# Burden of proof (section 106 Evidence Act) and explaining circumstance and (section 313 Cr.P.C)

- Link: https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/
- Published: 2023-10-09T14:46:19+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#analysis)
 * [Apex court ruled out suicide](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#apex-court-ruled-out-suicide)
 * [Poison was through her medicine ruled out](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#poison-was-through-her-medicine-ruled-out)
 * [Accused failed to prove he took the deceased to the hospital](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#accused-failed-to-prove-he-took-the-deceased-to-the-hospital)
 * [Conduct of accused not informing the deceased’s family member](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#conduct-of-accused-not-informing-the-deceased8217s-family-member)
 * [Principles of law governing the applicability of section 106 of the Evidence Act](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#principles-of-law-governing-the-applicability-of-section-106-of-the-evidence-act)
 * [Section 106 Evidence Act: Still the onus of burden of proving all the elements to establish the offence is on prosecution](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#section-106-evidence-act-still-the-onus-of-burden-of-proving-all-the-elements-to-establish-the-offence-is-on-prosecution)
 * [When section 106 Evidence Act has no application?: Explained](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#when-section-106-evidence-act-has-no-application-explained)
 * [What is ‘prima facie case’ in the context of section 106 of the Evidence Act?](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#what-is-8216prima-facie-case8217-in-the-context-of-section-106-of-the-evidence-act)
 * [Failure on the part of the appellant-convict in offering any plausible explanation in his further statement recorded under section 313 of the Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#failure-on-the-part-of-the-appellantconvict-in-offering-any-plausible-explanation-in-his-further-statement-recorded-under-section-313-of-the-crpc)
 * [Accused did not expalin in what circumstance and in what manner he had taken the deceased to the hospital and who attended deceased at the hospital](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#accused-did-not-expalin-in-what-circumstance-and-in-what-manner-he-had-taken-the-deceased-to-the-hospital-and-who-attended-deceased-at-the-hospital)
 * [Section 313 Cr.P.C: Circumstance not explained by the accused](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#section-313-crpc-circumstance-not-explained-by-the-accused)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-section-106-evidence-act-and-explaining-circumstance-and-section-313-cr-p-c/#party)

##### **Analysis**

 1. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through
    the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is 
    whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment and
    order.

##### **Apex court ruled out suicide**

 1. We take note of the following circumstances emerging from the facts on record:

##### **Poison was through her medicine ruled out**

a. The cause of death is due to poisoning. The poison detected in the viscera was
aluminium phosphide. Aluminium phosphide is used as a fumigant to control the insects
and rodents in the foodgrains and fields. It is too much for the convicts to say
that the presence of aluminium phosphide in the viscera could be due to the medicines
which the deceased used to take for her heart ailment. Such medicines even in high
dosage would not lead to formation of aluminium phosphide in the body. This theory
which has been put forward could be termed as something very absurd. No particular
question in this direction has been put to the expert witness (doctor) while he 
was in the witness box. In such circumstances, the only inference that can be drawn
is that aluminium phosphide either in the liquid form or in the form of tablets 
was procured by the accused husband and the same was administered to the deceased.

b. We completely rule out the theory of suicide as sought to be put forward on behalf
of the appellants.

##### **Accused failed to prove he took the deceased to the hospital**

c. If it is the case of the convict-husband that he had taken the deceased to the
Sanjay Gandhi Hospital at Delhi then he should have led some evidence to indicate
how she was taken to the hospital, in what type of vehicle and who attended the 
deceased at the hospital? In the case of the present type, it is very difficult 
to believe that if the deceased had been taken to the hospital and declared dead
on arrival, the hospital authorities would allow the convict/husband to carry the
dead body of his wife back home. It would become a medico-legal case and the hospital
would definitely inform the police.

##### **Conduct of accused not informing the deceased’s family member**

d. The dubious conduct of the convict-husband of not informing the family members
about the death of their daughter. Though in his further statement, the convict-
husband has said that he had informed the family members of the deceased yet the
evidence of PW3 Harender Singh (uncle of the deceased) is otherwise.

