# Culpable homicide not amounting to murder: The nature of the injury itself is enough to find out the intention or knowledge of the accused

- Link: https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/
- Published: 2024-06-29T13:51:31+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Prayer](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#prayer)
 * [Appellant stabbed the deceased with knife for spreading false rumours about his wife](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#appellant-stabbed-the-deceased-with-knife-for-spreading-false-rumours-about-his-wife)
 * [Final report filed under section 302 IPC](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#final-report-filed-under-section-302-ipc)
 * [Appellant pleaded not guilty on charge framing](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#appellant-pleaded-not-guilty-on-charge-framing)
 * [Trial  ](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#trial-nbsp)
 * [Appellant was convicted under section 302 IPC and preferred this present appeal](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#appellant-was-convicted-under-section-302-ipc-and-preferred-this-present-appeal)
 * [Consideration and analyzation of appeal](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#consideration-and-analyzation-of-appeal)
 * [Defence have not elicited anything from the doctor to suggest that his opinion is erroneous](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#defence-have-not-elicited-anything-from-the-doctor-to-suggest-that-his-opinion-is-erroneous)
 * [Though the ocular witnesses turned hostile the I.O recovered the butcher’s knife](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#though-the-ocular-witnesses-turned-hostile-the-io-recovered-the-butchers-knife)
 * [Deceased was conscious while giving statement to the police which can be treated as dying declaration](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#deceased-was-conscious-while-giving-statement-to-the-police-which-can-be-treated-as-dying-declaration)
 * [Hon’ble High Court came to the conclusion that the appellant was responsible for stab injury](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#honble-high-court-came-to-the-conclusion-that-the-appellant-was-responsible-for-stab-injury)
 * [Based on the nature of the injury High court has concluded the culpable homicide not amounting to murder](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#based-on-the-nature-of-the-injury-high-court-has-concluded-the-culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-nature-of-the-injury-itself-is-enough-to-find-out-the-intention-or-knowledge-of-the-accused/#further-study)

##### **Prayer**

Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374(2) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, 
against the conviction of the appellant and sentence in S.C. No.82 of 2015 ated 
28.06.2017, on the file of the learned Sessions Judge, Mahalir Neethi Mandram (Fast
Track Mahila Court), Vellore and set aside the conviction and sentence imposed in
judgment dated 28.06.2017 and acquit the appellant.

This Criminal Appeal has been filed by the sole accused, challenging the conviction
and sentence imposed upon him vide judgment dated 28.06.2017 in S.C.No.82 of 2015
on the file of the learned Sessions Judge, Magalir Neethi Mandram (Fast Track Mahila
Court), Vellore.

##### **Appellant stabbed the deceased with knife for spreading false rumours about his wife**

3(i) It is the case of the prosecution that the appellant is the son-in law of the
deceased; that the appellant, his wife, and the deceased were living jointly along
with the children of the appellant and deceased; that the appellant was aggrieved
by the fact that the deceased was spreading false rumours about her own daughter,
i.e., his wife; that on 18.07.2014 at about 10.00 p.m., when the deceased and her
daughter PW1 were fighting with each other, the appellant stabbed the deceased with
a knife and further cautioned the deceased that if she created further problems,
he would kill her.

(ii) It is the case of the prosecution that PW1 gave a complaint (Ex.P13) to the
Sub Inspector of Police (PW10), who registered an FIR (Ex.P14) for the **[offences under Sections 294(b](http://localhost:8080/section1/absence-of-words-involve-arousing-sexual-thoughts-or-feelings-or-words-cannot-attract-offence-u-s-294b-ipc/))**,
324, and 506(ii) of the IPC. The deceased was taken to the hospital and PW11 treated
her and made entries in the accident register, which was marked as Ex.P18. PW11 
had noted as follows:

“laceration wound in epigastric region appearing a evisceration wound 5x1x3cm”

Thereafter, on 19.07.2014, the deceased died at 09.00 a.m., and the FIR was altered
to Section 302 IPC by alteration report [Ex.P17].

(iii) PW12 took up the investigation, conducted an inquest on 20.07.2014 between
9.00 and 11.00 a.m., and prepared the inquest report [Ex.P19]. PW12 sent the body
of the deceased for a postmortem. PW3-doctor conducted a postmortem and issued a
postmortem certificate (Ex.P3). PW12 thereafter examined the postmortem doctor.

##### **Final report filed under section 302 IPC**

(iv) PW13, the Inspector of Police, who took over the investigation, had formed 
a special team to apprehend the accused. PW14 continued the investigation and arrested
the appellant on 02.12.2014 at about 3.30 p.m., and on his confession, the admissible
portion of which was marked as Ex.P6, he seized the knife M.O.1 under Seizure Mahazar[
Ex.P7]. PW15 conducted further investigation, and, after examining the other witnesses
filed a final report on 25.02.2015 against the appellant for the offence under Section
302 IPC before the learned Judicial Magistrate, Katpadi.

