# Appellant made total denial in his s.313 Cr.P.C statement which is contrary to he fact that he has been admitted in care hospital and no explanation to this denial lead to possession of poision

- Link: https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/
- Published: 2026-05-08T14:30:21+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against the high court judgment](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#appeal-against-the-high-court-judgment)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#facts)
    - [Both deceased and the appellant consumed poison and upon admitted in the hospital appellant survived](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#both-deceased-and-the-appellant-consumed-poison-and-upon-admitted-in-the-hospital-appellant-survived)
    - [FIR registered](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#fir-registered)
    - [Post mortem report doctor was neither on duty at the mortuary nor on call duty as professor](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#post-mortem-report-doctor-was-neither-on-duty-at-the-mortuary-nor-on-call-duty-as-professor)
    - [Post mortem doctor before giving report to the SHO gave TV interview as if the death of the deceased was due to gang rape and manual strangulation](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#post-mortem-doctor-before-giving-report-to-the-sho-gave-tv-interview-as-if-the-death-of-the-deceased-was-due-to-gang-rape-and-manual-strangulation)
    - [A.P FSL report revealed that the poison was found in the internal organs of the deceased](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#ap-fsl-report-revealed-that-the-poison-was-found-in-the-internal-organs-of-the-deceased)
    - [Post mortem doctor even after AP FSL report stuck to his opinion](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#post-mortem-doctor-even-after-ap-fsl-report-stuck-to-his-opinion)
    - [AP government constituted a three-member expert committee to submit a report](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#ap-government-constituted-a-threemember-expert-committee-to-submit-a-report)
    - [Writ petitions filed to transfer the case to CBI](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#writ-petitions-filed-to-transfer-the-case-to-cbi)
    - [Post Mortem doctor wrongly represented by filing affidavit that there was swelling in the neck and he had not mentioned these injuries in his postmortem report](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#post-mortem-doctor-wrongly-represented-by-filing-affidavit-that-there-was-swelling-in-the-neck-and-he-had-not-mentioned-these-injuries-in-his-postmortem-report)
    - [Investigation entrusted to CBI](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#investigation-entrusted-to-cbi)
    - [High Court of AP directed the CBI to conduct DNA test](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#high-court-of-ap-directed-the-cbi-to-conduct-dna-test)
    - [Upon examination none of the samples taken from the appellant and five other individuals matched with the male fraction of DNA found on the cotton swab](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#upon-examination-none-of-the-samples-taken-from-the-appellant-and-five-other-individuals-matched-with-the-male-fraction-of-dna-found-on-the-cotton-swab)
    - [CBI sought expert opinion from the FSL AAIMS New Delhi](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#cbi-sought-expert-opinion-from-the-fsl-aaims-new-delhi)
    - [Internal organs of the deceased were sent for FSL](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#internal-organs-of-the-deceased-were-sent-for-fsl)
    - [High Court closed the W.P and CBI filed charge sheet for offences under sections 306 and 309 IPC](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#high-court-closed-the-wp-and-cbi-filed-charge-sheet-for-offences-under-sections-306-and-309-ipc)
    - [Case of the prosecution](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#case-of-the-prosecution)
    - [Sessions court convicted the appellant-accused for sections 306 and 309](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#sessions-court-convicted-the-appellantaccused-for-sections-306-and-309)
    - [Criminal appeal filed by the accused and the criminal revision filed by the complainant (both are appellant in the present SLP) were dismissed by the High Court](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#criminal-appeal-filed-by-the-accused-and-the-criminal-revision-filed-by-the-complainant-both-are-appellant-in-the-present-slp-were-dismissed-by-the-high-court)
 * [Reasoning](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#reasoning)
 * [MURDER BY STRANGULATION IS RULED OUT](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#murder-by-strangulation-is-ruled-out)
    - [Deceased was able to speak demonstrates beyond doubt that strangulation was not the cause of death](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#deceased-was-able-to-speak-demonstrates-beyond-doubt-that-strangulation-was-not-the-cause-of-death)
    - [PW.13 stated that deceased testified to her that she had consumed poison](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#pw13-stated-that-deceased-testified-to-her-that-she-had-consumed-poison)
    - [No external injuries](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#no-external-injuries)
 * [OVERWHELMING OCULAR AND MEDICAL EVIDENCE PROVES DEATH DUE TO POISONING](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#overwhelming-ocular-and-medical-evidence-proves-death-due-to-poisoning)
    - [Death summary and post mortem report led to poison in stomach](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#death-summary-and-post-mortem-report-led-to-poison-in-stomach)
    - [Injuries found on the neck and wrist of the deceased had been due to court of treatment](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#injuries-found-on-the-neck-and-wrist-of-the-deceased-had-been-due-to-court-of-treatment)
 * [CONSEQUENCES OF PREMATURE AND DELIBERATE PUBLICATION](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#consequences-of-premature-and-deliberate-publication)
    - [Erroneous report and opinion through media far beyond individual misconduct](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#erroneous-report-and-opinion-through-media-far-beyond-individual-misconduct)
    - [Justice should not be erved through pressure and public sentiment but on evidence only](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#justice-should-not-be-erved-through-pressure-and-public-sentiment-but-on-evidence-only)
    - [Evidence Of Pw-34 Inspires Confidence and Is Trustworthy](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#evidence-of-pw34-inspires-confidence-and-is-trustworthy)
    - [Nothing on record to doubt the evidence of PW.34](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#nothing-on-record-to-doubt-the-evidence-of-pw34)
 * [ADVERSE INFERENCE AGAINST APPELLANT-ACCUSED](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#adverse-inference-against-appellantaccused)
    - [Appellant made total denial in his 313 Cr.P.C statement in fact he denied being admitted in care hospital and no explanation to this denial](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-313-crpc-statement-in-fact-he-denied-being-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial)
 * [DEFENCE OF ACCIDENTAL CONSUMPTION REJECTED](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#defence-of-accidental-consumption-rejected)
    - [Since the accused is an engineering student he understands the lethal nature of pesticide](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#since-the-accused-is-an-engineering-student-he-understands-the-lethal-nature-of-pesticide)
 * [ABETMENT BY PURCHASE OF NUVACRON](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#abetment-by-purchase-of-nuvacron)
    - [INAPPLICABILITY OF VELLADURAI (SUPRA) TO THE PRESENT CASE](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#inapplicability-of-velladurai-supra-to-the-present-case)
    - [SURVIVING PARTNER IN A MUTUAL SUICIDE PACT IS LEGALLY CULPABLE](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#surviving-partner-in-a-mutual-suicide-pact-is-legally-culpable)
    - [Accused conduct of entering into the suicide pact falls squarely within section 107 IPC](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#accused-conduct-of-entering-into-the-suicide-pact-falls-squarely-within-section-107-ipc)
 * [CONCLUSION](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#conclusion)
 * [Reference](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#reference)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/appellant-made-total-denial-in-his-s-313-cr-p-c-statement-which-is-contrary-to-he-fact-that-he-has-been-admitted-in-care-hospital-and-no-explanation-to-this-denial-lead-to-possession-of-poision/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against the high court judgment**