##### **Principles of law governing the applicability of section 106 of the Evidence Act**

 1. Section 106 of the Evidence Act referred to above provides that when any fact is
    especially within the knowledge of any person, the burden of proving that fact 
    is upon him. The word “especially” means facts that are pre-eminently or exceptionally
    within the knowledge of the accused. The ordinary rule that applies to the criminal
    trials that the onus lies on the prosecution to prove the guilt of the accused 
    is not in any way modified by the rule of facts embodied in Section 106 of the 
    Evidence Act. Section 106 of the Evidence Act is an exception to Section 101 of
    the Evidence Act. Section 101 with its illustration (a) lays down the general rule
    that in a criminal case the burden of proof is on the prosecution and Section 106
    is certainly not intended to relieve it of that duty. On the contrary, it is designed
    to meet certain exceptional cases in which it would be impossible or at any rate
    disproportionately difficult for the prosecution to establish the facts which are,“
    especially within the knowledge of the accused and which, he can prove without 
    difficulty or inconvenience”.

Apex court placed reliance on the following judgments:

Shambhu Nath Mehra v. The State of Ajmer reported in AIR 1956 SC 404,
 The aforesaid
decision of Shambhu Nath (supra) has been referred to and relied upon in **[Nagendra Sah v. State of Bihar ](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/26752/26752_2019_14_1501_30114_Judgement_14-Sep-2021.pdf)
reported in (2021) 10 SCC 725 ** [**Tulshiram Sahadu Suryawanshi and Another v. State of Maharashtra**](https://main.sci.gov.in/jonew/judis/39552.pdf)**
reported in (2012) 10 SCC 373** [**Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra**](https://main.sci.gov.in/jonew/judis/28109.pdf)**
reported in (2006) 10 SCC 681**

xxx

 1. The question of burden of proof, where some facts are within the personal knowledge
    of the accused, was examined by this Court in the case of State of W.B. v. Mir 
    Mohammad Omar and Others reported in (2000) 8 SCC 382. In this case, the assailants
    forcibly dragged the deceased from the house where he was taking shelter on account
    of the fear of the accused, and took him away at about 2:30 in the night. The next
    day in the morning, his mangled body was found lying in the hospital. The trial
    court convicted the accused under Section 364, read with Section 34 of the IPC,
    and sentenced them to ten years rigorous imprisonment. The accused preferred an
    appeal against their conviction before the High Court and the State also filed 
    an appeal challenging the acquittal of the accused for the charge of murder. The
    accused had not given any explanation as to what happened to the deceased after
    he was abducted by them. The Sessions Judge, after referring to the law on circumstantial
    evidence, had observed that there was a missing link in the chain of evidence after
    the deceased was last seen together with the accused persons, and the discovery
    of the dead body in the hospital, and concluded that the prosecution had failed
    to establish the charge of murder against the accused persons beyond any reasonable
    doubt.
 2. Applying the aforesaid principles, this Court while maintaining the conviction 
    under Section 364 read with Section 34 of the IPC, reversed the order of acquittal
    under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC, and convicted the accused under
    the said provision and sentenced them to imprisonment for life.
 3. Thus, from the aforesaid decisions of this Court, it is evident that the court 
    should apply Section 106 of the Evidence Act in criminal cases with care and caution.
    It cannot be said that it has no application to criminal cases. The ordinary rule
    which applies to criminal trials in this country that the onus lies on the prosecution
    to prove the guilt of the accused is not in any way modified by the provisions 
    contained in Section 106 of the Evidence Act.

##### **Section 106 Evidence Act: Still the onus of burden of proving all the elements to establish the offence is on prosecution**

 1. Section 106 cannot be invoked to make up the inability of the prosecution to produce
    evidence of circumstances pointing to the guilt of the accused. This section cannot
    be used to support a conviction unless the prosecution has discharged the onus 
    by proving all the elements necessary to establish the offence. It does not absolve
    the prosecution from the duty of proving that a crime was committed even though
    it is a matter specifically within the knowledge of the accused and it does not
    throw the burden of the accused to show that no crime was committed. To infer the
    guilt of the accused from absence of reasonable explanation in a case where the
    other circumstances are not by themselves enough to call for his explanation is
    to relieve the prosecution of its legitimate burden. So, until a prima facie case
    is established by such evidence, the onus does not shift to the accused.
 2. Section 106 obviously refers to cases where the guilt of the accused is established
    on the evidence produced by the prosecution unless the accused is able to prove
    some other facts especially within his knowledge which would render the evidence
    of the prosecution nugatory. If in such a situation, the accused gives an explanation
    which may be reasonably true in the proved circumstances, the accused gets the 
    benefit of reasonable doubt though he may not be able to prove beyond reasonable
    doubt the truth of the explanation. But if the accused in such a case does not 
    give any explanation at all or gives a false or unacceptable explanation, this 
    by itself is a circumstance which may well turn the scale against him. In the language
    of Prof. Glanville Williams:

