# Application of mind during taking cognizance means to contemplate on the material submitted and not checking veracity of the same

- Link: https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/
- Published: 2025-04-25T10:12:00+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

    - [Appeal against remand order of Hon’ble High Court](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#appeal-against-remand-order-of-honble-high-court)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#facts)
    - [Brief factual background](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#brief-factual-background)
    - [FIR was registered after 26 years against the accused for the offences under sections 498A, 406 and 420 of the IPC and 3(1)(iv) of the ‘SC/ST Act](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#fir-was-registered-after-26-years-against-the-accused-for-the-offences-under-sections-498a-406-and-420-of-the-ipc-and-31iv-of-the-scst-act)
    - [Allegations](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#allegations)
    - [Since no prayer for quash Apex court proceeded to consider only with the remand order](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#since-no-prayer-for-quash-apex-court-proceeded-to-consider-only-with-the-remand-order)
    - [Impugned High Court order](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#impugned-high-court-order)
 * [Analysis, reasoning and conclusion](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#analysis-reasoning-and-conclusion)
    - [First point/issue: What is taking cognizance? Explained](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#first-pointissue-what-is-taking-cognizance-explained)
    - [Second point/issue: Criminal proceeding filed for civil dispute](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#second-pointissue-criminal-proceeding-filed-for-civil-dispute)
    - [Trial court not recorded the prima facie material against the appellants is not correct since the investigation unearthed sufficient materials](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#trial-court-not-recorded-the-prima-facie-material-against-the-appellants-is-not-correct-since-the-investigation-unearthed-sufficient-materials)
    - [What is application of mind for taking cognizance is explained?](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#what-is-application-of-mind-for-taking-cognizance-is-explained)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#conclusion)
    - [No interference required in the order taking cognizance](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#no-interference-required-in-the-order-taking-cognizance)
    - [Hon’ble High Court’s order set aside](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#honble-high-courts-order-set-aside)
    - [The judgments cited in the case](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#the-judgments-cited-in-the-case)
    - [Acts and Sections](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#acts-and-sections)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/application-of-mind-during-taking-cognizance-means-to-contemplate-on-the-material-submitted-and-not-checking-veracity-of-the-same/#party)

##### **Appeal against remand order of Hon’ble High Court**

The present appeal has been preferred by the Appellants against the Final Judgment
and Order dated 09.03.2022 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Impugned Judgment’) [
2022:JHHC:9512] in Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No.235 of 2017 passed by the 
High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi (hereinafter referred to as the ‘High Court’) 
by which the High Court set aside the cognizance Order dated 13.06.2019 passed in
connection with SC/ST Case No.08 of 2017 arising out of Argora P.S. Case No.385 
of 2016, by the learned Additional Judicial Commissioner-XII, Ranchi (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Additional Judicial Commissioner’) and remitted the matter for
passing order afresh.

#### **Facts**

##### **Brief factual background**

##### **FIR was registered after 26 years against the accused for the offences under sections 498A, 406 and 420 of the IPC and 3(1)(iv) of the ‘SC/ST Act**

2. Respondent No.2 (Informant) claims to be the second wife of one Vishnu Sahu (
Deceased). Appellant No.1 is the first wife of Late Vishnu Sahu, and Appellants 
No.2 and 3 are their children. It was alleged that the deceased posing himself as
unmarried about 25-30 years ago befriended Respondent No.2 and married her in 1990
at Jagannath Temple under Hindu customs and traditions and lived peacefully for 
more than 26 years. From their marriage (Vishnu Sahu and Respondent No.2), three
children were born, namely Reshma Kumari, Rupa Kumari, and Vishal Kumar. It was 
pleaded that after 26 years, Respondent No.2 filed a written complaint against Vishnu
Sahu and the Appellants which culminated into First Information Report No.385/2016
dated 27.11.2016 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘FIR’) under Sections 498A, 406
and 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘IPC’) and
Section 3(1)(iv) of The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of
Atrocities) Act, 1989 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘SC/ST Act’).

##### **Allegations**

3. The allegations made in the FIR are that Vishnu Sahu posing himself to be unmarried,
performed marriage with Respondent No.2 in 1990, and two daughters and a son were
born to them from the said wedlock. By taking a loan in her name from a bank and
at her expense, a pakka house was constructed upon the land purchased by her father
in her name, and she was living in the said house with her family. She also alleged
that Vishnu Sahu along with the first wife and the children, born from wedlock of
Vishnu Sahu and his first wife (Appellant No.1) started to harass and assault her
and ultimately, in the year 2013, she and her children were ousted by them from 
the said house. It is further alleged that she has been deprived of her land and
house, that she is facing hardship, her daughters are of marriageable age and that
she was humiliated and abused by Vishnu Sahu, his first wife (Appellant No.1) and
their children in the name of Adivasi Kol. Bhurung, etc.