1. The present appeals have been filed challenging the common judgment and order
dated 28th December 2011 passed by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Criminal 
Appeal No. 405 of 2004 and [Criminal Revision Case](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-public-prosecutor-while-explaining-the-principles-of-106-iea-in-criminal-cases-honble-supreme-court-has-addressed-the-government-to-appoint-skilled-lawyers-as-public-prosec/)
No. 2055 of 2004, whereby the criminal [appeal filed by the Appellant-Accused and the criminal revision](https://section1.in/neither-the-state-nor-the-victim-nor-the-complainant-had-sought-enhancement-in-appeal-but-the-high-court-converted-the-sentence-into-a-conviction-of-the-accused-in-a-suo-motu-revision-is-illegal/)
filed by the mother of the deceased were dismissed. By way of the Impugned Judgment,
the High Court reduced the sentence for [offence punishable under Section 306 IPC](https://section1.in/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)
to two years but increased the fine to ₹ 50,000/.

2. It is pertinent to mention that the Criminal [Appeal](https://section1.in/whether-complainant-should-obtain-special-leave-in-the-case-of-appeal-against-acquittal-referred-to-larger-bench/)
and Criminal Revision were filed against the judgment dated 23rd February 2004 in
Sessions Case No.88 of 2003, whereby the Appellant-Accused was convicted for offences
punishable under Sections 306 and 309 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (“IPC”) and sentenced
to rigorous imprisonment for five years and fined ₹ 5,000/- under Section 306 IPC
and one year simple imprisonment and fined ₹ 1,000/- under Section 309 IPC.

#### **Facts**

3. The deceased Ms. Pratyusha was an actress, who had acted as a heroine in a number
of feature films in South India. The Appellant-Accused was an engineering student.
They had known each other close to a decade and wanted to marry each other. Smt.
Sarojini Devi (PW-1), mother of the deceased and [Appellant in Criminal Appeal](https://section1.in/supreme-court-set-guidelines-for-the-appellate-courts-on-how-to-appreciate-appeals-against-acquittal/)
Nos.894-895 of 2012 was initially opposed to the marriage but had subsequently agreed
to it. However, the parents of the Appellant-Accused were opposed to the marriage
and the mother of the Appellant-Accused had even threatened to [commit suicide](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-the-act-of-instigation-must-be-of-such-intensity-to-drive-deceased-to-commit-suicide/)
in the event the Appellant-Accused married the deceased.

4. In the morning of 23rd February 2002, the Appellant-Accused informed the deceased
of the threat of suicide extended by his mother. At around 5:00 PM, the deceased
along with her cousin Ms. Prafulla Sri (PW-2) went to a beauty parlour as the deceased
had been engaged for a Kannada feature film and had planned to leave for Bangalore
on the morning of 24th February 2002.

5. At the parlour, the deceased asked Ms. Prafulla Sri (PW-2) to call the Appellant-
Accused to the parlour. Upon his arrival, PW-2 talked to the Appellant-Accused for
a while and when the deceased came out of the parlour, the Appellant-Accused and
the deceased started crying and left together in the car of the former.

##### **Both deceased and the appellant consumed poison and upon admitted in the hospital appellant survived**

6. Both the deceased and the Appellant-Accused were thereafter [seen together](https://section1.in/last-seen-together-explained/)
at CARE Hospital, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad (‘CARE Hospital) at around 7:30 or 8:
00 PM. Both of them had consumed poison and were admitted in the said hospital. 
The deceased could not survive and passed away the next day, i.e., 24th February
2002. The Appellant-Accused, however, survived and was discharged from the hospital
on 09th March 2002.

##### **FIR registered**

7. Upon a complaint made by Sarojini Devi (PW-1), FIR No. 144 of 2002 dated 24th
February 2002 was registered under Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure(“
CrPC”) at Panjagutta [Police Station](https://section1.in/alibi-accused-must-prove-the-alibi-after-getting-answer-from-the-witness-that-the-accused-was-not-in-police-station/),
Hyderabad.

