# Class 2 – Principles on Sentencing Policy & Victim Compensation

- Link: https://section1.in/class-2-principles-on-sentencing-policy-victim-compensation/
- Published: 2023-01-12T07:52:33+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

**PRE BRITISH ERA:** Law makers thought to provide adequate and effective sentencing
to the offenders/criminals (after their trial is over and being convicted and not
before the trial) without any deviation from caste creed, religion and other factors
affecting general public. British thought it giving effective and correct sentencing
to every convict without any variance is the correct way of administering the CRIMES.

What happened to the earlier sentencing policy? If the earlier sentencing policy
was very effective why there was a need of writing a UNIFORM PENAL CODE, all over
INDIA in the year 1860? Does it mean now the PENAL administration or the Government
sentencing policy is for much better than the earlier? The answer is in affirmative.

**Why that the sentences though cruel in the PRE-BRITISH era were ineffective was
for the reason those sentences were not approved by the public.**

**CONVICTION:**

It is very necessary from the point of view of criminal justice that the guilty 
must be punished when the facts are fresh in the public mind **[M.S.sheriff and 
another vs. State of Madras – AIR 1954 SC 397 – 5 judge bench].**

**SENTENCING – A PROTRACTING DILEMMA:**

Guilt once established, the punitive dilemma begins. The choice between death penalty
and life term has to be made in a situation which is not altogether satisfactory.
Modern penology regards crime and criminal as equally material when the right sentence
has to be picked out, although in our processual system there is neither comprehensive
provision nor adequate machinery for collection and presentation of the social and
personal data of the culprit to the extent required in the verdict on sentence**[
Ediga Anamma vs. State of A.P – (1974) 4 SCC 443].**

**SENTENCING – AN APPLICATION OF MIND:**

1.** State of Punjab vs. Prem Sagar & Ors – (2008) 7 SCC 550** – We have noticed
the development of law in this behalf in other countries only to emphasise that 
the courts while imposing sentence must take into consideration the principles applicable
thereto. It requires application of mind. The purpose of imposition of sentence 
must also be kept in mind.

2. **State of A.P vs. Polamala Raju @ Rajarao – (2000)7 SCC 75** – To say the least,
the order contains no reasons, much less “special or adequate reasons”. The sentence
has been reduced in a rather mechanical manner without proper application of mind.

**DO WE HAVE SENTENCING POLICY – NEGATIVE:**

1. In our judicial system, we have not been able to develop legal principles as 
regards sentencing. The superior courts except making observations with regard to
the purport and object for which punishment is imposed upon an offender, had not
issued any guidelines. Other developed countries have done so. At some quarters,
serious concerns have been expressed in this behalf. Some Committees as for example
Madhava Menon Committee and Malimath Committee have advocated introduction of sentencing
guidelines **[STATE OF PUNJAB vs PREM SAGAR AND OTHERS – (2008) 9 SCALE 590=(2008)
7 SCC 550=(2008) 3 SCC(Cri) 183].**

2. There are no legislative or judicially laid down guidelines to assist the trial
court in meting out the just punishment to the accused facing trial before it after
he is held guilty of the charges** [Soman vs. State of Kerala – (2013) 11 SCC 382]**

**PRE-SENTENCE HEARING: [sections 235(2) & 248(2) Cr.P.C].**

Whether simply by way of oral submissions or by also bringing pertinent material
on record, there is no bar on the pre­sentencing hearing taking place on the same
day as the pre­conviction hearing. Depending on the facts and circumstances, a separate
date may be required for hearing on sentence, but it is equally permissible to argue
on the question of sentence on the same day if the parties wish to do so. Further
Apex Court has held that now we need to consider the impact of non­compliance of
procedure provided under Section 235(2) of CrPC by the trial court. Even assuming
that a procedural irregularity is committed by the trial court to a certain extent
on the question of hearing on sentence, the violation can be remedied by the appellate
Court by providing sufficient opportunity of being heard on sentence. It must be
kept in mind that Section 465 of the CrPC mandates that no finding, sentence or 
order passed by the Court of competent jurisdiction shall be reversed or altered
by the Court of appeal on account of any error, omission or irregularity in the 
order, judgment and other proceedings before or during trial unless such error, 
omission or irregularity results in a failure of justice. Such non­compliance can
be remedied by the appellate Court by either remanding the matter in appropriate
cases or by itself giving an effective opportunity to the accused **[Accused “X”
vs. State of Maharashtra – (2019) 6 Scale 407].**

**DO OTHER COUNTRIES HAVE SENTENCING POLICIES – AFFIRMATIVE:**

**UNITED KINGDOM**:Halliday report based on the white paper in the name of justice
for all presented before British Parliament. They are now having Sentencing council
for sentencing guidelines 2010 based on Criminal Court Sentencing Act, 2000.

**UNITED STATES**: Sentencing commission is an independent body created by Sentencing
Reform Act 1984.

**WHY THERE IS NO SENTENCING POLICY?**

That no two cases are exactly identical. There are countless permutations and combinations
which are beyond the anticipatory capacity of the human calculus. The court further
observed that standardization of the sentencing process tends to sacrifice justice
at the altar of blind uniformity **[Swamy Shraddananad’s case – 2013(5) SCC 546].**

**Finally, in simple words though we do not have any sentencing policy yet our sentencing
policy is more effective.**
 ** PRINCIPLE GOVERNING SENTENCING:

The principle governing imposition of punishment would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case. An offence which affects the morale of the society should
be severely dealt with**[(2009)2 SCC 272 – State of M.P vs. Babu Natt].**

**AIM/PURPOSE OF EFFECTIVE SENTENCING:**

A sentence aims to:

**Punish the offender** – this can include sending the accused to prison, paying
a fine.
 **(to) Protect the public**– from the offender and from the risk of more
crimes being committed by them. This could be by putting them in prison, restricting
their activities or supervision by probation. **(to provide) Compensation/ Make 
the offender give something back** – for example, by the payment of compensation
or through restorative justice. Restorative justice gives victims the chance to 
tell offenders about the impact of their crime and get an apology. **(helping society
in) Crimereduction** – by preventing the offender from committing more crime and
putting others off from committing similar offences. Maintain law and order [s.144
cr.p.c]. **Reform and rehabilitate offenders** – changing accused’s behaviour to
prevent future crime (for example by requiring an offender to have treatment for
drug addiction or alcohol abuse).

**EFFECTIVE SENTENCING STARTS WITH FOLLOWING:**

**1st stage:** during Remand, Bail, summons or warrant (includes recalling the warrants),
Administration of bonds – 88 and 446 cr.p.c

**2nd stage:**,Convicting in a non-cruel yet effective way as per Section 53 IPC[
Death Penalty, Imprisonment for life, Imprisonment, Forfeiture of property and Fine][
The main punishment removed by the British is ‘Banishment’] or as specified under
other Acts,

**3rd stage:**Considering Probation laws while delivering judgments

**4th stage:**Considering section 427 & Section 428 Cr.P.C while delivering,

**Final stage:** At last by suspending the sentence which was given following all
the above methodology.

**POWERS OF MAGISTRATES:**

1. Powers Under Cr.P.C – Section 29.

2. Sentencing powers under Cr.P.C –248 (chap –XIX – warrants case), 325, 360 and
361.

1. Section 325 Cr.P.C – cannot exceed the sentencing limits but can forward the 
accused to CJM/CMM.

2. Section 30 Cr.P.C – sentence of imprisonment for default [yes – but cannot exceeds
the power u/s 29 cr.p.c].

3. Section 31 Cr.P.C – several offences in one trial – subject to the provisions
of s.71 IPC.

4. Under N.I Act – s. 138 [has overriding effect of Cr.P.C pls see: **R.Vijyan v.
Baby & anr – (2012)1 L.W (Cri) 359 (SC)=2011 (4) Crimes 237 (SC)=(2011) 3 MWN (Cri)(
DCC) 107 (SC)].**

5. Probation, admonishing and compensatingvictim.

**PROBATION LAWS:**

Earlier Section 562 of the Code if Criminal Procedure, 1898, had been dealt with
probation. Thereafter, as under amendment in 1974 it turned as S.360 of Code of 
Criminal Procedure, 1973. S.361 makes it mandatory for the judge to declare the 
reasons for not awarding the benefit of probation.

