# Discharge Petition: Section 227 Cr.P.C: Courts must refrain from considering the grounds referring the case of the accused in discharge petition

- Link: https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/
- Published: 2024-07-21T17:20:28+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal against the order of the High Court confirming dismissal order of discharge petition](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#appeal-against-the-order-of-the-high-court-confirming-dismissal-order-of-discharge-petition)
 * [Under section 227 Cr.P.C read with section 209 Cr.P.C record of the case and documents means materials produced by the prosecution and not by the accused](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#under-section-227-crpc-read-with-section-209-crpc-record-of-the-case-and-documents-means-materials-produced-by-the-prosecution-and-not-by-the-accused)
 * [Hon’ble Supreme Court refrain itself from looking on to the grounds referring the case of the accused](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#honble-supreme-court-refrain-itself-from-looking-on-to-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused)
 * [Sales collections were snatched at gun point and FIR registered on robber](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#sales-collections-were-snatched-at-gun-point-and-fir-registered-on-robber)
 * [First closure was stopped, investigation continued and on second charge sheet cognizance taken and discharge petition filed and got dismissed](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#first-closure-was-stopped-investigation-continued-and-on-second-charge-sheet-cognizance-taken-and-discharge-petition-filed-and-got-dismissed)
 * [Scope of discharge: To consider only the prosecution material](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#scope-of-discharge-to-consider-only-the-prosecution-material)
 * [At the time of considering framing of charge court shall not hold a mini trial](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#at-the-time-of-considering-framing-of-charge-court-shall-not-hold-a-mini-trial)
 * [If no evidence framing charge would be against Article 21](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#if-no-evidence-framing-charge-would-be-against-article-21)
 * [Court must though not in detail but give reason for rejecting the application](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#court-must-though-not-in-detail-but-give-reason-for-rejecting-the-application)
 * [Criminal conspiracy is Explained](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#criminal-conspiracy-is-explained)
 * [Criminal conspiracy is an agreement and all conspirators are liable for the acts of each other of the crime committed](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#criminal-conspiracy-is-an-agreement-and-all-conspirators-are-liable-for-the-acts-of-each-other-of-the-crime-committed)
 * [A few bits on which prosecution may rely are not sufficient to prove the conspiracy](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#a-few-bits-on-which-prosecution-may-rely-are-not-sufficient-to-prove-the-conspiracy)
 * [Agreement to conspiracy may be expressed or implied](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#agreement-to-conspiracy-may-be-expressed-or-implied)
 * [Complainant himself added as an accused is not probable](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#complainant-himself-added-as-an-accused-is-not-probable)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/discharge-petition-section-227-cr-p-c-courts-must-refrain-from-considering-the-grounds-referring-the-case-of-the-accused-in-discharge-petition/#party)

##### **Appeal against the order of the High Court confirming dismissal order of discharge petition**

1. The dismissal of application under Section 482, No.21739 of 2007, essentially,
filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘the
Cr.PC’) against **[dismissal of an application](http://localhost:8080/section1/dismissal-of-complaint-and-s-311-cr-p-c-applications-by-magistrate-for-non-appearance-not-proper/)**
for discharge by the appellant herein under Section 227 Cr.PC, as per order dated
21.04.2023 by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad is under challenge in this
appeal. The appellant moved the said application for discharge in Crime No.371/1993,
the charge in essence there is about custodial death of one Ram Kishore who happened
to be cashier/accountant of the appellant, which in fact was registered based on
the complaint of the appellant.

##### **Under section 227 Cr.P.C read with section 209 Cr.P.C record of the case and documents means materials produced by the prosecution and not by the accused**

3. Before narrating the facts, we should bear in mind that exercise of power under
Section 227, Cr.PC, is legally permissible only by considering ‘the record of the
case and the documents submitted therewith’. Therefore, necessarily, the question
is what is the meaning of the expression ‘the record of the case and documents submitted
therewith’? According to us, it refers only to the materials produced by the prosecution
and not by the accused. A three-Judge Bench of this Court considered this question
in **State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi [(2005) 1 SCC 568]**. It was held that
the said expression as postulated in Section 227, Cr.PC, relate to the case and 
the documents referred to under Section 209, Cr.PC. Section 209, Cr.PC, reads thus:-

> “209. Commitment of case to Court of Session when offence is triable exclusively
> by it”.

