# Digest: Supreme Court & Madras HC Judgments (Jul-Sep 2026)

- Link: https://section1.in/digest-supreme-court-madras-hc-judgments-jul-sep-2026/
- Published: 2026-09-10T15:20:27+00:00
- Author: Reshma Azath

Thursday, September 10 – [Supreme Court Acquits in POCSO Case: TIP Cannot Replace Dock Identification](https://section1.in/supreme-court-acquits-in-pocso-case-tip-cannot-replace-dock-identification/)
The Supreme Court acquitted the appellant in a child sexual assault case, overturning
concurrent convictions by lower courts due to critical flaws in the prosecution’s
investigation and trial. The conviction was primarily based on a Test Identification
Parade (TIP), but the victim failed to specifically identify the accused in court,
rendering the TIP legally insufficient as substantive evidence. Furthermore, significant
discrepancies in medical evidence regarding the injury’s timing, the…

Wednesday, September 9 – [Inordinate Delay in Serving Summons Cannot Quash Criminal Proceedings After Charges are Framed: Madras HC](https://section1.in/inordinate-delay-in-serving-summons-cannot-quash-criminal-proceedings-after-charges-are-framed-madras-hc/)
This criminal original petition filed by the petitioner as against the charge sheet
and consequential proceedings pending before the District Munsif-cum-Judicial Magistrate
Court, seeking to quash the same. The proceedings arose out of a complaint lodged
by the complainant, who is the petitioner’s daughter-in-law, based on which a criminal
case was registered in the year 2013 for offences under Sections 294(b), 506(i) 
of IPC and Section 4 of the Tamil Nadu Prohibition of Harassment of Women…

Wednesday, September 9 – [Sivakumar vs State: Mere Use of the Word ‘Bastard’ is Not an Offence Under Section 294(b) IPC](https://section1.in/sivakumar-vs-state-mere-use-of-the-word-bastard-is-not-an-offence-under-section-294b-ipc/)
Section 294 (b) IPC – Mere use of the word ‘bastard’, by itself, is not sufficient
to arouse prurient interest of a person- such words are commonly used in modern 
era during heated conversations – Conviction under section 294(b) IPC set…

Tuesday, September 8 – [Acquittal: Gunshot: Witnesses might have already planned to frame the accused since they know the accused owned licensed weapon](https://section1.in/acquittal-gunshot-witnesses-might-have-already-planned-to-frame-the-accused-since-they-know-the-accused-owned-licensed-weapon/)
The Supreme Court reversed the concurrent convictions for murder under constructive
liability and the Arms Act, extending the benefit of doubt to the appellants due
to pervasive contradictions in the testimonies of related eyewitnesses and glaring
investigative deficiencies. The prosecution’s narrative was discredited by medical
evidence demonstrating that the fatal firearm wound was not instantaneously fatal
as claimed, the highly unnatural conduct of taking the victim to the police station…

Tuesday, September 8 – [Supreme Court Rejects ‘Falsus in Uno, Falsus in Omnibus’ and accused also well known to the witnesses](https://section1.in/supreme-court-rejects-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-and-accused-also-well-known-to-the-witnesses/)
In an appeal concerning a fatal ambush, the Supreme Court reversed the High Court’s
acquittal of two accused, ruling that holding the victim and exhorting the shooter
attracts constructive liability under Sections 34 and 149 of the IPC. The Court 
reaffirmed that the maxim falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus does not apply in India,
obligating courts to separate credible eyewitness and medical evidence from unproven
allegations, thereby restoring the convictions of the two active participants while…

Tuesday, September 8 – [Madras High Court Rules: Attacking Vital Body Parts is Attempted Murder, Even if Injuries are Minor](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-rules-attacking-vital-body-parts-is-attempted-murder-even-if-injuries-are-minor/)
Babu (Petitioner) and the State of Tamil Nadu represented by the Inspector of Police
and Umamaheshwari…

Monday, September 7 – [Strict Compliance Mandatory: The Necessity of Police Reports Before Directing Investigations Under Section 175(3) & (4) of BNSS](https://section1.in/strict-compliance-mandatory-the-necessity-of-police-reports-before-directing-investigations-under-section-1753-4-of-bnss/)
A Magistrate cannot mechanically order an investigation under Section 175(3) or 
175(4) of the BNSS without an affidavit, without calling for submissions/reports
from the police, and without applying judicial mind to those…

