# Appeal against acquittal: Appellate court would not scrutinize evidence once again unless there has been a total miscarriage of justice

- Link: https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/
- Published: 2024-10-27T12:44:29+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal against converting the conviction into one acquittal by the Hon’ble High Court of M.P](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#appeal-against-converting-the-conviction-into-one-acquittal-by-the-honble-high-court-of-mp)
 * [Case of the prosecution](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#case-of-the-prosecution)
 * [Prosecution examined 19 witnesses and the defence examined two witnesses](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#prosecution-examined-19-witnesses-and-the-defence-examined-two-witnesses)
 * [Trial court convicted the respondent and the Hon’ble High Court acquitted him](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#trial-court-convicted-the-respondent-and-the-honble-high-court-acquitted-him)
 * [Discussing position of law regard to appeal against acquittal](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#discussing-position-of-law-regard-to-appeal-against-acquittal)
 * [Appellate court would not scrutinize evidence once again unless there has been a total miscarriage of justice](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice)
 * [Trial court relied on the oral testimonies](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#trial-court-relied-on-the-oral-testimonies)
 * [Material improvements and omissions in PW.8 testimony](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#material-improvements-and-omissions-in-pw8-testimony)
 * [FIR is not an encyclopaedia](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#fir-is-not-an-encyclopaedia)
 * [FIR is not substantive piece of evidence and can be used for corroborating or contradicting](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#fir-is-not-substantive-piece-of-evidence-and-can-be-used-for-corroborating-or-contradicting)
 * [Omission in FIR impeaches the credibility of witness depend upon the question of fact](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#omission-in-fir-impeaches-the-credibility-of-witness-depend-upon-the-question-of-fact)
 * [FIR is used to corroborate its maker under Section 157 or to contradict its maker under Section 145 of the Evidence Act](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#fir-is-used-to-corroborate-its-maker-under-section-157-or-to-contradict-its-maker-under-section-145-of-the-evidence-act)
 * [Dying Declaration itself is not a strong piece of evidence](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#dying-declaration-itself-is-not-a-strong-piece-of-evidence)
 * [Apex court has come to the conclusion that the High Court has considered all the aspects of oral testimony while delivering judgment](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#apex-court-has-come-to-the-conclusion-that-the-high-court-has-considered-all-the-aspects-of-oral-testimony-while-delivering-judgment)
 * [Courts were perfectly right in holding the death of the deceased as culpable homicide amounting to murder](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#courts-were-perfectly-right-in-holding-the-death-of-the-deceased-as-culpable-homicide-amounting-to-murder)
 * [Omissions brought amount to material contradiction will go into the core of the prosecution case](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#omissions-brought-amount-to-material-contradiction-will-go-into-the-core-of-the-prosecution-case)
 * [Apex court confirmed the acquittal](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#apex-court-confirmed-the-acquittal)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/#party)

##### **Appeal against converting the conviction into one acquittal by the Hon’ble High Court of M.P**

1. This appeal is against the judgment of acquittal dated 31.01.2013 passed by the
High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Gwalior in Criminal Appeal No. 602 of 1998 in reversal
of the judgment of conviction recorded against the appellants therein viz., the 
respondents herein, by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Sironj in Sessions
Trial No. 320 of 1996 dated 28.10.1998.

2. Heard learned counsel for the appellant State and learned counsel for the respondents,
the convicts who were acquitted by the High Court vide the impugned judgment.

##### **Case of the prosecution**

3. The case of the prosecution, in succinct, was as under: –

Respondent was charged with murder under section 302 IPC

‘On 01.10.1996, at about 1.00 pm, the respondents herein viz., Ramjan Khan, Musaf
Khan @ Musab Khan and Habib Khan, by cutting/beating with sickle, axe and stick 
caused death of Naseem Khan, near the village well of Karaikheda and thereby committed
the crime punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34, of the Indian Penal
Code (for short the ‘IPC’).’

##### **Prosecution examined 19 witnesses and the defence examined two witnesses**

4. As mentioned above, the respondents herein were tried by the Court of Additional
Sessions Judge, Sironj. The prosecution had examined 19 witnesses including Haseen
Khan (PW-5) and Farid Khan (PW-9), who are the real brothers of deceased Naseem 
Khan and eye witnesses. Documentary evidence including the postmortem report prepared
by Dr. S.S. Thakur (PW-1) were tendered by the prosecution. On the side of the defence
two witnesses were examined.

