# Discharge: Expert witness examined by the complainant has stated that the death was natural.

- Link: https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/
- Published: 2024-01-20T19:05:46+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Present appeal against the order of High court setting aside the order discharging the accused under section 227 crpc](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#present-appeal-against-the-order-of-high-court-setting-aside-the-order-discharging-the-accused-under-section-227-crpc)
 * [Factual aspects](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#factual-aspects)
 * [Based on negative report the respondent’s father instead of filing protest petition has filed a complaint under section 200 cr.p.c](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#based-on-negative-report-the-respondents-father-instead-of-filing-protest-petition-has-filed-a-complaint-under-section-200-crpc)
 * [Order dismissed the complaint under section 203 crpc by the magistrate and the same was set aside by the High court](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#order-dismissed-the-complaint-under-section-203-crpc-by-the-magistrate-and-the-same-was-set-aside-by-the-high-court)
 * [Accused properly discharged by the sessions judge under section 227 crpc](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#accused-properly-discharged-by-the-sessions-judge-under-section-227-crpc)
 * [The expert witness examined by the respondent stated (proceeding before magistrate on complaint) that the death was natural](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#the-expert-witness-examined-by-the-respondent-stated-proceeding-before-magistrate-on-complaint-that-the-death-was-natural)
 * [According to the complainant there was an enmity between him and the accused](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#according-to-the-complainant-there-was-an-enmity-between-him-and-the-accused)
 * [conclusion](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#conclusion)
 * [Parties](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#parties)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/discharge-expert-witness-examined-by-the-complainant-has-stated-that-the-death-was-natural/#further-study)

##### Present appeal against the order of High court setting aside the order discharging the accused under section 227 crpc

The appellants have taken exception to the judgment and order dated 20th December
2018 passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Judicature at Madras.
The learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Salem, had passed an order dated
9th January 2009 granting discharge to the appellants in the exercise of powers 
under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short ‘CrPC’). One
Nanjundan, the husband of the deceased Siddammal, challenged the order of the learned
Additional District and Sessions Judge by filing a revision application. The High
Court, by the impugned judgment and order, has allowed the revision application 
and has remanded the case to the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge 
for holding trial. The said Nanjundan died during the pendency of revision application.
The respondent is his son.

##### Factual aspects

2. We must advert to a few factual aspects. The respondent’s father Nanjundan had
lodged a First Information Report bearing Cr. No.107 of 2004 (the FIR) alleging 
the commission of offences under Sections 341, 323 and 302 of the Indian Penal Code
against the appellants. The FIR was based on the incident of 9th October 2004. In
the complaint, based on which the FIR was registered, it was alleged that the first
appellant had filed a suit against the respondent, praying for carrying out the 
measurement of the property claimed by the appellants and removing encroachment.
On the date of the incident, around 11 am, the appellants and one Gopal assembled
in front of the respondent’s house, along with village munsif and a surveyor. They
informed the respondent’s father that Gopal had purchased the said property from
the first appellant, and they wanted to measure the property. The respondent’s mother(
the deceased) tried to prevent them from entering to carry out a survey. The allegation
is that at that time, the first appellant exhorted the second appellant to kill 
the deceased. Thereupon, the second appellant picked up a stick lying at the site
and assaulted her on the chest. After that, the third and first appellant kicked
the deceased on her chest and stomach. The respondent’s mother was declared dead
in the hospital where she was taken.

##### Based on negative report the respondent’s father instead of filing protest petition has filed a complaint under section 200 cr.p.c

3. After completing the investigation, the investigating officer submitted a final
report recording that the death of the deceased was due to natural cause and due
to prior enmity, the respondent falsely implicated the appellants. The final report
was accordingly, filed on 22nd December 2004. Instead of filing a protest petition,
the respondent’s father filed a complaint under Section 200 of CrPC containing the
same averments made in his complaint based on which the FIR was registered. The 
Judicial Magistrate recorded evidence of witnesses, including a doctor who performed
a post-mortem. The doctor deposed that the death was natural.