Under Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 provides for 
the release of children who have committed offences to be released on probation 
of good conduct and placed under the care of any parent, guardian or other fit person,
on such parent, guardian or other fit person executing a bond, with or without surety,
or any fit institution as the board may require, for the good behaviour and well-
being of juvenile for any period not exceeding three years.

**PROBATION ACT – FIVE IMPORTANT ASPECTS TO BE CONSIDERED:**

1. Admonition (section 3);

2. Probation of Good Conduct (section 4);

3. Compensation and Costs (section 5);

4. Offenders under 21 years of age (section 6);

5. Report of Probation Officer (section 7).

**ADMONISHING – PROBATION:**

As per s.3 of P.O Act the Court may release the offender after due admonition, instead
of sentencing him but under section 4 without sentencing the offender to any punishment,
the Court may release the offender on probation of good conduct. **[Please note:**
that “report of Probation officer” is not mandatory to apply this provision but 
if report is available on the record, the Court shall take into consideration the
report of probation officer before making an order of probation of good conduct]

**The key factor for enacting P.O Act “Prison overcrowding”.**

**PROBATION – BAIL:**

The Under-trial Review Committee will also look into issue of implementation of 
the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 particularly with regard to first time offenders
so that they have a chance of being restored and rehabilitated in society** [IN 
RE., INHUMAN CONDITIONS IN 1382 PRISONS – 2016 1 MWN (Cr.) 474].**

**PROBATION – HOW TO APPRECIATE?** The question next to be considered is whether
the accused are entitled to the benefit of probation of good conduct? Many offenders
are not dangerous criminals but are weak characters or who have surrendered to temptation
or provocation. In placing such type of offenders, on probation, the Court encourages
their own sense of responsibility for their future and protect them from the stigma
and possible contamination of prison**[HARI KISHAN vs. SUKHBIR SINGH AND OTHERS –(
1988) 2 SCALE 426=(1988) 4 SCC 551=(1988) SCC(Cri) 984].**

**DIFFERENCE BETWEEN SECTION 360 CR.P.C & PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT, 1958:**

Section 360 of the Code relates only to persons not under 21 years of age convicted
for an offence punishable with fine only or with imprisonment for a term of seven
years or less, to any person under 21 years of age or any woman convicted of an 
offence not punishable with sentence of death or imprisonment for life. The scope
of Section 4 of the Probation Act is much wider. It applies to any person found 
guilty of having committed an offence not punishable with death or imprisonment 
for life. Section 360 of the Code does not provide for any role for Probation Officers
in assisting the Courts in relation to supervision and other matters while Probation
Act does make such a provision. While Section 12 of the Probation Act states that
the person found guilty of an offence and dealt with u/s 3 or 4 of the Probation
Act shall not suffer disqualification, if any, attached to conviction of an offence
under any law, the Code does not contain parallel provision. Two statutes with such
significant differences could not be intended to co-exist at the same time in the
same area. Such co-existence would lead to anomalous results. The intention to retain
the provisions of Section 360 of the Code and the provisions of the Probation Act
as applicable at the same time in a given area cannot be gathered from the provisions
of Section 360 or any other provision of the Code. Therefore, by virtue of Section
8(1) of the General Clauses Act, where the provisions of the Act have been brought
into force, the provisions of Section 360 of the Code are wholly inapplicable.Enforcement
of Probation Act in some particular area excludes the applicability of the provisions
of Sections 360, 361 of the Code in that area **[CHHANNI vs THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH–(
2006) Cri.L.J 4068 (SC)].**

**General understanding between P.O Act & 360 Cr.P.C:** The P.O Act, 1958 is more
expand than section 360 Cr.P.C. It has supervision request, payment of compensation,
post-trial supervision. Since, P.O is the Special Act it would stop section 360 
Cr.P.C.

**DUTY OF THE CORUT – SECTION 360 CR.P.C:**

When the matter was listed before this Court, a limited notice was issued as to 
why the provisions of Section 360 of the Criminal Procedure Code should not be made
applicable Pursuance to the said notice, Mr. Singh, the learned standing counsel
for the State of Bihar has entered appearance. From the perusal of the judgment 
of the learned Magistrate as well as the Court of Appeal, and that of the High Court,
it transpires that none of the forums below had considered the question of applicability
of Section 360 of the CrPC. Section 361 and Section 360 of the Code on being read
together would indicate that in any case where the Court could have dealt with an
accused u/s 360 of the Code, and yet does not want to grant the benefit of the said
provision then it shall record in its judgment the specific reasons for not having
done so. This has apparently not been done, inasmuch as the Court overlooked the
provisions of Sections 360 and 361 of the CrPC. As such, the mandatory duty cast
on the Magistrate has not been performed** [Chandreshwar Sharma vs. State of Bihar–(
2000)9 SCC 245=2000 SCC (Cri) 1500].**

**REMITTED BACK BY HON’BLE APEX COURT FOR CONSIDERING SECTION 360:**

Considering the aforesaid decision Hon’ble Apex Court has held that therefore, while
upholding the conviction, we remit the matter to the trial court for limited purpose
for deciding whether the benefit u/s 360 Cr.P.C. can be extended to the appellants**[
Eliamma & another v. State of Karnataka – (2009) 2 SCALE 484=(2009) 11 SCC 42=(2009)
3 SCC(Cri) 1227].**

**PUBLIC OPINION:**

• Public opinion is often confused with public pressure (media reactions).

• Public opinion is based upon the impact on social, political and cultural affiliations.

• Current public opinions shall not influence courts in its verdict.

• **Nirbhaya case:** Media proposed as if Public demands death sentence to rape 
convicts whereas the sentencing policy is ‘rarest of rare’ cases for awarding death
penalty.

**EFFECTIVE SENTENCING – CASE LAWS [guidelines of Hon’ble Apex/High Courts]:**

1. **SENTENCE – UNDUE LENIENCY** – The law on the principles governing proper sentencing
has been elaborated by this Court in a large number of cases. It is the duty of 
the Court awarding sentence to ensure justice to both the parties and therefore 
undue leniency in awarding sentence needs to be avoided because it does not have
the necessary effect of being a deterrent for the accused and does not reassure 
the society that the offender has been properly dealt with. It is not a very healthy
situation to leave the injured and complainant side thoroughly dissatisfied with
a very lenient punishment to the accused** [State of M.P vs. Udaiban – (2016)2 SCC(
Cri) 244=(2016)4 SCC 116].**

2. **NON-COMPOUNDABLE OFFENCE – SENTENCING POLICY – s.326 IPC (LIFE/UPTO 10 YRS 
AND FINE)**: Though it is stated that both the parties have amicably settled, in
view of the fact that the offence charged u/s 326 is non compoundable and also in
the light of serious nature of the injuries and no challenge as to conviction, we
are of the view that the High Court is not justified in reducing the sentence to
the period already undergone **[State of M.P vs. Najab Khan – AIR 2013 SC 2997].**