##### **Post mortem report doctor was neither on duty at the mortuary nor on call duty as professor**

8. On 25th February 2002 one Dr. B. Muni Swamy conducted the postmortem examination
of the deceased. Even though one Dr. Krupal Singh was the doctor on duty at the 
mortuary, Dr. B. Muni Swamy, Professor, came to the mortuary on his own and conducted
postmortem of the deceased. This is surprising as Dr. B. Muni Swamy was neither 
on duty at the mortuary nor on call duty as Professor. Further, Dr. Rajgopal Reddy,
HOD, Department of Forensic Medicine [informed the investigative agency](https://section1.in/once-a-foreigner-is-released-on-bail-he-cannot-leave-india-without-the-permission-of-the-civil-authority-and-the-court-should-direct-the-investigating-agency-or-the-state-to-inform-the-concerned-regis/)
subsequently that Dr. B. Muni Swamy did not intimate or seek permission for conducting
the postmortem. The postmortem report dated 25th February 2002 is reproduced hereinbelow:-

“report”

##### **Post mortem doctor before giving report to the SHO gave TV interview as if the death of the deceased was due to gang rape and manual strangulation**

9. It is to be noted here that Dr. B. Muni Swamy made his opinion public by giving
an interview on Teja TV on 25th February 2002, even before giving the postmortem
report to the SHO on 26th February 2002 and before receiving the AP FSL report on
27th February 2002. In the interview Dr. B. Muni Swamy stated that the deceased 
died of manual strangulation and that she was gang raped.

##### **A.P FSL report revealed that the poison was found in the internal organs of the deceased**

10. However, the Andhra Pradesh Forensic Science Laboratory (“AP FSL”) report dated
27th February 2002 revealed that organophosphate an insecticide poison was found
in the internal organs of the deceased and the stomach wash of both the accused 
and the deceased. The AP FSL report dated 27th February 2002 is reproduced hereinunder:

“A.P FSL report”

##### **Post mortem doctor even after AP FSL report stuck to his opinion**

11. Even after the receipt of the AP FSL report dated 27th February 2002, Dr. B.
Muni Swamy stuck to his opinion that the death was due to manual strangulation and
that [sexual assault](https://section1.in/pocso-accused-is-guilty-of-having-committed-sexual-assault-and-not-of-penetrative-sexual-assault/)
could not be ruled out.

##### **AP government constituted a three-member expert committee to submit a report**

12. In view of the difference of opinion regarding the [cause of death and the public outcry caused due](https://section1.in/section-304-part-ii-ipc-though-cause-of-death-is-due-to-injuries-no-intention-found/)
to the sensation created by the interview given by Dr. B. Muni Swamy, the Government
of Andhra Pradesh vide G.O.Rt. No. 174 dated 05th March 2002, constituted a three-
member Expert Committee comprising Dr. M. Narayana Reddy (PW-31), Dr. P. Vijaya 
Kumar and Dr. K. Sathyavathi to conduct an enquiry and [submit a report](https://section1.in/magistrate-shall-consider-both-the-final-reports-and-proceed-further-if-further-investigation-u-s-1738-cr-p-c-shows-the-accused-is-innocent/).

13. The three-member Expert Committee gave its findings vide report dated 09th March
2002 stating the following:

“Three-member committee report”

##### **Writ petitions filed to transfer the case to CBI**

14. Due to the interview given by Dr. B. Muni Swamy in a matter pending investigation
regarding the cause of death of an actress and finding of sexual assault and the
controversy arising therefrom, [public interest](https://section1.in/quash-though-settlement-between-the-parties-taken-place-after-the-commission-of-offence-and-since-no-continuing-public-interest-apex-court-quashed-the-case/)
litigations being Writ Petitions Nos. 4054 and 4329 of 2002 were [filed before the High Court](https://section1.in/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)
of Andhra Pradesh seeking an investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation(“
CBI”).

##### **Post Mortem doctor wrongly represented by filing affidavit that there was swelling in the neck and he had not mentioned these injuries in his postmortem report**

15. Pertinently, Dr. B. Muni Swamy in his [affidavit dated 20th March 2002 filed before the High Court](https://section1.in/court-cannot-convert-complaint-into-a-1563-cr-p-c-petition-without-following-procedures/)
wrongly represented that there was swelling of the neck of the deceased and that
there were injuries on the back of the thighs even though he had not mentioned these
injuries in his postmortem report dated 25th February 2002.

##### **Investigation entrusted to CBI**

16. The investigation was entrusted by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh to the CBI
vide order dated 21st March 2002 passed in Writ Petitions Nos. 4054 and 4329 of 
2002.

17. Accordingly, CBI [registered an FIR](https://section1.in/police-has-no-other-option-except-to-register-fir-if-cognizable-offences-found-magistrate-must-direct-investigation-if-cognizable-offence-found-in-the-complaint/)
dated 28th March 2002 in Crime No.RC-1/S/2002/CBI/SCB/Chennai for offences punishable
under Section 302 IPC.

##### **High Court of AP directed the CBI to conduct DNA test**

18. On 26th March 2002, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh directed the Director, 
Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics (“CDFD”) to conduct a DNA test on 
the basis of swabs [collected from APFSL and submit a report to the Court](https://section1.in/court-cannot-return-final-report/).

