# Discharge: Death by electrocution while working is purely accidental (death) and hence section 304 II IPC would not apply

- Link: https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/
- Published: 2025-03-16T07:28:20+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against order of Hon’ble High Court dismissing criminal revision filed against discharge order](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#appeal-against-order-of-honble-high-court-dismissing-criminal-revision-filed-against-discharge-order)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#facts)
    - [The employees of appellant were electrocuted and fell down from the height of 12 feet while working on sign board resulted in their deaths](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#the-employees-of-appellant-were-electrocuted-and-fell-down-from-the-height-of-12-feet-while-working-on-sign-board-resulted-in-their-deaths)
    - [Report under section 174 Cr.P.C registered](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#report-under-section-174-crpc-registered)
    - [After two months an FIR came to be registered under sections 304 and 304A IPC](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#after-two-months-an-fir-came-to-be-registered-under-sections-304-and-304a-ipc)
    - [Arrest of appellants and release](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#arrest-of-appellants-and-release)
    - [After taking cognizance on the final report the J.M committed the case to the Sessions court](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#after-taking-cognizance-on-the-final-report-the-jm-committed-the-case-to-the-sessions-court)
    - [Appellants filed discharge applications](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#appellants-filed-discharge-applications)
    - [Contents on the discharge applications](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#contents-on-the-discharge-applications)
    - [Dismissal orders of Discharge applications](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#dismissal-orders-of-discharge-applications)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#analysis)
    - [Culpable homicide not amounting to murder: Explained](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-explained)
    - [To commit the offence of culpable homicide, intention or knowledge is of crucial importance](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#to-commit-the-offence-of-culpable-homicide-intention-or-knowledge-is-of-crucial-importance)
    - [To commit culpable homicide not amounting to murder the presence of knowledge and absence of intention is must](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#to-commit-culpable-homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-the-presence-of-knowledge-and-absence-of-intention-is-must)
    - [Trial and High Courts came to the conclusion that the accused had not taken proper care on their two employees as such accused are responsible for their death](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#trial-and-high-courts-came-to-the-conclusion-that-the-accused-had-not-taken-proper-care-on-their-two-employees-as-such-accused-are-responsible-for-their-death)
    - [No prima facie case of culpable homicide can be said to have been made out against the appellants](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#no-prima-facie-case-of-culpable-homicide-can-be-said-to-have-been-made-out-against-the-appellants)
    - [Scope of discharge explained](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#scope-of-discharge-explained)
    - [Death by electrocution while working is purely accidental and hence Keshub Mahindra case of no assistance](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-and-hence-keshub-mahindra-case-of-no-assistance)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#conclusion)
    - [Acts and sections are involved in this judgment](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#acts-and-sections-are-involved-in-this-judgment)
    - [Judgments Cited or Relied](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#judgments-cited-or-relied)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/discharge-death-by-electrocution-while-working-is-purely-accidental-death-and-hence-section-304-ii-ipc-would-not-apply/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against order of Hon’ble High Court dismissing criminal revision filed against discharge order**

This appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 02.11.2017
passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay (briefly ‘the High Court’ hereinafter)
in Criminal Revision Application No. 269 of 2017.

2. By the aforesaid judgment and order dated 02.11.2017, the revision application
filed by the appellants assailing the order dated 01.04.2017 passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Pune in Sessions Case No. 749 of 2014 came to be dismissed.

2.1. Be it stated that by the aforesaid order dated 01.04.2017, learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Pune dismissed the discharge applications filed by the appellants
being Exhibit Nos. 6 and 10 in Sessions Case No.749 of 2014.

#### **Facts**

4. Appellant No. 1 was doing interior decoration of the concerned shop in Pune on
contract basis. Appellant No. 2 was the Store Operation Manager of M/s. lntergold
Gems Private Limited which had taken the concerned shop on lease.

##### **The employees of appellant were electrocuted and fell down from the height of 12 feet while working on sign board resulted in their deaths**

4.1. On 27.09.2013, at about 09:00 PM, the work of decoration of the front side 
of the shop was being undertaken by two employees of appellant No.1, Salauddin Shaikh
and Arun Sharma. It is alleged that both the employees viz. Salauddin Shaikh and
Arun Sharma were provided with an iron ladder and they were working on the sign 
board which was approximately at a height of 12 feet from the ground level. While
they were working on the sign board, they were struck by electricity as a result
of which they got electrocuted and fell down. Due to the fall, they suffered head
injuries as well as injuries on their arms. They were taken to Pune Hospital and
Research Centre where they were declared dead on arrival.

