# Can’t claim false promise to marry if the relationship becomes distant or goes sour

- Link: https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/
- Published: 2025-05-27T15:31:58+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#appeal)
    - [Quash petitions dismissed by Hon’ble High Court](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#quash-petitions-dismissed-by-honble-high-court)
    - [FIR reveals the victim fell in love with the appellant and having physical relationship](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#fir-reveals-the-victim-fell-in-love-with-the-appellant-and-having-physical-relationship)
    - [Promise to marry not attracted](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#promise-to-marry-not-attracted)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#conclusion)
    - [Appeal allowed: Quash dismissal order set aside](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#appeal-allowed-quash-dismissal-order-set-aside)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/cant-claim-false-promise-to-marry-if-the-relationship-becomes-distant-or-goes-sour/#party)

                                                                                

#### **Appeal**

##### **Quash petitions dismissed by Hon’ble High Court**

2. This Appeal by special leave is directed against the Impugned Order dt. 28.06.2024
passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Crl. W.P. No. 3181 of 2023 whereby
the Petition u/s 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (‘CrPC’) seeking quashing
of the Criminal Case C.R. No. 490/2023 dt. 31.07.2023 for offences punishable u/
s 376, 376(2)(n), 377, 504 & 506 of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter “IPC”) registered
at Karad Taluka Police Station, Satara qua the Appellant was dismissed. Vide an 
amendment to the Petition, the Appellant also challenged the chargesheet filed on
26.09.2023 and the proceedings in RCC no. 378/2023 pending before the Additional
Sessions Judge, Karad.

6. The Appellant then preferred Crl. W.P. No. 3181 of 2023 seeking quashing of the
C.R. No. 490/2023 dt. 31.07.2023 & the proceedings emanating therefrom before the
High Court of Judicature at Bombay, and in the meanwhile, the investigation culminated
into a charge-sheet 26.09.2023 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Karad.

8. Having heard both sides in this case and after carefully considering the material
on record, the following attributes come to the fore:

##### **FIR reveals the victim fell in love with the appellant and having physical relationship**

(a) Even if the allegations in the FIR are taken as a true and correct depiction
of circumstances, it does not appear from the record that the consent of the Complainant/
Respondent no. 2 was obtained against her will and merely on an assurance to marry.
The Appellant and the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 were acquainted since 08.06.2022,
and she herself admits that they interacted frequently and fell in love. The Complainant/
Respondent no. 2 engaged in a physical relationship alleging that the Appellant 
had done so without her consent, however she not only sustained her relationship
for over 12 months, but continued to visit him in lodges on two separate occasions.
The narrative of the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 does not corroborate with her 
conduct.

(b) The consent of the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 as defined under section 90 
IPC also cannot be said to have been obtained under a misconception of fact. There
is no material to substantiate “inducement or misrepresentation” on the part of 
the Appellant to secure consent for sexual relations without having any intention
of fulfilling said promise. Investigation has also revealed that the Khulanama, 
was executed on 29.12.2022 which the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 had obtained from
her ex-husband. During this time, the parties were already in a relationship and
the alleged incident had already taken place. It is inconceivable that the Complainant
had engaged in a physical relationship with the Appellant, on the assurance of marriage,
while she was already married to someone else. Even otherwise, such promise to begin
with was illegal and unenforceable qua the Appellant.

(c) There is no evidence of coercion or threat of injury to the Complainant/Respondent
no. 2, to attract an offence under section 506 IPC. It is improbable that there 
was any threat caused to the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 by the Appellant when 
all along the relationship was cordial, and it was only when the Appellant graduated
and left for his hometown to Ahmednagar, the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 became
agitated. We also cannot ignore the conduct of the Complainant/Respondent no. 2 
in visiting the native village of the Appellant without any intimation, which is
also unacceptable and reflects the agitated and unnerved state of mind of the Complainant/
Respondent no. 2. For the same reason, the criminal prosecution against the Appellant
herein is probably with an underlying motive and disgruntled state of mind.

(d) There is also no reasonable possibility that the Complainant/Respondent no. 
2 or any woman being married before and having a child of four years, would continue
to be deceived by the Appellant or maintain a prolonged association or physical 
relationship with an individual who has sexually assaulted and exploited her.

##### **Promise to marry not attracted**

> 9. **In our considered view, this is also not a case where there was a false promise
> to marry to begin with. A consensual relationship turning sour or partners becoming
> distant cannot be a ground for invoking criminal machinery of the State. Such 
> conduct not only burdens the Courts, but blots the identity of an individual accused
> of such a heinous offence. This Court has time and again warned against the misuse
> of the provisions, and has termed it a folly to treat each breach of promise to
> marry as a false promise and prosecute a person for an offence under section 376
> IPC**.

10. As demonstrated hereinabove, the ingredients of the offence under Sections 376(
2)(n) or 506 IPC are not established. The present case squarely falls under categories
enumerated in Para 102(5) & 102(7) as identified by this Court in State of Haryana
Vs Bhajan Lal (supra) for the exercise of powers u/s 482 CrPC by the High Court 
so as to prevent the abuse of process of law. Para 102 reads as under:

“paras. 102”

11. Taking into consideration that the Appellant is just 25 years of age, and has
a lifetime ahead of him, it would be in the interest of justice that he does not
suffer an impending trial and, therefore, the proceedings emanating from C.R. No.
490/2023 dt. 31.07.2023 are quashed at this stage itself.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Appeal allowed: Quash dismissal order set aside**

12. Consequently, the Appeal is allowed and the Impugned Order dt. 28.06.2024 passed
by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Crl. W.P. No. 3181 of 2023 is set aside.
Accordingly, C.R. No. 490/2023 dt. 31.07.2023 registered at Karad Taluka Police 
Station, Satara and proceedings emanating therefrom in RCC no. 378/2023 pending 
before the Additional Sessions Judge, Karad are quashed, and Appellant is discharged.
Bail bonds, if any, also stand cancelled.

**The judgments involved with citation are**

1. State of Haryana vs Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335                   

2. Naim Ahmed vs State (NCT) of Delhi, 2023 SCC Online SC 89

**The Acts and Sections involved are**

**Indian Penal Code (IPC)**

**  – Section 376 (Rape)**

**  – Section 376(2)(n) (Aggravated rape)**

**  – Section 377 (Unnatural sex)**

**  – Section 504 (Intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of the peace)**

**  – Section 506 (Criminal intimidation)**

**Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC)**

**  – Section 482 (Inherent powers of High Court to prevent abuse of process)**

**  – Section 155 (Information to the police and their powers to investigate)   **

#### **Party**

Amol Bhagwan Nehul (Appellant) and The State of Maharashtra & Another (Respondents)–
Criminal Appeal No. 2835 of 2025 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 10044 of 2024) –
2025 INSC 782 – May 26, 2025, Hon’ble Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Hon’ble Justice
Satish Chandra Sharma.

[Amol Bhagwan Nehul vs. The State of Maharashtra 326152024_2025-05-26](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Amol-Bhagwan-Nehul-vs.-The-State-of-Maharashtra-326152024_2025-05-26.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Amol-Bhagwan-Nehul-vs.-The-State-of-Maharashtra-326152024_2025-05-26.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
