# Courts are not powerless they may permit amendments to the complaint even after cognizance has been taken

- Link: https://section1.in/courts-are-not-powerless-they-may-permit-amendments-to-the-complaint-even-after-cognizance-has-been-taken/
- Published: 2025-07-26T13:01:31+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

**Appeal**

2. Procedure, it is said, is only a handmaiden and not a mistress of justice. However,
the said adage has been followed only in the breach in this case. A simple issue
of an amendment to a complaint has held up a trial under Section 138 of the Negotiable
Instruments Act, 1881 (for short “the NI Act”) for the last nearly two years.

**Brief Facts**

3. The appellant, on 08.04.2022, filed a complaint under Section 138 of the NI Act,
against the respondents. The complaint averred that the respondents had purchased
Desi Ghee (milk products) and that cheques issued by them numbering three and totaling
to an amount of Rupees Fourteen Lakhs had been dishonored. Summons was issued to
the respondents and at the stage when the complainant was yet to be cross-examined,
an amendment application to amend the complaint was moved by the appellant. The 
appellant contended that due to a typographical mistake it had been pleaded that
the respondents had been purchasing Desi Ghee (milk products) while it should have
been that the respondents were purchasing “milk”. The respondents vehemently objected
to the amendment. It was contended that no amendment was permissible after cognizance
is taken and that the amendment sought, changed the nature of the complaint.

4. By order dated 02.09.2023, the Trial Court held that since the complainant was
yet to be cross-examined, no prejudice would be caused to the accused/respondents.
It was also held that the amendment was in the nature of a typographical error, 
moved at an initial stage of the case. So holding the amendment was allowed.

5. The respondents challenged the order under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure(
for short ‘the Cr.P.C.’). It was additionally contended that the amendment was not
a typographical error since even in the legal notice that preceded the filing of
the complaint, what was mentioned was “Desi Ghee (milk products)”. It was further
argued that the amendment is an attempt to avoid liability under the Goods and Services
Tax Act, 2017 (for short the ‘GST’).

6. By virtue of the impugned order, the High Court has allowed the petition, holding
that the amendment sought was not in the nature of a typographical error, but it
had a wider impact upon the entire matter in dispute and, therefore, it changed 
the nature of the complaint. The High Court also found merit in the contention of
the respondents that the amendment was sought, as no GST was leviable on milk.

**Analysis**

8. The issue, whether a criminal court has power to order amendment of a complaint
filed under Section 200 of the Cr.P.C., is no longer res integra. In S.R. Sukumar
v. S. Sunaad Raghuram this Court held as under:-

“19. What is discernible from U.P. Pollution Control Board case is that an easily
curable legal infirmity could be cured by means of a formal application for amendment.
If the amendment sought to be made relates to a simple infirmity which is curable
by means of a formal amendment and by allowing such amendment, no prejudice could
be caused to the other side, notwithstanding the fact that there is no enabling 
provision in the Code for entertaining such amendment, the court may permit such
an amendment to be made. On the contrary, if the amendment sought to be made in 
the complaint does not relate either to a curable infirmity or the same cannot be
corrected by a formal amendment or if there is likelihood of prejudice to the other
side, then the court shall not allow such amendment in the complaint.”

9. The learned counsel for the respondents sought to distinguish the judgement in
S.R. Sukumar’s case (supra) by contending that in the said case amendment was sought
and allowed at the pre-cognizance stage and as such the said case can have no application
here. We are unable to countenance the said submission.

10. A careful reading of the judgment in S.R. Sukumar’s case (supra) reveals that
the said judgment followed the earlier judgment of this Court in U.P. Pollution 
Control Board vs. Modi Distillery and Others. In Modi Distillery (supra), after 
the process was issued to the respondents therein, a revision was filed by few of
the accused and a Section 482 petition was filed by few other accused. Invoking 
the revisional jurisdiction, the High Court quashed the proceedings holding that
vicarious liability could not be saddled on the Directors unless “Modi Industries
Limited” was arrayed as accused. The Complainant in that case had arrayed “Modi 
Distillery”, an industrial unit and averred that Modi Distillery was a Company. 
The High Court focusing on the technical flaw in the complaint quashed the proceedings
on the premise that “Modi Industries Limited” was not made an accused. This Court,
while allowing the appeal of the Complainant-U.P. Pollution Control Board, held 
as follows:-

“paras. 6 and 7”

This Court allowed the appeal and set aside the order of the High Court and restored
the order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate directing issue of process and directed
that the trial be proceeded expeditiously. What is significant to notice is that
Modi Distillery (supra) was a case where cognizance was taken at a stage when the
accused approached the High Court and it was then that this Court observed that 
a formal application for amendment for substituting the name would have cured the
defect.

11. Reverting back to S.R. Sukumar (supra), it does not follow from the judgment
that post-cognizance, no amendment can be allowed. In fact, a reading of the penultimate
paragraph of the judgment clearly brings out the fact that four distinct reasons
were given: –

“para.20”

Hence, it is fallacious to contend that in no circumstance can amendments to complaints
be allowed after cognizance is taken.