##### **Report under section 174 Cr.P.C registered**

4.2. Accidental reports bearing Nos. 67/23 and 68/23 under Section 174 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) were registered.

##### **After two months an FIR came to be registered under sections 304 and 304A IPC**

4.3. After more than two months, on 04.12.2013, FIR was lodged at Vishrambag Police
Station, Pune by the Police Sub-Inspector Shri S.G. Patil against the appellants
which was registered as FIR No. 316/2013. It was stated that the appellants did 
not provide any safety equipments like belt, helmet, rubber shoes etc to the two
deceased employees. According to the investigating officer, the two accused persons
had not taken proper care and caution by providing safety shoes, safety belt etc
to the two employees though the work assigned to them was quite risky. Informant
opined that both the appellants were responsible for the unnatural death of the 
two employees since they had knowledge that there was risk to the lives of the employees.
Therefore, the first informant summed up by saying that both the accused persons
were responsible for the unnatural death of the two deceased persons. Accordingly,
it was alleged that appellants had committed offences under Sections 304 and 304A
IPC.

##### **Arrest of appellants and release**

4.4. On 04.12.2013 itself both the appellants were arrested in connection with the
aforesaid FIR. They were subsequently released on the same day. After completion
of investigation, police submitted chargesheet in which the two appellants were 
arrayed as accused. Appellants were chargesheeted for committing an offence under
Sections 304A/182/201 read with Section 34 IPC.

##### **After taking cognizance on the final report the J.M committed the case to the Sessions court**

4.5. Learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Pune, before whom the chargesheet 
was filed, was of the view that there were material to attract Section 304 Part 
II IPC. Since it became a sessions triable case, the same was committed to the Court
of Additional Sessions Judge, Pune where it was registered as Sessions Case No.749
of 2014.

##### **Appellants filed discharge applications**

5. Appellants filed Exhibit Nos. 6 and 10 applications in the Court of Additional
Sessions Judge, Pune seeking their discharge under Section 227 of CrPC.

##### **Contents on the discharge applications**

5.1. Contention of the appellants in the discharge applications was that there were
no materials to show that the appellants had committed the alleged offence. Ingredients
of the alleged offence charged were not even prima facie established against the
appellants. Charge levelled by the prosecution against the appellants was groundless.
FIR was totally silent about any overt act of the appellants. Appellants were not
present at the place of occurrence when the incident took place. There was no negligence
on the part of the appellants; not to speak of having any knowledge or intention
to cause the death of the two employees or such bodily injury as would likely cause
their death.

5.2. Even if all the statements of the witnesses were considered and accepted as
correct, the trial would not end in conviction of the appellants. Going ahead with
the trial would be a futile exercise. There were no materials to show that appellants
had committed the offence as charged. In the circumstances, appellants sought for
discharge as contemplated under Section 227 of the CrPC.

##### **Dismissal orders of Discharge applications**

6. Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Pune vide his order dated 01.04.2017 dismissed
both the discharge applications. He held that the two appellants were certainly 
not oblivious of the fact that they had not provided safety gear to the employees
which was certainly dangerous to them as they got exposed to electrocution risk.
Learned Additional Sessions Judge was also of the view that there was much force
in the argument advanced on behalf of the prosecution that there was sufficient 
material justifying framing of charge against the accused for the offence punishable
under Section 304 Part II read with Section 34 IPC. In that view of the matter, 
the discharge applications were dismissed.

7. Aggrieved by the aforesaid decision, appellants preferred Criminal Revision Application
No. 269 of 2017 before the High Court. After going through the materials on record
and after hearing the parties, High Court was of the view that there was strong 
suspicion against both the appellants for committing the offence for which they 
were charged. It could not be said that there were no grounds to proceed against
the appellants. No case for interference was made out. Hence, the revision petition
was dismissed vide the judgment and order dated 02.11.2017.

#### **Analysis**

11. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration
of the court.

