathbhai’s house and found him in an unconscious condition. They dialled 
108 and also informed the police. They took Dashrathbhai to the hospital where he
was declared dead. PW-7 stated that though he searched the body of his brother Dashrathbhai,
he did not find anything. Contradicting the above statement, he stated that though
one note was found, who found that note and what was written in it, he did not know.
He stated that he did not know for what reason, his brother died.

##### **Inconsistencies in evidence**

33. There are significant inconsistencies in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses
regarding the occurrence. PW-2 stated in her substantive evidence that on being 
informed about her mother-in-law’s illness, she had come home from her office. On
reaching home, she saw a huge crowd in front of her residence. As she entered her
house, she saw the dead body of her husband. However, in her cross-examination, 
she stated that when she reached home on that fateful afternoon, the relatives had
already taken her husband to the hospital. Such inconsistent testimony cast serious
doubts about the veracity of the evidence of the said prosecution witness.

##### **Suicide note’s credibility**

34. In so far the suicide note is concerned, PW-2 stated that PW-7 had told her 
on the next day about the same. It was only then that she came to know that her 
husband had written a suicide note. In fact, when the panchnama was drawn on 25.04.2009,
no note was found on the body of the deceased. She stated that from the time of 
death till the lodging of complaint, the suicide note was with PW-7. This again 
cast serious aspersions about the credibility of the suicide note.

35. There is another significant inconsistency. PW-6 stated that while he was at
home having lunch, his niece came and told him that something had happened to her
father (Dashrathbhai Karsanbhai Parmar). So he went to the residence of his brother
and found him lying motionless. At that time, PW-7 was also present. On the other
hand, PW-7 stated that while he was at home, his brother PW-6 came and told him 
that brother Dashrathbhai was lying unconscious. It was thereafter that he rushed
to Dashrathbhai’s house. Such inconsistencies clearly impeach the credibility of
the above two prosecution witnesses.

36. That apart, there is nothing on record to show recovery of any jewellery (ornaments)
by the police from the accused persons. No signed cheques of the deceased or cheque
book or passbook of the deceased were recovered and exhibited in court. In such 
circumstances, the very sub-stratum of the prosecution case that the accused persons
were making illegal gain by blackmailing the deceased falls flat.

##### **Post-mortem report**

37. Before we move on to the alleged suicide note, it would be appropriate to advert
to the postmortem report. As per the said report, cause of death was due to consumption
of Dichlorvos Organophosphorus Non-thio poison. The doctor who carried out the postmortem
examination, Dr. Prakash Laxmandas, deposed as PW-1. He stated that in the course
of postmortem examination, 400 cc of coffee coloured foul smelling liquid was found
in the small intestine and as per postmortem note, the same was Dichlorvos Organophosphorus
Non-thio poison. He stated that if anybody drinks such poisonous substance then 
this type of death can happen.

##### **The suicide occurred due to blackmail related to the deceased’s affair**

40. This takes us to the suicide note (Ex. 33). We have already noted the delayed
and controversial circumstances under which the suicide note surfaced which makes
it highly suspect. Nonetheless, since it was exhibited, let us deal with the same.
Sum and substance of the suicide note allegedly written by Dashrathbhai Karsanbhai
Parmar (the deceased) with the date given as 24.04.2009 is that appellant No. 3 
had joined his office following the illness of the existing cleaner. She used to
come to the office daily for cleaning purposes. Slowly they developed intimacy. 
It is alleged that appellant No. 3 had performed ‘black art’ on the deceased so 
much so that, he fell in love with her. Taking advantage of the situation, she took
photographs and video of them in compromising position. All the accused persons 
were shameless persons. As they started blackmailing him, he initially paid Rs. 
80,000.00 to them and thereafter started giving them ornaments. He also gave them
his passbook and cheque books after signing on the cheques. Because of such blackmailing,
he had to misappropriate money from his office for which he was suspended. It is
stated that he was totally ruined and, therefore, he had committed suicide as he
had no other alternative.