In view of Section 209, Cr.PC, as extracted above, to know what exactly are the 
documents falling within the said expression Sections 207 and 208, Cr.PC, are also
to be looked into.

##### Hon’ble Supreme Court refrain itself from looking on to the grounds referring the case of the accused

4. We referred to the provisions under Section 227 and the decision in Debendra 
Nath Padhi’s case (supra) only to conclude that even for the purpose of referring
to the facts leading to the case, as also for consideration of the contentions for
the purpose of Section 227, Cr.PC, we cannot refer to the grounds carrying or referring
to the case of the appellant-accused, in view of the aforesaid provisions of law
and position of law, requiring to confine such consideration only with reference
to the materials produced by the prosecution.

##### **Sales collections were snatched at gun point and FIR registered on robber**

6. The appellant, who is the owner of Goodwill Enterprises dealing with wood, registered
Case Crime No.351 of 1993 under Section 392 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for 
short ‘the IPC’) at Police Station Modi Nagar, District Ghaziabad, alleging that
his cashier/accountant-Ram Kishore and one Pappu Yadav went for collecting his business
proceeds from shops at Meerut and Modi Nagar in the morning of 15.07.1993. On their
way back from Meerut, after collecting such business proceeds, they stopped the 
car in front of Ginni Devi School in Modi Nagar and Ram Kishore went to Poonam Sales
for collection and Pappu Yadav remain seated in the car with the bag containing 
the collection and some documents. Soon, two persons came and snatched the said 
bag from Pappu Yadav after putting him at gun point and escaped on a motorcycle.
The appellant was given such **[information](http://localhost:8080/section1/questioning-whence-right-or-wrong/)**
over phone. Later, on that day itself the appellant got **[registered the abovementioned FIR about robbery and asked for investigation](http://localhost:8080/section1/powers-of-magistrate-u-s-1563-direction/)**
and appropriate legal action, in the incident.

##### **First closure was stopped, investigation continued and on second charge sheet cognizance taken and discharge petition filed and got dismissed**

7. The materials on record and the counter **[affidavit](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-cannot-convert-complaint-into-a-1563-cr-p-c-petition-without-following-procedures/)**
filed in this appeal on behalf of the respondent based on such materials would reveal
that the initial investigation in Case Crime No.351/1993 (hereinafter referred to
as ‘the robbery case’) found it to be false. However, the Supervising Officer concerned
viz., the Commanding Officer, Modi Nagar stopped the closure report and entrusted
the case for investigation to another officer. Thereafter, on 17.07.1993, the appellant
called Ram Kishore from his house through one of his employees viz., Jagannath and
took him to the Modi Nagar Police Station for inquiry. It is only appropriate to
extract from the chargesheet dated 21.02.2000 filed by CBCID, Lucknow, U.P., in 
FIR No. 371/1993 of Police Station, Modi Nagar, registered in connection with the
custodial death of Ram Kishore unfolding further the case of the prosecution instead
of narrating it. It in so far as relevant reads thus:-

“………………”

8. In the chargesheet dated 21.02.2000 filed in Crime No.371/1993, the aforesaid
Rameshwar Dayal Pathak, the then Inspector of Police and Jawahar Lal, the then Sub-
Inspector of Police and the appellant were made accused Nos. 1 to 3 respectively,
for commission of offences under Sections 302, 343, 217, 218, 330, 120B and 34, 
IPC. It is seeking discharge under Section 227, Cr.PC, in the aforesaid case viz.,
Crime No.371/1993 that appellant herein approached the court of Additional Sessions
Judge/Special Judge, Ghaziabad by filing application dated 04.04.2007 contending
absolute absence any ground to proceed against him. The said application for discharge
under Section 227, Cr.PC, was rejected by the court of Additional Sessions Judge/
Special Judge (CBI), as per order dated 19.04.2007. The impugned order dated 21.04.2023
was passed by the High **[Court in the petition filed under Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-451-cr-p-c-petition-for-disposal-return-of-property-cannot-be-filed-directly-by-invoking-article-226-without-invoking-section-451-cr-p-c-before-the-concerned-court/)**
482, Cr.PC, against the said order dated 19.04.2007.