“All that the shifting of the evidential burden does at the final stage of the case
is to allow the jury (Court) to take into account the silence of the accused or 
the absence of satisfactory explanation appearing from his evidence.”

xxx

##### **When section 106 Evidence Act has no application?: Explained**

 1. But Section 106 has no application to cases where the fact in question having regard
    to its nature is such as to be capable of being known not only by the accused but
    also by others if they happened to be present when it took place. From the illustrations
    appended to the section, it is clear that an intention not apparent from the character
    and circumstances of the act must be established as especially within the knowledge
    of the person whose act is in question and the fact that a person found travelling
    without a ticket was possessed of a ticket at a stage prior in point of time to
    his being found without one, must be especially within the knowledge of the traveller
    himself : see Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, illustrations (a) and (b).
 2. A manifest distinction exists between the burden of proof and the burden of going
    forward with the evidence. Generally, the burden of proof upon any affirmative 
    proposition necessary to be established as the foundation of an issue does not 
    shift, but the burden of evidence or the burden of explanation may shift from one
    side to the other according to the testimony. Thus, if the prosecution has offered
    evidence which if believed by the court would convince them of the accused’s guilt
    beyond a reasonable doubt, the accused is in a position where he should go forward
    with counter-vailing evidence if he has such evidence. When facts are peculiarly
    within the knowledge of the accused, the burden is on him to present evidence of
    such facts, whether the proposition is an affirmative or negative one. He is not
    required to do so even though a prima facie case has been established, for the 
    court must still find that he is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt before it can
    convict. However, the accused’s failure to present evidence on his behalf may be
    regarded by the court as confirming the conclusion indicated by the evidence presented
    by the prosecution or as confirming presumptions which might have been rebutted.
    Although not legally required to produce evidence on his own behalf, the accused
    may therefore as a practical matter find it essential to go forward with proof.
    This does not alter the burden of proof resting upon the prosecution (Wharton’s
    Criminal Evidence, 12th Edn. 1955, Vol. 1, Ch. 2 p. 37 and foil). Leland v. State
    reported in 343 U.S. 790=96 L.Ed. 1302, Raffel v. U.S. reported in 271 U.S. 294
    =70 L.Ed. 1054.

##### **What is ‘prima facie case’ in the context of section 106 of the Evidence Act?**

 1. The Latin expression prima facie means “at first sight”, “at first view”, or “based
    on first impression”. According, to Webster’s Third International Dictionary (1961
    Edn.), “prima facie case” means a case established by “prima facie evidence” which
    in turn means “evi-Ideuce sufficient in law to raise a presumption of fact or establish
    the fact in question unless rebutted”. In both civil and criminal law, the term
    is used to denote that, upon initial examination, a legal claim has sufficient 
    evidence to proceed to trial or judgment. In most legal proceedings, one party (
    typically, the plaintiff or the prosecutor) has a burden of proof, which requires
    them to present prima facie evidence for each element of the charges against the
    defendant. If they cannot present prima facie evidence, or if an opposing party
    introduces contradictory evidence, the initial claim may be dismissed without any
    need for a response by other parties.
 2. Section 106 of the Evidence Act would apply to cases where the prosecution could
    be said to have succeeded in proving facts from which a reasonable inference can
    be drawn regarding death.
 3. The presumption of fact is an inference as to the existence of one fact from the
    existence of some other facts, unless the truth of such inference is disproved.

xxx

 1. In the case on hand it has been established or rather proved to the satisfaction
    of the court that the deceased was in company of her husband i.e., the appellant-
    convict at a point of time when something went wrong with her health and therefore,
    in such circumstances the appellant-convict alone knew what happened to her until
    she was with him.

##### **Failure on the part of the appellant-convict in offering any plausible explanation in his further statement recorded under section 313 of the Cr.P.C**

##### Accused did not expalin in what circumstance and in what manner he had taken the deceased to the hospital and who attended deceased at the hospital

 1. We take notice of the fact that the appellant-convict (husband) has not explained
    in any manner as to what had actually happened to his wife more particularly when
    it is not in dispute that the appellant-convict was in company of his wife i.e.,
    deceased. It is important to bear in mind that the deceased died on account of 
    poisoning. The poison which was detected in the viscera was found to be “aluminium
    phosphide”. Although, the appellant-convict tried to project a picture that no 
    sooner the deceased fell sick than he immediately took her to the Sanjay Gandhi
    Hospital at Delhi, yet, there is no evidence worth the name in this regard. The
    appellant-convict was expected to lead some evidence as to what had transpired 
    at the Sanjay Gandhi Hospital. He has maintained a complete silence. It is only
    the appellant-convict who could have explained in what circumstances and in what
    manner he had taken his wife to the Sanjay Gandhi Hospital and who attended his
    wife at the hospital. If it is his case, that his wife was declared dead on being
    brought at the hospital then it is difficult to believe that the hospital authorities
    allowed the appellant to carry the dead body back home without completing the legal
    formalities.