Sunday, September 6 – [Surrogacy Act: Magistrates Cannot Reassess Eligibility Certificates; Age Limit of “50 Years” Includes the Entire 50th Year: Madras High Court](https://section1.in/surrogacy-act-magistrates-cannot-reassess-eligibility-certificates-age-limit-of-50-years-includes-the-entire-50th-year-madras-high-court/)
The Hon’ble Madras High Court ruled that Magistrates cannot second-guess surrogacy
eligibility certificates issued by medical boards unless there is apparent fraud.
Crucially, the Court clarified that the statutory upper age limit of “50 years” 
for intending mothers extends until their 51st birthday. Additionally, the Court
held that examining the surrogate’s husband in court is unnecessary if his consent
is already documented in the medical certificate, emphasizing that parentage proceedings…

Saturday, September 5 – [Oral Hearing Is Non-Negotiable: Non-Cooperation by Defence Counsel Requires Amicus Appointment, Not Ex-Parte Verdict](https://section1.in/oral-hearing-is-non-negotiable-non-cooperation-by-defence-counsel-requires-amicus-appointment-not-ex-parte-verdict/)
The appellate court set aside a conviction because the trial court pronounced judgment
without hearing defence arguments. Ruling that oral arguments are a mandatory, non-
waivable facet of a fair trial under Article 21 and Section 235 of the Cr.P.C., 
the court held that a judge cannot skip oral hearings even if the defense is uncooperative.
Instead, the trial court must appoint an amicus curiae. The case was remanded solely
for hearing arguments, with instructions to recover amicus fees from the…

Friday, September 4 – [Dowry death: Reversal of Acquittal with direction](https://section1.in/dowry-death-reversal-of-acquittal-with-direction/)
The Supreme Court reversed an appellate acquittal and restored convictions under
Sections 304-B and 498-A of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry
Prohibition Act, 1961, holding that persistent demands reiterated a day prior to
the bride’s unnatural burn death established cruelty “soon before her death” and
triggered the mandatory, unrebutted presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian
Evidence Act. Ruling that post-marital demands constitute dowry…

Friday, September 4 – [Section 306 IPC: Acquittal: some disputes or discord in matrimonial life would not itself attract the provisions of Sections 306 r/w 107 IPC](https://section1.in/section-306-ipc-acquittal-some-disputes-or-discord-in-matrimonial-life-would-not-itself-attract-the-provisions-of-sections-306-r-w-107-ipc/)
The appeal arises from the overturning of an acquittal by the Sessions Court, where
the appellant had initially been cleared of charges relating to cruelty and abetment
of suicide concerning his wife, only for the High Court to reverse the decision 
and convict…

Friday, September 4 – [Acquittal: Conviction cannot be based on confession to IO despite no Section 65B certificate for CCTV footage](https://section1.in/acquittal-conviction-cannot-be-based-on-confession-to-io-despite-no-section-65b-certificate-for-cctv-footage/)
The conviction was overturned because the prosecution relied on inadmissible confessions,
failed to provide mandatory Section 65B certifications for vital electronic evidence,
and could not prove the lease or ownership of the apartment where the body was found.
Consequently, both the “last seen” theory and adverse inferences under Section 106
collapsed, leaving no substantive proof connecting the accused to the…

Wednesday, September 2 – [Real estate is not an illegal business and the Indian Bank which kept the money sold in auction was not disbursed to the legal heirs is illegal](https://section1.in/real-estate-is-not-an-illegal-business-and-the-indian-bank-which-kept-the-money-sold-in-auction-was-not-disbursed-to-the-legal-heirs-is-illegal/)
The Supreme Court acquitted a former bank manager of corruption and loan fraud due
to a complete lack of evidence. Overturning the conviction, the Court highlighted
a fundamentally flawed investigation, noted that higher authorities had actually
authorized the loans, and observed that the bank fully recovered all debts with 
a massive…

