# Clarifying Arbitration Jurisdiction: The Role of Section 21 Notice, Section 11 Application, and Kompetenz-Kompetenz principle explained

- Link: https://section1.in/clarifying-arbitration-jurisdiction-the-role-of-section-21-notice-section-11-application-and-kompetenz-kompetenz-principle-explained/
- Published: 2025-04-25T10:48:44+00:00
- Author: section1

Contents

 * [Important points in the judgment](https://section1.in/clarifying-arbitration-jurisdiction-the-role-of-section-21-notice-section-11-application-and-kompetenz-kompetenz-principle-explained/#important-points-in-the-judgment)
 * [Points: Q and A](https://section1.in/clarifying-arbitration-jurisdiction-the-role-of-section-21-notice-section-11-application-and-kompetenz-kompetenz-principle-explained/#points-q-and-a)
 * [Case Overview](https://section1.in/clarifying-arbitration-jurisdiction-the-role-of-section-21-notice-section-11-application-and-kompetenz-kompetenz-principle-explained/#case-overview)
 * [Page by page](https://section1.in/clarifying-arbitration-jurisdiction-the-role-of-section-21-notice-section-11-application-and-kompetenz-kompetenz-principle-explained/#page-by-page)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/clarifying-arbitration-jurisdiction-the-role-of-section-21-notice-section-11-application-and-kompetenz-kompetenz-principle-explained/#party)

#### **Important points in the judgment**

I can’t display the flashcards directly here, but I can summarize the key important
paragraphs they cover:

1. Paragraphs 2-3: Issues framed regarding Section 21 notice and Section 11 application
as prerequisites for jurisdiction.

2. Paragraphs 8-14: Purpose and scope of Section 21 notice in arbitration.

3. Paragraphs 15-20: Role and limited scope of court in Section 11 applications.

4. Paragraphs 21-26: Source of arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction and principle of
kompetenz-kompetenz under Section 16.

5. Paragraphs 27-28: Arbitral tribunal’s incorrect approach in the present case.

6. Paragraphs 30-33: Review of High Court decisions on related issues.

7. Paragraphs 34-36: Determination of whether respondents 2 and 3 are parties to
the arbitration agreement.

#### **Points: Q and A**

**What is the significance of a notice invoking arbitration under Section 21 of 
the ACA?    **

It is mandatory as it fixes the date of commencement of arbitration, which is essential
for determining limitation periods and the applicable law.

**How does the court view the joinder of parties to arbitration proceedings?    **

The court acknowledges that non-service of a Section 21 notice does not automatically
bar a person from being made a party to arbitration proceedings.

**What principle allows an arbitral tribunal to determine its own jurisdiction? **

The principle of kompetenz-kompetenz allows an arbitral tribunal to rule on its 
own jurisdiction, including who is a party to the arbitration agreement.

**What must the arbitral tribunal inquire into when determining jurisdiction under
Section 16?       **

The tribunal must examine whether a person/entity is a party to the arbitration 
agreement.

**What was the court’s conclusion regarding respondent nos. 2 and 3’s status in 
the arbitration agreement?**

Respondent nos. 2 and 3 were found to be parties to the arbitration agreement despite
being non-signatories.

**What did the High Court conclude about the necessity of a Section 21 notice for
parties?   **

The High Court held that the notice is mandatory before a person can be made a party
to arbitral proceedings.

**What is the role of the court in a Section 11 application regarding arbitration?**

The court conducts a limited and prima facie examination of the existence of the
arbitration agreement and its parties.

#### **Case Overview**

**Key Legal Issues**

The appeal addresses whether the service of notice invoking arbitration under Section
21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (ACA) and the joinder of a person
in the Section 11 application for the appointment of an arbitrator are prerequisites
for an arbitral tribunal to exercise jurisdiction.

The court also examines the source of the arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction and the
relevant inquiry under Section 16 of the ACA.

**Findings on Jurisdiction**

The court concludes that while a Section 21 notice is mandatory for fixing the commencement
date of arbitration, non-service of such notice does not preclude a person from 
being impleaded in arbitral proceedings.

The purpose of a Section 11 application is to appoint an arbitrator, and the court’s
limited examination does not restrict the arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction to include
parties later.

**Arbitral Tribunal’s Decision**

The arbitral tribunal initially ruled that the proceedings against respondents 2
and 3 were not maintainable due to the absence of a Section 21 notice served on 
them.

The tribunal’s reasoning was that the Hon’ble High Court’s order did not include
these respondents, thus limiting the tribunal’s jurisdiction.

**High Court’s Ruling**

The High Court upheld the arbitral tribunal’s decision, stating that since the Section
21 notice and Section 11 application did not involve respondents 2 and 3, the appellant
could not raise disputes against them.

**Legal Principles Established**

The court emphasizes that the **arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction** is derived from
the consent of the parties as expressed in the arbitration agreement.

The principle of kompetenz-kompetenz allows the tribunal to determine its own jurisdiction,
including whether non-signatories can be included based on their conduct   .

