# Custody of child in Mohammaden Law: No system of adoption of child in Mohammaden law: Custody of children is the welfare of children and not the right of their parents

- Link: https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/
- Published: 2024-03-08T19:04:11+00:00
- Author: Reshma Azath

Contents

 * [Facts](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#facts)
 * [Appellants side submission](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#appellants-side-submission)
 * [Respondents side submission](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#respondents-side-submission)
 * [Observation from precedents](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#observation-from-precedents)
 * [Best interest of the child](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#best-interest-of-the-child)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#conclusion)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/custody-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-no-system-of-adoption-of-child-in-mohammaden-law-custody-of-children-is-the-welfare-of-children-and-not-the-right-of-their-parents/#party)

##### Facts

3) The child at present is 14 years of age, living since birth with the appellants
and respondent No.10.

4) Aggrieved against the order passed by the High Court in a Writ Petition filed
by respondent No.2, who is biological father of the child, for restoration of her
custody, namely, Sumaiya Khanam in his favour, the present appeal has been filed.

5) The High Court directed the Registrar (Judicial) of the Court to recover the 
child from the custody of appellant No. 2 and respondent No. 10, particularly from
appellant No. 1 and respondent No. 10 and to hand over to respondent No.2. The authorities
of the State Government were also directed to execute the writ of Habeas Corpus 
and hand over the child to respondent No. 2.

##### Appellants side submission

6) Learned counsel for the appellants submitted that twin daughters were born to
respondent No. 2 and his wife on 20.03.2010. The respondent No. 2 at that time was
living at Rourkela. The children were born at Ranchi where their maternal grandmother
was residing. As he was unable to take care of twins, on his request, one was left
at Ranchi. Appellant No. 2 is the real sister of respondent No. 2. As the maternal
grandmother could not take care of the small child, she was handed over to the appellant
No. 2. This happened when the child was merely 2-3 months old. Ever since then, 
she is living with her. No issue was raised by respondent No. 2 at any time. It 
was only in the year 2015, a complaint was filed by respondent No. 2 with the police
regarding kidnapping of the child against the appellants and respondents No. 7 and
9. As it was not a case of kidnapping, as alleged, closure report was filed by the
police on 31.08.2016, which was accepted by the Court, vide order dated 11.02.2017.
No objection was raised by respondent No. 2 to the acceptance of the closure report.
However, a private complaint dated 27.03.2017 was filed by respondent No. 2 under
Sections 363, 346, 120-B IPC with reference to the custody of the child by taking
a different stand. The aforesaid complaint is stated to be still pending. In a petition
filed by the appellants and respondents No. 7 and 9 before the High Court seeking
quashing of the complaint, further proceedings in the complaint have been stayed.

6.1) Immediately after filing of the aforesaid complaint by the respondent No.2,
wife of respondent No.2, namely, biological mother of the child, filed petition 
in the High Court of Judicature at Patna praying for issuance of directions to the
official respondents to recover the child from the wrongful confinement of the private
respondents therein.

6.3) He further submitted that number of documents were placed by the appellants
before the High Court which clearly establish that the child ever since is living
with the appellants and respondent No. 10. A the time of her birth, her name was
Sumaiya Khanam, which was later on changed to Dania Aman Khan. A Petition has been
filed under the Guardianship and Wards Act, 1890 by appellant No.1 and respondent
No.10, which is stated to be pending. However, he submitted that in the present 
proceedings, the appellants are only raising the issue regarding custody of the 
child and not guardianship. He fairly submitted that there is no system of adoption
of child in Mohammaden law. It is only Kafalah, in terms of which only custody can
be given to another person, however, the child does not sever relations with biological
parents.

6.4) Learned counsel for the appellants on instructions categorically stated that
appellant No. 1 and respondent No. 10 have two more children. The child, of which
they have the custody ever since her birth will have equal rights along with two
other children. She will not be discriminated in any manner whatsoever.

6.5) Further raising the issue regarding the conduct of respondent No. 2, he submitted
that firstly a petition for Habeas Corpus was filed by the wife of respondent No.
2 before the High Court of Judicature at Patna five years after the child had been
living with appellant No. 1 and respondent No. 10. The same was dismissed as withdrawn.
Four years thereafter, similar petition was filed by respondent No. 2 before the
High Court of Orissa. Time gap shows that the respondent No. 2 is not interested
in custody of the child.

6.6) He further submitted that to show their bonafide, appellant No. 1 and respondent
No. 10 are ready and willing to deposit a sum of ₹10,00,000/- in FDR in bank in 
her name and also transfer property having market value of about ₹50,00,000/-. At
present, the child is grown up. She is 14 years of age. She is capable of forming
an opinion about her best interest. The welfare of the child is of paramount consideration
and not the rights of the parties. Stability is most important factor as any order
passed by this Court may dislodge the child from the family where she is settled
for the last 14 years. Her transplantation at this stage may not be in her best 
interest. It is the welfare of the child and not the personal law or the statute
which has paramount consideration, when the parties are fighting. In support of 
his argument that it is only the best interest of the child which is to be considered.

##### Respondents side submission

7) In response, learned counsel for respondent No. 2 submitted that it is not the
case of abandonment of a child, as is sought to be projected by the appellants now.
No parents will ever think of that, what to talk of actually doing it. The child
was left with her maternal grand mother and thereafter handed over to appellant 
No.2 for her initial upbringing when she was 3-4 months old. She further submitted
that when repeated requests for returning back the child were not acceded to, respondent
No. 2 did not have any choice but to lodge an FIR in which a closure report was 
filed and accepted also. She further submitted that even during this period of five
years, the child had been coming to her parents off and on.