Tuesday, September 1 – [Sentencing: Fine: Forcing the Accused To Pay Duplicate Fines For the Same Sentence Would Be Amount To Double Punishment](https://section1.in/sentencing-fine-forcing-the-accused-to-pay-duplicate-fines-for-the-same-sentence-would-be-amount-to-double-punishment/)
Hem raj vd state of Himachal…

Tuesday, September 1 – [SC Shields Husband from Baseless DV Case; Dissolves Dead Marriage Citing Irretrievable Breakdown](https://section1.in/sc-shields-husband-from-baseless-dv-case-dissolves-dead-marriage-citing-irretrievable-breakdown/)
In the Supreme Court dissolved the marriage under Article 142(1) due to its irretrievable
breakdown. The Court also quashed the wife’s Domestic Violence complaint, determining
it lacked specific allegations and was a baseless afterthought filed merely to prolong
litigation after she backed out of a prior mutual…

Tuesday, September 1 – [Section 156(3) CrPC: Mere existence of a civil remedy does not by itself bar criminal proceedings If Allegations prima-facie disclose a cognizable offence](https://section1.in/section-1563-crpc-mere-existence-of-a-civil-remedy-does-not-by-itself-bar-criminal-proceedings-if-allegations-prima-facie-disclose-a-cognizable-offence/)
The Supreme Court restored criminal proceedings, ruling that a Magistrate ordering
a police investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. only needs to verify if the 
complaint *prima facie* discloses a cognizable offence. The Court further clarified
that the existence of a civil remedy does not bar criminal action, and High Courts
should exercise extreme caution when quashing…

Thursday, August 27 – [Limitation For Initiation Of Domestic Violence Proceedings: Revisiting The Ratio In Kamatchi](https://section1.in/limitation-for-initiation-of-domestic-violence-proceedings-revisiting-the-ratio-in-kamatchi/)
Author. Jegan.M. Advocate Practicing at Madurai Bench of Madras High Court….

Wednesday, August 26 – [No ambiguity: Section 351 of BNS is a non-bailable offence in Tamil Nadu](https://section1.in/no-ambiguity-section-351-of-bns-is-a-non-bailable-offence-in-tamil-nadu/)
Thiru. Sunil Nisi Kumar A holds “B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) and LL.M” degrees, and is a 
practising advocate appearing before the “Hon’ble Madras High Court” and trial courts
across Tamil Nadu. He completed his law degree at the *School of Excellence in Law,
Chennai, and later earned an LL.M. in Intellectual Property and Trade Law from Christ
University, Bangalore….

Wednesday, August 26 – [Supreme Court again discouraging DV Act proceedings after a valid divorce compromise](https://section1.in/supreme-court-again-discouraging-dv-act-proceedings-after-a-valid-divorce-compromise/)
The Supreme Court ruled that reviving waived financial claims from a mutual divorce
settlement through fresh Domestic Violence Act proceedings is an abuse of process.
However, while the spouses are bound by their settlement, independent dependents—
such as an adult daughter—retain their statutory right to pursue their own monetary…

Sunday, August 23 – [Corroboration of testimony of child witness before a conviction is required](https://section1.in/corroboration-of-testimony-of-child-witness-before-a-conviction-is-required/)
Due to a lack of conclusive evidence, the Supreme Court has allowed the appeal, 
overturned the previous High Court judgment, and fully acquitted the appellant, 
discharging their bail…

Sunday, August 23 – [Prosecution has proved the case through hostile witness](https://section1.in/prosecution-has-proved-the-case-through-hostile-witness/)
The High Court overturned an acquittal and imposed a life sentence for murder based
on reliable, corroborated eyewitness testimony. The ruling affirmed that minor medical
discrepancies don’t invalidate credible eyewitnesses, a victim’s hospital statements
hold evidentiary weight, and partially hostile witnesses can still support the prosecution
by verifying recovery…

Saturday, August 22 – [The facts of the present case can be brought under exception I of Section 300 of IPC and thus is punishable u/s. 304(I) of IPC and not u/s. 302 of IPC](https://section1.in/the-facts-of-the-present-case-can-be-brought-under-exception-i-of-section-300-of-ipc-and-thus-is-punishable-u-s-304i-of-ipc-and-not-u-s-302-of-ipc/)
MURUGESH VS STATE REP BY INSPECTOR OF…

