# Section 313 Cr.P.C: If the defence provided by the accused under section 313(1)(b) and the court did not considers it then the conviction does not stand

- Link: https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/
- Published: 2023-03-22T11:29:50+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Essentials of circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/#essentials-of-circumstantial-evidence)
 * [Accused must have a benefit of lawyer](https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/#accused-must-have-a-benefit-of-lawyer)
 * [Defence taken under section 313 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/#defence-taken-under-section-313-crpc)
 * [If the accused takes defence under section 313 cr.p.c then the court must consider the same](https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/#if-the-accused-takes-defence-under-section-313-crpc-then-the-court-must-consider-the-same)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/court-must-give-finding-accepting-or-rejecting-s-313-cr-p-c-statement/#further-study)

7. We have considered the respective submissions, the orders of the courts below,
as also the evidence available on record. Normally this court under Article 136 
of the Constitution, would be reluctant in appeal to interfere with the concurrent
findings of two courts by re-appreciating the facts and evidence. But in an appropriate
case, if this court finds that there has been erroneous consideration and appreciation
of facts and evidence, leading to miscarriage of justice, this court is duty bound
to ensure that ultimately justice prevails. It is a well established principle of
criminal jurisprudence that several accused may go free, but an innocent person 
should not be punished. In Anant Chintaman Lagu v. State of Bombay, (1960) 2 SCR
460 this court observed as follows :-

> “16. Ordinarily, it is not the practice of this Court to re-examine the findings
> of fact reached by the High Court particularly in a case where there is concurrence
> of opinion between the two Courts below. But the case against the appellant is
> entirely based on circumstantial evidence, and there is no direct evidence that
> he administered a poison, and no poison has, in fact been detected by the doctor,
> who performed the post-mortem examination, or by the Chemical Analyser. The inference
> of guilt having been drawn on an examination of a mass of evidence during which
> subsidiary findings were given by the two Courts below, we have felt it necessary,
> in view of the extraordinary nature of this case, to satisfy ourselves whether
> each conclusion on the separate aspects of the case, is supported by evidence 
> and is just and proper. Ordinarily, this Court is not required to enter into an
> elaborate examination of the evidence, but we have departed from this rule in 
> this particular case, in view of the variety of arguments that were addressed 
> to us and the evidence of conduct which the appellant has sought to explain away
> on hypotheses suggesting innocence. These arguments, as we have stated in brief,
> covered both the factual as well as the medical aspects of the case, and have 
> necessitated a close examination of the evidence once again, so that we may be
> in a position to say what are the facts found, on which our decision is rested.”

##### **Essentials of circumstantial evidence**

8. The essentials of circumstantial evidence stand well established by precedents
and we do not consider it necessary to reiterate the same and burden the order unnecessarily.
Suffice it to observe that in a case of circumstantial evidence the prosecution 
is required to establish the continuity in the links of the chain of circumstances,
so as to lead to the only and inescapable conclusion of the accused being the assailant,
inconsistent or incompatible with the possibility of any other hypothesis compatible
with the innocence of the accused. Mere invocation of the last seen theory, sans
the facts and evidence in a case, will not suffice to shift the onus upon the accused
under Section 106 of the Evidence Act,1872 unless the prosecution first establishes
a prima facie case. If the links in the chain of circumstances itself are not complete,
and the prosecution is unable to establish a prima facie case, leaving open the 
possibility that the occurrence may have taken place in some other manner, the onus
will not shift to the accused, and the benefit of doubt will have to be given.

##### **Accused must have a benefit of lawyer**

9. Before proceeding with the discussion further, we deem it proper to notice that
the appellant did not have the benefit of a lawyer of her choice, both before the
trial court and the High Court, naturally because of some handicap. She had to be
provided legal assistance by the Legal Services Authority. This is not to make any
comment or observation on the nature of the defence made available to the appellant,
but only to notice her handicap in establishing her innocence.

##### **Defence taken under section 313 Cr.P.C**

15. In the background of the aforesaid discussion regarding the nature of evidence
and the manner of its appreciation, we deem it proper to set out the English translation
in the paper book of defence taken by the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C. as
follows:-

“Ans: On the date of occurrence at about 8-8:30 while I have returned from my work
at Satgaon, I saw that my husband was lying in the room with bleeding injury. On
my cry, Manoj Dekaand his brothers come there with drink in the hand of one brother.
Thereafter I saw Manoj Deka was putting Dettol on the wound of my husband. I also
rang to 108 ambulance. When, I wanted to call police Manoj Deka, snatched the phone
from me. On my crying neighbouring peoples arrived there. I tried to take my husband
to medical but due to non-co-operation my Manoj Deka and others, I failed to take
him to Medical. On that night at about 9.30 expired and Manoj Deka and other neighbours
were sitting. Subsequently Manoj Deka has falsely implicated me. I have the suspicion
that my husband was physically assaulted earlier at some place by Mintu Nath, Dipak
Das and Jeetu Deka while taking liquor and brought by husband on injured condition
and laid in the room. I also saw the lock of my room in broken condition, when I
arrived here. I have not killed my husband. I am innocent.” PW-2 has acknowledged
in his evidence that he would have drinks with the deceased. According to the post-
mortem report, the stomach of the deceased was found empty, suggesting that the 
assault had taken place earlier in the evening contrary to the evidence of PWs. 
1, 2 and 3 suggesting the assault in the late hours of the night by which time the
deceased would undoubtedly have had his dinner”.

PW-2 has acknowledged in his evidence that he would have drinks with the deceased.
According to the post-mortem report, the stomach of the deceased was found empty,
suggesting that the assault had taken place earlier in the evening contrary to the
evidence of PWs. 1, 2 and 3 suggesting the assault in the late hours of the night
by which time the deceased would undoubtedly have had his dinner.