##### **Appellant pleaded not guilty on charge framing**

(v) On the appearance of the appellant, the provisions of Section 207 Cr.P.C., were
complied with, and the case was committed to the Court of Session in S.C.No.82 of
2015 and was made over to the learned Sessions Judge, Magalir Neethi Mandram (Fast
Track Mahila Court), Vellore, for trial. The trial Court framed charges u/s.302 
of the IPC as against the appellant, and when questioned, the appellant pleaded ‘
not guilty.

##### **Trial  **

(vi) To prove the case, the **[prosecution examined 15 witnesses](http://localhost:8080/section1/when-chief-examination-of-prosecution-witness-is-being-recorded-presence-of-accused-advocate-is-required-to-object-to-a-leading-or-irrelevant-question-being-asked-to-the-witness/)**
as P.W.1 to P.W.15 and marked 19 exhibits as Exs.P1 to P19, and marked one Material
Object, viz., M.O.1. When the appellant was questioned, u/s.313 Cr.P.C., on the 
incriminating circumstances appearing against him, he denied the same. The appellant/
accused neither examined any witnesses, nor marked any documents.

##### **Appellant was convicted under section 302 IPC and preferred this present appeal**

(vii) On appreciation of oral and documentary evidence, the **[trial Court](http://localhost:8080/section1/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)**
found that the prosecution had established the case beyond reasonable doubt, and
held the accused guilty of the offences under Section 302 of the IPC, and sentenced
him to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs.5000/- in default to
undergo simple imprisonment for two months. Hence, the accused/appellant has preferred
the **[appeal challenging the said](http://localhost:8080/section1/disbelieving-dying-declaration-both-dying-declarations-were-said-to-have-given-to-the-interested-witnesses-and-not-properly-proved/)**
conviction and sentence.

##### **Consideration and analyzation of appeal**

7. We have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the materials 
on record.

##### **Defence have not elicited anything from the doctor to suggest that his opinion is erroneous**

8. The entries made in the Accident Register [Ex.P18] which were extracted earlier
show that the deceased sustained a stab injury. PW3 the postmortem doctor found 
the following injuries:

> “Surgical suture seen center of the abdomen.
> On removal of sutures: Peritoneal cavity contains 200ml of sero-sanguinous fluid.
> Evidence of peritonitis noted. Sutured incised wound right lobe of liver. Sutured(
> tear) incised wound anterior wall of stomach to a length of 4 cm x entire wall
> thickness.”

and ultimately, opined that,

“the deceased would appear to have died of peritonitis a complication of injury 
to abdominal visceral organs.”

The defence have not elicited anything in the **[cross](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)**
examination of PW3 to suggest that his opinion is erroneous. Thus, it is seen that
the **[prosecution has established that the deceased sustained an injury](http://localhost:8080/section1/non-explanation-of-injuries-sustained-by-the-accused-is-fatal-to-the-prosecution/)**
due to the homicidal violence.

##### **Though the ocular witnesses turned hostile the I.O recovered the butcher’s knife**

9. PW1, the wife of the deceased, who had lodged the complaint, had disowned her
complaint. However, she would admit her signature alone in the complaint. She turned
hostile. PW2, the son of PW1 and grandson of the deceased also turned hostile. Thus,
there is no ocular evidence to prove the occurrence. The other witnesses are either
Mahazar witnesses, doctors, or the investigating officers. The appellant was arrested,
and on his confession, a knife [M.O.1] said to have been used for the occurrence
was seized by the investigating officer, as stated earlier. Seizure Mahazar-Ex.P7
would show that the knife was a butcher’s knife (khL mWf;Fk; fj;jp) with a total
length of 26½ cm, measuring 15½ cm of iron knife and 11 cms of iron handle.

##### **Deceased was conscious while giving statement to the police which can be treated as dying declaration**

10. It is also the **[prosecution case](http://localhost:8080/section1/acquittal-by-using-entire-procedures-available-to-disprove-the-prosecution-case/)**
that the appellant was a butcher. The only piece of evidence that is placed by the
prosecution is the entries made in the Accident Register [Ex.P18] by PW11, which
were extracted earlier. When PW11 examined the deceased, she was conscious and oriented.
She had informed PW11 that she sustained a stab injury which was caused by **_‘her
son-in-law with a knife in her residence’. _**This statement of the deceased to 
PW11 has to be treated as dying declaration as it satisfies all the conditions under**
[Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/).**
It is well settled that a **[dying declaration](http://localhost:8080/section1/dying-declaration-witness-who-recorded-the-dying-declaration-must-state-in-his-chief-examination-that-the-doctor-examined-the-deceased-before-giving-fitness-certificate/),**
if found to be truthful and voluntary, can be the sole basis for conviction. This
position of law is well settled and is reiterated by the Hon’ble **[Supreme Court](http://localhost:8080/section1/burden-of-proof-public-prosecutor-while-explaining-the-principles-of-106-iea-in-criminal-cases-honble-supreme-court-has-addressed-the-government-to-appoint-skilled-lawyers-as-public-prosec/)**
in **[Harendra Rai Vs. State of Bihar and Others](http://localhost:8080/section1/fir-is-a-public-document-and-also-a-dying-declaration-and-hence-it-shall-be-treated-as-substantive-piece-of-evidence-and-admissible-u-s-321-evidence-act-1872/)_,_**
reported in **2023 SCC OnLine SC 1023**. The relevant observations are extracted
hereunder.