3**. CORRECTIVE MACHINERY or DETERRENCE SENTENCING POLICY – ONLY IN HEINOUS CRIMES:**
We would like to expand this principle in some more detail. We find, in practice
and in reality, after recording the conviction and while awarding the sentence/punishment
the court is generally governed by any or all or combination of the aforesaid factors.
Sometimes, it is the deterrence theory which prevails in the minds of the court,
particularly in those cases where the crimes committed are heinous in nature or 
depict depravity, or lack morality. After considering many principles Hon’ble Apex
Court has guided that in any case,** it cannot be denied that the purpose of punishment
by law is deterrence,** constrained by considerations of justice. What, then, is
the role of mercy, forgiveness and compassion in law? These are by no means comfortable
questions and even the answers may not be comforting. There may be certain cases
which are too obvious, namely, cases involving heinous crime with element of criminality
against the society and not parties inter se**[State Of H.P vs Nirmala Devi – (2017)
4 Scale 468=(2017) 7 SCC 262=(2017) 3 SCC(Cri) 380].**

4. **Section 324 IPC – SENTENCING POLICY (UPTO THREE YEARS OR FINE OR BOTH):** At
this juncture, we may repeat at the cost of repetition that imposition of sentence,
apart from the illustrations which have been stated to be mitigating factors would
depend upon many a other factors which will depend/vary from case to case. The legislature
in respect of an offence punishable u/s 124 of the Indian Penal Code has provided
punishment which may extend to three years or with fine or with both. Further Apex
Court reduced the sentence of three years of imprisonment to one year** [Gopal Singh
vs. State of Uttarakhand – AIR 2013 SC 3048].**

5. **MINIMUM OR MAXIMUM – Section – 307 IPC:** It is clear that the maximum punishment
provided therein is imprisonment for life or a term which may extend to 10 years.
Although section 307 IPC does not expressly state the minimum sentence to be imposed,
it is the duty of the courts to consider all the relevant factors to impose an appropriate
sentence. The legislature has bestowed upon the judiciary this enormous discretion
in the sentencing policy, which must be exercised with utmost care and caution.The
punishment awarded should be directly proportionate to the nature and the magnitude
of the offence. The benchmark of proportionate sentencing can assist the judges 
in arriving at a fair and impartial verdict **[Hazara Singh vs. Raj Kumar and others–(
2013) 9 SCC 519=(2014)1 SCC (Cri) 159] [Also please see: National Conference of 
Judges of the District Judiciary on Just sentencing: policy & Practice – 20th to
22nd March 2015].**

**6. RETRIBUTIVE THEORY OR REFORMATIVE THEORY:** The retributive theory has had 
its day and is no longer valid. Deterrence and reformation are the primary social
goals which make depreciation of life and liberty reasonable as penal panacea **[
Kunju Kunju Janartharan vs. State of Kerala – AIR 1979 SC 916].**

7. **EFFECTIVE SENTENCING IN CROSS CASES / COUNTER CASE–Nathi Lal & ors. vs. State
of U.P – (1990) Supp SCC 145; Sudhir vs State (2001) 2 SCC 688; State of M.P vs 
Mishrilal – (2003) 9 SSC 426.**

8. **CONCURRENT OR CONSECUTIVE – SECTION 279 IPC & SECTION 304-A IPC:**

a. It is not correct to state that when the court directs that two sentences should
run concurrently they merge into one sentence. **The word ‘concurrent’ means meeting
in the same point, running, coming, acting or existing together, coinciding, accompanying.‘
Concurrently’ means agreeing, when two sentences are directed to run concurrently,
it means, they run together** **[1982 Cr.L.J 1844 (A.P) – K. Venkata Reddy vs. Inspector
General of Prisons].**

b. In our considered opinion, it was necessary for the Magistrate to have ensured
compliance of Section 31 of the Code when she convicted and sentenced the appellant
for two offences in a trial and inflicted two punishments for each offence, namely,
Section 279 and Section 304-A IPC.In such a situation, it was necessary for the 
Magistrate to have specified in the order by taking recourse to Section 31 of the
Code as to whether the punishment of sentence of imprisonment so awarded by her 
for each offence would run concurrently or consecutively **[Gagan Kumar v The State
of Punjab – (2019) 3 SCALE 390].**

c. **MORE THAN TWO CASES** – Reliance has also been placed by Mr. Joshi in Ammavassi
and Anr. v. Inspector of Police, Valliyanur and Ors. AIR 2000 SC 3544. Therein, 
the appellants were convicted in four-five different cases, during a period of three
to four months. The appellants therein claimed benefit u/s 427 of the Code in order
to avoid undergoing imprisonment of a total period of 28 or 35 years in jail. This
Court opined that 14 years rigorous imprisonment would meet the ends of justice.
It is, therefore, clear that even in that case whereas Section 427 of the Code was
applied in three cases, but in two cases, the sentences were directed to run consecutively.
The said decisions, therefore, are not the authorities for the proposition that 
it is incumbent upon the court to direct in a case of this nature that both the 
sentences shall run concurrently and not consecutively **[M.R. KUDVA vsSTATE OF 
ANDHRA PRADESH – (2006) 14 SCALE 118=(2007) 2 SCC 772=(2007) 1 SCC(Cri) 648].**

**9. DEFAULT SENTENCE: CONCURRENT OR CONSECUTIVE:** In the circumstances, we reject
the submission regarding concurrent running of default sentences, as in our considered
view default sentences, inter se, cannot be directed to run concurrently **[Sharad
Hiru Kolambe vs The State Of Maharashtra – (2018) 11 Scale 305=(2019) Cri.L.J 567(
SC)].**

10. **SECTION 427 CR.P.C – FINE NOT PAID – CONSECUTIVE** – In terms of section 427(
1), if a person already undergoing a sentence of imprisonment is sentenced on a 
subsequent conviction imprisonment, such subsequent term of imprisonment would normally
commence at the expiration of the imprisonment to which he was previously sentenced.**
Only in appropriate cases, considering the facts of the case, the court can make
the sentence run concurrently with an earlier sentence imposed.** The investiture
of such discretion, presupposes that such discretion be exercised by the court on
sound judicial principles and not in a mechanical manner. Whether or not the discretion
is to be exercised in directing sentences to run concurrently would depend upon 
the nature of the offence/offences and the facts and circumstances of each case.**
Further Supreme Court has held that If the fine amount is not paid, the default 
sentence will run consecutively and not concurrently** [Anil Kumar vs. State of 
Punjab – 2017(2) MWN (Cri) 17 (SC)].

11.** SECTION 428 CR.P.C – SET OFF** – Reading section 428 Cr.P.C in the above perspective,
the words ‘of the same case’ are not to be understood as suggesting that the set-
off is allowable only if the earlier jail life was undergone by him exclusively 
for the case in which the sentence is imposed. The period during which the accused
was in prison subsequent to the inception of a particular case, should be credited
towards the period of imprisonment awarded as sentence in that particular case. 
It is immaterial that the prisoner was undergoing sentence of imprisonment in another
case also during the above said period. **The words ‘of the same case’, were used
to refer to the pre-sentence period of detention undergone by him**. Nothing more
can be made out of the collocation of those words [State of Maharashtra vs. Najakat@
Mubarak Ali – AIR 2001 SC 2255=(2001)SCC (Cri) 1106].