11. For appreciating the aforesaid contentions, we are of the considered view that
it is only appropriate to refer to the position of law with respect to the scope
of exercise of power under Section 227, Cr.PC, as also the ingredients to attract
Section 120B, IPC. Section 227, Cr.PC, reads thus:

> “227. Discharge.- If, upon consideration of the record of the case and the documents
> submitted therewith, and after hearing the submissions of the accused and the 
> prosecution in this behalf, the Judge considers that there is not sufficient ground
> for proceeding against the accused, he shall discharge the accused and record 
> his reasons for so doing.”

##### **Scope of discharge: To consider only the prosecution material**

12. We have already considered the meaning of the expression “the record of the 
case and the documents submitted therewith” relying on the decision in Debendra 
Nath Padhi’s case (supra) only to re-assure as to what are the materials falling
under the said expression and thus, available for consideration of an **[application filed for discharge](http://localhost:8080/section1/stages-when-accused-can-raise-the-issue-of-taking-cognizance-without-sanction-discharge-application-cannot-be-filed-after-the-trial-starts/)**
under Section 227, Cr.PC. **In the light of the same, there cannot be any doubt 
with respect to the position that at the stage of consideration of such an application
for discharge, defence case or material, if produced at all by the accused, cannot
be looked at all**. Once “the record of the case and the documents submitted therewith”
are before the Court they alone can be looked into for considering the application
for discharge and thereafter if it considers that there is no sufficient ground 
for proceeding against the accused concerned then he shall be discharged after recording
reasons therefor. In that regard, it is only appropriate to consider the authorities
dealing with the question as to what exactly is the scope of consideration and what
should be the manner of consideration while exercising such power.

##### **At the time of considering framing of charge court shall not hold a mini trial**

13. The decision in **Yogesh alias Sachin Jagadish Joshi v. State of Maharashtra[
AIR 2008 SC 2991]** this Court held that the words “not sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused” appearing in Section 227, Cr.PC, postulate exercise of judicial
mind on the part of the Judge to the facts of the case revealed from the materials
brought on record by the prosecution in order to determine whether a case for trial
has been made out. In the decision in **State of Tamil Nadu v. N Suresh Rajan & 
Ors [(2014) 11 SCC 709]** this Court held that at a stage of consideration of an
application for discharge, the Court has to proceed with an assumption that the 
materials brought on record by the prosecution are true, and evaluate the materials
to find out whether the facts taken at their face value disclose the existence of
the ingredients constituting the offence. At this stage, only the probative value
of the materials has to be gone into and the court is not expected to go deep into
the matter to hold a mini-trial.

14. In the decision in **BK Sharma v. State of UP [1987 SCC OnLine ALL 314],** the
High Court of judicature at Allahabad held that the standard of test and judgment
which is finally applied before recording a finding of conviction against an accused
is not to be applied at the stage of framing the charge. It is just a very strong
suspicion, based on the material on record, and would be sufficient to frame a charge.

15. We are in agreement with the said view taken by the High Court. At the same 
time, we would add that the strong suspicion in order to be sufficient to frame 
a charge should be based on the material brought on record by the prosecution and
should not be based on supposition, suspicions and conjectures. In other words, 
in order to be a basis to frame charge the strong suspicion should be the one emerging
from the materials on record brought by the prosecution.

16. In the decision in **Stree Atyachar Virodhi Parishad v. Dilip Nathumal Chordia&
Anr [(1989) 1 SCC 715]**, this Court held that the word ‘ground’ in Section 227,
Cr.PC, did not mean a ground for conviction, but a ground for putting the accused
on trial.