Saturday, August 22 – [Recall: 70(2) CrPC: Only Revision lies against order issuing against NBW and not Crl.O.P jurisdiction [Editor’s note inside]](https://section1.in/recall-702-crpc-only-revision-lies-against-order-issuing-against-nbw-and-not-crl-o-p-jurisdiction-editors-note-inside/)
Only a revision petition can challenge an order refusing to cancel an NBW. The High
Court’s inherent power (Section 482) is not a substitute. Courts should handle recall
applications quickly without automatically remanding the…

Saturday, August 22 – [POCSO: Victim’s testimony before the Court is clear and cogent and almost the same as per the statement recorded u/s. 164 Cr.P.C and there has been no exaggeration or any inconsistency](https://section1.in/pocso-victims-testimony-before-the-court-is-clear-and-cogent-and-almost-the-same-as-per-the-statement-recorded-u-s-164-cr-p-c-and-there-has-been-no-exaggeration-or-any-inconsistency/)
Here is the revised excerpt with the party names removed:**Excerpt:** In this case,
the High Court upheld the accused’s conviction under the POCSO Act, finding the 
victim’s testimony and medical evidence sufficient without requiring a DNA test.
However, the Court reduced the sentence from 20 years to 10 years, ruling that applying
the 2019 amendment’s enhanced penalties to an offence committed in 2014 is unconstitutional
and barred by Article 20(1) of the…

Friday, August 21 – [Discrepancy in the use of the complainant’s fingers (two or five) to pick up the demanded money from his pocket has some bearing while considering the entire evidence](https://section1.in/discrepancy-in-the-use-of-the-complainants-fingers-two-or-five-to-pick-up-the-demanded-money-from-his-pocket-has-some-bearing-while-considering-the-entire-evidence/)
The Supreme Court held that the prosecution failed to prove the demand for illegal
gratification beyond reasonable doubt and that mere recovery or possession of tainted
money was insufficient to establish guilt. It also found the sanction against the
first accused invalid, as it was not granted by the competent authority. Consequently,
the convictions were set aside and both accused were…

Wednesday, August 19 – [Rejecting the petition filed under section 156(3) CrPC does not prevent the police to register FIR inasmuch the poser of registering FIR flows from section 154 CrPC](https://section1.in/rejecting-the-petition-filed-under-section-1563-crpc-does-not-prevent-the-police-to-register-fir-inasmuch-the-poser-of-registering-fir-flows-from-section-154-crpc/)
The Court held that rejecting a plea for a court-directed investigation does not
bar the subsequent registration of an FIR on similar allegations, as such threshold
dismissals are not merit-based adjudications attracting res judicata. The police
retain an independent statutory duty to register an FIR upon receiving information
disclosing cognizable offences, meaning the present allegations of fraud and forgery
must undergo a full investigation rather than being quashed at the…

Saturday, August 15 – [Acquittal: Defence of the accused is that the deceased accidentally drowned and the post-mortem report did not suggest homicide](https://section1.in/acquittal-defence-of-the-accused-is-that-the-deceased-accidentally-drowned-and-the-post-mortem-report-did-not-suggest-homicide/)
The Supreme Court acquitted the accused because the evidence showed accidental drowning
was more likely than murder, as the medical report did not prove homicide, the FIR
was delayed, the motive was weak, and the witnesses did not clearly prove…

Friday, August 14 – [Alibi: Quash: The service certificate is not a disputed one thus the High Court can quash the criminal proceedings on the fact of alibi based on that certificate](https://section1.in/alibi-quash-the-service-certificate-is-not-a-disputed-one-thus-the-high-court-can-quash-the-criminal-proceedings-on-the-fact-of-alibi-based-on-that-certificate/)
The Supreme Court quashed criminal proceedings involving dowry death llegations,
ruling that continuing the trial would constitute an abuse of the legal process.
Indisputable Armed Forces service records confirmed the accused was on official 
duty elsewhere during the incident, and co-accused relatives were already acquitted
on identical evidence. The Court emphasized that technical procedural rules cannot
compel a trial when unimpeachable documentary evidence definitively disproves the…

