# Digitization of records: Records not available in the appeal hence conviction set aside

- Link: https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/
- Published: 2023-05-18T14:53:03+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Question of Law](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#question-of-law)
 * [Proceedings before the High Court](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#proceedings-before-the-high-court)
 * [Records missing](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#records-missing)
 * [High Court convicted despite non-availability of records](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#high-court-convicted-despite-nonavailability-of-records)
 * [The present appeal](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#the-present-appeal)
 * [Consideration by the Hon’ble Supreme Court](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#consideration-by-the-hon8217ble-supreme-court)
 * [High Court must benefit from the documents produced in the trial](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#high-court-must-benefit-from-the-documents-produced-in-the-trial)
 * [Appeal court has to decide the appeal not by trial court judgment but based on the records](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#appeal-court-has-to-decide-the-appeal-not-by-trial-court-judgment-but-based-on-the-records)
 * [Conclusions](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#conclusions)
 * [Digitization process](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#digitization-process)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/#party)

##### **Question of Law**

> 2. The questions which arise for our consideration are; One, whether, in the absence
> of the records of the Court of Trial, the appellate Court could have upheld the
> conviction and enhanced the quantum of fine? And Two, whether, given the language
> employed under Section 385 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the present
> situation constitutes a violation of the accused’s fundamental rights under Article
> 21 of the Constitution of India?

6. Having so recorded, the Trial Court sentenced the Appellant to rigorous imprisonment
of one year and rupees five hundred by way of fine (in default thereof, further 
imprisonment of six months) under Section 7 of the PC Act and rigorous imprisonment
of two years and rupees five hundred by way of fine (in default thereof, further
imprisonment of six months) under Section 13(2) of the PC Act.

##### **Proceedings before the High Court**

##### **Records missing**

7. Assailing the judgment of conviction and sentence, the High Court admitted the
petitioner’s appeal on 07.12.1999. A perusal of the Order dated 04.03.2016 reveals
that despite repeated summoning of records of the trial, no reply was received from
the Court concerned and as a result, the District Judge was asked to furnish an 
explanation and, in any event, take steps for reconstruction of the record.

7.1 The record further reveals that “the entire record has been lost and is not 
traceable” and the documents sent as “reconstructed documents” do not constitute
the relevant trial court record. They were found to be not to be in accordance with
Rules nor endorsed by the Central Bureau of Investigation.

##### **High Court convicted despite non-availability of records**

8. The High Court, vide the impugned judgment dated 23.11.2022, upheld the conviction
despite having noted on an earlier occasion that the reconstruction of records was
not in accordance with rules and the admission of nonavailability Of material on
record, for which the Appellant herein was in no manner responsible. Significantly,
despite arguments, the Court did not discuss the merits of conviction.

##### **The present appeal**

11. The learned counsel for the Appellant states that the law is settled on the 
issue, and in the absence of such records, a conviction cannot be stated to be on
firm grounds and is liable to be set aside. The learned counsel places reliance 
on Shyam Deo Pandey and Others v. State of Bihar [(1971) 1 SCC 855], State of U.
P. v. Abhai Raj Singh and Another [(2004) 4 SCC 6]. He further placed reliance on
High Court decisions, namely Ramesh Kaushik v. State of Delhi [2022 SCC Online Del
4185] of the Delhi High Court; Raghuvir Sahai and Others v. State of U.P [Criminal
Appeal No.786 of 1979], Avdesh Rai and Others v. State of U.P [Criminal Appeal No.
346 of 1984] and Tej Pal Singh and Others v. State of U.P [2015 SCC Online All 6581]
of the Allahabad High Court.

##### **Consideration by the Hon’ble Supreme Court**

12. A conviction of any nature permanently marks a person’s character. It would 
be, in the specific circumstances of this case, unjustified. This is not to say 
that five hundred rupees as far back as 1995 was a small or insignificant amount;
however, when the possibility of appeal is extinguished due to the absence of essential
material, the perusal and consideration of which is required to take stock of the
matter and then uphold or reverse, as the case may be, then the benefit of the doubt
has to be extended to the accused when he is in no manner responsible for the same.