We find no merit in the contentions of the applicant. The following are the reasons.
Section 428 of Cr.P.C. on which the applicant lays considerable store by, actually
contemplates the presence of two circumstances. They have been highlighted in the
very judgment which the applicant relies on, namely (2001) 6 SCC 311, State of Maharashtra
and Another versus Najakat Alia Mubarak Ali. During the stage of investigation, 
inquiry or trial of a particular case the prisoner should have been in jail at least
for a certain period. The second requisite is that he should have been sentenced
to a term of imprisonment in that case. In the facts of this case, the applicant
was in custody admittedly in connection with another case on 15.11.2019 as also 
on 03.02.2020 and also on 16.03.2020. For the mere reason that this Court after 
convicting the applicant by order dated 15.11.2019 caused the production of the 
applicant before this Court for the purpose of considering the imposition of an 
appropriate sentence, it cannot be said that the applicant would be in custody. 
In this regard we notice that in the order dated 15.11.2019, the Court contemplated
a chance being afforded to the applicant to purge himself of the contempt. **Hon’ble
Apex Court after distinguishing Supreme court Judgment Niranjan Singh and Another
Versus Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote and Others – (1980) 2 SCC 559 which explains what
is custody has held as follows:**

As far as Section 428 of Cr.P.C. is concerned, an indispensable requirement to invoke
Section 428 of Cr.P.C. is that there must be a conviction. The conviction must be
followed by a sentence of imprisonment. It must be for a term and it should not 
be imprisonment in default of payment of fine. If these requirements exist, then
the occasion opens up for applying the beneficial provisions of Section 428 of Cr.
P.C. However, for it to be invoked the existence of detention undergone by the convict
during investigation, enquiry or trial in the ‘same case’ is indispensable. If these
requirements are satisfied, the convict would be entitled to the set off for the
period of detention which he has undergone **[Miscellaneous Application No.1902 
OF 2022 (@ DIARY NO.33420 OF 2022) with interlocutory application NO.157792/2022(
application for clarification/direction) IN CONTEMPT PETITION (CIVIL) NO.2120 OF
2018 IN SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) NO.20417 OF 2017 – MR. VINAY PRAKASH SINGH
PETITIONER(S) VERSUS SAMEER GEHLAUT & ORS. RESPONDENT(S) – IN THE MATTER OF:- SHIVINDER
MOHAN SINGH APPLICANT – 14th November, 2022].**

12. **SHALL ALSO BE FINE** – In the above case, this Court had considered Section
325 IPC and the phrase ‘and shall also be liable to fine’. The Court held that when
the punishment provided is for sentence of imprisonment and also with fine, the 
imprisonment and fine both are imperative** [Zunjarrao Bhikaji Nagarkar v. Union
of India and Others – (1999) 7 SCC 409 followed in State Of H.P vs Nirmala Devi –(
2017) 4 Scale 468=(2017) 7 SCC 262=(2017) 3 SCC(Cri) 380].**

13. **COMPOUNDING OF OFFENCE**– Section 320 of the Cr.P.C. enumerates and draws 
a distinction between offences as compoundable, either between the parties or with
the leave of the court.

14. **COMPOUNDING OF OFFENCE** – who may enter contract compounding? Section 320
of the Code articulates public policy with regard to the compounding of offences.
It catalogues the offences punishable under Indian Penal Code which may be compounded
by the parties without permission of the Court and the composition of certain offences
with the permission of the Court. **The offences punishable under the special statutes
are not covered by Section 320. When an offence is compoundable u/s 320, abatement
of such offence or an attempt to commit such offence or where the accused is liable
u/s 34 or 149 Indian Penal Code can also be compounded in the same manner. A person
who is under 18 years of age or is an idiot or a lunatic is not competent to contract
compounding of offence but the same can be done on his behalf with the permission
of the Court.** If a person is otherwise competent to compound an offence is dead,
his legal representatives may also compound the offence with the permission of the
Court. Where the accused has been committed for trial or he has been convicted and
the appeal is pending, composition can only be done with the leave of the Court 
to which he has been committed or with the leave of the appeal Court, as the case
may be. The Revisional Court is also competent to allow any person to compound any
offence who is competent to compound. The consequence of the composition of an offence
is acquittal of the accused. Sub-section (9) of Section 320 mandates that no offence
shall be compounded except as provided by this section. Obviously, in view thereof
the composition of an offence has to be in accord with Section 320 and in no other
manner **[DASAN vsSTATE OF KERALA AND ANOTHER – (2014) 1 SCALE 633=(2014) 12 SCC
666=(2014) 5 SCC(Cri) 186].**

15. **COMPOUNDING OF OFFENCE – SS..307 R/W 34 IPC** – The offence for which both
the appellants have been convicted is one under Section 307 read with Section 34
of the Indian Penal Code, but having regard to the nature of the injury sustained
by Shri Ram, we think that the proper offence for which the appellants should have
been convicted was under Section 324 read with Section 34. Shri Ram received only
one injury on the shoulder and that was also in the nature of simple hurt. We would,
therefore, convert the conviction of the appellants to one under Section 324 read
with Section 34. Since the parties belong to the same village and desire to compound
the offence, we think, in the larger interest of peace and harmony between the parties
and having regard to the nature of the injury, that it would be proper to allow 
the parties to compound the offence **[RAM PRASAD vs**
 **STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH–(
1982) 2 SCC 149=(1982) SCC(Cri) 375].**

16. **COMPOUNDING OF OFFENCE – SS 341 AND 325 IPC**– Offences Under Sections 341
and 325 are compoundable. In view of the settlement they can be permitted to be 
compounded. However, offences Under Sections 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code
are not compoundable. Hence, permission to compound them cannot be granted. However,
since the accused and the victim have entered into a compromise, we feel that it
would be in the interest of both sides to reduce the sentence awarded to the accused
Under Sections 325 and 341 of the Indian Penal Code to the sentence already undergone**[
SATHIYAMOORTHY vsSTATE – (2014) 8 SCALE 642=(2014) 13 SCC 52=(2014) 5 SCC(Cri) 540]**.
contradicting dasan case (supra).

17. **COMPOUNDING – LATEST GUIDELINES BY SUPREME COURT** – Merely because an offence
is compoundable under Section 320 Cr.PC, still discretion can be exercised by the
court having regard to nature of offence, as such it is rightly held in the impugned
judgment that as the offence for which appellant was convicted and sentenced, it
will have its own effect on the society at large. In view of the reasons recorded
in the impugned order rejecting the application for compounding, it cannot be said
that the High Court has committed any error in not accepting the application filed
for compounding the offence** [Bhagyan Das Versus The State of Uttarakhand & Another–
Criminal Appeal No. 465 of 2019 (Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No. 125 of 2017) – 11-
03-2019].**

18. **SECTION 138 N.I ACT – COMPROMISE – WHETHER PROSECUTION WILL BE OVER?**

An interesting question of law as to whether in view of payments or settlements 
made after the issuance of a Cheque, a Complainant can disclose the true state of
affairs and issue a demand for a lesser amount and whether in such circumstances
the Criminal prosecution for dishonour of a Cheque Page No: 146 for higher amount
is legally sustainable or not, did arise in this case. However, on account of subsequent
talks between the parties, an amicable Settlement has been arrived at and hence,
there is no requirement now to answer the aforesaid question of law in the present
proceedings and hence, the same is left open for adjudication in any other appropriate
case** [MOSER BAER PHOTO VOLTAIC LTD vs. PHOTON ENERGY SYSTEMS LTD – 2016 1 MWN (
Cr.) DCC 145 (SC)].**

**PLEA BARGAINING & GUILTY MEMO**

**Plea bargaining – what is?**

Plea bargaining is a concept based on the latin term “Nolo Contendere” which means
I do not wish to contend.

If an accused who is eligible admits his guilt voluntarily before the Presiding 
Officer than the court may release him on probation or award lesser punishment than
prescribed.

**EVOLUTION OF PLEA BARGAINING IN INDIA:**

Murlidhar Meghraj Loya and Another Vs State Of Maharashtra And Others – **AIR 1976
SC 1929;**

Thippaswamy vsState of Karnataka –** (1982) 2 SCALE 1398=(1983) 1 SCC 194.**

Kasambhai Abdulrehmanbhai Sheikh and Others Vs State Of Gujarat And Another – **
AIR 1980 SC 854** – Hon’ble Apex Court has held ‘Plea Bargaining” as **“unconstitutional”**.