##### **Upon examination none of the samples taken from the appellant and five other individuals matched with the male fraction of DNA found on the cotton swab**

19. Accordingly, DNA tests were conducted on the basis of cotton swab collected 
from AP FSL and the samples submitted by the mother of the deceased and Appellant
in Criminal Appeal Nos.894-895 of 2012. Pertinently, the report dated 24th April
2002 revealed that cotton swab contained two fractions of DNA i.e. female fraction
and male fraction. The female fraction matched with the DNA of the mother of the
deceased and Appellant in Criminal Appeal Nos.894-895 of 2012. However, to ascertain
the source of the male fraction, samples were taken from the Appellant-Accused herein
and five other individuals known to the Appellant-Accused. Upon examination, none
of the samples which were taken from the Appellant-Accused and five other individuals
matched with the male fraction of the DNA found on the cotton swab. The [relevant portions](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-contradiction-public-prosecutor-has-to-confront-relevant-portions-to-the-witness-and-contradict-as-required-by-section-145-iea/)
of the CDFD reports dated 5th April 2002, 24th April 2002 and 13th May 2002 are 
reproduced hereinbelow: –

“report”

##### **CBI sought expert opinion from the FSL AAIMS New Delhi**

20. The CBI vide its letter dated 19th April 2002 (Ex. P-55) [sought expert opinion](https://section1.in/prosecution-did-not-sought-opinion-as-to-the-death-to-show-whether-it-was-suicide-or-accidental/)
from the Department of Forensic Medicine, All India Institute of Medical Sciences(“
AIIMS”) New Delhi, inter alia, as to the exact cause of death and the finding of
manual strangulation in the postmortem report dated 25th February 2002.

##### **Internal organs of the deceased were sent for FSL**

22. Meanwhile, the internal organs of the deceased, the stomach wash of both the
deceased and the Appellant-Accused and a bottle labeled ‘Nuvacron’ were sent for
forensic examination to Central Forensic Science Laboratory (“CFSL”), which gave
two reports dated 16th May, 2002 and 20th May, 2002.

23. A perusal of the report dated 16th May 2002 reveals that Monocrotophos, an organo-
phosphorous insecticide was detected in the internal organs of the deceased and 
in the bottle labeled as ‘Nuvacron’. However, Monocrotophos an organo-phosphorous
insecticide was not found in the stomach wash of the Appellant-Accused and the deceased.
In another report dated 20th May 2002 submitted by CFSL, it was stated that no semen
could be detected on the portion of cotton swab or the cloth belonging to the deceased.
The relevant portion of the reports dated 16th May 2002 and 20th May 2002 are reproduced
hereinbelow:-

“……………”

##### **High Court closed the W.P and CBI filed charge sheet for offences under sections 306 and 309 IPC**

25. The High [Court after examining the entire record including the affidavit filed](https://section1.in/dont-mention-as-lower-courts-acquittal-based-on-the-affidavits-filed-by-the-eyewitness-in-court/)
by Dr. B. Muni Swamy closed the public interest litigations vide its order dated
6th September 2002 and permitted the CBI to file its charge-sheet. Accordingly, 
CBI filed a chargesheet for offences punishable under [Sections](https://section1.in/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)
306 and 309 IPC.

##### **Case of the prosecution**

34. The [case of the prosecution](https://section1.in/in-dowry-death-cases-prosecution-has-to-prove-the-initial-burden/)
was that due to opposition to the marriage proposal between the deceased and the
Appellant-Accused by the family of the latter, both of them decided to commit suicide
by consuming ‘Nuvacron’ pesticide mixed with coca-cola. According to the prosecution,
it was the AppellantAccused who purchased the poison, i.e., ‘Nuvacron’ on the evening
of 23rd February 2002 from G. Anil Kumar (PW-34) who was at that time a salesman
in a shop called Revathi Agencies at Hyderguda, Hyderabad. Further, the AppellantAccused
also procured chocolate and knife from Anand Rao (PW-35) who at the time was working
in Foodworld Shop at Himayatnagar. Relevant portion of the testimonies of G. Anil
Kumar (PW-34) and Anand Rao (PW-35) are reproduced hereinbelow:

“….”

##### **Sessions court convicted the appellant-accused for sections 306 and 309**

35. The Sessions [Court vide judgment](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
dated 23rd February 2004 convicted the Appellant-Accused of offences punishable 
under Sections 306, and 309 IPC and sentenced him to rigorous imprisonment for five
years and fined ₹ 5,000/- under Section 306 IPC and one year simple imprisonment
and fined ₹1,000/- under Section 309 IPC. The relevant portion of the judgment dated
23rd February 2004 is reproduced hereinbelow:-

“……”

##### **Criminal appeal filed by the accused and the criminal revision filed by the complainant (both are appellant in the present SLP) were dismissed by the High Court**

36. Vide the impugned judgment, the criminal [appeal filed](https://section1.in/complainants-are-victim-in-cheque-cases-and-they-may-file-appeal-against-acquittal-under-section-372-cr-p-c-itself-without-seeking-special-leave-under-section-3784-cr-p-c/)
by the AppellantAccused and the criminal revision filed by the Appellant-Complainant,
were dismissed. The relevant portion of the said judgment is reproduced hereinbelow:-

“……”

#### **Reasoning**

#### **MURDER BY STRANGULATION IS RULED OUT**

##### **Deceased was able to speak demonstrates beyond doubt that strangulation was not the cause of death**

79. This Court is of the view that the allegation of [homicidal death](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-though-homicidal-death-is-not-disputed-accused-has-successfully-disproved-the-extra-judicial-confession-through-defence-witness/)
by manual strangulation is wholly unsustainable. The testimony of PW-1, the mother
of the deceased and appellant in Criminal Appeal Nos. 894–895 of 2012, is particularly
telling. She admitted that when she saw her daughter in the ICU of CARE Hospital,
the latter was not only alive but also conscious, able to respond in a feeble voice
to the doctor’s questions and her legs were trembling. Such a condition is medically
inconsistent with strangulation. The fact that the deceased was able to speak and
exhibit motor activity demonstrates beyond doubt that strangulation was not the 
cause of death.

