# After appointing the amicus Curiae he must given a reasonable time to prepare and to meet the accused to get instructions

- Link: https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/
- Published: 2026-05-25T14:10:10+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against the judgment passed by the High Court dismissing the appeal preferred by the appellant](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#appeal-against-the-judgment-passed-by-the-high-court-dismissing-the-appeal-preferred-by-the-appellant)
    - [High Court appointed amicus curiae for appellant](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#high-court-appointed-amicus-curiae-for-appellant)
    - [Amicus and counsel for state argued the matter](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#amicus-and-counsel-for-state-argued-the-matter)
    - [Division Bench dismissed the appeal and affirmed the conviction of Trial court](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#division-bench-dismissed-the-appeal-and-affirmed-the-conviction-of-trial-court)
    - [Argument on behalf of the appellant is that he case was decided within 6 days from the date of appointment of amicus and the amicus did not meet or have any conference with the appellant](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#argument-on-behalf-of-the-appellant-is-that-he-case-was-decided-within-6-days-from-the-date-of-appointment-of-amicus-and-the-amicus-did-not-meet-or-have-any-conference-with-the-appellant)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#analysis)
    - [Judgments regarding appointment of Amicus curie and his time for preparation](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#judgments-regarding-appointment-of-amicus-curie-and-his-time-for-preparation)
    - [Not the settled principles met in this case](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#not-the-settled-principles-met-in-this-case)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#conclusion)
    - [Remanded back for de novo hearing of appeal](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#remanded-back-for-de-novo-hearing-of-appeal)
 * [Resources](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#resources)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/after-appointing-the-amicus-curiae-he-must-given-a-reasonable-time-to-prepare-and-to-meet-the-accused-to-get-instructions/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against the judgment passed by the High Court dismissing the appeal preferred by the appellant**

2. Appellant is challenging the judgment and order dated 26thNovember, 20251 passed
by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, at Jabalpur dismissing the appeal under Section
374(2) of the [Code of Criminal Procedure](https://section1.in/bail-ability-of-section-3513-of-the-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-2023-do-colonial-era-notifications-survive-the-new-criminal-procedure-code/),
1973. He was convicted under Section 302 of Indian Penal Code, 18604 and sentenced
to [life imprisonment](https://section1.in/releasing-of-accused-after-20-years-confirming-her-life-imprisonment/)
by the trial court; and the conviction and sentence was affirmed by the High Court
vide the impugned order.

3. Having regard to the final order we propose to pass, it is not considered necessary
to examine the appeal on its own merits. [Appellant was convicted by the relevant sessions court](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
on 20th December, 2022 in respect of the crime of murder committed by him on 16th
October, 2020. Thereafter, the appellant carried the [conviction and sentence in appeal](https://section1.in/appeal-against-conviction-of-gruesome-murder-of-children-and-causing-disappearance-of-evidence/).
It is pertinent to note that the appellant has been in [custody](https://section1.in/prosecution-must-prove-the-custody-of-sealed-article-from-the-time-of-seizure-till-they-reach-the-fsl/)
since 16th October, 2020 itself as per the custody certificate on record and has
remained in custody during the pendency of the appeal.

##### **High Court appointed amicus curiae for appellant**

4. Appellant’s appeal was listed on 20th November, 2025 before a Division Bench 
of the High Court. As per the [order passed](https://section1.in/sec-214-nia-act-order-passed-relying-on-wikipedia-by-trial-court-unsustainable/)
on that day, since no one was appearing on behalf of the appellant, the Division
Bench appointed an amicus curiae to assist the Court and also listed the case for
hearing the following week.

##### **Amicus and counsel for state argued the matter**

5. The amicus argued the appeal on 26th November, 2025. [He submitted that the eye-witness account is](https://section1.in/witness-did-not-name-any-person-from-the-locality-who-had-seen-the-incident-and-not-a-single-witness-from-the-locality-was-examined-who-had-seen-the-incident/)
unreliable; pointing particularly towards the account of one Arun Singh (PW-2) who,
as per the amicus, was unable to explain how he could see the incident from a distance
of about 100 metres. Furthermore, stress was [also put onPW-2’s statements during cross-examination in which he stated that he was not knowing the appellant at the time of the incident and only at the instance of one Umashankar, PW-5, who was the brother of the deceased and also the complainant in the case](https://section1.in/plea-of-alibi-gone-wrong-for-murder-case-also-defence-on-lack-of-sanction-wont-work/),
he got to know that the person who hit the deceased was in fact the appellant. Apart
from this, the learned amicus also raised the point regarding the appellant being
74 years of age and accordingly prayed for some leniency in the matter. Learned 
counsel appearing for the State opposed the appeal and argued that the eye witness
account is reliable and is supported by the axe recovered at the instance of the
appellant on which human blood was found as per the FSL report and whose recovery
has been duly proved by the [Investigating Officer](https://section1.in/officers-investigating-the-offence-are-duty-bound-to-be-vigilant-before-invoking-any-provision-of-a-very-stringent-statute-like-the-sc-st-act/).
Dismissal of the appeal was, accordingly, prayed.

