# Section 65B IEA: Section 65B Certificate cannot be substituted with oral evidence

- Link: https://section1.in/certificate-u-s-65-b-evidence-act/
- Published: 2023-03-10T04:06:26+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appreciation of circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/certificate-u-s-65-b-evidence-act/#appreciation-of-circumstantial-evidence)
 * [Certification under section 65-B I.E.A for call records](https://section1.in/certificate-u-s-65-b-evidence-act/#certification-under-section-65b-iea-for-call-records)
 * [Certificate under section 65-B I.E.A cannot be substituted with oral evidence](https://section1.in/certificate-u-s-65-b-evidence-act/#certificate-under-section-65b-iea-cannot-be-substituted-with-oral-evidence)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/certificate-u-s-65-b-evidence-act/#party)

##### **Appreciation of circumstantial evidence**

10. The conviction of A2 is based only upon circumstantial evidence. Hence, in order
to sustain a conviction, it is imperative that the chain of circumstances is complete,
cogent and coherent. This court has consistently held in a0 long line of cases [
See Hukam Singh v. State of Rajasthan AIR (1977 SC 1063); Eradu and Ors. v. State
of Hyderabad (AIR 1956 SC 316); Earabhadrappa @ Krishnappa v. State of Karnataka(
AIR 1983 SC 446); State of U.P. v. Sukhbasi and Ors. (AIR 1985 SC 1224); Balwinder
Singh @ Dalbir Singh v.State of Punjab (AIR 1987 SC 350); Ashok Kumar Chatterjee
v. State of M.P. (AIR 1989 SC 1890)] that where a case rests squarely on circumstantial
evidence, the inference of guilt can be justified only when all the incriminating
facts and circumstances are found to be incompatible with the innocence of the accused.
The circumstances from which an inference as to the guilt of the accused is drawn
have to be proved beyond reasonable doubt and have to be shown to be closely connected
with the principal fact sought to be inferred from those circumstances. In Bhagat
Ram v. State of Punjab (AIR 1954 SC 621), it was laid down that where the case depends
upon the conclusion drawn from circumstances, the cumulative effect of the circumstances
must be such as to negate the innocence of the accused and bring the offence home
beyond any reasonable doubt. We may also make a reference to a decision of this 
Court in C. Chenga Reddy and Ors. v. State of A.P. (1996) 10 SCC 193, wherein it
has been observed that:

> “In a case based on circumstantial evidence, the settled law is that the circumstances
> from which the conclusion of guilt is drawn should be fully proved and such circumstances
> must be conclusive in nature. Moreover, all the circumstances should be complete
> and there should be no gap left in the chain of evidence. Further the proved circumstances
> must be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and totally
> inconsistent with his innocence….”.[Emphasis supplied]

11. Upon thorough application of the above settled law on the facts of the present
case, we hold that the circumstantial evidence against the present appellant i.e.
A2 does not conclusively establish the guilt of A2 in committing the murder of the
deceased children. The last seen theory, the arrest of the accused, the recovery
of material objects and the call details produced, do not conclusively complete 
the chain of evidence and do not establish the fact that A2 committed the murder
of the children of PW5. Additionally, the argument of the Respondent that the call
details produced relating to the phone used by A1 and A2 have established that they
shared an intimate relationship and that this relationship became the root cause
of offence is also unworthy of acceptance.

##### **Certification under section 65-B I.E.A for call records**

20. Lastly, this appeal also raised an important substantive question of law that
whether the call records produced by the prosecution would be admissible under section
65A and 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, given the fact that the requirement of certification
of electronic evidence has not been complied with as contemplated under the Act.
The uncertainty of whether Anvar P.V. vs P.K. Basheer & Ors [(2014) 10 SCC 473] 
occupies the filed in this area of law or whether Shafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal
Pradesh (2018) 2 SCC 801 lays down the correct law in this regard has now been conclusively
settled by this court by a judgement dated 14/07/2020 in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar
vs Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal [ (2020) 7 SCC 1] wherein the court has held that:

“We may reiterate, therefore, that the certificate required under Section 65B(4)
is a condition precedent to the admissibility of evidence by way of electronic record,
as correctly held in Anvar P.V. (supra), and incorrectly “clarified” in Shafhi Mohammed(
supra). Oral evidence in the place of such certificate cannot possibly suffice as
Section 65B(4) is a mandatory requirement of the law. Indeed, the hallowed principle
in Taylor v. Taylor (1876) 1 Ch.D 426, which has been followed in a number of the
judgments of this Court, can also be applied. Section 65B(4) of the Evidence Act
clearly states that secondary evidence is admissible only if lead in the manner 
stated and not otherwise. To hold otherwise would render Section 65B(4) otiose.

Anvar P.V. (supra), as clarified by us hereinabove, is the law declared by this 
Court on Section 65B of the Evidence Act. The judgment in Tomaso Bruno (supra), 
being per incuriam, does not lay down the law correctly. Also, the judgment in SLP(
Crl.) No. 9431 of 2011 reported as Shafhi Mohammad (supra) and the judgment dated
03.04.2018 reported as (2018) 5 SCC 311, do not lay down the law correctly and are
therefore overruled.

The clarification referred to above is that the required certificate under Section
65B(4) is unnecessary if the original document itself is produced. This can be done
by the owner of a laptop computer, computer tablet or even a mobile phone, by stepping
into the witness box and proving that the concerned device, on which the original
information is first stored, is owned and/or operated by him. In cases where the“
computer” happens to be a part of a “computer system” or “computer network” and 
it becomes impossible to physically bring such system or network to the Court, then
the only means of providing information contained in such electronic record can 
be in accordance with Section 65B(1), together with the requisite certificate under
Section 65B(4).”

##### **Certificate under section 65-B I.E.A cannot be substituted with oral evidence**

21. In light of the above, the electronic evidence produced before the High Court
should have been in accordance with the statute and should have complied with the
certification requirement, for it to be admissible in the court of law. As rightly
stated above, Oral evidence in the place of such certificate, as is the case in 
the present matter, cannot possibly suffice as Section 65B(4) is a mandatory requirement
of the law.

##### **Party**

**RAVINDER SINGH @ KAKU VERSUS STATE OF PUNJAB – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1307 OF 2019[
ARISING OUT OF SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION [CRL] NO.9431 OF 2011] – MAY 4, 2022.**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2011/19865/19865_2011_9_1501_35499_Judgement_04-May-2022.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2011/19865/19865_2011_9_1501_35499_Judgement_04-May-2022.pdf)**

[**Ravinder Singh vs. State of Punjab19865_2011_9_1501_35499_Judgement_04-May-2022**](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Ravinder-Singh-vs.-State-of-Punjab19865_2011_9_1501_35499_Judgement_04-May-2022.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