##### **PW.13 stated that deceased testified to her that she had consumed poison**

80. This conclusion is further reinforced by the testimony of Dr. Laxmi Kanthaiah(
PW-13), who stated that at the time of admission, the deceased was conscious and
herself disclosed that she had consumed poison. Dr. Saraschandra (PW-10) corroborated
this account, testifying that both the deceased and the accused informed him that
they had consumed organophosphate poison. These statements, made contemporaneously
by the deceased herself, carry great evidentiary weight and cannot be brushed aside.

##### **No external injuries**

81. Moreover, three [witnesses namely](https://section1.in/in-complaint-cases-the-complainant-is-not-bound-to-examine-all-the-witnesses-named-in-the-complaint/),
Dr. Kalyansundaram (PW-32), Dr. Saraschandra (PW-10) and A. Anitha (PW-16), all 
confirmed that they observed no external injuries on the deceased’s body. The absence
of injuries is significant because strangulation ordinarily leaves tell-tale signs
such as abrasions, bruises or hemorrhages.

82. Taken together, these facts conclusively establish that the deceased was conscious
at the time of admission, bore no injuries consistent with strangulation and herself
disclosed poisoning. The argument of death by strangulation is therefore ruled out.

#### **OVERWHELMING OCULAR AND MEDICAL EVIDENCE PROVES DEATH DUE TO POISONING**

83. Having ruled out strangulation, the Court turns to the actual cause of death.
A wealth of ocular and medical [evidence](https://section1.in/literature-on-secondary-evidence-judgment-explaining-statutory-procedure-to-introduce-mark-and-appreciate-secondary-evidence/)
points to poisoning. The materials on record, when examined holistically, leave 
no room for doubt that the deceased died due to consumption of organophosphate poison,
specifically Nuvacron.

84. Dr. Laxmi Kanthaiah (PW-13) of CARE Hospital has deposed that the deceased had
informed her in the ICU that she had consumed poison which was some sort of pesticide.
Dr. Kalyanasundram (PW-32) of CARE Hospital has deposed that when he was informed
that the deceased and the Appellant-Accused had consumed poison he had asked his
junior resident doctors to secure the container of the poison through the relative
of the persons. Dr. Kalyanasundram (PW-32) has further deposed that after about 
two hours the friends of the Appellant-Accused had shown him the poison container
which was marked as M.O.1 which contained Nuvacron poison. Dr. Saraschandra (PW-
10) of CARE Hospital has deposed that Ex. P-17 & P-18 prepared at the time of admission
mentioned that the deceased and the Appellant-Accused had consumed Organophosphate
poison and the entire line of treatment in the hospital was on that basis. Even,
[Investigating Officer](https://section1.in/officers-investigating-the-offence-are-duty-bound-to-be-vigilant-before-invoking-any-provision-of-a-very-stringent-statute-like-the-sc-st-act/)(
PW-24) has deposed that the mother of the deceased and appellant in Criminal Appeal
Nos.894-895 of 2012 and the uncle of the deceased had informed him that the deceased
had consumed poison.

##### **Death summary and post mortem report led to poison in stomach**

85. Also, the death summary prepared by CARE Hospital mentions the cause of death
as Organophosphate poison. Even, the postmortem report dated 25th February 2002 
prepared by Dr. B. Muni Swamy records that the stomach of the deceased contained
150 ml. yellowish brown liquid with thick consistency and an abnormal odor with 
the congested mucosa.

86. Additionally, the AP FSL upon a chemical analysis of viscera and stomach wash
of the deceased had stated in its report dated 27th February 2002 that it had found
Organophosphate, an insecticide poison, in all the body pieces and liquids forwarded
to it for examination.

87. Further, Mr. R.K. Sarine (PW-26), CFSL Hyd., confirmed the presence of Monocrotophos
in the items sent to FSL. Dr. M. Narayana Reddy (PW-31) reiterated his opinion given
in three-member Expert Committee report dated 09th March 2002 that death was caused
by poison. Dr. D.N. Baradwaj (PW-33), Additional Professor Forensic Medicine and
Toxicology, AIIMS stated that considering all the documents provided, the observations
recorded in PME report dated 25th February 2002 prepared by Dr. B. Muni Swamy did
not appear to be indictive of manual strangulation as the congestion in the brain
and abdominal organs, as found in the [present case](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/),
is found in cases of Organophosphate poisoning.

88. Consequently, the convergence of multiple independent expert opinions lends 
overwhelming credibility to the conclusion that the deceased died of poisoning.

##### **Injuries found on the neck and wrist of the deceased had been due to court of treatment**

94. Also, Dr. Kalyanasundram (PW-32) of CARE Hospital has clarified to the [Investigating Officer](https://section1.in/officers-investigating-the-offence-are-duty-bound-to-be-vigilant-before-invoking-any-provision-of-a-very-stringent-statute-like-the-sc-st-act/)(
PW-24) that injuries found on the neck and the wrist of the deceased had been caused
during the course of treatment.

95. Consequently, in light of the deceased’s own statement, hospital records, forensic
reports and expert opinions, allegations of rape or murder are devoid of legal or
factual foundation.

#### **CONSEQUENCES OF PREMATURE AND DELIBERATE PUBLICATION**

##### **Erroneous report and opinion through media far beyond individual misconduct**

103. The premature and erroneous opinion of Dr. Muni Swamy unleashed a wave of public
controversy. Media reports amplified his conclusions, leading to widespread suspicion
of investigators and calls for immediate action against alleged perpetrators. This
demonstrates how a single erroneous report, when publicised prematurely, can distort
public perception and derail the course of justice.

