# Conviction Sudden provocation

- Link: https://section1.in/conviction-sudden-provocation/
- Published: 2023-04-08T08:39:32+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Party](https://section1.in/conviction-sudden-provocation/#party)

The Appellant in Criminal Appeal No.430 of 2014 was convicted for an offence under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘IPC’)
and sentenced to life imprisonment. The Appeal preferred by him was dismissed by
the High Court. The Appellants in Criminal Appeal Nos.458-459 of 2014 who were tried
along with the Appellant in Crl. Appeal 430 of 2014 were acquitted by the Trial 
Court. Their acquittal was challenged by the State and the wife of the deceased 
before the High Court. The High Court reversed the acquittal and convicted them 
under Section 302 and sentenced them to life imprisonment. Aggrieved by the judgment
of the High Court, the Appellants have filed the above Appeals.

 1. An FIR was registered at 11:45 am on 11.01.2010 on the basis of statement given
    by Sadiq Hussain Majloom Jafri (PW-3). As per the FIR, Sarfraj Akbar Syyed who 
    was a resident of Jamkhed, District Ahmednagar was eking out his livelihood by 
    selling goggles and spectacles. Sadiq Hussain Majloom Jafri (PW-3) along with his
    cousin Jafar Ali (PW-4) reached Ahmednagar at 10:00 am on 09.01.2010. They spent
    the whole day selling goggles at Ahmednagar and spent the night in a hotel. They
    continued their activity of selling goggles during the day time on 10.01.2010 also.
    On the night of 10.01.2010, they were joined by their maternal uncle Sarfraj and
    all of them stayed at a lodge. At 09:00 am PW-3, PW-4 and Sarfraj reached Chaudhari
    Dhaba at Nagar Manmad road, Tal. Nagar, Ahmednagar. They made an attempt to sell
    the goggles to the truck drivers at the dhaba, in vain. They sat on a cot in front
    of the dhaba and were having tea. The Appellants reached the dhaba and asked Sarfraj
    to step aside as they wanted to speak to him. Sarfraj went with the Appellants 
    to the rear side of the dhaba. After some time PW-3 and PW-4 heard abuses and shouts
    from the back side of dhaba and they rushed to see what was happening. They saw
    Sigva Ali (A-4) and Javed Ali (A-3) catching hold of the hands of Sarfraj. Sikandar
    Ali (A-1) attacked Sarfraj with a knife on the left side of his neck. They also
    saw Shahajan Ali (A-2) abusing Sarfraj and assaulting him by giving him fist blows.
    PW-3 and PW-4 started shouting for help and caught hold of A-1 and A-2 not permitting
    them to escape. A-3 and A-4 ran away from the spot. PW-7 who was working at the
    dhaba also witnessed the incident. On receipt of information, the police reached
    the place of occurrence within half an hour. A-1 and A-2 were taken into custody
    by the police. PW-3 and PW-4 took Sarfraj to the Civil Hospital, Ahmednagar in 
    an auto rickshaw. At 11:30 am, the doctor examined Sarfraj and declared him dead.
    Thereafter, PW-3 and PW-4 went to the MIDC Police Station and reported the incident.
 2. The Post-mortem was conducted by Dr. Sandhya Deorao Chavan (PW 8) at the Civil 
    Hospital, Ahmednagar at 2.30 pm. The external injury found on the dead body was
    described as follows in the post-mortem certificate issued by PW 8 :-

> “1/- Deep incised wound on left side of neck at corotidregion, horizontal, slightly
> curved laterally 3” length, 1” in breadth and 2.1/2” in depth. Deeper on lateral
> aspect than medical aspect. Edges are well defined clean and everted and deeply
> stained. Sprouting of blood seen on left side of chest, shoulder and back. Carotid
> vessel torn and retracted on left side.”