11.1. At the outset, it would apposite to deal with the relevant legal provisions.

12. We have noted above that the appellants have been charged for committing offence
under Section 304 Part II IPC read with Section 34 IPC. Since Section 34 IPC covers
common intention, the substantive charge against the appellants is under Section
304 Part II IPC which reads as under:

Punishment for culpable homicide not amounting to murder – Whoever commits culpable
homicide not amounting to murder shall be punished with imprisonment of either description
for a term which may extend to ten years or with fine or with both, if the act is
done with the knowledge that it is likely to cause death; but without any intention
to cause death or to cause such bodily injury as is likely to cause death.

12.1. The ingredients constituting an offence under Section 304 Part II IPC are 
as follows:

(i) he must commit culpable homicide not amounting to murder;

(ii) the act must be done with the knowledge that it is likely to cause death;

(iii) but such act is done without any intention to cause death or to cause such
bodily injury as is likely to cause death.

##### **Culpable homicide not amounting to murder: Explained**

12.2. Therefore, the first important expression is ‘culpable homicide not amounting
to murder’. Culpable homicide is defined in Section 299 IPC. It says that whoever
causes death by doing an act with the intention of causing death or with the intention
of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death or with the knowledge 
that he is likely by such act to cause death, commits the offence of culpable homicide.

##### **To commit the offence of culpable homicide, intention or knowledge is of crucial importance**

12.3. All culpable homicides are murders except in the cases excepted under Section
300 IPC. Thus, except the cases specifically exempted under Section 300 IPC, all
other acts within the meaning of Section 299 IPC would amount to committing the 
offence of culpable homicide. However, what is important to note is that for committing
the offence of culpable homicide, a positive act must be done by the doer with the
intention that such act would cause death or cause such bodily injury as is likely
to cause death or he having the knowledge that by such an act, death may be caused.
What, therefore, is significant is that the doer of the act must have the intention
of causing death or the intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to 
cause death or has the knowledge that by doing such an act he is likely to cause
death. Therefore, to commit the offence of culpable homicide, intention or knowledge
is of crucial importance.

##### **To commit culpable homicide not amounting to murder the presence of knowledge and absence of intention is must**

12.4. Coming back to Section 304 Part II IPC, we find that the said section would
be attracted if anyone commits culpable homicide not amounting to murder if the 
act is done with the knowledge that it is likely to cause death but without any 
intention to cause death or to cause such bodily injury as is likely to cause death.
Therefore, the requirement of Section 304 Part II IPC is that the doer must have
the knowledge that the act performed is likely to cause death or to cause such bodily
injury as is likely to cause death but without any intention to cause death. Thus,
the basic ingredient of Section 304 Part II IPC is presence of knowledge and absence
of intention. The doer must have the knowledge that the act performed by him would
likely cause death etc but there should not be any intention to cause death.

##### **Trial and High Courts came to the conclusion that the accused had not taken proper care on their two employees as such accused are responsible for their death**

13. This being the legal framework, let us now deal with the charge against the 
appellants taking the same as correct. According to the prosecution and accepted
by the Trial Court and the High Court, the two accused persons had not taken proper
care and caution by providing safety shoes, safety belt etc to the two employees
though they were asked to perform the job of working on the sign board as part of
decorating the front side of the shop which was approximately at a height of 12 
feet from the ground level. The accused persons had provided only an iron ladder
to the two employees but while working they were struck by electricity as a result
of which they suffered electrocution and fell down. They suffered multiple injuries
which led to their death. Therefore, both the accused persons were declared to be
responsible for the unnatural death of the two deceased employees.

##### **No prima facie case of culpable homicide can be said to have been made out against the appellants**

14. Even if we take the allegation against the appellants as correct, we are afraid
no prima facie case can be said to have been made out against the appellants for
committing an offence under Section 304 Part II IPC. From the record of the case,
it is evident that there was no intention on the part of the two appellants to cause
the death or cause such bodily injury as was likely to cause the death of the two
deceased employees. **It cannot also be said that the appellants had knowledge that
by asking the two deceased employees to work on the sign board as part of the work
of decoration of the frontage of the shop, they had the knowledge that such an act
was likely to cause the death of the two deceased employees**. As such, no prima
facie case of culpable homicide can be said to have been made out against the appellants.
If that be so, the subsequent requirement of having knowledge that the act was likely
to cause the death but not having any intention to cause death would become irrelevant
though we may hasten to add that nothing is discernible from the record of the case
that the appellants had the knowledge that by asking the two employees to work on
the sign board would likely cause their death or cause such bodily injury as is 
likely to cause their death.

15. Therefore, the basic ingredients for commission of offence under Section 304
Part II IPC are absent in the present case.