##### **Since no prayer for quash Apex court proceeded to consider only with the remand order**

5. The Additional Judicial Commissioner took cognizance against Vishnu Sahu and 
Appellants on 13.06.2019 in SC/ST Case No.08/2017. Though before the High Court,
the Appellants had initially sought quashing of the FIR, in Criminal Miscellaneous
Petition No.235/2017 the prayer was later amended by filing an Interlocutory Application
challenging the Order taking cognizance dated 13.06.2019. The High Court in the 
Impugned Judgment, instead of going into the question of whether the FIR itself 
was fit to be quashed, focused only on the cognizance-taking Order dated 13.06.2019.
Even before this Court, the Appellants challenged the Impugned Judgment to the extent
the matter was remanded to pass order afresh after disclosure of the prima facie
material against the Appellants. **No prayer was pressed to quash FIR No.385/2016.****
In such view, we would proceed only with regard to the challenge whether the High
Court by the Impugned Judgment ought to have remanded the matter to the Trial Court
for disclosure of the prima facie material against the Appellants**.

##### **Impugned High Court order**

6. The High Court, by way of the Impugned Judgment, set aside the cognizance Order
and remitted the matter to the Additional Judicial Commissioner to pass order afresh
as in the cognizance Order, prima facie material against the Appellants had not 
been disclosed.

#### **Analysis, reasoning and conclusion**

13. We have considered the matter in its entirety. Two basic issues arise for consideration.

14. Firstly, whether the Additional Judicial Commissioner while taking cognizance
has to record detailed reasons for taking cognizance? **Secondly, whether the FIR
itself was instituted with mala fide intention and was liable to be quashed?**

##### **First point/issue: What is taking cognizance? Explained**

15. Coming to the first issue, we have no hesitation to record that the approach
of the High Court was totally erroneous. Perusal of the Order taking cognizance 
dated 13.06.2019 discloses that the Additional Judicial Commissioner has stated 
that the ‘case diary and case record’ have been perused, which disclosed a prima
facie case made out under Sections 498(A), 406 and 420 of the IPC and Section 3 (
1)(g) of the SC/ST Act against the accused including appellants. **Further, we find
the approach of the Additional Judicial Commissioner correct inasmuch as while taking
cognizance, it firstly applied its mind to the materials before it to form an opinion
as to whether any offence has been committed and thereafter went into the aspect
of identifying the persons who appeared to have committed the offence. Accordingly,
the process moves to the next stage; of issuance of summons or warrant, as the case
may be, against such persons.**

16. In the present case, we find that the Additional Judicial Commissioner has taken
cognizance while recording a finding that – from a perusal of the case diary and
case record, a prima facie case was made out against the accused, including the 
Appellants. In **Bhushan Kumar v State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 5 SCC 424**, this 
Court held that an order of the Magistrate taking cognizance cannot be faulted only
because it was not a reasoned order; relevant paragraphs being as under:

“Paras. 14 to 19”

17. The view in Bhushan Kumar (supra) was reiterated in **Mehmood Ul Rehman v Khazir
Mohammad Tunda, (2015) 12 SCC 420 **and **State of Gujarat v Afroz Mohammed Hasanfatta,(
2019) 20 SCC 539**. This Court in **Rakhi Mishra v State of Bihar, (2017) 16 SCC
772 **restated the settled proposition of law enunciated in **Sonu Gupta v Deepak
Gupta, (2015) 3 SCC 424**, as under:

‘4. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties. We are of the considered
opinion that the High Court erred in allowing the application filed by Respondents
2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 and quashing the criminal proceedings against them. A
perusal of the FIR would clearly show that the appellant alleged cruelty against
Respondents 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10. This Court in **Sonu Gupta v. Deepak Gupta[
Sonu Gupta v. Deepak Gupta, (2015) 3 SCC 424: (2015) 2 SCC (Cri) 265] held as follows:(
SCC p. 429, para 8)**

“8. … **At the stage of cognizance and summoning the Magistrate is required to apply
his judicial mind only with a view to take cognizance of the offence … to find out
whether a prima facie case has been made out for summoning the accused persons. 
At this stage, the learned Magistrate is not required to consider the defence version
or materials or arguments nor is he required to evaluate the merits of the materials
or evidence of the complainant, because the Magistrate must not undertake the exercise
to find out at this stage whether the materials would lead to conviction or not**.”

5. The order passed by the trial court taking cognizance against R-2 and R-4 to 
R-9 is in conformity with the law laid down in the above judgment. It is settled
law that the power under Section 482 CrPC is exercised by the High Court only in
exceptional circumstances only when a prima facie case is not made out against the
accused. The test applied by this Court for interference at the initial stage of
a prosecution is whether the uncontroverted allegations prima facie establish a 
case.’ (emphasis supplied)

##### **Second point/issue: Criminal proceeding filed for civil dispute**

18. Coming to the second point which the Appellants canvassed before this Court 
viz. the background of lodging of the FIR to impress that the same is mala fide,
an afterthought and at best, a civil dispute being tried to be settled through criminal
proceedings by way of arm twisting. On this point, need for a detailed discussion
is obviated in view of our answer on the first point supra and the paragraphs infra.