Laws in India do not recognize the concept of plea-bargaining as such. However, 
section 206 (1) & (3) Cr.P.C and section 208 (1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
enable the accused to plead guilty to petty offences and to pay small fines. This
does not in any way involve bargaining between the prosecution and the accused. 
Section 320 Cr.P.C, specifies only 53 offences as compoundable (with or without 
the permission of the court) out of total of 383 offences under the I.P.C. Thus,
a large number of offences under the I.P.C cannot be compounded. Most of the special
enactments, that have created new offences, do not contain any provision for compounding
of such offences [please see also – State of U.P v. Chandrika – AIR 2000 SC 164=
2000 Cr.L.J 384 (SC)=1999 AIR SCW 4251=1999 (3) Crimes 137 (SC)=2000 (1) L.W (Cri)
375 (SC)=2000 SCC (Cri) 16=1999 (8) Supreme 723=1999 (8) SCC 638=2000 (1) SCJ 385].

**INTRODUCTION OF CONCEPT OF PLEA-BARGAINING IN INDIA:** Plea bargaining was introduced
in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 through Chapter – XXIA by Criminal Law (
Amendment) Act, 2 of 2006 **(w.e.f 05thJuly, 2006.)** Sections 265 A to L – 142nd,
154th& 177th Law Commission recommended.

**Plea Bargaining not applicable in the following cases:-**

1. The offence in which the maximum sentence is above 7 years.

2. The offence which has been committed against a woman or a child below 14 years
of age.

3. Where the accused has been previously convicted for the same offence.

4. Offence which affects the socio-economic condition of the country.

How to identify Socio-Economic Offences?

The Central Government has, by S.O. 1042(E), dated 11th July, 2006, determined the
offences under the following laws for the time being in force which shall be the
offences affecting the socio-economic condition of the country for the purposes 
of sub-section (1) of section 265A, namely,-

(i) Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961.

(ii) The Commission of Sati Prevention Act, 1987.

(iii) The Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986

(iv) The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956.

(v) The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005

(vi) The Infant Milk Substitutes, Feeding Bottles and Infant Foods (Regulation of
Production, Supply and Distribution) Act, 1992.

(vii) Provisions of Fruit Products Order, 1955 (issued under the Essential Services
Commodities Act, 1955).

(viii) Provisions of Meat Food Products Orders, 1973) (issued under the Essential
Commodities Act, 1955).

(ix) Offences with respect to animals that find place in Schedule I and Part II 
of the Schedule II as well as offences related to altering of boundaries of protected
areas under the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.

(x) The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.

(xi) Offences mentioned in the Protection of Civil Rights Act, 1955.

(xii) Offences listed in sections 23 to 28 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection
of Children) Act, 2000.

(xiii) The Army Act, 1950.

(xiv) The Air Force Act, 1950.

(xv) The Navy Act, 1957.

(xvi) Offences specified in sections 59 to 81 of the Delhi Metro Railway (Operation
and Maintenance) Act, 2002.

(xvii) The Explosives Act, 1884.

(xviii) Offences specified in sections 11 to 18 of the Cable Television Networks(
Regulation) Act, 1995.

(xix) The Cinematograph Act, 1952.

**PLEADING GUILTY:**

**GUILTY MEMO** –The scheme of the provision in the Cr.P.C makes it clear that when
particulars of the offence are put to the accused u/s 242 Cr.P.C, it is open to 
him to admit the allegation or if he does not plead guilty the Magistrate shall 
proceed to take evidence u/s 242(3) Cr.P.C and thereafter question the accused u/
s 313 Cr.P.C on the incriminating circumstances, then the Magistrate can accept 
the said plea, but not before the case reaches the stage of 313 Cr.P.C. There is
no provision in the Code which contemplates filing of a memo by the accused admitting
the guilt after the initial stage u/s 242 Cr.P.C and the conviction passed on such
memo is not according to law and following such a procedure is not justified **[
Balaji vs. Inspector of Police – (2001) 2 LW(Cri) 528=(2001) 2 M.W.N(Cri) 244].**

**ACCUSED PLEADED GUILTY WHILE QUESTIONING:**
 But, in my considered opinion, normally
an accused will plead guilty only expecting lenient punishment. The common principle
of penological proposition is that when an accused without contesting the matter
pleads guilty, the Court should be lenient [Geetha Devi and others vsD.I. Nathan
and others – (2015) 1 LW(Cri) 585=(2015) 2 MWN(Cri) 59].

**PLEADING GUILTY UNDER THE Cr.P.C:**

**Sections 229, 240, 252 Cr.P.C** – P. SARAVANAN vs. STATE – 2016 2 MWN (Crl) 626.

**GUILTY MEMO – DIRECTION TO PRESIDING OFFICERS:**

It is necessary to record as a future guidance to the Learned Magistrates who accept
the guilty plea that before acting upon such guilty memo, the Presiding Officer 
should ensure that the said memo is a voluntary one and it has emanated from the
proper source. Before acting upon the guilty memo, adequate time to the accused 
should be offered to reflect upon the guilty plea. While imposing sentence, based
on the guilt plea, the Presiding Officer should always consider the previous conduct
of the party, nature of offence and the possibility of indulging in similar offence
in future. After considering all these three facts, appropriate sentence should 
be imposed **[M.Manga vs State by: Inspector of Police, Police Station, Kancheepuram
District – Crl.R.C No.471 of 2012-15.02.2019].**
 **Aggravating or Mitigating:**

**What are mitigating circumstances?**[SANTOSH KUMAR SATISHBHUSHAN BARIYAR vsSTATE
OF MAHARASHTRA – (2009) 7 SCALE 341=(2009) 6 SCC 498=(2009) 2 SCC(Cri) 1150]

1. That the offence was committed under the influence of extreme mental or emotional
disturbance.

2. The age of the accused.

3. The probability that the accused would not commit criminal acts in the future.

4. The probability that the accused can be reformed and rehabilitated.

5. That the accused acted under the duress or domination of another person.

6. That the condition of the accused showed that he was mentally defective and that
the said defect impaired his capacity to appreciate the criminality of his conduct.

**SUSPENSION OF SENTENCE:**

Sections 389 (1), (2) and (3) of the code of criminal procedure deal with suspension
of sentence. Sections 389 (1)(2) deal with situation where convicted person can 
get a bail from Appellate court after appeal being filed and numbered. Section 389(
3) Cr.P.C deals with a situation whereby the Trial court itself can grant a bail
to person who has been convicted.

**COMPENSATION & VICTIM COMPENSATION**

**PROVISIONS:**

**General laws:**

1. compensation to victims of crime – sections 357, 357(1), 357 (2), 357 (3), 357A,
358, 359 and 250 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973

2. Constitution of India – Articles 14 and 21.

a. **Rudal Shah vs. State of Bihar** – AIR 1983 SC 1086 – Article 21 which guarantees
the right to life and liberty will be denuded of its significant content if the 
power of this Court were limited to passing orders to release from illegal detention.
One of the telling ways in which the violation of that right can reasonably be prevented
and due compliance with the mandate of Article 21 secured, is to mulct its violaters
in the payment of monetary compensation.

b. **D.K.Basu vs. state of W.B – (1997) SCC(Cri) 92** – Investigation – Arrest –
Custodial death – Right to constitutional remedies – Power of Court – Torture during
interrogation and investigation punishable under Section 330 IPC – Citizen is also
entitled to compensation from State.