##### **Scope of discharge explained**

16. Section 227 CrPC deals with discharge. What Section 227 CrPC contemplates is
that if upon consideration of the record of the case and the documents submitted
therewith and after hearing the submissions of the accused and the prosecution in
this behalf, the judge considers that there is no sufficient grounds for proceeding
against the accused, he shall discharge the accused and record his reasons for doing
so. **At the stage of consideration of discharge, the court is not required to undertake
a threadbare analysis of the materials gathered by the prosecution. All that is 
required to be seen at this stage is that there are sufficient grounds to proceed
against the accused. In other words, the materials should be sufficient to enable
the court to initiate a criminal trial against the accused.** It may be so that 
at the end of the trial, the accused may still be acquitted. At the stage of discharge,
court is only required to consider as to whether there are sufficient materials 
which can justify launch of a criminal trial against the accused. By its very nature,
a discharge is at a higher pedestal than an acquittal. Acquittal is at the end of
the trial process, may be for a technicality or on benefit of doubt or the prosecution
could not prove the charge against the accused; but when an accused is discharged,
it means that there are no materials to justify launch of a criminal trial against
the accused. Once he is discharged, he is no longer an accused.

##### **Death by electrocution while working is purely accidental and hence Keshub Mahindra case of no assistance**

17.3. In so far facts of the present case is concerned, the two deceased employees
of appellant No. 1 were undertaking the work of decoration of the front side of 
the shop. As part of the said work, they were working on the sign board which was
approximately at a height of 12 feet from the ground level. For this purpose, they
were provided with an iron ladder. While working on the sign board, they were struck
by electricity as a result of which they got electrocuted and fell down resulting
in multiple injuries leading to their death. It was purely accidental. On these 
basic facts, no prima facie case can be said to be made out against the appellants
for committing an offence under Section 304A IPC, not to speak of Section 304 Part
II IPC. In any case, the Trial Court only considered culpability of the appellants
qua Section 304 Part II IPC as the committing Magistrate had committed the case 
to the Court of Sessions confining the allegations against the appellant to Section
304 Part II IPC and not Section 304A IPC.

17.4 Therefore, Keshub Mahindra (supra) can be of no assistance to the respondent.

#### Conclusion

18. That being the position and having regard to the discussions made above, we 
are of the view that both the Trial Court and the High Court fell in error in rejecting
the discharge applications of the appellants. For the reasons stated above, the 
order of the Trial Court dated 01.04.2017 and that of the High Court dated 02.11.2017
are hereby set aside and quashed. Consequently, the discharge applications being
Exhibit Nos. 6 and 10 in Sessions Case No. 749 of 2014 are hereby allowed. Appellants
are discharged from Sessions Case No. 749 of 2014. Consequently, Criminal Appeal
No. 2356 of 2024 is allowed.         

##### **Acts and sections are involved in this judgment**

Indian Penal Code (IPC):

 * Section 304 Part II (Culpable homicide not amounting to murder) 
 * Section 304A (Causing death by negligence) 
 * Section 182 (False information with intent to cause public servant to use lawful
   power to injury) 
 * Section 201 (Causing disappearance of evidence) 
 * Section 34 (Common intention) 
 * Section 299 (Definition of culpable homicide) 
 * Section 300 (Murder) 

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC):

 * Section 174 (Police to inquire and report on suicide, etc.) 
 * Section 227 (Discharge) 

Constitution of India:

 * Article 142 (Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court) 

##### **Judgments Cited or Relied**

1. **Keshub Mahindra Vs. State of M.P – Citation: (1996) 6 SCC 129** – This case
was referenced regarding the standards for establishing culpability and the requirements
for framing charges under IPC sections. The Hon’ble Supreme Court notices that the
facts in Keshub Mahindra (which arose from the Bhopal Gas tragedy) were “poles apart”
from the present case and therefore could not assist the respondent’s arguments

#### **Party**

Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther & Anr. vs. State of Maharashtra – Criminal Appeal No. 2356
of 2024 – 2025 INSC 338 – March 7, 2025 – Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Abhay
S. Oka

[Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther vs. State of Maharashtra 404632017_2025-03-07](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Yuvraj-Laxmilal-Kanther-vs.-State-of-Maharashtra-404632017_2025-03-07.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Yuvraj-Laxmilal-Kanther-vs.-State-of-Maharashtra-404632017_2025-03-07.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