##### **Trial court not recorded the prima facie material against the appellants is not correct since the investigation unearthed sufficient materials**

19. Perusal of the entire gamut of the pleadings of the Appellants does not disclose
any categorical statement to the effect that during investigation by the police,
no evidence has emerged to warrant taking of cognizance, much less against the Appellants.**
The only averment which has been made is that the Trial Court had not recorded the
prima facie material against the Appellants because it does not exist. This is too
simplistic an argument and does not shift the burden from the Appellants of taking
a categorical stand that no material whatsoever for taking cognizance is available
in the police papers/case diary against the Appellants. Be it noted, the State has
argued that sufficient material warranting cognizance has been unearthed during 
the course of investigation.**

##### **What is application of mind for taking cognizance is explained?**

20. **Here, the Court would pause to delve on what is the scope of the exercise 
of application of mind on the police papers/case diary for deciding as to whether
to take cognizance or not – it has only to be seen whether there is material forthcoming
to indicate commission of the offence(s) alleged. The concerned Court is not empowered
to go into the veracity of the material at that time. That is why, the law provides
for a trial where it is open to both the parties i.e., the prosecution as well as
the defence to lead evidence(s) either to prove the materials which have come against
the accused or to disprove such findings**. This Court vide Order dated 13.09.2024
directed the Appellants to file a translated copy of the chargesheet, as the State
filed the chargesheet in Hindi along with an application seeking exemption from 
filing official translation (I.A. No.198073/2024). As this Court [Coram: Sudhanshu
Dhulia and Ahsanuddin Amanullah, JJ.] is well-conversant with Hindi, the language
in which the chargesheet is and which has been brought on record, we have examined
the same. However, the Appellants failed to comply with the specific direction issued
on 13.09.2024. Be that as it may, we find that chargesheet mentions that on the 
basis of investigation, site inspection and statements of the complainant, the police
has found the allegations true against all the accused including appellants.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **No interference required in the order taking cognizance**

21. For reasons aforesaid and on an overall circumspection of the facts and circumstances
of the case and submissions of learned counsel for the parties, we find that the
Order taking cognizance dated 13.06.2019, being in accordance with law, was not 
required to be interfered with by the High Court.

##### **Hon’ble High Court’s order set aside**

22. Though no cross-appeal against the Impugned Judgment has been filed by Respondent
No.2, yet to render complete justice as also set right the error committed by the
High Court, on the legal issue of requirement of recording detailed grounds/reasons
for taking cognizance, the Impugned Judgment is set aside in toto.

##### **The judgments cited in the case**

1. Bhushan Kumar v State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 5 SCC 424 

2. Kanti Bhadra Shah v State of W.B, (2000) 1 SCC 722 

3. Nagawwa v Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi, (1976) 3 SCC 736 

4. Chief Controller of Imports & Exports v Roshanlal Agarwal, (2003) 4 SCC 139 

5. U.P. Pollution Control Board v Mohan Meakins Ltd., (2000) 3 SCC 745 

6. U.P. Pollution Control Board v Bhupendra Kumar Modi, (2009) 2 SCC 147 

7. Mehmood Ul Rehman v Khazir Mohammad Tunda, (2015) 12 SCC 420 

8. State of Gujarat v Afroz Mohammed Hasanfatta, (2019) 20 SCC 539 

9. Rakhi Mishra v State of Bihar, (2017) 16 SCC 772 

10. Sonu Gupta v Deepak Gupta, (2015) 3 SCC 424 …

##### **Acts and Sections**

**Acts**

– The Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 
1989 (SC/ST Act)

– Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)

**Sections**

> IPC Sections
>   – Section 498A (Cruelty by husband or relatives)
>   – Section 406 (Criminal breach of trust)
>   – Section 420 (Cheating)
>   – Sections 341, 323, 506 (from an earlier related case)
> SC/ST Act Sections
>   – Section 3(1)(iv)
>   – Section 3(1)(g)

#### **Party**

Pramila Devi & Ors. vs. The State of Jharkhand & Anr – Criminal Appeal No. 2551 
of 2024 2025 INSC 560 – April 23, 2025 – Hon’ble Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah Hon’ble
Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia.

[Pramila Devi vs. The State of Jharkhand 113852022_2025-04-23](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Pramila-Devi-vs.-The-State-of-Jharkhand-113852022_2025-04-23.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Pramila-Devi-vs.-The-State-of-Jharkhand-113852022_2025-04-23.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
