# Recall: All about section 311 Cr.P.C

- Link: https://section1.in/all-about-section-311-cr-p-c-recall/
- Published: 2023-03-12T12:43:26+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Section 311, Code of Criminal Procedure](https://section1.in/all-about-section-311-cr-p-c-recall/#section-311-code-of-criminal-procedure)
 * [Section 138, Evidence Act](https://section1.in/all-about-section-311-cr-p-c-recall/#section-138-evidence-act)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/all-about-section-311-cr-p-c-recall/#party)

13. Having heard the learned counsel for the respective parties and having bestowed
our serious consideration to the issue involved, we find force in the submission
of the counsel for the appellant, as the same merits acceptance. In order to appreciate
the stand of the appellant it will be worthwhile to refer to Section 311 Cr.P.C.,
as well as Section 138 of the Evidence Act. The same are extracted hereunder:

##### **Section 311, Code of Criminal Procedure**

311. **Power to summon material witness, or examine person present**: Any Court 
may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or other proceeding under this Code, summon
any person as a witness, or examine any person in attendance, though not summoned
as a witness, or recall and re-examine any person already examined; and the Court
shall summon and examine or recall and re-examine any such person if his evidence
appears to it to be essential to the just decision of the case.

##### **Section 138, Evidence Act**

**138. Order of examinations**– witnesses shall be first examined-in-chief, then(
if the adverse party so desires) cross-examined, then (if the party calling him 
so desires) re-examined.

The examination and cross-examination must relate to relevant facts, but the cross-
examination need not be confined to the facts to which the witness testified on 
his examination-in-chief.

Direction of re-examination- The re-examination shall be directed to the explanation
of matters referred to in cross-examination; and, if new matter is, by permission
of the Court, introduced in re-examination, the adverse party may further cross[
1]examine upon that matter.”

14. A conspicuous reading of Section 311 Cr.P.C. would show that widest of the powers
have been invested with the Courts when it comes to the question of summoning a 
witness or to recall or re-examine any witness already examined. A reading of the
provision shows that the expression “any” has been used as a pre-fix to “court”,“
inquiry”, “trial”, “other proceeding”, “person as a witness”, “person in attendance
though not summoned as a witness”, and “person already examined”. By using the said
expression “any” as a pre-fix to the various expressions mentioned above, it is 
ultimately stated that all that was required to be satisfied by the Court was only
in relation to such evidence that appears to the Court to be essential for the just
decision of the case. Section 138 of the Evidence Act, prescribed the order of examination
of a witness in the Court. Order of re-examination is also prescribed calling for
such a witness so desired for such re-examination. Therefore, a reading of Section
311 Cr.P.C. and Section 138 Evidence Act, insofar as it comes to the question of
a criminal trial, the order of re-examination at the desire of any person under 
Section 138, will have to necessarily be in consonance with the prescription contained
in Section 311 Cr.P.C. It is, therefore, imperative that the invocation of Section
311 Cr.P.C. and its application in a particular case can be ordered by the Court,
only by bearing in mind the object and purport of the said provision, namely, for
achieving a just decision of the case as noted by us earlier. The power vested under
the said provision is made available to any Court at any stage in any inquiry or
trial or other proceeding initiated under the Code for the purpose of summoning 
any person as a witness or for examining any person in attendance, even though not
summoned as witness or to recall or re-examine any person already examined. Insofar
as recalling and re-examination of any person already examined, the Court must necessarily
consider and ensure that such recall and re-examination of any person, appears in
the view of the Court to be essential for the just decision of the case. Therefore,
the paramount requirement is just decision and for that purpose the essentiality
of a person to be recalled and re-examined has to be ascertained. To put it differently,
while such a widest power is invested with the Court, it is needless to state that
exercise of such power should be made judicially and also with extreme care and 
caution.

xxx

23. From a conspectus consideration of the above decisions, while dealing with an
application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. read along with Section 138 of the Evidence
Act, we feel the following principles will have to be borne in mind by the Courts:

a) Whether the Court is right in thinking that the new evidence is needed by it?
Whether the evidence sought to be led in under Section 311 is noted by the Court
for a just decision of a case?