##### **Handwriting expert was not examined**

41. The suicide note was sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL) for examination.
The Deputy Chief Handwriting Expert of FSL, Gandhinagar opined that the handwriting
was of the deceased. However, the prosecution did not examine the Deputy Chief Handwriting
Expert as an expert witness. The records also do not indicate that the accused had
admitted genuineness of the report of the handwriting expert.

##### **Opinion of handwriting expert rarely takes place of substantive evidence**

42. In Shashi Kumar Banerjee versus Subodh Kumar Banerjee (since deceased) this 
Court observed that expert’s evidence as to handwriting is opinion evidence. It 
can rarely, if ever, take the place of substantive evidence. Before acting on such
opinion evidence, it is necessary to see if it is corroborated either by clear direct
evidence or by circumstantial evidence.

43. In the case of Murari Lal versus State of M.P., this Court opined that having
due regard to the imperfect nature of the science of identification of hand-writing,
the approach of the court should be one of caution. Reasons for the opinion must
be carefully probed and examined. In an appropriate case, corroboration may be sought.
Where the reasons for the opinion are convincing and there is no reliable evidence
throwing a doubt, uncorroborated testimony of a handwriting expert may be accepted.

##### **Unless the accused admitted the handwriting report the expert should be examined to prove the handwriting opinion report**

44. This Court dealt with the effect of placing reliance on the opinion of handwriting
expert without examining him in court in Keshav Dutt versus State of Haryana. One
of the questions which fell for consideration in that case was whether the opinion
of a handwriting expert can be admitted in evidence without examination of the handwriting
expert. In this connection, this Court took the view that when the trial court chose
to rely on the report of the handwriting expert, it ought to have examined the handwriting
expert in order to give an opportunity to the accused to cross-examine the said 
expert. In that case, it was found that there was nothing on record to show that
the accused persons had admitted to the report of the handwriting expert.

##### **No act is attributed to the appellants proximate to the time of suicide**

45. Finally, even if we take the suicide note as correct and genuine, we do not 
find any act of incitement on the part of the appellants proximate to the date on
which the deceased committed suicide. No act is attributed to the appellants proximate
to the time of suicide which was of such a nature that the deceased was left with
no alternative but to commit suicide. In such circumstances, it cannot be said that
any offence of abetment to commit suicide is made out against the appellants.

#### **Conclusion**

46. Accordingly and in the light of the above, we allow this appeal. Consequently,
the impugned judgment and order of the High Court dated 17.12.2013 and of the trial
court dated 12.05.2011 are hereby set aside. Since the appellants are already on
bail, their bail bonds stand discharged.

##### **Cited Judgments**

 * Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh – (2001) 9 SCC 618
 * Chitresh Kumar Chopra v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) – (2009) 16 SCC 605
 * Amalendu Pal alias Jhantu v. State of West Bengal – (2010) 1 SCC 707
 * Ude Singh v. State of Haryana – (2019) 17 SCC 301
 * Rajesh v. State of Haryana – (2020) 15 SCC 359
 * Kamaruddin Dastagir Sanadi v. State of Karnataka – (2024) SCC Online SC 3541
 * Prakash v. State of Maharashtra – 2024 INSC 1020
 * Sanju @ Sanjay Singh Sengar v. State of M.P. – (2002) 5 SCC 371
 * Shashi Kumar Banerjee v. Subodh Kumar Banerjee – AIR 1964 SC 529
 * Murari Lal v. State of M.P. – (1980) 1 SCC 704
 * Keshav Dutt v. State of Haryana – (2010) 9 SCC 286
 * Kumar @ Shiva Kumar v. State of Karnataka – 2024 INSC 156

##### **Acts and Sections Involved**

 * Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
    - Section 306: Punishment for abetment of suicide.
    - Section 114: Abetment of an act done with intent to commit an offence.
 * Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989
    - Section 3(2)(5): Specific provisions related to offences against members of
      Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. 

#### **Party**

Patel Babubhai Manohardas & Ors. (Appellants) vs. State of Gujarat (Respondents)–
Criminal Appeal No. 1388 of 2014 – 2025 INSC 322 – March 5, 2025 – Abhay S. Oka 
and Ujjal Bhuyan

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