Thursday, August 13 – [Section 161 CrPC witness statements cannot be used to convict the accused only their testimony can be used to convict or acquit the accused](https://section1.in/section-161-crpc-witness-statements-cannot-be-used-to-convict-the-accused-only-their-testimony-can-be-used-to-convict-or-acquit-the-accused/)
The ratio decidendi is that a criminal conviction cannot be sustained solely on 
the basis of dying declarations and the invocation of Section 106 when major unexplained
discrepancies in timing, medical contradictions rendering the victim’s physical 
capacity to make coherent statements highly doubtful, and the failure of the prosecution
to independently establish a foundational chain of reliable incriminating circumstances
collectively generate a reasonable doubt regarding the guilt of the…

Tuesday, August 11 – [Rape of child: Acquittal based on the Forensic Lab Report which is inconsistent with the testimony of the witness before the court](https://section1.in/rape-of-child-acquittal-based-on-the-forensic-lab-report-which-is-inconsistent-with-the-testimony-of-the-witness-before-the-court/)
The Court said the conviction could not stand because the evidence and dying declarations
were doubtful and not well supported. The prosecution had to clearly prove that 
the death was murder and prove all key facts beyond reasonable doubt. Since the 
medical evidence raised doubt about whether the victim could give a statement, and
witnesses supported the possibility of suicide, the accused was entitled to acquittal.[
Paragraphs 13,…

Monday, August 10 – [Acquittal: A confession taken from a suspected person in police custody by using third-degree methods is not acceptable as evidence hence trial court conviction is set aside](https://section1.in/acquittal-a-confession-taken-from-a-suspected-person-in-police-custody-by-using-third-degree-methods-is-not-acceptable-as-evidence-hence-trial-court-conviction-is-set-aside/)
The ratio decidendi established by the Court is that appellate courts cannot dismiss
criminal appeals involving severe sentences like life imprisonment solely on the
ground of delay or limitation. Also, institutional failure in processing jail appeals
or providing effective legal representation to prisoners prejudices the fundamental
right to personal liberty and a fair trial under Article 21 of the Constitution 
of India [paragraphs 2, 12,…

Sunday, August 9 – [Acquittal: Since the limitation for a suit for money recovery has expired a criminal case cannot be used for money recovery](https://section1.in/acquittal-since-the-limitation-for-a-suit-for-money-recovery-has-expired-a-criminal-case-cannot-be-used-for-money-recovery/)
When a money recovery claim is time-barred, it should not be pursued through criminal
proceedings unless there is clear proof of cheating from the…

Sunday, August 9 – [Madras High Court Quashed: Section 69 and 351(2) BNS: Distinction between a promise to marry and a mere breach of promise due to later circumstances explained.](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-quashed-section-69-and-3512-bns-distinction-between-a-promise-to-marry-and-a-mere-breach-of-promise-due-to-later-circumstances-explained/)
PRAYER: Petition filed under Section 528 BNSS to call for the records pertaining
to PRC.No.75 of 2025 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate No.III, Dindigul and
quash the…

Sunday, August 9 – [Hon’ble Madras High Court suggests the need for structured and digital handling practices for e-filing of final report by district registry staff and police](https://section1.in/honble-madras-high-court-suggests-the-need-for-structured-and-digital-handling-practices-for-e-filing-of-final-report-by-district-registry-staff-and-police/)
Prayer: Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 528 of BNSS, to call for 
the records in Crime No.156 of 2020 on the file of the first respondent and quash
the…

Sunday, August 9 – [Sudalaimani case upheld & Selvam case distinguished: Confession given the police during investigation cannot be used in favour of the accused due to the bar u/s 162 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/sudalaimani-case-upheld-selvam-case-distinguished-confession-given-the-police-during-investigation-cannot-be-used-in-favour-of-the-accused-due-to-the-bar-u-s-162-cr-p-c/)
Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374(2) of Cr.P.C. to call for the entire records
in connection with S.C.No.139 of 2015 on the file of the Mahalir Neethi Mandram (
Fast Track Court), Tiruppur and set aside the conviction and sentence imposed by
the Mahalir Neethi Mandram (Fast Track Court), Tiruppur by judgment dated 26.12.2019
in S.C.No.139 of…