19. In the light of the decisions referred supra, it is thus obvious that it will
be within the jurisdiction of the Court concerned to sift and weigh the evidence
for the limited purpose of finding out whether or not a prima facie case against
the accused concerned has been made out. We are of the considered view that a caution
has to be sounded for the **[reason that the chances of going beyond](http://localhost:8080/section1/prosecution-not-proved-the-murder-case-beyond-reasonable-doubt/)**
the permissible jurisdiction under Section 227, Cr.PC, and entering into the scope
of power under Section 232, Cr.PC, cannot be ruled out as such instances are aplenty.
In this context, it is relevant to refer to a decision of this Court in Om Parkash
Sharma v. CBI8. Taking note of the language of Section 227, Cr.PC, is in negative
terminology and that the language in Section 232, Cr.PC, is in the positive terminology
and considering this distinction between the two, this Court held that it would 
not be open to the Court while considering an application under Section 227, Cr.
PC, to weigh the pros and cons of the evidence alleged improbability and then proceed
to discharge the accused holding that the statements existing in the case therein
are unreliable. It is held that doing so would be practically acting under Section
232, Cr.PC, even though the said stage has not reached. In short, though it is permissible
to sift and weigh the materials for the limited purpose of finding out whether or
not a prima facie case is made out against the accused, on **[appreciation](http://localhost:8080/section1/dying-declaration-witness-who-recorded-the-dying-declaration-must-state-in-his-chief-examination-that-the-doctor-examined-the-deceased-before-giving-fitness-certificate/)**
of the admissibility and the evidentiary value such materials brought on record 
by the prosecution is impermissible as it would amount to denial of opportunity 
to the prosecution to prove them appropriately at the appropriate stage besides 
amounting to exercise of the power coupled with obligation under Section 232, Cr.
PC, available only after taking the evidence for the prosecution and examining the
accused.

##### **If no evidence framing charge would be against Article 21**

20. Even after referring to the aforesaid decisions, we think it absolutely appropriate
to refer to a decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in **Kaushalya Devi v. State
of MP [2003 SCC OnLine MP 672]**. It was held in the said case that if there is 
no legal evidence, then framing of charge would be groundless and compelling the
accused to face the trial is contrary to the procedure offending Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. While agreeing with the view, we make it clear that the expression‘
legal evidence’ has to be construed only as evidence disclosing prima facie case,‘
the record of the case and the documents submitted therewith’.

21. The stage of Section 227, Cr.PC, is equally crucial and determinative to both
the prosecution and the accused, we will dilate the issue further. In this context,
certain other aspects also require consideration. It cannot be said that Section
227, Cr.PC, is couched in negative terminology without a purpose. Charge sheet is
a misnomer for the **[final report filed under Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)**
173 (2), Cr.PC, which is not a negative report and one that carries an accusation
against the accused concerned of having committed the offence (s) mentioned therein.