> _”92. Now further issue crops up about the treatment of the FIR/Bayan Tahriri 
> as dying declaration and in this respect various earlier pronouncements of this
> Court have clarified the position of law that the statement by an injured person
> recorded as FIR can be treated as a dying declaration and such a statement is 
> admissible under _**[Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/test-identification-parade-not-proved/).**_
> It was also held that the dying declaration must not cover the whole incident 
> or narrate the case history. Corroboration is not necessary for this situation;
> a _[**dying declaratio**](http://localhost:8080/section1/appreciation-of-evidence-of-dying-declaration-explained/)_
> [n](http://localhost:8080/section1/appreciation-of-evidence-of-dying-declaration-explained/)
> can be the sole basis for conviction._

Therefore, there cannot be any doubt that the entries in the accident register which
is based on the information given by the deceased himself can be treated as a dying
declaration. The medical records viz., portmortem certificate also confirms that
there was an injury in the abdomen and the deceased died of peritonitis as stated
earlier. Except for a suggestion made by the **[defence](http://localhost:8080/section1/defence-counsels-dont-worry-i-teach-you-to-take-defence/)**
that the arrest and recovery is false, nothing has been elicited to disbelieve the
arrest and recovery of the knife. The arrest and recovery of a butcher’s knife from
the accused has been established by the prosecution.

##### **Hon’ble High Court came to the conclusion that the appellant was responsible for stab injury**

11. Therefore, we are of the view that the appellant was responsible for inflicting
a stab injury on the deceased, which ultimately resulted in her death. The question
is whether the act of the accused would constitute an offence of murder within the
meaning of Section 300 of the IPC. There is no evidence either on the side of the
prosecution or on the side of the defence to understand as to the circumstances 
under which the occurrence took place, though originally it was the prosecution 
case that the appellant caused injury since the deceased spread false rumours about
her own daughter (appellant’s wife). From the entries in the accident register and
the nature of the injury, we cannot safely conclude that the appellant intended 
to cause an injury of such a nature, which in all probability would cause the death
of the deceased, or commit the said act with the knowledge that it was so imminently
dangerous and that it would in all probability cause the death of the deceased.

##### **Based on the nature of the injury High court has concluded the culpable homicide not amounting to murder**

12. The injury as found in the Accident Register [Ex.P18] shows that the deceased
sustained a laceration wound measuring 5x1x3cm in the epigastric region. The nature
of the injury is an indicator of the intention or knowledge of the accused. The**
[victim](http://localhost:8080/section1/pocso-accused-did-not-rebut-the-evidence-against-evidence-of-victim/)**
died of peritonitis, a complication of injury to abdominal visceral organs, as per
PW3, the postmortem doctor. Even as per the prosecution case, the accused did not
intend to cause death and threatened the deceased with dire consequences if she 
continued to insult his wife. Therefore, we can only infer the appellant’s knowledge
that his act is likely to cause death, amounting to an offence of culpable homicide.
Hence, we are of the view that the appellant is guilty and liable to be punished
for the offence under Section 304 (II) of the IPC.

##### **Party**

Siva … Appellant/Sole Accused v. State by Inspector of Police Katpadi Police Station,
Vellore District. (Crime No.231/2014) … Respondent/Complainant – – RESERVED ON :
05.02.2024 – PRONOUNCED ON : 09.02.2024 – CORAM : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.S.RAMESH
AND THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNDER MOHAN – Crl.A.No.116 of 2019

[**https://mhc.tn.gov.in/judis/index.php/casestatus/viewpdf/1102255**](https://mhc.tn.gov.in/judis/index.php/casestatus/viewpdf/1102255)

**[siva-vs-state](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/siva-vs-state.pdf)**

##### Further study

 * [**Murder case acquittal: Death of deceased as per fir is with knife but the postmortem suggests firing from close range**](http://localhost:8080/section1/murder-case-acquittal-death-of-deceased-as-fir-is-with-knife-but-the-postmortem-suggest-firing-from-close-range/)
 * **[Murder case: Appreciation of evidence – Circumstantial evidence & recovery under section 27 Indian Evidence Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/appreciation-of-evidence-circumstantial-evidence-recovery-u-s-27-iea/)**
 * **[Section 173(2) Cr.P.C: The opinion in the final report would not have a bearing on the claim petition](http://localhost:8080/section1/thus-the-opinion-in-the-final-report-would-not-have-a-bearing-on-the-claim-petition/)**
 * **[SECTION 188 IPC – REGISTERING FIR & INVESTIGATION PROCEDURE EXPLAINED](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-188-ipc-registering-fir-investigation-procedure-explained/)**
 * **[Dying Declaration: Disbelieving the dying declaration recorded (appreciation)](http://localhost:8080/section1/disbelieving-dying-declaration-appreciation/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