##### **If the accused takes defence under section 313 cr.p.c then the court must consider the same**

16. Section 313, Cr.P.C. cannot be seen simply as a part of audi alteram partem.
It confers a valuable right upon an accused to establish his innocence and can well
be considered beyond a statutory right as a constitutional right to a fair trial
under Article 21 of the Constitution, even if it is not to be considered as a piece
of substantive evidence, not being on oath under Section 313(2), Cr.P.C. The importance
of this right has been considered time and again by this court, but it yet remains
to be applied in practice as we shall see presently in the discussion to follow.
If the accused takes a defence after the prosecution evidence is closed, under Section
313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. the Court is duty bound under Section 313(4) Cr.P.C. to consider
the same. The mere use of the word ‘may’ cannot be held to confer a discretionary
power on the court to consider or not to consider such defence, since it constitutes
a valuable right of an accused for access to justice, and the likelihood of the 
prejudice that may be caused thereby. Whether the defence is acceptable or not and
whether it is compatible or incompatible with the evidence available is an entirely
different matter. If there has been no consideration at all of the defence taken
under Section 313 Cr.P.C., in the given facts of a case, the conviction may well
stand vitiated. To our mind, a solemn duty is cast on the court in dispensation 
of justice to adequately consider the defence of the accused taken under Section
313 Cr.P.C. and to either accept or reject the same for reasons specified in writing.

17. Unfortunately neither Trial Court nor the High Court considered it necessary
to take notice of, much less discuss or observe with regard to the aforesaid defence
by the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C. to either accept or reject it. The defence
taken cannot be said to be irrelevant, illogical or fanciful in the entirety of 
the facts and the nature of other evidence available as discussed hereinbefore. 
The complete non-consideration thereof has clearly caused prejudice to the appellant.
Unlike the prosecution, the accused is not required to establish the defence beyond
all reasonable doubt. The accused has only to raise doubts on a preponderance of
probability as observed in Hate Singh Bhagat Singh vs. State of Madhya Bharat, AIR
1953 SC 468 observing as follows :-

> “26. We have examined the evidence at length in this case, not because it is our
> desire to depart from our usual practice of declining to the assess, the evidence
> in an appeal here, but because there has been in this case a departure from the
> rule that when an accused person but for the word a reasonable defence which is
> likely to be true,…… then the burden on the other side becomes all the heavier
> because a reasonable and probable story likely to be true friend pitted against
> AV and vacillating case is bound to raise a reasonable doubts of which the accused
> must get the benefit….”

A similar view is expressed in M. Abbas vs. State of Kerala, (2001) 10 SCC 103 as
follows :-

> “10….On the other hand, the explanation given by the appellant both during the
> cross-examination of prosecution witnesses and in his own statement recorded under
> Section 313 CrPC is quite plausible. Where an accused sets up a defence or offers
> an explanation, it is well settled that he is not required to prove his defence
> beyond a reasonable doubt but only by preponderance of probabilities….”

18. The entirety of the discussion, in the facts and circumstances of the case, 
the nature of evidence available coupled with the manner of its consideration, leaves
us satisfied that the links in the chain of circumstances in a case of circumstantial
evidence, cannot be said to have been established leading to the inescapable conclusion
that the appellant was the assailant of the deceased, incompatible with any possibility
of innocence of the appellant. The possibility that the occurrence may have taken
place in some other manner cannot be completely ruled out. The appellant is therefore
held entitled to acquittal on the benefit of doubt. We accordingly order the acquittal
and release of the appellant from custody forthwith, unless wanted in any other 
case.

19. The appeal is allowed.

##### **Party**

REENA HAZARIKA v. STATE OF ASSAM – Criminal Appeal No. 1330 of 2018 – OCTOBER 31,
2018 – 2018(13) SCR 1108.

**[Reena Hazarika vs. State of Assam 7005_2018_Judgement_31-Oct-2018](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Reena-Hazarika-vs.-State-of-Assam-7005_2018_Judgement_31-Oct-2018.pdf)**

 

##### Further study

 * [**SECTION 27 EVIDENCE ACT – FACT DISCOVERED AND RECOVERY MAHAZAR WITNESSES**](http://localhost:8080/section1/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/)
 * **[WHETHER DEFENCE COUNSEL CAN ARGUE IF HE DOES NOT ASK QUESTION IN CROSS?](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-defence-counsel-can-argue-if-he-does-not-ask-question-in-cross/)**
 * **[WHETHER MAGISTRATE CAN TAKE COGNIZANCE ON PRIVATE COMPLAINT EVEN AFTER ACCEPTING THE NEGATIVE REPORT FILED BY THE POLICE? (and) HOW TO WRITE PROTEST PETITION AND ITS APPRECIATION?](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-magistrate-can-take-cognizance-on-private-complaint-even-after-accepting-the-negative-report-filed-by-the-police-and-how-to-write-protest-petition-and-its-appreciation/)**
 * **[Judicial officers are advised to take advantage of section 313 (5) Cr.P.C by getting advice from P.P and defence counsels at the state of questioning under section 313 Cr.P.C](http://localhost:8080/section1/judicial-officers-are-advised-to-take-advantage-of-section-313-5-cr-p-c-by-getting-advice-from-p-p-and-defence-counsels-at-the-stage-of-questioning-u-s-313-cr-p-c/)**
 * **[Section 106 Evidence Act: Yardstick in convicting accused in circumstantial evidence invoking s.106 Evidence Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/yardstick-in-convicting-accused-in-circumstantial-evidence-and-invoking-s-106-i-e-act/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