**Special laws:**

1. Probation of Offenders Act, 1958.

2. Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,

3. The Scheduled Castes & The Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities Act, 1989),

4. Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993,

5. Workmen Compensation Act, 1923,

6. Domestic Violence Act, 2005,

7. Railways Act, 1989,

8. Tamil Nadu Victim Compensation Scheme, 2013 – by G.O M.S no: 1055 (30.11.2013)
based on the judgment **S. Sathia Chandran Versus State of Tamil Nadu, Rep. by the
Secretary to Government, Home Department & Another – W.P. NO. 17598 OF 2012** – 
This writ petition as Public Interest Litigation has been filed seeking a direction
upon the respondents to take steps and prepare a Victim Compensation Scheme as mandated
by Section 357-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

9. **Victim Compensation scheme, 2018**: for Protection of Children from Sexual 
Offences Act, 2012 (for short ‘POCSO’) – **NIPUN SAXENA AND ANOTHER vs. UNION OF
INDIA AND OTHERS – (2018) 15 Scale 769=(2019) 2 SCC 703**– by G.O. Ms. No. 1591,
Home (Pol.12) (24th September 2018) – published in Government Gazette dated: 3.10.2018

**OBJECT & SCOPE OF COMPENSATION – EXPLAINED**: after explained section 357 Cr.P.
C in detail the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that in awarding compensation as cautioned
by this Court in a decision reported in Palaniappa Gounder Vs. State of Tamil Nadu
and Others, , the Court should not first consider what compensation ought to be 
awarded to the heirs of the deceased and then impose a fine which is higher than
the compensation. It is the duty of the Court to take into account the nature of
the crime, the injury suffered, the justness of the claim for compensation, the 
capacity of the accused to pay and order relevant circumstances in fixing the amount
of fine or compensation **[SARWAN SINGH AND OTHERSvs. State of Punjab – AIR 1978
SC 1525].**

**Section 357 Cr.P.C:** Under S. 357 Cr.P.C only accused person can be directed 
to pay compensation to victim/injured and not state. Also, accused has to pay compensation
to victim and not to state [Section 357(3) Cr. P.C. provides for ordering of payment
by way of compensation to the victim by the accused- Balraj vs. State of H.P – (
1994) 4 SCC 29].

According to s. 357 subs. (1) and sub-s. (3) of Cr.P.C, the court may award compensation
to the victim of crime at the time of passing judgment. These provisions make the
trial courts and the appellate courts competent to award compensation to the victims
of crime only after conviction of the accused.

For payment of compensation under Section 357 (1) of Cr.P.C. imposition of fine 
is must as compensation can be ordered to be paid out of the fine imposed. Section
357(3) Cr.P.C empowers the Court to award compensation for loss or injury suffered
by a person, in cases where fine does not form a part of the sentence.

The basic difference between sections 357 (1) & (3) is that in the former case, 
the imposition of the fine is the basic and essential requirement, while in the 
latter even in the absence (of fine) thereof court can direct payment of compensation.

**COMPENSATION – DUTY OF COURT:** while the award or refusal of compensation in 
a particular case may be within the court’s discretion, there exists a mandatory
duty on the court to apply its mind to the question in every criminal case. Application
of mind to the question is best disclosed by recording reasons for awarding/refusing
compensation **[MANOHAR SINGH vsSTATE OF RAJASTHAN – (2015) 1 SCALE 448=(2015) 3
SCC 449=(2015) 2 SCC(Cri) 332].**

**Section 357A Cr.P.C:** This is because the object of Section 357- A Cr.P.C. is
to pay compensation to victims, where compensation paid under Section 357 of Cr.
P.C. is not adequate or where the case ended in acquittal or discharge and where
the victim is required to be rehabilitated **[E.AthiyasaKumar vs. The State of Tamil
Nadu, through the Secretary to Government, Home (Prison) Department, Secretariat,
Fort St. George, Chennai – W.P.(MD)No.16822 of 2016 and W.M.P.(MD) No.12198 of 2016–
21.02.2018].**

[When a person convicted for life sentence and directed to pay compensation and 
has no property to recover and also he determined to stay inside. Now, what would
be the fate of the compensation directed by the court to the victim].

**Who is entitled?** Every victim (irrespective of getting compensation under special
laws) is entitled to get compensation.

a. **ACCIDENT CASE – INSURANCE COMPANY PAID ALREADY**: In our view, the sentence
of mere fine of Rs. 40,000/- imposed by the High Court is not adequate and proportionate
to the offence. We have been informed that a sum of Rs. 3,60,000/- has been awarded
as compensation by the insurance company to the heirs of the deceased. We are also
of the view that where the accused is unable to pay adequate compensation to the
victim or his heir, the Court ought to have awarded compensation Under Section 357A
against the State from the funds available under the Victim Compensation Scheme 
framed under the said section **[State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Ram Pal – (2015) 
3 SCALE 111 : (2015) 11 SCC 584]**

b. **ACCUSED PAID ALREADY** – Regard being had to the aforesaid decisions we direct
the accused-respondent No. 2 to pay a compensation of Rs. 50,000/- and the State
to pay a compensation of Rs. 3 lakhs. If the accused does not pay the compensation
amount within six months, he shall suffer further rigorous imprisonment of six months,
in addition to what has been imposed by the trial court. The State shall deposit
the amount before the trial court within three months and the learned trial Judge
on proper identification of the victim, shall disburse it in her favour **[Ravada
Sasikala Versus State of Andhra Pradesh & Another – Criminal Appeal Nos. 406-407
of 2017 (@ S.L.P. (Criminal) Nos. 9389-90 of 2016) – dt: 27-02-2017]**.

**COMPENSATION – MUST BE REASONABLE**: The payment by way of compensation must, 
however, be reasonable. **What is reasonable, may depend upon the facts and circumstances
of each case. The quantum of compensation may be determined by taking into account
the nature of crime, the justness of claim by the victim and the ability of accused
to pay. If there are more than one accused, they may be asked to pay in equal terms
unless their capacity to pay varies considerably.** The payment may also vary depending
upon the acts of each accused. Reasonable period for payment of compensation, if
necessary by instalments, may also be given. The Court may enforce the order by 
imposing sentence in default **[HARI KISHAN vs. SUKHBIR SINGH AND OTHERS – (1988)
2 SCALE 426=(1988) 4 SCC 551=(1988) SCC(Cri) 984].**

**CAPACITY OF OFFENDER/CONVICT:**

1. In awarding compensation, the court has to decide whether the case is fit one
in which compensation has to be awarded. If it is found that compensation should
be paid, then the capacity of the accused to pay compensation has to be determined**[
Baldev singh @ anr vs. State of Punjab – (1995)6 SCC 593].**

2. Before issuing a direction to pay compensation, the capacity of accused to pay
the same must be judged. A fortiori, an enquiry in this behalf even in a summary
way may be necessary **[Dilip S. Dahnukar vs. Kotak Mahindra Co Ltd & anr – (2007)
6 SCC 528].**

3. Capacity of the accused to pay which constitutes an important aspect of any order
u/s 357 Code of Criminal Procedure would involve a certain enquiry albeit summary
unless of course the facts as emerging in the course of the trial are so clear that
the court considers it unnecessary to do so. Such an enquiry can precede an order
on sentence to enable the court to take a view, both on the question of sentence
and compensation that it may in its wisdom decide to award to the victim or his/
her family **[Ankish Shivaji Gaikwad vs. State of Maharashtra – (2013) 6 SCALE 778:(
2013) 6 SCC 770 : (2014) 1 SCC(Cri) 285 ].**

**LIMIT OF COMPENSATION**: No limit is mentioned in the sub-section and therefore,
a Magistrate can award any sum as compensation. Of course while fixing the quantum
of such compensation the Magistrate has to consider what would be the reasonable
amount of compensation payable to the complainant **[Pankajbhai Nagjibhai Patel 
vs. State of Gujarat – AIR 2001 SC 567=(2001) 1 SCALE 102=(2001) 2 SCC 595=(2001)
SCC(Cri) 369].**

**Sections 357(1) & 357 (3) Cr.P.C – difference of opinion in default of payment
of compensation [Chapter 32 – Execution]:**

1. Compensation can be directed to be paid both in terms of sub-section (1) of Section
357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure as also sub-section (3) thereof. However, 
while exercising jurisdiction under sub-section (3) of Section 357, no direction
can be issued that in default to pay the amount of compensation, the accused shall
suffer simple imprisonment. Such an order could have been passed only in terms of
sub-section (1) of Section 357. If the compensation directed to be paid by the Court
in exercise of its jurisdiction under sub- section (3) of Section 357, Criminal 
Procedure Code is not deposited, the same can be realised as fine in terms of Section
421 of the Code **[Ahmed Kutty vs. Abdullakoya – (2009) 6SCC 660=(2009) 3 SCC(Cri)
302]**.

