# Baptismal Certificate Inadmissible under sec.35 IEA and Cannot Prove the Age of Minor: Conviction Modified POCSO Conviction to Rape

- Link: https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/
- Published: 2026-09-17T13:26:15+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

    - [Analysis of the Judgment](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#analysis-of-the-judgment)
       * [Appeal and Impugned Order](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#appeal-and-impugned-order)
       * [Factual Matrix and Lower Courts Verdicts](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#factual-matrix-and-lower-courts-verdicts)
       * [Core Legal Arguments](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#core-legal-arguments)
       * [Ratio Decidendi](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#ratio-decidendi)
 * [ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#analysis-and-conclusion)
    - [ISSUE NO.(I)](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#issue-noi)
       * [How to prove the age of the victim? Explained](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#how-to-prove-the-age-of-the-victim-explained)
       * [Age proved based on baptism birth certificate case is distinguished](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#age-proved-based-on-baptism-birth-certificate-case-is-distinguished)
    - [ISSUE NO.(II)](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#issue-noii)
       * [The appellate court can examine offence under section 375 IPC even if the charge was not framed](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#the-appellate-court-can-examine-offence-under-section-375-ipc-even-if-the-charge-was-not-framed)
       * [What is minor offence explained?](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#what-is-minor-offence-explained)
       * [Court can convict the accused under section 376 IPC even if he tried for the charges framed under POCSO Act](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#court-can-convict-the-accused-under-section-376-ipc-even-if-he-tried-for-the-charges-framed-under-pocso-act)
       * [Charge how to frame? Explained](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#charge-how-to-frame-explained)
    - [Conclusion](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#conclusion)
       * [Conviction modified to rape](https://section1.in/baptismal-certificate-inadmissible-under-sec-35-iea-and-cannot-prove-the-age-of-minor-conviction-modified-pocso-conviction-to-rape/#conviction-modified-to-rape)

**Pynchemalangaki Bareh v. State of Meghalaya – Criminal Appeal No. 4337 of 2026(
Arising out of S.L.P. (Criminal) No. 9809 of 2025) – 2026 INSC 984 – September 10,
2026 – Hon’ble Mr Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Hon’ble Mr N.V. Anjaria.**

#### **Analysis of the Judgment**

##### **Appeal and Impugned Order**

The appellant has filed the present criminal appeal challenging the final judgment
and order dated 08.07.2024 passed by the High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong in 
Crl. A. No. 38/2023. The impugned order upheld the [Trial Court’s verdict convicting the appellant](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
under Section 506 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 3(a) read with Section
4 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, sentencing him
to twenty years of rigorous imprisonment. (Paragraph 1-2).

##### **Factual Matrix and Lower Courts Verdicts**

On 27.11.2019, an [FIR was lodged](https://section1.in/quash-delay-in-lodging-fir-without-date-and-time-affects-the-case/)
by the victim’s mother alleging that her 13-year-old daughter was dragged into the
bushes, sexually assaulted, and threatened by the appellant. After investigation,
charges were framed, and the [prosecution examined 14 witnesses](https://section1.in/when-chief-examination-of-prosecution-witness-is-being-recorded-presence-of-accused-advocate-is-required-to-object-to-a-leading-or-irrelevant-question-being-asked-to-the-witness/)
while introducing a Baptismal Certificate as proof of the victim’s age. The [Special Judge](https://section1.in/p-c-act-special-judge-discharge-shall-be-u-s-227-cr-p-c-and-not-u-s-239-cr-p-c/)(
POCSO) vide judgment dated 16.06.2021 convicted the appellant, relying on the mother’s
testimony, the Baptismal Certificate, and medical reports to conclude that the victim
was a 13-year-old minor, sentencing him to twenty years of rigorous imprisonment.
Subsequently, the High Court of Meghalaya dismissed the appellant’s criminal appeal
and upheld the Trial Court’s conviction and sentence in its entirety. (Paragraph
4-9).

##### **Core Legal Arguments**

The appellant principally argued that the conviction under the POCSO [Act](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/)
was unsustainable because the prosecution failed to prove the victim’s age strictly
in accordance with Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children)
Act, 2015, contending that a Baptismal Certificate issued by a private church is
legally inadmissible. The defense also highlighted the lack of an ossification test
or independent forensic findings. Conversely, the respondent-State argued that the
Baptismal Certificate, corroborated by the mother’s testimony and medical records
indicating the victim was in a pre-pubescent stage, conclusively established her
minority, rendering the appellant’s challenge based on alleged procedural discrepancies
untenable. (Paragraph 10-24).