7.1) Explaining the delay in filing the petition before the High Court, learned 
counsel for respondent No. 2 submitted that it is was because of COVID pandemic.
She further submitted that since 2015, the biological parents of the child have 
not even been able to meet her. Respondent No. 2 was and is able to take care of
all the needs of the child and provide her best education, as is being provided 
to the sister of the child as twins were born. It was further argued that appellant
No. 1 got married with respondent No. 10, who is a stranger to the family. In terms
of Mohammedan law, custody of the child cannot be given to the stranger, who is 
beyond prohibitory degree for marriage but she fairly submitted that they all are
living in a joint family.

7.2) In fact, when the child was handed over to appellant No.1, she was un-married.
However, thereafter she got married and is having two children. The child may be
discriminated. If the custody of the child is handed over to respondent No. 2, the
distance between Patna and Rourkela being not much, the appellants are always welcome
to visit the child. The question is also of the identity of the child which has 
been lost in the process. If she comes back, she will also have love, affection 
and company of her twin sister.

##### Observation from precedents

11) This Court in Athar Hussain v. Syed Siraj Ahmed and others’case had elaborated
the concept of custody,guardianship and stability of child, while holding as under:

“31. We are mindful of the fact that, as far as the matter of guardianship is concerned,
the prima facie case lies in favour of the father as under Section 19 of the GWC
Act, unless the father is not fit to be a guardian, the Court has no jurisdiction
to appoint another guardian. It is also true that the respondents, despite the voluminous
allegations leveled against the appellant have not been able to prove that he is
not fit to take care of the minor children, nor has the Family Court or the High
Court found him so. However, the question of custody is different from the question
of guardianship. Father can continue to be the natural guardian of the children;
however, the considerations pertaining to the welfare of the child may indicate 
lawful custody with another friend or relative as serving his/her interest better”

13) In Nil Ratan Kundu and another v. Abhijit Kundu, this Court laid down the principles
governing custody of minor children and held that welfare of the children is to 
be seen and not the rights of the parties by observing as under:

“Principles governing custody of minor children 53. In our judgment, the law relating
to custody of a child is fairly well-settled and it is this. In deciding a difficult
and complex question as to custody of minor, a Court of law should keep in mind 
relevant statutes and the rights flowing therefrom. But such cases cannot be decided
solely by interpreting legal provisions. It is a humane problem and is required 
to be solved with human touch. A Court while dealing with custody cases, is neither
bound by statutes nor by strict rules of evidence or procedure nor by precedents.
In selecting proper guardian of a minor, the paramount consideration should be the
welfare and well-being of the child. In selecting a guardian, the Court is exercising
parens patriae jurisdiction and is expected, nay bound, to give due weight to a 
child’s ordinary comfort, contentment, health, education, intellectual development
and favourable surroundings. But over and above physical comforts, moral and ethical
values cannot be ignored. They are equally, or we may say, even more important, 
essential and indispensable considerations. If the minor is old enough to form an
intelligent preference or judgment, the Court must consider such preference as well,
though the final decision should rest with the Court as to what is conducive to 
the welfare of the minor”.

##### Best interest of the child

> 17) In the case in hand, vide order dated 12.12.2023, we had called the child 
> in Court. We had interacted with the child, the appellants and respondent No. 
> 2 individually in chamber. We found the child to be quite intelligent, who could
> understand her welfare. She categorically stated that she is happy with the family
> where she has been brought up. She has other brother and sister. She is having
> cordial relations with them. She does not wish to be destabilized.
> 19) The fact that appellant No. 1, when custody of the child was handed over to
> her, was un-married and is now married having two children will also not be a 
> deterrent for this Court to come to the conclusion that best interest of the child
> still remains with the appellant No. 2 as the child is living with her ever since
> she was 3-4 months old and is now about 14 years of age having no doubt in her
> mind that she wishes to live with them.

##### Conclusion

20) In view of our aforesaid discussions, we find that the welfare of the child 
lies with her custody with the appellants and respondent No. 10. This is coupled
with the fact that even she also wishes to live there. Keeping in view her age at
present, she is capable of forming an opinion in that regard. She was quite categoric
in that regard when we interacted with her. She cannot be treated as a chattel at
the age of 14 years to hand over her custody to the respondent No.2, where she has
not lived ever since her birth. Stability of the child is also of paramount consideration.

21) The appeal is accordingly allowed. The impugned order passed by the High Court
is set aside, as a result of which the writ petition filed by respondent No. 2 in
the High Court is dismissed

##### Party

**Shazia Aman Khan And Another … Appellant(S) -Vs- The State Of Orissa And Others…
Respondent(S),Dated On 4th March – Criminal Appeal No. Of 2024 (Arising Out Of Special
Leave Petition (Crl.) No.7290 Of 2023) **

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/23396/23396_2023_13_1501_51045_Judgement_04-Mar-2024.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/23396/23396_2023_13_1501_51045_Judgement_04-Mar-2024.pdf)**

**[Shazia Aman Khan -Vs- The State Of Orissa And Others (SC)](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Shazia-Aman-Khan-Vs-The-State-Of-Orissa-And-Others-SC.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