13. We must consider whether the nonavailability of trial court records before the
High Court and upholding conviction, despite the absence thereof, infringes the 
right to life and liberty of the accused enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution
of India.

14. It is well settled that following “procedure established by law” in a criminal
prosecution is a sacrosanct requirement.

17. In Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi)9(two Judge Bench), this Court has also
noted that the due process of law shall deem to include fairness in trial. The Court
gives a right to the accused to receive all documents and statements and move applications
for the production of records relating to the case.

##### **High Court must benefit from the documents produced in the trial**

18. If a right of production of documents at the trial stage exists, it is a natural
corollary that the High Court, sitting in appeal, must benefit from those documents.
In the considered view of this Court, this is a demand of the abovementioned sacrosanct
requirement.

19. As we have noted earlier, in the present case, despite efforts, documents such
as the witness statements, statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C. are neither available
nor have been able to be reconstructed. Therefore, upholding conviction in the absence
of such documents cannot be said to be in consonance with due process of law and
fairness.

21. The instant case is governed by Section 385 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973.

22. A bare reading of the provision makes it clear that when appeals are not dismissed
summarily, the Appellate Court shall call for the records of the Court below except
in cases where the question for consideration is the legality of a sentence. There
is undoubtedly a compulsion upon the Appellate Court to call for the record and 
then proceed to examine the merits of a case before it. That, as is prima facie 
observable, is not the case before us.

24. The abovementioned requirement is found in the Old Code (Criminal Procedure 
Code, 1898, now repealed), under Section 423 as well. Section 423 of the 1898 Code,
corresponds to Section 385 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898.

26. This Court in Biswanath Ghosh v. State of W.B [(1987) 2 SCC 55] (two Judge Bench)
observed that an Appellate Court allowing a conviction without having the records
before it and the evidence adduced by the prosecution is a flagrant miscarriage 
of justice.

29. In a case with similar circumstance, we notice that the Allahabad High Court
in Sita Ram & Others v. State [1981 Cr.LJ, 65] has held that when the entire record
was lost or destroyed and the reconstruction of the record was not possible, the
Appellate Court shall order retrial provided the time lag date of incident and the
date of hearing of appeal is short. If the same is long and/or the FIR, statement,
of witnesses under Section 161 and other relevant papers are not available, the 
Appellate Court should not order retrial.

30. In numerous judgments rendered by various High Courts, a similar view to the
effect that a conviction cannot be upheld in the absence of the records of the Court
below has been expressed. Taking note of Sita Ram (supra), the time elapsed between
the occurrence of the offence and the appeal being finally decided, these courts
have held that in the absence of essential documents such as the FIR or witness 
statements, a retrial too cannot be said to be serving the ends of justice. [Khalil
Ahmad v. State of U.P [1986 SCC OnLine All 211]; Vir Pal v. State [1999 SCC OnLine
All 1348]; Hira Lal v. State of U.P [1999 SCC OnLine All 1392] and Bhunda and Ors.
V. State of U.P [2001 SCC OnLine All 864].

31. In the present case, the impugned judgment of the High Court records the statement
of the CBI that the records have “got lost”. The “reconstructed” record consists
of the following:

> **i. FIR of RC 18(A)/95LKO;**
>  **ii. Complaint dated 03.05.1995 of Sri J.P.N. 
> Upadhyay, CIT, Varanasi (2 pages);** **iii. Photocopy of S.F.II dated 24.03.1995(
> one page);** **iv. Pretrap memorandum dated 3.5.95 (4 pages);** **v. Recovery 
> memo dated 3.5.1995 (5 pages);** **vi. Search list dated 3.5.95 (5 pages);** **
> vii. One file containing chargesheet (SFII) of Sri JPN Upadhyay and Notesheet.(
> Pages 1 to 6 & Notesheet PP2);** **viii. Search list dated 4.5.95 (1 sheet);****
> ix. Site plan dated 3.5.95 (1 sheet);** **x. Misc. Papers containing Draft chargesheet
> etc. (7 sheets);** **xi. Sanction order dated 28.12.95.**

Subsection, 2 of Section 385, requires that the parties are heard in light of the
records received by the Court. The documents undoubtedly need to include the essential
documents necessary to properly appreciate the appeal on its merits. Even the depositions
of the witnesses, both prosecution and defence, have not been reconstructed and 
are not available for the Court. This position of disposal of an appeal on merits
being only after perusal of record, has been held by a three Judge Bench in Bani
Singh (supra).