 1. The cause of death was haemorrhage shock due to rupture of right carotid vessel.
    Charge-sheet was filed against all the four accused and thereafter charges were
    framed for an offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. The
    Trial Court **[convicted the Appellant in Criminal](http://localhost:8080/section1/suicide-no-dowry-demand-a-moral-conviction-regarding-the-guilt-of-an-individual-has-no-place-in-criminal-jurisprudence/)**
    Appeal No. 430 of 2014 for an offence punishable under Section 302 and sentenced
    him to life imprisonment. The other accused who are Appellants in Criminal Appeal
    Nos. 458-459 of 2014 were acquitted by the Trial Court. As stated earlier, the 
    conviction and sentence of the Appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 430 of 2014 was
    confirmed by the High Court. The acquittal of the Appellants in Criminal Appeal
    Nos. 458-459 of 2014 was reversed by the High Court and they were convicted under
    Section 302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment.
 2. The deceased Sarfraj was having a shop at Jamkhed where he was selling goggles.
    He was the maternal uncle of PW-3 who is also in the same business. PW-3 was being
    helped by the deceased for selling goggles in the Ahmednagar area. The case of 
    the prosecution is that there was rivalry between the accused and the deceased 
    as they were in the same business. PW-3, PW-4 and PW-7 deposed that at 10:00 am
    the deceased, PW-3 and PW-4 reached Chaudhari dhaba at Nagar Manmad road and were
    having tea. All the accused reached the dhaba and took the deceased behind the 
    dhaba saying that they wanted to speak to him. There is evidence on record to show
    that the deceased was attacked by Sikandar Ali (A-1) with a knife and the other
    accused assisted him in the attack. Sikardar Ali (A-1) and Shahjahan Ali (A-2) 
    were caught and handed over to the police at the spot. Though PW-3 and PW-4 were
    related to the deceased, their evidence is credible and trustworthy. The oral testimony
    of PW-7 who was working at the dhaba is consistent with the version of PW-3 and
    PW-4. The medical evidence of PW-8 corroborates the oral testimonies. We are in
    agreement with the findings recorded by the Trial Court that the death of Sarfraj
    is homicidal in nature. We also do not find fault with the finding recorded by 
    the Trial Court that the death of Sarfraj was caused due to the injury caused by
    Sikandar Ali (A-1). We find no fault with the judgment of the High Court in confirming
    the findings of the Trial Court that Sikandar Ali is guilty of causing the death
    of Sarfraj.
 3. The Trial Court acquitted accused 2 to 4 on the ground that the only role that 
    was attributed to them by PW-3 and PW-4 was that they caught hold of the hands 
    of the deceased during the attack. The Trial Court further held that though the
    presence of the Appellants in Crl. Appeal Nos.458-459 of 2014 was proved there 
    was no evidence to prove the common intention of these accused along with A-1. 
    The Trial Court also held that there was no evidence to show that the attack was
    pre-meditated. In the appeals against acquittal, the High Court held that there
    was a common intention on the part of A-1 to A-4 to eliminate Sarfraj. The High
    Court further held that A-2 to A-4 assisted A-1 to cause injury to the deceased,
    and, thus, were liable to be punished for the homicide. On the basis of the said
    findings, the High Court convicted A-2 to A-4 under Section 302 IPC and sentenced
    them to life imprisonment.
 4. We have no doubt about the complicity of all the accused in the homicide of Sarfraj.
    A-1 attacked the deceased with the knife and caused injury on his neck which resulted
    in his death. The other accused assisted him in committing the crime by holding
    the hands of the deceased. However, the only question that falls for our consideration
    is whether the accused are liable to be punished for an offence under Section 302
    IPC. After considering the submissions made by the counsel for the Appellants and
    scrutinising the material on record, we are of the opinion that the accused are
    not liable to be convicted under Section 302 IPC. We are convinced that there was
    neither prior concert nor common intention to commit a murder. During the course
    of their business activity the accused reached the dhaba where the deceased was
    present. An altercation took place during the discussion they were having behind
    the dhaba. That led to a sudden fight during which A-1 attacked the deceased with
    a knife. Exception 4 to Section 300 is applicable to the facts of this case. As
    we are convinced that the accused are responsible for the death of Sarfraj, we 
    are of the opinion that they are liable for conviction under Section 304 part II
    of the IPC. We are informed that A-1 has undergone a sentence of seven years and
    that A-2 to A-4 have undergone four years of imprisonment. We modify the judgment
    of the High Court converting the conviction of the accused from Section 302 to 
    Section 304 part II of the IPC sentencing them to the period already undergone.
    They shall be released forthwith.
 5. The Appeals are disposed of accordingly.

##### **Party**

SHAHAJAN ALI & ORS. .. Appellant(s) Versus STATE OF MAHARASHTRA ETC Respondent(s)–
CRIMINAL APPEAL Nos.458-459 of 2014 – May 23, 2017

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2013/36089/36089_2013_Order_23_May_2017.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2013/36089/36089_2013_Order_23_May_2017.pdf)**

**[SHAHAJAN-ALI-ORS-vs.-STATE-OF-MAHARASHTRA-ETC-CRIMINAL-APPEAL-Nos.458-459-of-2014](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/SHAHAJAN-ALI-ORS-vs.-STATE-OF-MAHARASHTRA-ETC-CRIMINAL-APPEAL-Nos.458-459-of-2014-1.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