##### **Trial court convicted the respondent and the Hon’ble High Court acquitted him**

5. The trial Court relied on the oral testimonies of PW5 and PW-9, the minor brothers
of the deceased besides the testimony of PW-8, the mother of the deceased who happened
to be the informant and further found that the ocular evidence got corroboration
from the medical evidence, to enter conviction on the appellants for having committed
murder of Naseem Khan. Consequently, the respondents herein were sentenced to undergo
imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs. 35,000/-. The respondents herein,
the convicts preferred appeal jointly, against the judgment of conviction for the
offence punishable under Section 302, IPC read with Section 34, IPC and the life
sentence imposed therefor, the High Court acquitted them of the offences with which
they were charged and allowed the appeal in the impugned judgment of acquittal.

##### **Discussing position of law regard to appeal against acquittal**

6. Before dealing with the rival contentions raised before us, we think it only 
appropriate to refer to some of the relevant decisions of this Court laying law 
in regard to appeal against acquittal. It is true that the judgment of acquittal
was passed after setting aside the judgment of conviction passed against the respondents
herein by the trial Court.

##### **Appellate court would not scrutinize evidence once again unless there has been a total miscarriage of justice**

7. In the decision in **Jai Karan & Ors. v. State of U.P [(2003) 12 SCC 655]** this
Court held that where the trial Court and the High Court had concurrently found 
the accused guilty, the Supreme Court would not scrutinize the evidence once again,
unless there has been a total miscarriage of justice. We may hasten to add here 
that this Court may have to re-appreciate evidence in cases where a prima facie 
perverse appreciation of evidence is brought out, even in such cases. We shall also
not be understood to have held that merely because the trial Court and the High 
Court have rendered divergent findings, this Court should invariably scrutinize 
the evidence once again and in that regard this Court should entertain an appeal.
In an appeal, against conviction in murder case under Section 374 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure (for short the ‘Cr.P.C.’), a proper analysis of the evidence 
and accepting or rejecting, the appreciation of evidence by the trial Court must
reflect in the judgment of the High Court. In other words, the disposal of the appeal
under Section 374, Cr.P.C., shall not be by cryptic or nonreasoned order. In the
decision in **Govindaraju v. State by Sivaramapuram PS [(2012) 4 SCC 722]**, this
Court held that a very vital distinction has to be kept in mind while dealing with
appeal under Section 374, Cr.P.C., that interference would be justifiable only when
distinction is kept between perversity in appreciation of evidence and mere possibility
of another view. Furthermore, it was held therein that it would not be appropriate
for the High Court to merely record that the judgment of the trial Court was perverse
without specifically dealing with the facets of perversity relating to the issues
of law and/or appreciation of evidence, as otherwise such observation of the High
Court would not be sustainable in law.

8. Having taken note of the position settled thus we may add that when the High 
Court acquitted the convict(s) in the appeal filed under Section 374, Cr.P.C., in
reversal of conviction, by granting the benefit of doubt after a proper appreciation
of evidence interference is permissible and justifiable only if it is infected with
perversity in troth, the prosecution was not successful in establishing the guilt
of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. In the decision in **State of U.P. v. Dharmaraj
and Anr [(2003) 9 SCC 39]**, which involved a challenge against a judgment of acquittal
in a murder case by the High Court, this Court held that when on facts the view 
taken by the High Court was a reasonably possible view, though not the only view
that could be taken, interference with acquittal would be uncalled for.

##### **Trial court relied on the oral testimonies**

9. Bearing in mind the aforesaid decisions and the fact that the trial Court and
the High Court are at issue on the question whether the respondents are guilty in
the case on hand, we will proceed to consider the captioned appeal. Obviously, the
trial Court relied on the oral testimonies of PWs 5, 8 and 9 whereas in the appeal
the High Court found the oral evidence of PWs 5, 8 and 9 as unreliable.