##### **Division Bench dismissed the appeal and affirmed the conviction of Trial court**

6. Upon consideration of the evidence led at the trial, the Division Bench dismissed
the appeal and affirmed the conviction and sentence of the [trial court](https://section1.in/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-6-general-introduction-to-inquiries-and-trials-part-4-criminal-courts-powers-administration/).

7. [Appellant was already](https://section1.in/p-c-act-reduced-the-sentence-of-appellant-already-underwent-imprisonment-for-31-years/)
in custody during the pendency of the appeal.

##### **Argument on behalf of the appellant is that he case was decided within 6 days from the date of appointment of amicus and the amicus did not meet or have any conference with the appellant**

8. Before us, the learned counsel for the appellant vehemently contended that he
was denied justice. According to him, while the appellant was languishing in custody,
he was not notified by the High Court that in the absence of the advocate engaged
by him, an amicus has been appointed. The amicus was appointed by an order passed
on 20th November, 2025 and the appeal was dismissed on 26thNovember, 2025, merely
six days after the appointment of the amicus. In the intervening period, the amicus
did not meet or have any conference with the appellant who was still lodged in the4correctional
home regarding his pending [appeal and failed to effectively present](https://section1.in/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)
his case. This, as per the learned counsel for appellant, denied him an effective
opportunity of being heard, in gross violation of [principles of natural justice](https://section1.in/supreme-court-overturns-high-courts-decision-in-mumbai-eviction-case-and-directed-to-proceed-with-the-principles-of-natural-justice/).
With regard to the absence of the advocate engaged by the appellant, he submitted
that the advocate was taking medical [treatment and his illness](https://section1.in/bihari-migrant-ill-treatment-in-tamilnadu-case-quash-dismissed-since-the-alternative-remedy-is-available-u-s-482-cr-p-c/)
prevented him to appear before the Court on 20th November, 2025.

#### **Analysis**

10. Therefore, in our considered opinion, we find that the High Court in its anxiety
to deliver justice without further delay and decide the appeal expeditiously had
not [made an attempt to inform the appellant](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/)
that in the absence of representation from his side an amicus had been appointed
to represent him. Furthermore, it also does not seem that the amicus had any opportunity
to interact with the appellant who was lodged in a correctional home. The High [Court was under no obligation to inform the appellant](https://section1.in/section-391-cr-p-c-if-no-questions-put-to-the-witnesses-or-lead-evidence-the-appellate-court-has-no-obligation-to-allow-application-filed-under-section-391-cr-p-c/)
regarding the absence of his advocate. Nevertheless, it would have been a prudent
and desirable step had the appellant been intimated of the same. This acquires added
significance in light of the consistent view taken by this Court that **legal aid
to an [accused person](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
must not be a mere ritual or a token formality, but a substantive and meaningful
exercise that ensures effective assistance of counsel.** While there can be no doubt
about the bona fide intention of the High Court in appointing an amicus to represent
convict whose advocate is not present to argue his appeal with a view to advancing
the cause of justice, it would perhaps have better served the ends of justice had
a formal notice been issued to the appellant informing him of the hearing and the
arrangement made for his representation. Such a course becomes all the more imperative
where, as in the [present case](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/),
the appellant remained incarcerated during the pendency of the appeal.

##### **Judgments regarding appointment of Amicus curie and his time for preparation**

11.At this juncture, it may be apposite to note that this Court had the occasion
to deal with a similar case quite recently. In Bhola Mahto v State of Jharkhand,
accepting a similar technical plea raised by the appellant regarding non-service
of notice after the appointment of an amicus, this Court ordered a de-novo hearing
of his appeal and remanded the case back to the High Court. While doing so, this
[Court relied upon and reiterated the directions](https://section1.in/suo-moto-guidelines-common-practice-and-procedure-in-criminal-trials-all-over-india/)
given in Anokhi Lal vs. State of Madhya Pradesh by a three-Judge Bench of this Court
regarding the appointment of amicus while also making certain additional observations
regarding service of notice after such appointment. For the sake of brevity, we 
do not wish to repeat the directions in Anokhi Lal (supra) and Bhola Mahto (supra)
here. However, having regard to the facts of the present case, we deem it appropriate
to emphasise two [directions issued](https://section1.in/reason-is-necessary-while-recording-direction-to-pay-the-interim-compensation-u-s143a1-n-i-act/)
in Anokhi Lal (supra). **First, that the amicus must be afforded [reasonable time](https://section1.in/duty-of-the-court-to-give-a-reasonble-time-to-the-advocate-appointed-to-go-through-the-file-and-get-ready-to-assist-the-court/)
to prepare the matter; and second, that adequate opportunity must be granted to 
the amicus to meet and confer with the accused/convict concerned. Admittedly, neither
of these directions appear to have been complied with in the present case.**