**Conclusion and Directions**

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, ruling that respondents 2 and 3 should be 
impleaded as parties to the arbitration proceedings.

The court directed the arbitral tribunal to continue proceedings from the stage 
of its order dated 15.02.2024, emphasizing the need for expeditious resolution.

#### **Page by page**

**Page 2**

Issues Presented: The court outlines the main issues, focusing on whether the service
of notice under Section 21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and the
joinder in the Section 11 application are prerequisites for an arbitral tribunal’s
jurisdiction.

**Page 3**

Mandatory Notice: The court states that while a notice invoking arbitration under
Section 21 is mandatory, its non-service does not prevent a person from being impleaded
in the arbitration proceedings.

**Page 4**

Jurisdiction Source: The arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction is derived from the consent
to the arbitration agreement, and the inquiry under Section 16 should focus on whether
the person is a party to the agreement.

**Page 5**

Facts of the Case: The appellant and respondent no. 1 entered into an LLP agreement
to form Vishal Capricorn Energy Services LLP. The agreement includes a clause for
arbitration in case of disputes.

**Page 6**

Disputes Arising: Disputes arose in 2018 regarding the accounts of the LLP. The 
appellant issued a notice invoking arbitration only to respondent no. 1 and filed
a Section 11 application for the appointment of an arbitrator.

**Page 7**

Arbitral Tribunal’s Decision: The arbitral tribunal ruled that proceedings against
respondents 2 and 3 were not maintainable due to the absence of a notice invoking
arbitration served on them.

**Page 8**

High Court’s Ruling: The High Court dismissed the appellant’s appeal, affirming 
that since the Section 21 notice and Section 11 application did not include respondents
2 and 3, they could not be included later.

**Page 9**

Submissions by Appellant: The appellant’s counsel argued that the arbitral tribunal
has the power to implead parties even after reference to arbitration, based on their
involvement in the LLP agreement.

**Page 10**

Respondents’ Counterarguments: The respondents’ counsel contended that the absence
of a Section 21 notice and their non-inclusion in the Section 11 application barred
their participation in the arbitration.

**Page 11**

Legal Issues Framed: The court frames two legal questions regarding the prerequisites
for impleading a person in arbitration and the source of the tribunal’s jurisdiction.

**Page 12**

Section 21 Notice Explained: The court explains the purpose of the Section 21 notice,
emphasizing its role in determining the commencement of arbitration and the applicable
law.

**Page 13**

Implications of Non-Service: The court notes that non-service of the Section 21 
notice does not automatically bar a person from being impleaded in arbitration proceedings.

**Page 14**

Section 11 Application Purpose: The court discusses the limited scope of the Section
11 application, which is primarily to appoint an arbitrator and does not conclusively
determine who can be parties to arbitration.

**Page 15**

Jurisdictional Inquiry: The court emphasizes that the inquiry into who can be made
a party to arbitration is based on whether they are parties to the arbitration agreement.

**Page 16**

Competence-Competence Principle: The court reiterates that the arbitral tribunal
has the authority to determine its own jurisdiction, including the inclusion of 
non-signatories.

**Page 17**

High Court Decisions Reviewed: The court reviews various High Court decisions related
to the necessity of a Section 21 notice and the implications of non-service on jurisdiction.

**Page 18**

Cox and Kings Case Reference: The court references the Cox and Kings case, which
discusses the conditions under which non-signatories can be considered parties to
an arbitration agreement.

**Page 19**

Factors for Non-Signatories: The court outlines factors to determine if non-signatories
are bound by an arbitration agreement, including mutual intent and involvement in
the contract.

**Page 20**

Conclusion on Respondents’ Status: The court concludes that respondents 2 and 3 
are bound by the arbitration agreement due to their conduct and roles within the
LLP.

**Page 21**

Final Ruling: The court allows the appeal, reinstating the arbitral tribunal’s jurisdiction
over respondents 2 and 3, and directs that they be impleaded in the proceedings.

**Page 22**

No Costs Ordered: The court concludes with no order as to costs and disposes of 
any pending applications.

#### **Party**

Adavya Projects Pvt. Ltd. vs. M/s Vishal Structurals Pvt. Ltd. & Ors – Civil Appeal
No. 5297 of 2025 – 2025 INSC 507, April 17, 2025 – Hon’ble Justices Pamidighantam
Sri Narasimha and Manoj Misra.

[Adavya Projects Pvt Ltd vs. Vishal Structurals Pvt Ltd 45960_2024_11_1501_60992_Judgement_17-Apr-2025](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Adavya-Projects-Pvt-Ltd-vs.-Vishal-Structurals-Pvt-Ltd-45960_2024_11_1501_60992_Judgement_17-Apr-2025.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/Adavya-Projects-Pvt-Ltd-vs.-Vishal-Structurals-Pvt-Ltd-45960_2024_11_1501_60992_Judgement_17-Apr-2025.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