4. As stated earlier, the appellants invoked Section 227 of CrPC for discharge, 
which was allowed by order dated 9th January, 2009.

##### Order dismissed the complaint under section 203 crpc by the magistrate and the same was set aside by the High court

7. Perusal of the impugned judgment shows that the High Court was of the view that
the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge had conducted a mini-trial. We
may note here that initially, the learned Judicial Magistrate had dismissed the 
complaint by exercising the power under Section 203 of CrPC on the ground that the
death was not proved to be homicidal. The High Court, in a petition filed by the
respondent’s father, interfered and, by judgment and order dated 18th September 
2007, set aside the order of the learned Magistrate. We find from a copy of the 
said judgment and order that the same was passed without a notice being issued to
the present appellants.

##### Accused properly discharged by the sessions judge under section 227 crpc

8. After having perused the order of the learned Additional District and Sessions
Judge dated 9th January 2009, we find that a mini-trial was not conducted. The Court
has considered the case within four corners of its limited jurisdiction under Section
227 of the CrPC.

##### The expert witness examined by the respondent stated (proceeding before magistrate on complaint) that the death was natural

10. Thus, the expert witness examined by the respondent, who admittedly carried 
out a post-mortem on the body of the deceased, has categorically stated that the
death of the deceased was natural. This is coupled with the fact that there were
no external injuries found on the body of the deceased.

##### According to the complainant there was an enmity between him and the accused

11. The version of the respondent’s father who was examined as PW-1 is that one 
of the appellants hit the deceased with a stick on her chest, and the other appellant
repeatedly kicked her on her chest. In the post-mortem, no injury was found on the
chest or any other part of the body of the deceased. Therefore, taking the evidence
of the respondent’s father and other witnesses as it is, there was no material to
proceed against the appellants in the private complaint filed by the respondent’s
father. We may also note here that even according to the case of the respondent’s
father, there was a dispute between him and the appellants over the property, and
the incident occurred when, as per the order of the Civil Court, an attempt was 
made to survey the property through a government surveyor.

##### conclusion

12. The High Court, even after referring to the post-mortem certificate, has completely
ignored the doctor’s evidence. Hence, the impugned judgment and order cannot be 
sustained, and the same is set aside. The Judgment and order dated 9th January 2009
in Crl. Misc. Petition No.51 of 2008 in Sessions Case no. 270 of 2008 is restored.

##### Parties

Ramalingam & Ors vs. N. Viswanathan – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 212 OF 2024 – January 
18, 2024 – 2024 INSC 45

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/34839/34839_2019_6_1501_49494_Judgement_18-Jan-2024.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2019/34839/34839_2019_6_1501_49494_Judgement_18-Jan-2024.pdf)**

[**Ramalingam vs. N.Viswanathan – 34839_2019_6_1501_49494_Judgement_18-Jan-2024**](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Ramalingam-vs.-N.Viswanathan-34839_2019_6_1501_49494_Judgement_18-Jan-2024.pdf)

##### Further study

**[P.C act – special judge – discharge shall be u/s 227 cr.p.c and not u/s 239 cr.p.c](https://demonew.section1.in/p-c-act-special-judge-discharge-shall-be-u-s-227-cr-p-c-and-not-u-s-239-cr-p-c/)**

**[High court shall not discharged the accused in a murder case without referred the chargesheet in its entirety](https://demonew.section1.in/4076-2/)**

**[Discharge application cannot be filed after the trial starts](https://demonew.section1.in/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/)**

**[Protest petition – Even in a case where the final report of the police under section 173 is accepted and the accused persons are discharged, the magistrate has the power to take cognizance of the offence on a complaint or a protest petition on the same or similar allegations](https://demonew.section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)**

**[Whether Criminal case against police officer can be filed without sanction obtained u/s 197 Cr.P.C?](https://demonew.section1.in/whether-criminal-case-against-police-officer-can-be-filed-without-sanction-obtained-u-s-197-cr-p-c/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