##### **Ratio Decidendi**

The Supreme Court established that a Baptismal Certificate is not a statutorily 
prescribed document under Section 94 of the [Juvenile Justice Act](https://section1.in/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/),
meaning the prosecution failed to legally establish the victim’s minority, which
is a fundamental jurisdictional prerequisite for a conviction under the POCSO Act.
However, the Court ruled that the failure to prove minority does not completely 
absolve an accused when the underlying substantive offence of sexual assault is 
independently proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Applying Section 464 of the CrPC,
the Court held that the omission to frame a specific alternative [charge under Section 376 IPC](https://section1.in/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)
does not vitiate the trial or cause a failure of justice if the accused had ample
opportunity to defend against the factual allegations, thus allowing the Court to
convert the invalid POCSO conviction into a valid conviction for the cognate offence
of rape under Section 376(1) of the IPC. (Relevant final paragraphs of the judgment).

### **ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION**

31. Considering the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties, as 
noted above, and the material on record, this Court needs to dwell upon the following
issues:

> (i) Whether the age (minority) of the victim has been rightly determined by the
> [Trial Court](https://section1.in/pocso-victims-contradictory-statements-cannot-form-the-basis-for-quashing-criminal-proceedings-but-trial-court-must-careful-on-misusing-this-act/)
> and affirmed by the High Court for convicting the appellant for committing offence
> under Section 3 of the POCSO Act punishable under Section 4 of the said Act?
> (ii) If the age (minority) of the victim has not been proved in accordance with
> law, whether the appellant can be held guilty for [committing offence under Section](https://section1.in/offence-committed-in-journey-or-voyage/)
> 376(1) of the IPC?

#### **ISSUE NO.(I)**

32. The issue as to legal requisite for determination of age of a victim under the
POCSO Act has been considered by this Court in at least the following three judgments
cited before us.

##### **How to prove the age of the victim? Explained**

34. Thereafter, in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Anoop Singh, this Court referred and
[relied upon](https://section1.in/cheque-conviction-the-accused-has-only-relied-upon-plausible-theories-with-conjectures-and-surmises/)
its earlier judgment in Mahadeo v. State of Maharashtra and Another, to hold that
the age of a rape victim should be determined on the basis of the provisions contained
in the 2007 Rules and the same yardstick can be rightly followed by the Courts for
the purpose of ascertaining the age of a victim as well.

    ```wp-block-verse
    36. In the case at hand, the Investigating Officer did not obtain the birth certificate from the school where the victim had studied or the matriculation or equivalent certificate from the examination Board concerned or birth certificate given by a corporation, a municipal authority or a panchayat, to prove that the victim was a minor on the date of offence. The victim was also not sent for any age determination test as provided under Rule 12 of the 2007 Rules or under Section 94(2)(iii) of the JJ Act which is in pari materia with Rule 12 of the 2007 Rules. The said provision prescribes that in the absence of the date of birth certificate from the school or the matriculation or equivalent certificate from the examination Board concerned, or birth certificate given by a corporation, a municipal authority or a panchayat, the age shall be determined by an ossification test or any other latest medical age determination test conducted on the orders of the Committee or the Board. Admittedly, the victim was not subjected to any ossification test or any other latest medical age determination test. The only document available on the record for proving the age of the victim is the Baptismal Certificate issued by the Khasi Jaintia Presbyterian Assembly. Although the date of birth in the Baptismal Certificate finds corroboration in the deposition of P.W.-2, the mother of the victim girl, stating the girl was born on 05.03.2006, yet since the document itself is not the one prescribed under Section 94 of the JJ Act, we are of the considered view that the prosecution has failed to prove the age of the victim in the manner required under Section 94 of the JJ Act.
    ```

37. The learned Advocate General for the respondent-State has strenuously urged 
before this Court that the Baptismal Certificate should be taken to be a document
which duly proves the date of birth of the victim. For this, [reliance has been placed](https://section1.in/section-311-cr-p-c-though-the-accused-has-right-to-keep-his-defence-closed-till-cross-examination-but-the-accused-cannot-reserve-a-few-questions-for-a-later-point-of-time-placing/)
on the decision of this Court in Luis Caetano Viegas (supra).