##### **Not the settled principles met in this case**

12.Needless to say, judicial time is both valuable and finite, and ought not to 
be expended in a casual or avoidable manner. We therefore reiterate, at the cost
of repetition, that the directions issued in Anokhi Lal (supra), as well as the 
observations made in Bhola Mahto (supra), must be followed scrupulously, in addition
to adherence to the relevant rules governing the business and procedure of the [courts concerned](https://section1.in/section-451-cr-p-c-petition-for-disposal-return-of-property-cannot-be-filed-directly-by-invoking-article-226-without-invoking-section-451-cr-p-c-before-the-concerned-court/).

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Remanded back for de novo hearing of appeal**

13. We are, therefore, inclined to order a remand for hearing of the appeal de novo.
The impugned order dated 26th November, 2025 is [set aside](https://section1.in/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/)
with the result that the appellant’s appeal shall stand revived on the file of the
High Court. It shall be decided in the manner observed hereafter

#### **Resources**

Judgments Cited/Relied Upon

 * _Anokhi Lal v. State of Madhya Pradesh_, (2019) 20 SCC 196
    - Brief: In this case, the [Supreme Court established critical guidelines regarding the appointment](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-public-prosecutor-while-explaining-the-principles-of-106-iea-in-criminal-cases-honble-supreme-court-has-addressed-the-government-to-appoint-skilled-lawyers-as-public-prosec/)
      of an _amicus curiae_. The Court in _Nandkishore Mishra_ reiterated these 
      principles, specifically emphasizing that an _amicus_ must be provided with
      reasonable time to prepare the case and, crucially, must be [given an adequate opportunity](https://section1.in/pmla-trial-court-ought-to-have-given-opportunity-to-the-accused-in-complaint-case-before-taking-cognizance-and-hence-cognizance-order-set-aside-case-remanded-back/)
      to meet and confer with the accused or convict.
 * [_Bhola Mahto v. State of Jharkhand_, Criminal Appeal No. 1450 of 2026]
    - Brief: This recent judgment was cited alongside _Anokhi Lal_ to reinforce 
      the same [principles of natural justice](https://section1.in/principles-of-natural-justice-are-not-applicable-at-the-stage-of-reporting-a-criminal-offence/).
      The Supreme Court underscored that the appointment of an _amicus_ should not
      be a mere ritual or token formality; it must be a substantive, meaningful 
      exercise to ensure that the accused receives effective legal assistance.

[Acts and Sections](https://section1.in/pc-act-sections-7-131di-and-ii-presumption-can-also-be-drawn-for-smaller-bribe-amounts-further-accused-has-not-proved-that-rs-2000-bribe-amount-was-a-legal-fee-or-repayment-of-loan/)

 * Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
    - Section 374(2): This section is cited as the basis under which the appellant
      filed his appeal against the conviction and sentence passed by the [trial court](https://section1.in/pocso-victims-contradictory-statements-cannot-form-the-basis-for-quashing-criminal-proceedings-but-trial-court-must-careful-on-misusing-this-act/).
 * Indian Penal Code, 1860
    - Section 302: This is the primary charge under which the appellant was convicted
      and sentenced to life imprisonment by the lower court.

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    Nandkishore Mishra vs The State of Madhya Pradesh - Criminal Appeal No. 2787/2026 -2026 INSC 531 - May 22, 2026 – Hon’ble Justice Dipankar Datta and Hon’ble Justice Satish Chandra Sharma.
    ```

[Nandkishore 71622026_2026-05-22](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Nandkishore-71622026_2026-05-22.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Nandkishore-71622026_2026-05-22.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [If unnecessary adjournment seeks for cross-examination then the courts are empowered to appoint amicus for cross-examination](https://section1.in/if-unnecessary-adjournment-seeks-for-cross-examination-then-the-courts-are-empowered-to-appoint-amicus-for-cross-examination/)
 * [Strict Procedure: Trial courts must inform the accused of their right to engage legal aid if they cannot afford a counsel](https://section1.in/strict-procedure-trial-courts-must-inform-the-accused-of-their-right-to-engage-legal-aid-if-they-cannot-afford-a-counsel/)