2. It is true that the said provision does not include the power to impose a default
sentence, but read with Section 431 Cr.P.C. the said difficulty can be overcome 
by the Magistrate imposing the sentence. Supreme Court further concludes that the
provisions of Sections 357(3) and 431 Cr.P.C., when read with Section 64 IPC, empower
the Court, while making an order for payment of compensation, to **also include 
a default sentence in case of non-payment of the same [Vijayan vs. Sadanandan – 
2009 (6) SCC 652].**

3. **LATEST PROPOSITION:**

All the circumstances in sub­section (1) of Section 357 refer to direction to pay
compensation out of the fine imposed. Thus, all the circumstances are circumstances
where fine imposed and recovered is to be applied in the above circumstances **[
Satyendra Kumar Mehra @ Satendera Kumar Mehra vs. The State of Jharkhand – CRIMINAL
APPEAL NO.406 OF 2018 (ARISING OUT OF SLP(CRL.)NO.1994 OF 2018)]. As far as section
357 (3) Vijayan vs. Sadanandan (supra) case has been approved in Kumaran vs. State
of Kerala @ anr – (2017) 6 Scale 62=(2017) 7 SCC 471=(2017) 3 SCC(Cri) 431.**

**INTERIM COMPENSATION**: It is the duty of the court, on taking cognizance of a
criminal offence, to ascertain whether there is tangible material which showed the
commission of the crime, whether the victim was identifiable and whether the victim
of crime require immediate financial relief. On being satisfied either on application
or suo moto, the court ought to direct the grant of interim compensation, subject
to the final determination of compensation at a later stage. This duty continues
at every stage of criminal case, where compensation ought to be given but not given,
irrespective of the application by the victim. At the stage of final hearing, it
is obligatory on the part of the court to advert to the provision and record a finding
as to whether a case for grant of compensation had been made, if so who is entitled
to compensation and how much. Award of the compensation can be interim. 5. Gravity
of the offence and need of victim are to be the guiding factors, apart from other
factors which are relevant to the facts and circumstances of the case **[Suresh 
v. State of Haryana – criminal appeal No.420 of 2012 decided on 28 November, 2014]**[
Also there is a direction to National Judicial Academy to circulate this judgment
to all the courts in INDIA].

**DEPOSIT OF COMPENSATION AMOUNT**: On perusal of the S. 357(2) indicates that even
if the compensation amount is deposited, the payment cannot be made to the victim
before the decision of the appeal. It is not always necessary to insist for the 
payment of compensation amount as condition precedent for passing an order of suspension
of sentence. **The order of directing payment of compensation amount by the Trial
Court is also a subject matter of appeal being right of the accused. The position
may be different it is a case of remission.** [2011 – 1 – LW (Crl) 646 – C.Murugesan
vs. Prabakaran & ors].

**VICTIM COMPENSATION – DEPOSIT:**

Victim Compensation Scheme has been considered by this Court in State of H.P. Vs.
Rampal (2015(11) SCC 584) and this Court opined that compensation of Rs. 40,000/-
was inadequate taking note of the fact that the life of young child aged 20 years
was lost and taking note of the precedents observed that in the interest of justice,
the accused is required to pay a sum of Rs. 1 lakh and the State to pay a sum of
Rs. 3 lakhs as compensation. Taking note of the precedents of which reference has
been made, we consider it appropriate to observe that both the accused shall pay
the additional compensation of Rs. 1,50,000/-(Rupees One Lakh and Fifty Thousand)
each and the State of Himachal Pradesh shall pay the compensation as admissible 
under the Victim Compensation Scheme as in vogue to the acid victim (Ishita Sandhu,
D/o Late Shri Rikhi Ram Sandhu) (Appellant No. 2). If the accused does not pay the
additional compensation amount of Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees One Lakh and Fifty Thousand)
each within six months, the defaulting accused shall suffer rigorous imprisonment
of six months. The State shall deposit the compensation before the trial Court within
three months from today and the learned trial Court, after proper identification
of the victim, disburse at the earliest [State of Himachal Pradesh & Another Versus
Vijay Kumar Alias Pappu & Another – Criminal Appeal No. 753 of 2010 – 15-03-2019].

**EVALUATION OF VICTIM COMPENSATION SCHEME**: The 154th Law Commission Report on
the CrPC devoted an entire chapter to ‘Victimology’ in which the growing emphasis
on victim’s rights in criminal trials was discussed extensively as under:

**SECTION 357 – A CR.P.C – NO TRIAL:** Sub-section (4) of Section 357Astates that
even where no trial takes place and the offender is **not traced or identified**;
but the victim is known, the victim or his dependents can apply to the State or 
the District Legal Services Authority for award of compensation.

**VICTIM COMPENSATION SCHEME– NOT ENOUGH:** The Courts have provided solace to the
victim with monetary compensation, but that is not enough. There are victim compensation
schemes in force due to the mandate of Section 357A of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (the Cr.P.C.) but even that is not enough, though they are being implemented
in several parts of the country. We are of the view that the judiciary is obliged
to go and has gone beyond merely awarding compensation and has taken into consideration
the larger picture from the perspective of the victim of an offence, relating to
infrastructure in court buildings and has recommended and implemented some recommendations
such as the construction of child friendly courts and courts that address the concerns
of vulnerable witnesses. The Courts have done and are continuing to do their best
for the victims of crime** [MALLIKARJUN KODAGALI (DEAD) REPRESENTED THROUGH LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES vs STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS – (2018) 14 Scale 32 : (2019) 2 SCC
752 : (2019) 1 SCC(Cri) 801].**

**VICTIM COMPENSATION FUNDUTILISATION – Tamilnadu:** While dealing a Writ Petition,
Madras (Madurai) High Court has directed that the first respondent shall thereafter
issue appropriate directions for disbursement of the victim compensation fund deducted
from the wages of the prisoners under rule 486(6) of Tamil Nadu Prison Rules, 1983.
Such direction shall be issued within 8 weeks thereafter **[E.AthiyasaKumar vs. 
The State of Tamil Nadu, through the Secretary to Government, Home (Prison) Department,
Secretariat, Fort St. George, Chennai – W.P.(MD)No.16822 of 2016 and W.M.P.(MD) 
No.12198 of 2016 – 21.02.2018].**

**DIFFERENCE BETWEEN COMPENSATION SCHEME UNDER SECTION 357-A AND SECTION 357,CRPC:**

1. Under Section 357 A, compensation is payable out of funds created by the State
Government and under Section 357, it is payable out of fine recovered from convict.

2. Under Section 357 A, compensation is payable even if offender is not traced or
identified but under Section 357, it is payable only upon conviction of offender.

3. Under Section 357 A, compensation is payable in addition to compensation awarded
under Section 357 and under Section 357, there is no such provision.

4. Section 357 A is a mandatory provision for compensation whereas Section 357 is
discretionary for the courts but mandatory for State government.

5. Under Section 357 A, order for compensation is made by District Legal Service
Authority or State Legal Service Authority and under Section 357 by the Court.

6. Section 357 A empowers District Legal Service Authority or State Legal Service
Authority to make Order for interim relief and under Section 357, there is no such
provision.

7. Under Section 357 A, no condition is specified for dependents of victim entitled
to compensation.Under Section 357 only dependents or heirs of victim who are entitled
under Fatal Accidents Act can claim compensation.

**PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT,1958** – Power of court to require released offenders
to pay compensation – The Court directing the release of an offender under section
3 or section 4 may make at the same time a further order directing him to pay such
compensation as the court thinks reasonable for loss or injury caused to any person
by the commission of the offence; and such costs of the proceedings as the court
thinks reasonable.