##### **Age proved based on baptism birth certificate case is distinguished**

38. In Luis Caetano Viegas (supra), this Court was dealing with an issue [concerning](https://section1.in/section-451-cr-p-c-petition-for-disposal-return-of-property-cannot-be-filed-directly-by-invoking-article-226-without-invoking-section-451-cr-p-c-before-the-concerned-court/)
inventory proceedings for partition of inheritance of the property of common ancestors.
In the said context, dealing with the issue of parentage, this Court in paragraph
9 held thus:

> “9. The emphasised portion stated above clearly indicates that the baptismal record
> was read and checked before the godparents, and the same has been signed by the
> Parson along with them. The learned District Judge felt that the certificate of
> [registration of birth merely](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/)
> proceeds on the basis of the baptism certificate. If the birth certificate is 
> a true reflection of the baptism record and it contains the fact that it was read
> and checked before the godparents, the same need not be discarded and it must 
> be held that the same had been made in the presence of both godparents. In that
> view of the matter, the trial court was justified in the conclusion it reached
> and not the learned District Judge who proceeded on misreading of the record. 
> Hence the High Court ought to have reversed the finding recorded by the learned
> District Judge who ignored this crucial aspect in the course of his order.”

It is, thus, apparent that in the above matter, in addition to the Baptismal Certificate,
a birth certificate was also issued and was duly proved in the course of proceedings.
Thus, the said case did not rest only on the basis of the Baptismal Certificate.
Moreover, the present is a case where this Court is dealing with the issue relating
to proof of age of a POCSO [victim for which a statutory prescription is put](https://section1.in/section-313-cr-p-c-rape-case-the-stand-taken-by-the-accused-that-they-have-paid-money-for-sexual-intercourse-was-not-put-in-the-cross-examination-of-victim/)
in place by the legislation in the form of Section 94 of the JJ Act which had been
found applicable in the case of POCSO victims also as held by this Court in the 
judgments discussed by us in the preceding paragraphs.

Thus, the case of Luis Caetano Viegas (supra) is not only distinguishable, but it
does not apply in the background of the statutory mechanism for proving the age 
of the POCSO victim with which we are concerned in this case. The argument raised
by the learned Advocate General for the respondent-State basing on Luis Caetano 
Viegas (supra) is, thus, rejected.

39. Reverting to the facts of the case insofar as the proof of commission of rape
is concerned, we have found that the factum of rape clearly stands established by
way of medical evidence and the said finding cannot be [set aside](https://section1.in/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/)
merely on the ground of absence of medical evidence establishing the age of the 
victim. In such a case, it has been rightly observed in Sucha Singh and Another 
v. State of Punjab that exaggerated devotion to the rule of benefit of doubt must
not nurture fanciful doubts or lingering suspicion and thereby destroy social defence.
Justice cannot be made sterile on the plea that it is better to let a hundred guilty
escape than punish an innocent. Letting guilty escape is not doing justice to a 
rape victim.

#### **ISSUE NO.(II)**

40. Minority of the victim has not been established by the prosecution. Therefore,
we are [required to consider the next limb of the argument](https://section1.in/oral-hearing-is-non-negotiable-non-cooperation-by-defence-counsel-requires-amicus-appointment-not-ex-parte-verdict/)
raised by the appellant that the conviction and sentence for commission of rape 
is not sustainable as no charge was framed against the appellant for commission 
of offence under Section 376 of the IPC.

41. The issue [regarding conviction](https://section1.in/suicide-no-dowry-demand-a-moral-conviction-regarding-the-guilt-of-an-individual-has-no-place-in-criminal-jurisprudence/)
of accused under Section 376 of the IPC arises only due to absence of a charge framed
thereunder by the Trial Court. In the facts of the [present case](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/),
it was the duty of the Trial Court to be careful in framing charges, particularly
charge under Section 376 of the IPC in the alternative to Section 4 of the POCSO
Act, in view of prima facie commission of said offence. However, an omission to 
frame a charge cannot absolve the accused of liability for commission of offence
of rape of the victim, where such irregularity can be cured.