104. This Court is of the view that the impact of a doctor issuing an erroneous 
postmortem report and publicising it through the media goes far beyond individual
misconduct. It spreads misinformation, erodes trust in investigative agencies and
institutions such as the police and judiciary, prejudices public opinion, traumatises
the victim’s family, and undermines the rule of law. Such misconduct does not merely
harm one case; it corrodes public trust in medicine, law, and governance, destabilising
peace and harmony in society. It also violates the sub judice rule, which restricts
commentary on matters under judicial consideration to preserve fairness and integrity.

##### **Justice should not be erved through pressure and public sentiment but on evidence only**

105. The Court emphasises that justice is not served by following majority sentiment
or public pressure. Justice is served by truth, established through evidence and
impartial investigation. While public outrage is understandable in high-profile 
cases, it should never dictate the course of inquiry. Investigations require careful
collection of evidence, impartial analysis, and conclusions grounded in fact. Allowing
public sentiment to shape outcomes risks miscarriages of justice. A society committed
to fairness must recognise that investigators and courts serve the truth, not popularity.
Their independence is not a luxury but the foundation of justice itself.

106. Consequently, this Court holds that the conduct of Dr. Muni Swamy in furnishing
an erroneous report, publicising it prematurely and thereby violating professional
ethics and the sub judice rule constitutes contempt of Court. It also breaches medical
ethics, which demand competence, honesty and diligence. However, in view of his 
demise, this Court refrains from imposing any further consequences.

##### **Evidence Of Pw-34 Inspires Confidence and Is Trustworthy**

    ```wp-block-verse
    107. The submission that Appellant-Accused is entitled to benefit of doubt merely because of a purportedly faulty TIP is untenable. In the present case, G. Anil Kumar (PW-34) and Anand Rao (PW-35) identified the accused in Court as the person who purchased Nuvacron as well as knife and chocolates. It is pertinent to mention that TIPs are primarily meant to give an assurance to the investigating agency that their progress with the investigation into the offence is proceeding in the right direction. TIP or identification in Court is not sine qua non in every case if from circumstances the guilt is otherwise established. The fact that a particular witness has been able to identify the accused at an identification parade is only a circumstance corroborative of the identification in Court.
    ```

##### **Nothing on record to doubt the evidence of PW.34**

108. This Court is of the view that the [evidence](https://section1.in/whether-the-judicial-confession-of-an-approver-is-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence/)
of PW-34 with respect to identification of the Appellant-Accused as the person who
bought ‘Nuvacron’ on 23rd February 2002 inspires confidence. There is nothing on
record to doubt his deposition.

109. The contention of the learned senior counsel for the Appellant-Accused that
Ex. P-42 is not a reliable document as the said bill shows sale of three items when
allegedly the accused had purchased only a single item, is misconceived on facts.
A perusal of the deposition of G. Anil Kumar (PW-34) shows that he has explained
that all the three items mentioned in Ex. P-42 were not purchased by the same person
and that Ex.P-42 bill reflected consolidated daily sales for accounting purposes,
not a single transaction. His explanation is logical and consistent with business
practice and therefore the objection is rejected.

#### **ADVERSE INFERENCE AGAINST APPELLANT-ACCUSED**

##### **Appellant made total denial in his 313 Cr.P.C statement in fact he denied being admitted in care hospital and no explanation to this denial**

110. Additionally, it is an admitted fact that both the deceased and the AppellantAccused
consumed poison. It is also an admitted fact that both the deceased and Appellant-
Accused were seen outside the beauty parlor and thereafter seen together in the 
hospital for their treatment. Since the deceased is no more, it was for the Appellant-
Accused to [explain the circumstances](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/)
in which the poison was purchased and consumed. In his Section 313 CrPC statement,
the response of the [accused was that of complete](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/)
denial. In fact, not only did the Appellant-Accused denied being in a relationship
with the deceased, but he also denied being admitted in CARE Hospital, despite overwhelming
evidence to the contrary. No explanation regarding the manner of purchase or consumption
of pesticide was forthcoming from the Appellant-Accused. It was not his case that
the deceased or some other person had purchased the poison for them or that either
of them were in possession of the poison prior to the date of the incident. Consequently,
in the circumstances, an adverse inference has to be drawn against the AppellantAccused.[
See: Munna Kumar Upadhyay Alias Munna Upadhyaya vs. State of Andhra Pradesh Through
Public Prosecutor, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, (2012) 6 SCC 1741 ; State of W.B. 
vs. Mir Mohammad Omar & Ors., (2000) 8 SCC 3822 ; RajKumar vs. State of Madhya Pradesh,(
2014) 5 SCC 3533 ; Munish Mubar vs, State of Haryana, (2012) 10 SCC 4644 ]

#### **DEFENCE OF ACCIDENTAL CONSUMPTION REJECTED**

##### **Since the accused is an engineering student he understands the lethal nature of pesticide**

111. The accused’s contention that he consumed pesticide either accidentally or 
with intent to threaten family members is implausible. As an engineering student,
he was expected to understand the lethal nature of pesticide. There is no evidence
to suggest that he mistook pesticide for a harmless substance. His defence is therefore
rejected as unbelievable.

112. Pertinently, the pesticide Nuvacron is one of the highly toxic pesticides available
for purchase. It is the evidence of PW-34 that the accused came to the shop and 
asked for Nuvacron, meaning thereby that the accused was likely aware of the toxicity
of the said pesticide and had purchased it with the knowledge that ingesting the
same will likely result in death.

#### **ABETMENT BY PURCHASE OF NUVACRON**

**Abetment explained**

113. The offence of abetment is defined under Section 107 of the IPC, the same is
reproduced hereinbelow:-

> “107. Abetment of a thing.—A person abets the doing of a thing, who—
> First.—Instigates any person to do that thing; or
> Secondly.—Engages with one or more other person or persons in any conspiracy for
> the doing of that thing, if an act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance
> of that conspiracy, and in order to the doing of that thing; or
> Thirdly.—Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the doing of that
> thing.
> Explanation 1.—A person who, by wilful misrepresentation, or by wilful concealment
> of a material fact which he is bound to disclose, voluntarily causes or procures,
> or attempts to cause or procure, a thing to be done, is said to instigate the 
> doing of that thing.”