##### **Section 313 Cr.P.C: Circumstance not explained by the accused**

 1. In the aforesaid context, we must look into the decision of this Court in the case
    of **[Deonandan Mishra v. The State of Bihar](https://main.sci.gov.in/jonew/judis/807.pdf)
    reported in AIR 1955 SC 801**. In the said decision, there is a very important 
    passage in which, the learned Judges deal with the effect of failure of the accused
    to offer any explanation for circumstances appearing in evidence against him in
    a prosecution based upon circumstantial evidence. At the cost of repetition, the
    law is very clear that the accused is not bound to offer any explanation, that 
    there is no burden cast upon him to do so and that the onus of proof does not shift
    in respect of the vital matter of [guilt at any stage of a criminal](http://localhost:8080/section1/suicide-no-dowry-demand-a-moral-conviction-regarding-the-guilt-of-an-individual-has-no-place-in-criminal-jurisprudence/)
    trial. But as stated by this Court:

“It is true that in a case of circumstantial evidence not only should the various
links in the chain of evidence be clearly established, but the completed chain must
be such as to rule out a reasonable likelihood of the innocence of the accused. 
But in a case where the various links have been satisfactorily made out and the 
circumstances point to the accused as the probable assailant, with reasonable definiteness
and in proximity to the deceased as regards time and situation, and he offers no
explanation, which, if accepted, though not proved, would afford a reasonable basis
for a conclusion on the entire case consistent with his innocence, such absence 
of explanation or false explanation would itself be an additional link which completes
the chain.” (Emphasis supplied).

xxx

 1. In the aforesaid context, we may also refer to and rely on a decision of this Court
    in **[Kalu alias Laxminarayan v. State of Madhya Pradesh](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2009/33329/33329_2009_11_1501_17942_Judgement_07-Nov-2019.pdf)**
    reported in (2019) 10 SCC 211, wherein this Court after referring to its various
    other decisions on the applicability of Section 106 of the Evidence Act observed
    as under:

“16. In view of our conclusion that the prosecution has clearly established a prima
facie case, the precedents cited on behalf of the appellant are not considered relevant
in the facts of the present case. Once the prosecution established a prima facie
case, the appellant was obliged to furnish some explanation under Section 313 CrPC
with regard to the circumstances under which the deceased met an unnatural death
inside the house. His failure to offer any explanation whatsoever therefore leaves
no doubt for the conclusion of his being the assailant of the deceased.”

xxx

 1. We are of the view that the circumstances narrated by us in para 28 of this judgment
    constitute more than a prima facie case to enable the prosecution to invoke Section
    106 of the Evidence Act and shift the burden on the accused husband to explain 
    what had actually happened on the date his wife died.
 2. These appeals remind us of what this Court observed in the case of Dharam Das Wadhwani
    v. State of Uttar Pradesh:

“The rule of benefit of reasonable doubt does not imply a frail willow bending to
every whiff of hesitancy. Judges are made of sterner stuff and must take a practical
view of legitimate inferences flowing from evidence, circumstantial or direct.” 
The role of courts in such circumstances assumes greater importance and it is expected
that the courts would deal with such cases in a more realistic manner and not allow
the criminals to escape on account of procedural technicalities, perfunctory investigation
or insignificant lacunas in the evidence as otherwise the criminals would receive
encouragement and the victims of crime would be totally discouraged by the crime
going unpunished. The courts are expected to be sensitive in cases involving crime
against women.

##### _**Party**_

**BALVIR SINGH vs. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 301 OF 2015 – October
06, 2023.**

[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2015/353/353_2015_1_1502_47423_Judgement_06-Oct-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2015/353/353_2015_1_1502_47423_Judgement_06-Oct-2023.pdf)

[Balvir Singh vs. State of Uttarakhand 353_2015_1_1502_47423_Judgement_06-Oct-2023](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Balvir-Singh-vs.-State-of-Uttarakhand-353_2015_1_1502_47423_Judgement_06-Oct-2023.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