42. In view of Section 464(1) of the Cr.PC, such error will not be material unless
it has occasioned a failure of justice, stated as below:

> “464. Effect of omission to frame, or absence of, or error in, charge.—(1) No 
> finding, sentence or order by a [Court of competent jurisdiction](https://section1.in/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)
> shall be deemed invalid merely on the ground that no charge was framed or on the
> ground of any error, omission or irregularity in the charge including any misjoinder
> of charges, unless, in the opinion of the Court of appeal, confirmation or revision,
> a failure of justice has in fact been occasioned thereby.”

43. This Court in Sandeep Yadav v. Satish and Others, reiterated this position, 
relying on Rafiq Ahmad alias Rafi v. State of Uttar Pradesh, wherein Court held 
that when a charge of a major [offence is not made](https://section1.in/quash-the-security-clause-in-the-agreement-discusses-adjustment-and-not-refunds-thus-no-criminal-offence-made-out/)
out, conviction for a minor offence even in the absence of the charge for the said
minor offence can be sustained. It has also been held that the purpose of framing
of charge is to put the accused to notice regarding the offence for which he is 
being tried. It was further held that non-framing of a charge or defects therein
would not [ipso facto](https://section1.in/in-exceptional-circumstances-the-court-may-grant-anticipatory-bail-to-an-absconder-but-a-co-accuseds-acquittal-does-not-ipso-facto-entitle-him-to-a-b-relief/)
vitiate the trial and that the question must always be examined in the facts of 
each case to determine whether prejudice or failure of justice has been occasioned.

##### **The appellate court can examine offence under section 375 IPC even if the charge was not framed**

44. On a perusal of [Section](https://section1.in/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/)
375 of the IPC and Section 3 of the POCSO Act, the actus reus mentioned, for constituting
rape is the same as the actus reus specified in cases of commission of penetrative
sexual assault within the meaning of Section 3 of the POCSO Act. The only distinguishing
feature between [Section 375 of the IPC](https://section1.in/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)
and Section 3 of the POCSO Act is the minority of the victim, which determines the
charge of offence under Section 376 of the IPC and/or under Section 4 of the POCSO
Act. In such a case, where the victim is a minor, the accused is usually tried for
[prosecution of a charge under Section](https://section1.in/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/)
376 of the IPC in addition to charge under Section 4 of the POCSO Act. However, 
where the [Trial Court erred in framing a charge under Section](https://section1.in/section-319-cr-p-c-trial-court-can-decide-whether-an-application-under-section-319-cr-p-c-should-be-decided-with-or-without-waiting-for-cross-examination/)
376 of the IPC but factum of rape is clearly proven, and prosecution failed to establish
the age of the victim, charge under Section 4 of the POCSO Act fails, while prosecution
for charge under Section 376 of the IPC sustains. However, in [cases where charge under Section](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
376 of the IPC has not been framed, nothing impairs the Appellate Court to proceed
on examination of commission of offence under Section 376 of the IPC by the accused.

47. The only determinative test under Section 464 of the Cr.PC is whether there 
occasioned a failure of justice in upholding findings of the [Trial Court](https://section1.in/strict-procedure-trial-courts-must-inform-the-accused-of-their-right-to-engage-legal-aid-if-they-cannot-afford-a-counsel/).
The [Trial Court and High Court have concurrently recorded](https://section1.in/denovo-trial-unusual-recording-of-confession-statements-based-on-judicial-directions-and-the-doubt-of-subsequent-insertion-of-statutory-warning-in-the-confession-creates-serious-doubts/)
a finding of fact regarding commission of penetrative sexual assault by the accused/
appellant within the meaning of Section 3 of the POCSO Act. Section 375 of the IPC
and Section 3 of the POCSO Act sharing the same ingredients and actus reus, Section
376 of the IPC being cognate offence, there seems to be no failure of justice when
[accused was given an adequate opportunity to defend](https://section1.in/ratio-decidendi-failing-to-inform-the-accused-of-the-grounds-of-arrest-denying-the-opportunity-to-defend-through-counsel-and-failing-to-provide-information-about-the-proposed-remand-is-unconstituti/)
himself against a charge under Section 3 of the POCSO Act. In a [case where the accused](https://section1.in/case-diary-section-1723-cr-p-c-the-accused-has-a-right-to-cross-examine-police-officer-as-per-section-145-evidence-act-whenever-the-police-officer-uses-it-to-refresh-his-memory/)
was charged with an offence, different in nature and kind than the offence charged
under POCSO Act, it would not have been in the interest of justice to proceed against
him in the event of failure to prove the charge under POCSO Act. Barring the case
of commission of [sexual assault on a child](https://section1.in/accused-behaviour-stems-from-internalised-misogyny-which-is-a-product-of-our-male-dominated-society-and-hence-the-words-spoken-by-the-accused-are-excessively-harsh-and-extremely-sexually-charged-lik/)
below the age of sixteen years, a close analysis of punishment provided under clause(
1) of Section 376 of the IPC and clause (1) of Section 4 of the POCSO Act also reveals
that they are offences of the same nature, both providing for a minimum imprisonment
of ten years.