114. Also, in order to constitute abetment, the abettors [must have intentionally aided the commission of offence](https://section1.in/quash-cheating-in-order-to-constitute-an-offence-of-cheating-the-intention-to-cheat-must-be-available-from-the-inception/).
Aiding can be construed as an act of intentionally facilitating the commission of
an offence.

115. In the present case, the Appellant-Accused has abetted the offence under Section
306 of the IPC by purchasing the pesticide with the knowledge of its lethal nature.
Furthermore, in absence of any explanation by the accused as to why the deceased
and the accused consumed poison would lead to an adverse inference that it was consumed
with intent to commit suicide. Driving to the hospital is a natural human conduct
in face of death.

##### **INAPPLICABILITY OF VELLADURAI (SUPRA) TO THE PRESENT CASE**

116. The judgment in Velladurai (supra) is not applicable to the present matter 
as in the said case, the accused-husband had harassed the deceased-wife to the extent
that she was left with no [option but to commit suicide](https://section1.in/a-gap-of-over-a-month-would-be-a-sufficient-time-to-dissolve-the-proximate-link-between-the-two-acts-instigation-and-suicide/).
In the said case, there were no allegations of aiding the deceased wife in commission
of suicide.

##### **SURVIVING PARTNER IN A MUTUAL SUICIDE PACT IS LEGALLY CULPABLE**

117. Notwithstanding the culpability of the act of purchasing pesticide, the Accused’s
participation in a suicide pact renders him culpable under [Section](https://section1.in/there-cannot-be-a-conspiracy-by-only-one-accused/)
107 IPC. A suicide pact involves mutual encouragement and reciprocal commitment 
to die together. The survivor’s presence and participation acts as a direct catalyst
for the deceased’s actions. It is pertinent to mention that abetting as defined 
under [Section 107 IPC is not limited to physical act](https://section1.in/sudden-provocation-overt-act-of-killing-the-deceased-happened-during-a-fit-of-anger-in-the-heat-of-a-passionate-verbal-quarrel-and-would-fall-under-exception-4-to-section-300-ipc/)
of supplying means to commit suicide. Accordingly, any psychological assurance or
instigation, as long as the same is intentional and directly related to the commission
of offence, also constitutes abetment.

118. This Court is of the view that it is the reciprocal commitment of each party
to commit suicide which provides necessary impetus/support to the other to go through
with the act. In a suicide pact, it is implicit that each participant knows the 
intent of the other to commit the act knowing that their withdrawal from the pact
will likely deter the other. Each party’s resolve to commit the act is, therefore,
reinforced and strengthened due to the participation of the other party. Suicide
in a suicide pact is conditional upon mutual participation of the other. In other
words, if not for the active participation of both the parties, the act would not
occur. The law treats such conduct as abetment because the State has a fundamental
interest in preserving life. Any assistance in ending life is treated as a crime
against the State.

##### **Accused conduct of entering into the suicide pact falls squarely within section 107 IPC**

    ```wp-block-verse
    119. Consequently, this Court holds that the accused’s conduct in entering into and acting upon the suicide pact falls squarely within all the three situations envisaged in Section 107 of the IPC. His participation directly facilitated the deceased’s suicide. Notably, it is not his defence that the deceased was the dominant personality who pressured him into the pact. His culpability therefore stands established.
    ```

#### **CONCLUSION**

120. Keeping in view the aforesaid reasons, the present Appeals being bereft of 
merits are dismissed, but with no order as to costs. The Appellant is directed to
surrender within four weeks.

#### **Reference**

[Directly Cited Supreme Court](https://section1.in/suo-moto-guidelines-common-practice-and-procedure-in-criminal-trials-all-over-india/)
Precedents

 * Abhinav Mohan Delkar vs. State of Maharashtra and Others (2025) SCC Online SC
   1725 – Defines the essential ingredients of abetment of suicide.
 * Patel Babubhai Manohardas and Ors. vs. State of Gujarat (2025) SCC Online SC 
   503 – Regarding the liability of an abettor present at the scene under Section
   114 IPC.
 * Velladurai vs. State (2022) 17 SCC 523 – Distinguished from the current case 
   regarding active roles in suicide pacts.
 * Gian Kaur vs. State of Punjab (1996) 2 SCC 648 – Regarding the right to be released
   under the Probation of Offenders Act for Section 309 IPC offenses.
 * Dana Yadav alias Dahu and Ors. vs. State of Bihar (2002) 7 SCC 295 – Establishes
   that court identification is admissible even if a [Test Identification Parade](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-not-proved/)(
   TIP) was not held.

Precedents on Identification Evidence: Cited to address the reliability of witness
identification in court:

 * Umesh Chandra vs. State of Uttarakhand (2021) 17 SCC 616
 * Amrik Singh vs. State of Punjab (2022) 9 SCC 402
 * Ganpat Singh vs. State of Rajasthan (1997) 11 SCC 565
 * Girja Shankar Misra vs. State of U.P. 1994 Supp (1) SCC 26

Precedents on [Section 106 Evidence Act](https://section1.in/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/)&
Adverse Inference: Cited regarding the burden of proof for facts within the “exclusive
knowledge” of the accused:

 * Munna Kumar Upadhyay vs. State of Andhra Pradesh (2012) 6 SCC 174
 * Munish Mubar vs. State of Haryana (2012) 10 SCC 464
 * State of W.B. vs. Mir Mohammad Omar & Ors. (2000) 8 SCC 382
 * RajKumar vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2014) 5 SCC 353

The legal history of this case:

 * [Trial Court](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/):
   Judgment dated February 23, 2004, in Sessions Case No. 88 of 2003 (Conviction
   under Sections 306/309 IPC).
 * High Court of Andhra Pradesh: Common judgment dated December 28, 2011, in Criminal
   Appeal No. 405 of 2004 and Criminal Revision Case No. 2055 of 2004.
 * PIL/Writ Jurisdiction: Orders dated March 21, 2002, and September 6, 2002, in
   Writ Petitions Nos. 4054 and 4329 of 2002 (Transferring investigation to the 
   CBI).