12. Similarly, in Kunapareddy alias Nookala Shanka Balaji vs. Kunapareddy Swarna
Kumari and Another, it was held that even in criminal cases governed by the Code,
Court is not powerless and may allow amendments in appropriate cases. The Court 
in Kunapareddy (supra) followed the holding in S.R. Sukumar (supra).

**Normally complaint could even be oral but in Cheque cases it must be in writing**

14. The term “complaint” is defined in Section 2(d) of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 [Section 2(1)(h) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023] which reads
as follows:-

“2 (d) “complaint” means any allegation made orally or in writing to a Magistrate,
with a view to his taking action under this Code, that some person, whether known
or unknown, has committed an offence, but does not include a police report.”

**As would be seen ordinarily, a complaint could even be oral. However, dealing 
with a case under Section 138 of the NI Act, we must notice that Section 142 of 
the NI Act states that to take cognizance of any offence punishable under Section
138, a written complaint is mandatory. Unless expressly prescribed, if to set a 
criminal case in motion ordinarily an oral complaint would be sufficient, any question
about amendment of a written complaint should be considered by giving the widest
latitude. However, as was rightly pointed out in S.R. Sukumar (supra), it should
be ensured that no prejudice should be caused to the accused**.

15. It will be appropriate to observe that amendments/alterations are not alien 
to the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 216 of the Cr.P.C. deals with the power
of Court to alter any charge and the concept of prejudice to the accused. No doubt
when a charge is altered, what is altered is the legal provision and its application
to a certain set of facts. The facts per se may not be altered. However, the section
does throw some light in considering the issue of amendments.

**Alteration of Charge**

16. Section 216 and 217 of Cr.P.C [Section 239 and 240 of the Bharatiya Nagarik 
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023] read as follows:-

“sections 216 & 217 Cr.P.C”

It will be noticed that when a charge is altered, if there is no prejudice to the
accused, the trial can be proceeded with. Further, if it is likely to prejudice,
the Court may either direct a new trial or adjourn the trial to such period. Section
217 of the Cr.P.C. grants liberty to the prosecutor and the accused to recall witnesses
when charges are altered under the conditions prescribed therein. The test of ‘prejudice
to the accused’ is the cardinal factor that needs to be borne in mind.

17. We have carefully perused the complaint and the application for amendment. The
amendment was moved at a stage when after summons being issued to the respondents,
the chief examination of the complainant had concluded and when cross-examination
was awaited. The amendment made is also only with regard to the products supplied.
According to the complainant, while what was supplied was “milk”, by an inadvertent
error “Desi Ghee (milk products)” was mentioned. The error which occurred in the
legal notice was carried in the complaint also.

19. The High Court completely mis-directed itself in delving into the aspects of
leviability of GST which would be the concern of the appropriate authorities under
the relevant statute. It could also not be said that the amendment altered the nature
and character of the complaint.

20. For the reasons aforestated, the appeal is allowed. The judgment and order of
the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in CRM-M No. 53932 of 2023 (O&
M) is set aside and that of the Trial Court dated 02.09.2023 is restored. The Trial
Court shall proceed expeditiously and the parties will be at liberty to apply for
recall of witnesses already examined.

**The judgments cited or involved in this case are:**

S.R. Sukumar v. S. Sunaad Raghuram – (2015) 9 SCC 609 

U.P. Pollution Control Board vs. Modi Distillery and Others – (1987) 3 SCC 684 

Kunapareddy alias Nookala Shanka Balaji vs. Kunapareddy Swarna Kumari and Another–(
2016) 11 SCC 774 

Munish Kumar Gupta vs. Mittal Trading Company – 2024 SCC OnLine 1732

**Acts and their sections**

**Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act)**

     Section 138   

     Section 142 

**Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (GST) **

**Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.)**

      Section 482  

      Section 200 

     Section 216  

    Section 217  

**Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023**

  Section 2(1)(h) (equivalent to Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C.) 

  Section 239 (equivalent to Section 216 of Cr.P.C.) 

  Section 240 (equivalent to Section 217 of Cr.P.C.)

**Party**

Bansal Milk Chilling Centre – Rana Milk Food Private Ltd. & Anr – Criminal Appeal
No. 3178 of 2025 (Special Leave Petition (CRL.) No. 15699 of 2024) – 2025 INSC 899–
July 25, 2025 His Lordship Mrs. Justice B.V. Nagarathna and His Lordship Mr. K.V.
Viswanathan.

[Bansal Milk Chilling Centre vs. Rana Milk Fook Private ltd519432024_2025-07-25](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Bansal-Milk-Chilling-Centre-vs.-Rana-Milk-Fook-Private-ltd519432024_2025-07-25.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Bansal-Milk-Chilling-Centre-vs.-Rana-Milk-Fook-Private-ltd519432024_2025-07-25.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