**PROBLEMS**

**PROBLEM-1: SECTION 360 CR.P.C – ADMONISHING – SECTION 357 CR.P.C:**

The Trial Court (Judicial Magistrate), after having taken into account the prosecution
case, the supporting evidences as well as the facts and circumstances of the case,
ultimately had come to a conclusion that A1 deserved to be admonished. According
to the Trial Court (J.M), even though the charge against him under Section 323 of
IPC was proved, it was not a serious one and therefore, taking into account the 
situation faced by the said A1, instead of sentencing him, released him by admonishing
under Section 360 of Cr.P.C.. Further, at the same time, the Trial Court ordered
a compensation of a sum of Rs.5000/- to be paid by A1 to the victim, viz., P.W.2
by invoking Section 357(3) of Cr.P.C –** Legal Position to be discussed.**

**PROBLEM-2: SUSPENSION OF SENTENCE – EXTENSION OF TIME:**

Accused got convicted in the Judicial Magistrate Court – sentenced for 1 year and
fine of rs.1000 rupees for section 324 IPC (since S.324 is for punishment for extend
to 3 years, or with fine, or with both) – paid fine – sentence suspended upto 30
days under section 389 (3) Cr.P.C – preferred appeal late and pending before the
Sessions Court – sentence not suspended – nearing the deadline directed by the J.
M – Appellant/Accused filed application for extension of time –**Legal Position 
to be discussed.**

**Discussion:**

1. Whether P.O Act 1958 will apply on N.I Act 1872 (section138)?

2. Whether complainant in N.I Act can recover his compensation even after the accused
undergone imprisonment for default?

3. Whether s.320 Cr.P.C will apply to J.J. Act 2000?

4. Whether compounding of offences will be effective even after the death of the
complainant or accused?

5. Whether High Court or Trial Court can direct the accused to file suspension of
sentence application for a prescribe period (for instance 1 year) after filing the
appeal?

**ANSWERS,/u>**

**PROBLEMS:**

**A – Problem-1: s.360 – Admonishing – S.357 Cr.P.C:** – After a person gets admonished,
he cannot be treated to be a person who had suffered with sentence. He may be a 
convicted person, but has not been sentenced. When the court thinks to impose a 
sentence, in view of the language used in sub section (3) of section 357, the Court
does not have the power to impose compensation payable to the victim, on the person
who has been admonished **[R.Chinnadurai & Others Versus State rep. by The Inspector
of Police, Irumpulikurichi Police Station, Irumpulikurichi, Sendurai Taluk, Ariyalur
District – (2018) 2 MLJ (Crl) 710 (mad)=2018(2) MWN (crl) 387]**.

**A – Problem-2: SUSPENSION OF SENTENCE – EXTENSION OF TIME:** As per section 389(
3) Cr.P.C sufficient time to present appeal and obtain orders of the Appellate court
must be given to the accused while suspending the sentence. Further, Madras High
Court has held that section 389(3) Cr.P.C also says that sufficient time not only
to present the appeal but also to obtain the orders of the court [Samuvel and Others
vs. Inspector of Police – 2013(1) CLT (Cri) 745 (Mad)].The learned Magistrate lacks
jurisdiction to grant suspension beyond 30 days from the date of imposition of sentence[
P.Ramakrishnan vs. Rani Rambai – 2012(1) MWN(Cri) (DCC) 97]

**DISCUSSION**

**Whether P.O Act 1958 will apply on N.I Act 1872 (section138)?**

If the trial Court comes to the conclusion that the accused is guilty, then it is
open to the learned Judicial Magistrate to take into consideration about the payment
made by the accused and also take into consideration the other factors and to show
leniency while sentencing the accused. Even the learned Judicial Magistrate may 
apply the relevant provision u/s 3 of the Probation of Offenders Act and admonish
him, subject to Section 361 of Code of Criminal Procedure [P.S. SETHURAMAN vsP. 
ELAVAZHAGAN – (2010) 1 LW(Cri) 697=(2010) 1 MWN(Cri) DCC 80=(2010) 3 MLJ(Criminal)
313]. Also: KUMARAN vsSTATE OF KERALA – (2017) 6 Scale 62=(2017) 7 SCC 471=(2017)
3 SCC(Cri) 431.

**Whether complainant in N.I Act can recover his compensation even after the accused
undergone imprisonment for default?**

Thus it is clear that the object of the legal fiction created by Section 431 is 
to extend for the purpose of recovery of compensation until such recovery is completed–
and this would necessarily take us not only to Section 421 of the Cr.P.C. but also
to Section 70 of the Penal Code, a companion criminal statute, as has been held 
above [KUMARAN vsSTATE OF KERALA – (2017) 6 Scale 62=(2017) 7 SCC 471=(2017) 3 SCC(
Cri) 431].

**Whether s.320 Cr.P.C will apply to J.J. Act 2015?**

Yes, only to the IPC offences. Though the J.J Act is the procedurally overflow, 
there are sections which are penal in nature to the accused therein. Those sections
cannot be compounded in the terms of section 320 Cr.P.C inasmuch as J.J Act is a
special Act [Theoffences punishable under the special statutes are not covered by
Section 320 – DASAN vsSTATE OF KERALA AND ANOTHER – (2014) 1 SCALE 633=(2014) 12
SCC 666=(2014) 5 SCC(Cri) 186].

**Whether compounding of offences will be effective even after the death of the 
complainant or accused?**

State cannot compound the offence: no one on behalf of the State is empowered to
compound the offences. However, the public prosecutor may withdraw from prosecution
with the consent of the Court, as provided for in Section 321 CrPC [LAW COMMISSION
OF INDIA – Compounding of (IPC) Offences Report No. 237 December, 2011]. Then only
the parties can compound the offences. De-facto complainant can enter into the contract
of compounding of offences with the accused, if the the complainant is dead then
their legal heirs can enter into compounding of offences [Deva Ram … Appellant Vs.
The State of Rajasthan & Anr – CRL APL NO:1165 OF 2014 –23rd july 2014 in trial 
court section 302 Cr.P.C].

**Accused: Jugal Kishore Khetawat vs. State of W.B; II (2011) CCR 378 (SC) – to 
continue prosecution.** [An amendment to S. 431 Cr.P.C (old code) was suggested 
in the Bill introduced in the Parliament by a private member, Shri.K.V.Raghunatha
Reddy. **The main object of the amendment was to provide machinery whereby the children
or the members of the family of a convicted person who dies during the appeal could
challenge the conviction and get rid of the odium attaching to the family as a result
of the conviction.** The Law Commission of India by its Forty – Fourth(44th)Report[
1] found the proposed amendment ‘eminently sound’ and recommended that the amendment
be made with certain modifications. Accordingly S. 394 Cr.P.C has made the said 
proviso].

**Whether High Court or Trial Court can direct the accused to file suspension of
sentence application for a prescribe period (for instance 1 year) after filing the
appeal?**

However, we have also taken note of the observations made in the last part of the
order impugned, whereby, the High Court has provided that the petitioner shall not
approach the Court “before a minimum period of three years from the date of conviction”.
The aforesaid observations cannot be approved for the simple reason that seeking
relief of suspension of execution of sentence and to be released on bail is the 
statutory right of the appellant and there is no warrant for such a proposition 
that any appellant be debarred, from renewing his prayer for suspension of execution
of sentence, for a particular period. As to whether such a prayer is to be granted
or not is a matter entirely different but such kind of time-specific debarment is
not envisaged by the law. Therefore, we would annul the aforesaid observations occurring
in the penultimate paragraph of the order impugned **[Krishan Kumar vs. The State
of Haryana – S.L.P (crl) No: 612 / 2022- 31.01.2022 – Court-14 – Item No.20].**

[1]September, 1969, Vol. I, pp. 279-81

**URL:**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