48. The appellant/accused was convicted by the Trial [Court for a grave offence under Section](https://section1.in/high-court-has-granted-bail-without-contemplating-statements-recorded-u-s-161-and-164-cr-p-c-for-considering-prima-facie-in-grave-offences/)
4(2) of the POCSO Act, providing a minimum sentence of twenty years. In a [question before this Court on conviction under Section 304B](https://section1.in/dowry-death-since-witnesses-stating-the-dowry-demand-only-before-the-court-significant-omission-would-not-establish-section-304b-ipc/)
in a trial for offence under Section 302 of the IPC, in the absence of charge framed
under Section 304B of the IPC, this Court in Shamnsaheb M. Multtani v. State of 
Karnataka, on a conjoint reading of Section 222 of the Cr.PC and Section 464 of 
the Cr.PC held that such conviction would be valid even if there is any omission
or irregularity in the charge, provided there was no failure of justice. This Court
held:

> “15. Section 222(1) of the Code deals with a case “when a person is charged with
> an offence consisting of several particulars”. The [section permits the court to convict the accused](https://section1.in/accused-were-permitted-to-leave-the-court-without-any-formal-order-of-release-or-even-without-taking-a-bond-under-section-88-of-the-code/)“
> of the minor offence, though he was not charged with it. …

##### **What is minor offence explained?**

16. What is meant by “a minor offence” for the purpose of Section 222 of the Code?
Although the said expression is not defined in the Code it can be discerned from
the context that the test of minor offence is not merely that the prescribed punishment
is less than the major offence. The two illustrations provided in the section would
bring the above point home well. Only if the two offences are cognate offences, 
wherein the main ingredients are common, the one punishable among them with a lesser
sentence can be regarded as minor offence vis-àvis the other offence.”

##### **Court can convict the accused under section 376 IPC even if he tried for the charges framed under POCSO Act**

50. When the accused has been given an opportunity to defend himself against an 
offence under Section 3 of the POCSO Act, being of the same nature as offence under
Section 376 of the IPC, there is no hesitation in holding that in event of [prosecution’s failure to prove](https://section1.in/in-pocso-cases-section-29-comes-into-play-only-after-prosecution-proves-the-foundational-facts/)
victim’s minority, there would be no failure of justice in proceeding against him
under a charge of Section 376 of the IPC.

##### **Charge how to frame? Explained**

53. In a [case involving trial of an accused under Sections](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
302, 498-A and 304- B of the IPC, while answering issue with respect to conviction
of accused under Section 306 of the IPC in the absence of charge framed under it,
this Court in Dalbir Singh v. State of U.P. held that having regard to Section 464
of the Cr.PC, Appellate Court or Revisional [Court has the power](https://section1.in/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-6-general-introduction-to-inquiries-and-trials-part-4-criminal-courts-powers-administration/)
to convict the accused. It was held that conviction is possible if,

> (i) the accused was aware of the basic ingredients of that offence,
> (ii) the main facts sought to be established against him were explained to him
> clearly, and
> (iii) he got a fair chance to defend himself.

54. There is a catena of decisions of this Court on the same lines and it is not
necessary to [burden](https://section1.in/section-106-iea-appellant-did-not-provide-satisfactory-explanation-either-for-injury-marks-found-on-the-deceased-wife-though-this-fact-was-within-the-special-knowledge-of-the-accused/)
this judgment making reference to each one of them. Therefore, in view of Section
464 of the Cr.PC, it is possible for the [Appellate Court or Revisional Court to convict an accused](https://section1.in/section-389-cr-p-c-condition-for-suspension-of-sentence-appellate-court-should-confirm-that-the-condition-does-not-make-it-difficult-or-impossible-for-the-accused-to-comply/)
for an offence for which no charge was framed unless the Court is of the opinion
that a failure of justice would in fact occasion. In order to judge [whethe](https://section1.in/whether-the-same-accused-can-be-arrested-and-grant-bail-for-new-offence-added-in-the-fir-whether-victim-has-rights-during-bail/)
r a failure of justice has been occasioned, it will be relevant to examine whether
the accused was aware of the basic ingredients of the offence for which he is being
convicted and whether the main facts sought to be established against him were explained
to him clearly and whether he got a fair chance to defend himself.

