# Bail refused till recording of statements of protected witnesses

- Link: https://section1.in/bail-refused-till-recording-of-statements-of-protected-witnesses/
- Published: 2023-05-09T09:13:36+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Analysis, reasoning and conclusion](https://section1.in/bail-refused-till-recording-of-statements-of-protected-witnesses/#analysis-reasoning-and-conclusion)
 * [6 out of 12 accused obtained bail](https://section1.in/bail-refused-till-recording-of-statements-of-protected-witnesses/#6-out-of-12-accused-obtained-bail)
 * [On facts bail is rejected till the recording of statements of protected witnesses](https://section1.in/bail-refused-till-recording-of-statements-of-protected-witnesses/#on-facts-bail-is-rejected-till-the-recording-of-statements-of-protected-witnesses)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/bail-refused-till-recording-of-statements-of-protected-witnesses/#party)

##### **Analysis, reasoning and conclusion**

8. Having examined the rival contentions, the Court does not consider it necessary
to go into the legal aspect pertaining to the applicability of the GCTOC Act in 
praesenti, as the current Appeal has been filed only for the purpose of seeking 
bail during the pendency of the trial.

9. Had there been no other case against the Appellant and no material, at least 
prima facie, to indicate his regular participation in any crime, the Court could
have considered his prayer, but keeping in view his alleged role, we are not inclined
to exercise discretion in his favour, for now. When we speak of discretion, we 9
have in mind “judicial discretion” as explained in Gudikanti Narasimhulu v Public
Prosecutor, (1978) 1 SCC 240.

##### **6 out of 12 accused obtained bail**

10. The fact, that out of the twelve charge-sheeted accused, six co-accused have
not been granted bail, five have availed the benefit of default bail and only one
is on regular bail, have also persuaded this Court not to interfere. We have also
considered the allegations levelled and perused carefully the statements of the 
witnesses shown to the Court. In Niranjan Singh v Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, (1980)
2 SCC 559, this Court opined:
 “3… Detailed examination of the evidence and elaborate
documentation of the merits should be avoided while passing orders on bail applications.
No party should have the impression that his case has been prejudiced. To be satisfied
about a prima facie case is needed but it is not the same as an exhaustive exploration
of the merits in the order itself.” (emphasis supplied) 11. In Vilas Pandurang Pawar
v State of Maharashtra, (2012) 8 SCC 795, this Court observed “…Moreover, while 
considering the application for bail, scope for appreciation of evidence and other
material on record is limited. The court is not expected to indulge in critical 
analysis of the evidence on record…”. We are in respectful agreement with the law
exposited in these cases. We consciously refrain from detailing our views on the
merits of the matter.

12. Insofar as parity is concerned, we need only reproduce the apt observations 
from Ramesh Bhavan Rathod v Vishanbhai Hirabhai Makwana (Koli), (2021) 6 SCC 230,
of which we take note: “26.… Parity while granting bail must focus upon the role
of the accused. Merely observing that another accused who was granted bail was armed
with a similar weapon is not sufficient to determine whether a case for the grant
of bail on the basis of parity has been established. In deciding the aspect of parity,
the role attached to the accused, their position in relation to the incident and
to the victims is of utmost importance. The High Court has proceeded on the basis
of parity on a simplistic assessment as noted above, which again cannot pass muster
under the law.” (emphasis supplied)

##### **On facts bail is rejected till the recording of statements of protected witnesses**

13. In the facts and circumstances, at the present juncture, this Court is not inclined
to allow the prayer for enlarging the Appellant on bail. Accordingly, the prayer
for bail is hereby rejected.

14. However, the stand taken on behalf of the State of Gujarat is that the prayer
for bail of the Appellant may be considered only after the protected witnesses are
examined. In this context, learned Additional Solicitor General has indicated that
six months’ time be granted for recording statements of the protected witnesses.

15. In such light, it is observed that upon the completion of recording of statements
of the said protected witnesses, the Appellant is at liberty to renew his plea for
bail, if so advised.

##### **Party**

**ATULBHAI VITHALBHAI BHANDERI vs. STATE OF GUJARAT – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1390 OF
2023 (@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO.10051 OF 2022) – MAY 4, 2023.**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/32563/32563_2022_2_1502_44245_Judgement_04-May-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/32563/32563_2022_2_1502_44245_Judgement_04-May-2023.pdf)**

**[Atulbhai-Vithalbhai-Bhanderi-vs.-State-of-Gujarat](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Atulbhai-Vithalbhai-Bhanderi-vs.-State-of-Gujarat-1.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