Saturday, August 8 – [Remedy and Challenges after the order of the Magistrate for FIR Direction](https://section1.in/remedy-and-challenges-after-the-order-of-the-magistrate-for-fir-direction/)
Author: Thiru. Jegan Manohar (Ms.No.1567/2020), Advocate, Practicing before the 
Madurai Bench of the Madras High court. Email.@jeganmanohar26@gmail.com. (Views 
and opinions are…

Saturday, August 8 – [Madras High Court: 14% of the disproportionate assets is inconsistent with the known sources of income thus conviction upheld](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/)
Prayer: Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374 of Code of Criminal Procedure, against
the Judgment of the learned XIII Additional Judge for CBI Cases, Chennai made in
C.C.No.38 of 2010 on his file dated 06.06.2014 convicting the accused / appellant
herein under Section 13 (2) r/w 13 (1) (e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 
1988 and sentencing him to undergo two years R.I.and to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/-
in default to undergo 3 months simple…

Friday, August 7 – [Cheque conviction: The accused has only relied upon plausible theories with conjectures and surmises](https://section1.in/cheque-conviction-the-accused-has-only-relied-upon-plausible-theories-with-conjectures-and-surmises/)
This Supreme Court of India judgment concerns a criminal appeal involving the dishonour
of a cheque under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The dispute originated
from a loan of ₹4,50,000 provided by the appellant to the respondent, which resulted
in a convicted status at the trial level after the repayment cheque was returned
for insufficient funds. However, the Karnataka High Court later overturned this 
conviction, questioning the appellant’s financial capacity to provide such…

Wednesday, July 29 – [Murder acquittal: No revision against the order of acquittal whereas the remedy of appeal is available in Cr.P.C after 2009 amendment](https://section1.in/murder-acquittal-no-revision-against-the-order-of-acquittal-whereas-the-remedy-of-appeal-is-available-in-cr-p-c-after-2009-amendment/)
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and restored the trial court’s judgment of 
acquittal in a 1988 murder case, holding that an acquittal fortifies the presumption
of innocence and cannot be disturbed or remitted under revisional jurisdiction when
the trial court’s view is plausible. Upon re-evaluating the evidence, the Court 
found the eyewitness testimonies uncredible, the alleged dying declarations doubtful,
and the scene of occurrence suspect. It held that the mere recovery of a…

Sunday, July 26 – [Quashing of Multiple FIRs: A citizen of India may approach S.C through Article 32 is a fundamental right but may follow judicial principle and orderly procedure at first](https://section1.in/quashing-of-multiple-firs-a-citizen-of-india-may-approach-s-c-through-article-32-is-a-fundamental-right-but-may-follow-judicial-principle-and-orderly-procedure-at-first/)
The petitioner Rutvij Bhagat Singh Wakhare instituted a writ petition under Article
32 before the Supreme Court seeking to quash or club multiple FIRs arising from 
cyber fraud, wherein the Court held that a direct Article 32 petition to quash criminal
proceedings without establishing fundamental rights violations is not maintainable,
and that clubbing multiple FIRs is impermissible when each relates to distinct transactions
by different victims with no live…

Sunday, July 26 – [Denovo Trial: Unusual recording of confession statements based on judicial directions and the doubt of subsequent insertion of statutory warning in the confession creates serious doubts](https://section1.in/denovo-trial-unusual-recording-of-confession-statements-based-on-judicial-directions-and-the-doubt-of-subsequent-insertion-of-statutory-warning-in-the-confession-creates-serious-doubts/)
This judgment adjudicates a batch of criminal appeals stemming from a devastating
bomb explosion on a public transport bus in 1996, which resulted in fourteen fatalities
and numerous injuries. The Supreme Court reviewed the convictions and sentences,
including a death penalty, alongside appeals against the acquittal of several co-
accused individuals. Upon thorough scrutiny, the Court found that the trial of the
primary convicted individual was constitutionally flawed because they were denied…