##### **Material improvements and omissions in PW.8 testimony**

10. Before dealing with the oral testimonies of the minor brothers of the deceased(
PWs 5 and 9), we will deal with the oral evidence of PW-8, the mother of the deceased.
She is the informant at whose instance FIR No.78/96 was registered against the respondents
herein. Though she was believed by the trial Court, on reappreciation the High Court
found her unreliable owing to the material improvements and omissions made while
being examined as PW-8. It was brought out while being cross-examined that she had
not deposed at all about a dying declaration made to her by the deceased son. Before
analysing her evidence further, it is not inappropriate to refer to a few decisions
having bearing on her testimony.

##### **FIR is not an encyclopaedia**

11. FIR is not an encyclopedia disclosing all facts and details relating the entire
prosecution case. (See the decisions in Superintendent of Police, **CBI & Ors. v.
Tapan Kumar Singh [(2003) 6 SCC 175]**; **State of UP v. Naresh & Ors [(2011) 4 
SCC 324]**; **Lalitha Kumari v. Government of UP & Ors [(2014) 2 SCC 1]**, and **
Amish Devgan v. UOI & Ors [(2021) 1 SCC 1]**).

12. It is true that the aforementioned decisions would undoubtedly reveal the position
that an FIR is not meant to be a detailed document containing chronicle of all intricate
and minute details.

##### **FIR is not substantive piece of evidence and can be used for corroborating or contradicting**

13. Even after, referring to the decisions mentioned above, we think it equally 
relevant to refer to the decision of this Court in **Dharma Rama Bhagare v. State
of Maharashtra [(1973) 1 SCC 537]**. It was held therein thus: –

“The first information report, it may be pointed out, is never treated as a substantive
piece of evidence. It can only be used for corroborating or contradicting its maker
when he appears in court as a witness.”

##### **Omission in FIR impeaches the credibility of witness depend upon the question of fact**

14. There can be no doubt with respect to the position that the prime object of 
FIR, from the point of view of the informant is to set the criminal law in motion
and from the point of the investigating authorities is to obtain information about
the alleged activity so as to enable to take suitable steps to trace and book the
guilty. Thus, it can be said that FIR is an important document, though not a substantial
piece of evidence, and may be put in evidence to support or contradict the evidence
of its maker viz., the informant. Whether the omission(s) is one which seriously
impeaches the credibility of the witness and is sufficient to reject the testimony
of the informant would depend upon the question whether it is of an important fact
and whether that fact was within the knowledge of the informant, going by the case
of prosecution unraveled through the witness concerned.

##### **FIR is used to corroborate its maker under Section 157 or to contradict its maker under Section 145 of the Evidence Act**

15. Thus, the position with respect to FIR is clear from the decisions referred 
supra that even though it is not meant to be an encyclopedia containing chronicle
of all intricate and minute details, it could be used to corroborate its maker under
Section 157 of the Evidence Act or to contradict its maker viz., the informant under
Section 145 of the Evidence Act to establish whether he is a trustworthy witness
or not.

##### **Dying Declaration itself is not a strong piece of evidence**

17. Through the evidence of PW8, the mother of the deceased, who is also the informant,
the prosecution has attempted to establish the existence of an oral dying declaration.
It is to be noted that dying declaration itself is not a strong piece of evidence
and therefore, when it is verbal and that too, allegedly made to a close relative(
in this case allegedly to the mother), evidence of mother about the oral dying declaration
was to be treated with care and caution. To show that the trial Court dealt with
the same without due care and caution self- evident from paragraph 32 of the judgment
of the Trial Court, which reads thus: –

“para. 32 and 42”

19. The Judgment of the Trial Court would reveal that after considering the aforesaid
aspect in such a light manner, believing the oral evidence of PW8 as well, the Trial
Court arrived at the finding that accused Ramjan Khan had beaten Naseem Khan with
sickle, accused Musab had beaten him with bamboo lathi (equipped with Farsa) and
accused Habib inflicted axe blow on Naseem Khan and thereby caused his murder.