32. The Court below, in our considered view, by taking a mutually contradictory 
view, proceeded to decide the appeal on merits sentencing the accused, forgetting
that the challenge was also for conviction. And yet did not deal with the merits
of the appeal, laying specific challenge to the judgment of conviction. The whole
approach is illegal and erroneous. Firstly, it is observed that the record was missing,
and then it casts the onus to produce the same on the Appellant.

##### **Appeal court has to decide the appeal not by trial court judgment but based on the records**

33. In light of the abovementioned discussion, the Accused, in appeal, has a right
to have the record perused by the Appellate Court and, therefore, upholding a conviction
by merely having noted that the counsel for the accused not having the record at
the time of filing the appeal is “doubtful” and that “no one can believe” the appeal
would have been filed without perusing the record, as observed by the High Court
is not correct. The job of the Court of Appeal is not to depend on the lower Court’s
judgment to uphold the conviction but, based on the record available before it duly
called from the Trial Court and the arguments advanced before it, to come to a conclusion
thereon.

34. In the facts at hand, the alleged offence in question was committed on 21.3.1995,
and the judgment of the Trial Court was delivered on 7.12.1999. More than 28 years
have passed since the commission of the offence. As already indicated, the relevant
Trial Court record has not been able to be reconstructed, despite the efforts of
the courts below. Hence, in our considered view, as discussed above, ordering a 
retrial is not in the interest of justice and will not serve any fruitful purpose.
The time elapsed must be taken into consideration by the Court, and we may stress
on that, only after taking due note of and taking steps to abide by the warning 
issued by this Court in Abhai Raj Singh (supra), as was correctly done in Sita Ram(
supra).

##### **Conclusions**

35. Protection of the rights under Article 21 entails protection of liberty from
any restriction thereupon in the absence of fair legal procedure. Fair legal procedure
includes the opportunity for the person filing an appeal to question the conclusions
drawn by the trial court. The same can only be done when the record is available
with the Court of Appeal. That is the mandate of Section 385 of the CrPC. Therefore,
in the considered view of this Court, it is not within prudence to lay down a straightjacket
formula, we hold that noncompliance with the mandate of the section, in certain 
cases contingent upon specific facts and circumstances of the case, would result
in a violation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India, which we find it to be
so in the instant case.

36. The language of Section 385 shows that the Court sitting in appeal governed 
thereby is required to call for the records of the case from the concerned Court
below. The same is an obligation, power coupled with a duty, and only after the 
perusal of such records would an appeal be decided.

##### **Digitization process**

42. Therefore, this Court finds it fit to issue the following directions:

> **1. The Registrar General of the High Courts shall ensure that in all cases of
> criminal trial, as well as civil suits, the digitization of records must be duly
> undertaken with promptitude at all District Courts, preferably within the time
> prescribed for filing an appeal within the laws of procedure.**
> **2. The concerned District Judge, once the system of digitization along with 
> the system of authentication of the digitized records is in place in their judgeship,
> to ensure that the records so digitized are verified as expeditiously as possible.**
> **3. A continually updated record of Register of Records digitized shall be maintained
> with periodic reports being sent to the concerned High Courts for suitable directions.**
> **4. Interlocutory application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.**

Accused Aquitted.

##### **Party**

**JITENDRA KUMAR RODE vs. UNION OF INDIA – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO……………OF 2023 Arising
out of SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO. 2063 OF 2023 – 24th April, 2023;**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/5292/5292_2023_8_1504_43930_Judgement_24-Apr-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/5292/5292_2023_8_1504_43930_Judgement_24-Apr-2023.pdf)**

**[jitendra-kumar-rode-vs-uoi-absence-of-records](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/jitendra-kumar-rode-vs-uoi-absence-of-records-1.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