Tuesday, July 21 – [NDPS:Even if the independent witnesses to the seizure memo turned hostile conviction can be based on official witnesses if it inspires confidence](https://section1.in/even-if-the-independent-witnesses-to-the-seizure-memo-turned-hostile-conviction-can-be-based-on-official-witnesses-if-it-inspires-confidence/)
Even if the independent witnesses to the seizure memo turned hostile conviction 
can be based on official witnesses if it inspires…

Tuesday, July 21 – [Appreciation of the quantum of sentence is explained](https://section1.in/appreciation-of-the-quantum-of-sentence-is-explained/)
The Supreme Court partly allowed the appeal strictly regarding the quantum of sentence
for a conviction under Section 376-D IPC, reducing the punishment from imprisonment
for the remainder of natural life to the statutory minimum of twenty years with 
remission benefits. Applying the doctrine of proportionality, the Court balanced
the heinous nature of the crime against mitigating factors—such as the offender’s
young age, lack of criminal antecedents, good prison conduct, and potential for…

Sunday, July 19 – [If the Magistrate cannot direct the I.O to file a particular opinion (charge sheet) then the S.P has no power to direct the same](https://section1.in/if-the-magistrate-cannot-direct-the-i-o-to-file-a-particular-opinion-charge-sheet-then-the-s-p-has-no-power-to-direct-the-same/)
The Supreme Court acquitted the accused, overturning the lower courts’ decisions
regarding a dowry death conviction. The prosecution failed to prove beyond a reasonable
doubt that the victim’s fatal burn injuries resulted from marital cruelty, lacking
concrete evidence, an immediate FIR, and a postmortem report. Conversely, the defense
provided uncontroverted proof of an accidental fire and a stable marriage, supported
by an exculpatory dying declaration and joint financial records. Emphasizing…

Wednesday, July 15 – [Murder: Conviction: Corpus delicti means that the offence has been committed and not that the dead body of the murdered person has been recovered](https://section1.in/murder-conviction-corpus-delicti-means-that-the-offence-has-been-committed-and-not-that-the-dead-body-of-the-murdered-person-has-been-recovered/)
Appeal 1. The present criminal appeal is directed against the judgment and order
dated 22.12.2022 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Gauhati at Guwahati
in Criminal Appeal (J) No. 16/2019. By the impugned judgment and order, the High
Court dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant and upheld the order of…

Tuesday, July 14 – [As per section 21 POCSO Act only those who received credible information directly could be prosecuted for failure to report and not all the teachers or office bearers of the institution also no suppression of information is reported](https://section1.in/as-per-section-21-pocso-act-only-those-who-received-credible-information-directly-could-be-prosecuted-for-failure-to-report-and-not-all-the-teachers-or-office-bearers-of-the-institution-also-no-suppre/)
The Supreme Court of India partially overturned a High Court order that discharged
school staff for failing to report a minor’s sexual assault under the POCSO Act 
and IPC. The Court ruled that under Section 19(1) of the POCSO Act, statutory “knowledge”
of an offense includes receiving credible, direct information from a victim, rejecting
the lower courts’ view that a lack of physical or medical evidence negates this 
knowledge. Emphasizing that mandatory reporting duties cannot be bypassed or…

Wednesday, July 8 – [Anticipatory Bail is not needed in complaint cases if apprehension of arrest is only by the police](https://section1.in/anticipatory-bail-is-not-needed-in-complaint-cases-only-if-apprehension-of-arrest-is-by-the-police-only/)
1. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioners and also learned counsel for
the State who has appeared on advance notice. 2. This anticipatory bail application
arises out of a Complaint Case No. 410 of 2023 pending on the file of Learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Division, Madhubani, State of Bihar. 3. This Court has…

Sunday, July 5 – [Honour killing: The court must see whether a hostile witness is totally discredited if not the court should not discard his testimony entirely](https://section1.in/honour-killing-the-court-must-see-whether-a-hostile-witness-is-totally-discredited-if-not-the-court-should-not-discard-his-testimony-entirely/)
In an honour killing case, the Hon’ble S.C upheld the Madras High Court by giving
a detailed research judgment, particularly handling the hostile…

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