##### **Apex court has come to the conclusion that the High Court has considered all the aspects of oral testimony while delivering judgment**

23. A scanning of the oral testimony of PW-8 would show that on many other materials
points the defence could brought out, upon confronting her with Ext.P12- FIR, Ext.
D3-previous statement, various serious omissions. About her statement in Court that
PW-5 and PW-9 went along with deceased Naseem Khan on 01.10.1996 for taking bath
nothing was seen recorded in Ext.D3. As noted earlier, as to the alleged oral dying
declaration made to her by the deceased from the place of occurrence after sustaining
injuries nothing was recorded in Ext.P12-FIR as also in Ext.D3. Though she deposed
that upon seeing her Ramjan, Musaf Khan and Habib Khan ran away from the place of
occurrence this fact was not recorded in Ext.D3. So also, about the attack by the
accused persons on deceased Naseem Khan though she deposed that PW-5 and PW-9 told
her and in turn she told such facts to police they were not recorded in Ext.D3. 
She would depose that she got no enmity with the family of accused persons and got
no dispute in respect of land. In view of the aforementioned aspects revealed from
the testimony of PW-8 which were not given due weight by the trial Court while considering
whether PW-8 is reliable or not, we are of the considered view that the High Court
had rightly given due consideration to all such aspects and ultimately discredited
her testimony.

##### **Courts were perfectly right in holding the death of the deceased as culpable homicide amounting to murder**

25. PW-1 opined that all the aforesaid injuries except injury Nos.1 and 2 were sufficient
in the ordinary course of nature to cause death and that the cause of death was 
comma as a result of head injuries. In short, in view of the necroscopical evidence
as above the Courts were perfectly right in holding that the death of Naseem Khan
is culpable homicide amounting to murder

26. Now, the surviving question is only whether the prosecution had succeeded in
establishing conclusively beyond any reasonable doubt that the culprits for the 
murder of Naseem Khan, are the respondents herein as held by the trial Court or 
whether they are entitled to the benefit of doubt and consequential acquittal as
held by the High Court. In the decision in **Anil Phukan v. State of Assam[(1993)
3 SCC 282]**, this Court held that conviction could be based on testimony of a single
witness provided his testimony is found reliable and inspires confidence. In the
decision in **Chandu Bhai Shana Bhai Parmar v. State of Gujarat [AIR 1982 SC 1022]**,
this Court held that when the ocular evidence in a murder case is unreliable benefit
of doubt to be given to all accused.

27. We have already held, for the reasons given earlier, that the High Court had
rightly held the oral testimony of PW-8 as unreliable. As a matter of fact, the 
case of the prosecution is that Isab Khan (PW-2), Haseen Khan (PW-5), Fareed Khan(
PW-9), and Anees Khan (PW17) had witnessed the incident that led to the death of
Naseem Khan. In the light of the decisions in Anil Phukan’s case and Chandu Bhai’s
case (supra) the oral testimonies of PWs 2, 5, 9 & 17 are to be appreciated to answer
the aforementioned surviving question. PW-2 was declared hostile by the prosecution
and concurrently his evidence was held unreliable. Though PW-17 also turned hostile,
the trial Court held that on that account the accused / the respondents herein are
not entitled to any benefit as PW-5 and PW-9 proved the fact that accused/the respondents
herein had caused murder of Naseem Khan using sickle, danda affixed with farsa, 
and axe. However, the High Court held the evidence of PW-17 as unreliable. The High
Court found that though PW-17 was declared hostile prior to such declaration he 
deposed that the accused Ramjan/the first respondent herein had thrown the deceased
on a stone boulder. He had not deposed anything against the other accused / the 
other respondents herein. The High Court found his testimony unreliable as according
to him the first respondent Ramjan threw the deceased on a stone boulder which caused
head injuries, but that is not the case of the prosecution at all and that apart
he had stated so, for the first time only in the Court. In that regard he was confronted
with his previous statement – Ext.P22. Besides the same, there is nothing in the
opinion of PW1, the Doctor who conducted autopsy on the body of Naseem Khan, which
would indicate that the head injury was caused on account of the deceased being 
thrown on the stone boulder. When that be the nature of evidence of PW-17, it can
only be held that the finding of the trial Court that the evidence of PW-17 would
not fetch any benefit for the accused cannot be sustained. Hence, according to us,
the High Court held his evidence unreliable correctly.