b) The exercise of the widest discretionary power under Section 311 Cr.P.C. should
ensure that the judgment should not be rendered on inchoate, inconclusive speculative
presentation of facts, as thereby the ends of justice would be defeated.

c) If evidence of any witness appears to the Court to be essential to the just decision
of the case, it is the power of the Court to summon and examine or recall and re-
examine any such person.

d) The exercise of power under Section 311 Cr.P.C. should be resorted to only with
the object of finding out the truth or obtaining proper proof for such facts, which
will lead to a just and correct decision of the case.

e) The exercise of the said power cannot be dubbed as filling in a lacuna in a prosecution
case, unless the facts and circumstances of the case make it apparent that the exercise
of power by the Court would result in causing serious prejudice to the accused, 
resulting in miscarriage of justice.

f) The wide discretionary power should be exercised judiciously and not arbitrarily.

g) The Court must satisfy itself that it was in every respect essential to examine
such a witness or to recall him for further examination in order to arrive at a 
just decision of the case.

h) The object of Section 311 Cr.P.C. simultaneously imposes a duty on the Court 
to determine the truth and to render a just decision.

i) The Court arrives at the conclusion that additional evidence is necessary, not
because it would be impossible to pronounce the judgment without it, but because
there would be a failure of justice without such evidence being considered.

j) Exigency of the situation, fair play and good sense should be the safe guard,
while exercising the discretion. The Court should bear in mind that no party in 
a trial can be foreclosed from correcting errors and that if proper evidence was
not adduced or a relevant material was not brought on record due to any inadvertence,
the Court should be magnanimous in permitting such mistakes to be rectified.

k) The Court should be conscious of the position that after all the trial is basically
for the prisoners and the Court should afford an opportunity to them in the fairest
manner possible. In that parity of reasoning, it would be safe to err in favour 
of the accused getting an opportunity rather than protecting the prosecution against
possible prejudice at the cost of the accused. The Court should bear in mind that
improper or capricious exercise of such a discretionary power, may lead to undesirable
results.

l) The additional evidence must not be received as a disguise or to change the nature
of the case against any of the party.

m) The power must be exercised keeping in mind that the evidence that is likely 
to be tendered, would be germane to the issue involved and also ensure that an opportunity
of rebuttal is given to the other party.

n) The power under Section 311 Cr.P.C. must therefore, be invoked by the Court only
in order to meet the ends of justice for strong and valid reasons and the same must
be exercised with care, caution and circumspection. The Court should bear in mind
that fair trial entails the interest of the accused, the victim and the society 
and, therefore, the grant of fair and proper opportunities to the persons concerned,
must be ensured being a constitutional goal, as well as a human right.

24. Keeping the above principles in mind, when we examine the case on hand, at the
very outset, it will have to be stated that the High Court, while passing the impugned
order has completely ignored the principal objectives with which the provision under
Section 311 Cr.P.C. has been brought into the statute book. As rightly argued by
the learned counsel for the appellant, at the foremost when the trial was very much
in the grip of the trial Court, which had every opportunity to hear the appellant,
the State, as well as the second respondent, had not even bothered to verify whether
the appellant, who was facing criminal trial was impleaded as a party to the proceedings
in the High Court. A perusal of the order discloses that the High Court appears 
to have passed orders on the very first hearing date, unmindful of the consequences
involved. The order does not reflect any of the issues dealt with by the Learned
Sessions Judge, while rejecting the application of the respondents in seeking to
re-examine PW[1]9, the second respondent herein. Though orders could have been passed
in this appeal by remitting the matter back to the High Court, having regard to 
the time factor and since the entire material for passing final orders, are available
on record and since all parties were before us, the correctness of the order of 
the Sessions Judge dated 18.11.2009, can be examined and final orders can be passed
one way or the other in the present criminal appeal itself.

##### **Party**

**RAJARAM PRASAD YADAV vs. STATE OF BIHAR & ANR – {Criminal Appeal No. 830 of 2013)–
July 04, 2013 – [2013) 7 S.C.R. 420**

**[rajaram-prasad-yadav-vs.-state-of-bihar-anr](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/rajaram-prasad-yadav-vs.-state-of-bihar-anr.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