Acts and Sections

Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860

 * Section 306 (Abetment of Suicide): The primary charge against the appellant. 
   The Court held that purchasing lethal pesticide and participating in a [“suicide pact” constituted intentional aiding and instigation](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-there-must-be-either-an-instigation-or-an-engagement-or-intentional-aid-to-doing-of-a-thing-and-based-on-that-accused-must-have-encouraged-the-person-to-commit-suici/).
 * Section 309 (Attempt to Commit Suicide): Applied because the appellant also consumed
   the poison but survived. The Court noted that driving to a hospital afterward
   is a natural human conduct and does not negate the initial attempt.
 * Section 107 (Abetment): Used to define the three ways abetment occurs: instigation,
   conspiracy, and intentional aiding. The [Court found the appellant’s](https://section1.in/section-391-cr-p-c-if-no-questions-put-to-the-witnesses-or-lead-evidence-the-appellate-court-has-no-obligation-to-allow-application-filed-under-section-391-cr-p-c/)
   actions fell under all three.
 * Section 114 (Abettor present when [offence is committed): Cited to establish that an abettor present at the time of the act is deemed to have committed](https://section1.in/offence-committed-in-journey-or-voyage/)
   the act themselves.
 * Section 302 (Murder): While the original [FIR was registered under this section](https://section1.in/section-188-ipc-registering-fir-investigation-procedure-explained/),
   the Court ruled out homicidal death by strangulation, confirming it was a case
   of poisoning.

Indian [Evidence Act](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/),
1872

 * Section 106 (Burden of proving fact especially within knowledge): The [Court drew an adverse inference against the appellant](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/)
   because he failed to explain facts exclusively known to him (the events leading
   to the poisoning) and instead offered a “complete denial.
 * Section 32(1) (Dying Declaration): The deceased’s statement to the doctor at 
   CARE Hospital—confirming she consumed pesticide—was treated as a relevant and
   heavyweight [piece](https://section1.in/the-statement-of-the-complainant-recorded-in-the-abscondence-proceedings-is-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-as-per-section-299-cr-p-c-read-with-section-33-of-iea/)
   of evidence.
 * Section 8 & 9 (Conduct and Facts): The appellant argued their conduct (going 
   to the hospital) suggested accidental consumption, but the Court rejected this,
   viewing it as a natural reaction to the fear of death.
 * Section 114 (Presumption of existence of certain facts): Discussed regarding 
   the appellant’s awareness of the toxicity of the pesticide he purchased.

Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), 1973

 * Section 174 (Inquest): The initial investigation into the cause of death.
 * Section 313 (Power to examine the accused): The [Court highlighted the appellant’s](https://section1.in/appeal-against-acquittal-appellate-court-would-not-scrutinize-evidence-once-again-unless-there-has-been-a-total-miscarriage-of-justice/)
   false answers during his examination (denying even his relationship with the 
   deceased) as a basis for drawing an adverse inference.
 * Section 386(b) (Powers of the Appellate Court): Mentioned regarding the High 
   Court’s power to [set aside convictions or order](https://section1.in/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/)
   retrials.

Other Statutes

 * Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (Section 4): The appellant sought release under
   this Act. While the Court noted precedents for Section 309 IPC, it ultimately
   dismissed the appeals, meaning the benefit was not extended for the Section 306
   conviction.
 * Andhra Pradesh Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964: Cited in relation to the
   disciplinary action recommended against Dr. B. Muni Swamy for his “unprofessional”
   postmortem report.

#### **Party**

**Gudipalli Siddhartha Reddy vs. State C.B.I –** [2026 INSC 160](https://api.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2012/660/660_2012_12_1501_68565_Judgement_17-Feb-2026.pdf)–**
Criminal Appeal No. 457 of 2012** – **February 17, 2026** – **Justice Rajesh Bindal**
and **Justice Manmohan**.

[Gudipalli Siddhartha Reddy vs. State CBI 660_2012_12_1501_68565_Judgement_17-Feb-2026](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Gudipalli-Siddhartha-Reddy-vs.-State-CBI-660_2012_12_1501_68565_Judgement_17-Feb-2026.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Gudipalli-Siddhartha-Reddy-vs.-State-CBI-660_2012_12_1501_68565_Judgement_17-Feb-2026.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [Dock identification not relied since the Test Identification was not conducted](https://section1.in/dock-identification-not-relied-since-the-test-identification-was-not-conducted/)
 * [Section 9 Evidence Act: Test identification parade not proved](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-not-proved/)
 * [Test Identification parade (TIP) is not a substantive piece of evidence and it hits under section 162 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-tip-is-not-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-it-is-hit-u-s-162-cr-p-c/)
 * [Detailed analysis of the test identification parade](https://section1.in/detailed-analysis-of-test-identification-parade/)
 * [What is substantive evidence and how to conduct questioning under section 313 Cr.P.C?](https://section1.in/what-is-substantive-evidebnce-how-to-conduct-questioning-u-s-313-cr-p-c/)