28. In the aforesaid circumstances the question is with respect to the reliability
on the oral testimonies of PW-5 and PW-9 who are the younger brothers of deceased
Naseem Khan. As noticed hereinbefore, their oral testimonies were held as reliable
by the trial Court and at the same time the High Court found their testimonies as
unreliable. At the outset, it is to be noted that as in the case of PW-8, the defence
had succeeded in bringing out the fact that both PW-5 and PW-9 had omitted to mention
certain material facts to police while their statements were recorded. The question
is whether they were omissions tantamounting to discredit the said witnesses. PW-
5, while being examined in chief, deposed to have seen Ramjan causing injury by 
parena (sickle), Musaf Khan causing injury by stick and Habib causing injury by 
axe on his brother Naseem Khan. However, during crossexamination he would depose
that regarding the infliction of injuries by the respondents using the aforementioned
weapons on Naseem Khan, he did not make any statement before the police and stated
so for the first time before the Court. PW-2, Isab Khan, and PW17, Anees Khan, are
respectively the sons of Yaseem Khan and Mohar Khan, who are the cousin brothers
of Munne Khan, the father of PWs 5 and 9. As noticed hereinbefore, both PW-2 and
PW-17 did not support the case of the prosecution. High Court also took note of 
the Page 19 of 21 Criminal Appeal No. 2129 of 2014 fact that PW-5 did not depose
that when he along with his mother (PW-8) reached the place of occurrence the deceased
was alive and gave oral dying declaration to PW-8.

##### **Omissions brought amount to material contradiction will go into the core of the prosecution case**

29. While being cross-examined PW-9 deposed that he did not tell the police that
Ramjan with parena, Musaf Khan with farsa and, Habib Khan with axe assaulted his
brother Naseem Khan. While being examined in chief he would depose that his mother
was also beaten by the accused persons. It is to be noted that there is absolutely
no such case even for PW-8, the mother of PW-9. As can be seen from paragraph 6 
of his oral testimony the defence had brought out some other omissions and contradictions.
The aforementioned omissions on the part of PWs 5 and 9 cannot be said to be minor
contradictions to be taken lightly as according to them they did not name the accused
persons in their previous statements made to the police. **Hence, omissions thus
brought amount to material contradiction which will go into the core of the prosecution
case.** Their oral testimonies would reveal that they stated about the infliction
of injuries on Naseem Khan, their elder brother by the respondents with the weapons
mentioned above for the first time only before the Court while being examined. That
apart, it is to be noted that though the case of the prosecution is that both PWs
5 and 9 had gone with deceased Naseem Khan for taking bath on the fateful day the
evidence of PW-8 would reveal that in her previous statement to the police she had
not disclosed the said fact to the police. In this context, it is relevant to note
that the prosecution had not revealed, rather established, the genesis of the incident
that led to the death of Naseem Khan. In other words, none of the witnesses including
PWs 5 and 9 had deposed as to the genesis of the incident. This assumes relevance
as PW-8 herself deposed that she got no enmity with the families of the accused 
and got no land dispute with them. When this be the nature of the evidence of PWs
5 and 9 as also the evidence of PWs 2, 8 and 17, we are of the considered view that
there can be no good reason to hold that the prosecution had succeeded in conclusively
proving the guilt of the accused/respondents herein beyond reasonable doubt warranting
displacement of the finding of the High Court that in view of the omissions and 
contradictions, the oral testimonies of the aforesaid witnesses are not reliable
and the respondents herein are entitled to the benefit of doubt. We have already
taken note of the decision in **Dharmaraj’s case (supra)** involving a challenge
against judgment of acquittal in a murder case in reversal of conviction entered
against the accused by the trial Court holding that if on facts the view taken by
the High Court is a reasonable possible view, though not the only view that could
be taken, interference with acquittal would be uncalled for. In view of the nature
of the evidence discussed above and the finding of the High Court that the respondents/
accused are entitled to benefit of doubt and consequently for acquittal, we do not
find any reason to hold that it is not a reasonably possible view though not the
only view that could be taken.

##### **Apex court confirmed the acquittal**

30. The long and short of the above discussion is that we are not inclined to interfere
with the judgment of acquittal passed by the High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 602
of 1998. Hence the appeal stands dismissed.

##### **Party**

The State of Madhya Pradesh …Appellant(s) Versus Ramjan Khan & Ors. …Respondent(
s) – Criminal Appeal No. 2129 of 2014 – 2024 INSC 823 – October 25, 2024

[The State vs Ramjan Khan 178482013_2024-10-25](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/The-State-vs-Ramjan-Khan-178482013_2024-10-25.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/The-State-vs-Ramjan-Khan-178482013_2024-10-25.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