58. In view of the above, we find no good reason to interfere with the concurrent
judgments convicting the [accused and sentencing him under Section 506 of the IPC](https://section1.in/there-cannot-be-a-conspiracy-by-only-one-accused/),
details of which have been set out hereinabove. In the facts of present case, the
appellant/accused is convicted under Section 376 of the IPC for commission of rape.
As provided under sub-clause (iii) to clause (b) of Section 386 of the Cr.PC detailed
hereinabove, the powers of the Appellate Court extend to altering the findings and
nature and extent of [sentence awarded](https://section1.in/section-304a-ipc-awarding-sentence-under-section-304-a-ipc-is-not-mandatory/)
by Trial Court. Hence, we hereby sentence the appellant/accused to [undergo 10 years of rigorous imprisonment](https://section1.in/under-section-307-ipc-first-part-court-cannot-be-sentenced-to-undergo-imprisonment-beyond-the-period-of-ten-years/)
and fine of Rs.10,000/- under Section 376 of the IPC, in default of payment of fine
to undergo additional rigorous imprisonment for 06 months.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Conviction modified to rape**

59. Consequently, impugned judgments dated 08.07.2024 of the High [Court and 16.06.2021 passed by the Special](https://section1.in/s-c-quashed-g-o-of-tamilnadu-for-anti-land-grabbing-cell-and-adviced-to-enact-appropriate-legislation-for-land-grabbing-cases/)
Judge (POCSO), District and Sessions Court in Special (POCSO) Case No. 9/2020, is
modified to the extent of conviction and sentence of appellant/accused under Section
376 of the IPC in addition to conviction and sentence under Section 506 of the IPC
awarded by Trial Court and upheld by the High Court and the appellant/accused is
[sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and fine](https://section1.in/sentencing-fine-forcing-the-accused-to-pay-duplicate-fines-for-the-same-sentence-would-be-amount-to-double-punishment/)
of Rs.10,000/-, in default of payment of fine to undergo additional rigorous imprisonment
for 06 months.

60. We, therefore, partly allow the Appeal in the above stated terms.

**Judgments Cited:**

 * **P. Yuvaprakash v. State:** Cited by the appellant to argue that the [conviction under the POCSO Act is unsustainable since](https://section1.in/hostile-won-over-since-there-is-a-long-gap-between-the-chief-and-cross-examination-it-appears-that-the-witnesses-were-won-over-and-confirmed-the-conviction/)
   the victim’s age was not proved as per the mandatory procedure of Section 94 
   of the Juvenile Justice Act.
 * **Luis Caetano Viegas v. State of Goa:** Cited by the respondent-State to argue
   in favour of the validity of the Baptismal Certificate as reliable proof of age.
 * **Sucha Singh and Another v. State of Punjab:** [Quoted by the Court](https://section1.in/a-cryptic-order-rejecting-the-prolonged-incarceration-22-years-for-premature-release-is-quashed-supreme-court-quoted-platos-advice/)
   to emphasise that an exaggerated devotion to the rule of benefit of doubt must
   not destroy social defence, and justice cannot be made sterile by letting the
   guilty escape.

**Acts and Sections:**

 * **Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012:** Sections 3,
   3(a), 4, 4(2).
 * **Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860:** Sections 375, 376, 376(1), 506.
 * **[Juvenile Justice](https://section1.in/juvenile-justice-act-issue-of-juvenility-can-be-claimed-even-before-the-honble-supreme-court/)(
   Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015:** Section 94.
 * **[Code of Criminal Procedure](https://section1.in/bail-ability-of-section-3513-of-the-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-2023-do-colonial-era-notifications-survive-the-new-criminal-procedure-code/)(
   CrPC), 1973:** Sections 161, 164, 222, 313, 386, 464.
 * **Indian [Evidence Act](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/),
   1872:** Section 35.

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