##### **Court must though not in detail but give reason for rejecting the application**

22. In cases, where it appears that the said offence(s) is one triable exclusively
by the Court of Session, the **[Magistrate shall have to commit the case to the Court](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)**
of Session concerned following the prescribed procedures under Cr.PC. In such cases,
though it carries an accusation as aforementioned still legislature thought it appropriate
to provide an inviolable right as a precious safeguard for the accused, a pre-battle
protection under Section 227, Cr.PC. Though, this provision is couched in negative
it obligated the court concerned to unfailingly consider the record of the case 
and document submitted therewith and also to hear the submissions of the accused
and the prosecution in that behalf to arrive at a conclusion as to whether or not
sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused is available thereunder. Certainly,
if the answer of such consideration is in the negative, the court is bound to discharge
the accused and to record reasons therefor. The corollary is that the question of
framing the charge would arise only in a case where the court upon such exercise
satisfies itself about the prima facie case revealing from “the record of the case
and the documents submitted therewith” against the accused concerned. In short, 
it can be said in that view of the matter that the intention embedded is to ensure
that an accused will be made to stand the ordeal of trial only if ‘the record of
the case and the documents submitted therewith’ discloses ground for proceeding 
against him. When that be so, in a case where an application is filed for discharge
under Section 227, Cr.PC, it is an irrecusable duty and obligation of the Court 
to apply its mind and answer to it regarding the existence of or otherwise, of ground
for proceeding against the accused, by confining such consideration based only on
the record of the case and the documents submitted therewith and after hearing the
submissions of the accused and the prosecution in that behalf. To wit, such conclusion
on existence or otherwise of ground to proceed against the accused concerned should
not be and could not be based on mere suppositions or suspicions or conjectures,
especially not founded upon material available before the Court. We are not oblivious
of the fact that normally, the Court is to record his reasons only for discharging
an accused at the stage of Section 227, Cr.PC. However, when an application for 
discharge is filed under Section 227, Cr.PC, the Court concerned is bound to disclose
the reason(s), though, not in detail, for finding sufficient ground for rejecting
the application or in other words, for finding prima facie case, as it will enable
the superior Court to examine the challenge against the order of rejection.

23. By applying the laws enunciated and the principles laid, we will proceed to 
consider the case on hand. In the **[final report filed](http://localhost:8080/section1/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)**
in FIR No.371 of 1993 viz., in the custodial death case, the afore-extracted portion
from it revealed that the essence of the accusation is commission of custodial death
owing to the torture to which Ram Kishore was subjected to, from 17.07.1993 to 23.07.1993.
It reveals that going by the same, he was illegally kept in the Police Station by
accused Nos.1 and 2. A scanning of the charge as also the other materials including
the statements of the **[witnesses recorded](http://localhost:8080/section1/dying-declaration-witness-who-recorded-the-dying-declaration-must-state-in-his-chief-examination-that-the-doctor-examined-the-deceased-before-giving-fitness-certificate/)**
under Section 161, Cr.PC, would reveal that there is absolute absence of any accusation
or even an insinuation that the appellant had played any role in torturing Ram Kishore.
Therefore, the question is how he is arraigned as third accused in the aforesaid
crime. In that regard, it is apposite to refer again to the final report dated 21.02.2000
filed in Crime No.371/1993. The relevant portion in the [final report](http://localhost:8080/section1/closure-report-and-further-investigation-entire-settled-propositions-explained/)
in this regard, reads thus: –

> “…In this manner from this investigation, it was found that deceased Ram Kishore
> was kept in the Police Station from dated 17.07.1993 to 23.07.1993 in the Police
> Station under the criminal Conspiracy of the accused persons mentioned in the 
> column no.3 during which he was tortured and interrogated regarding the incident
> of loot and knowingly with the intention of saving their skins no entry of the
> same was made in the records of the Police Station nor was the same mentioned 
> by the complainant in its report. Charge under Section 341/217/218/201/330/34 /
> 120B Indian Penal Code, 1860 was found to have been made out against all the accused
> persons. …”.

24. From the above extracted portion, it is evident that the implication of the 
appellant in the crime is with the aid of Section 120B and Section 34, IPC. Apart
from using the expression “criminal conspiracy” there is absolute absence of anything
whatsoever in the said final report as also in the statement of any of the witnesses,
suggesting that the appellant herein conspired with the other accused or what exactly
is the criminal conspiracy.

##### **Criminal conspiracy is Explained**

25. This Court in the decision in **R. Venkatakrishnan v. CBI [(2009) 11 SCC 737]**,
held that criminal conspiracy, in terms of Section 120B, IPC, is an independent 
offence and its ingredients are:

> (i) an agreement between two or more persons;
> (ii) the agreement must relate to doing or causing to be done either –
> (a) an illegal act;
> (b) an act which is not illegal in itself but is also done by illegal means.

##### **Criminal conspiracy is an agreement and all conspirators are liable for the acts of each other of the crime committed**

26. An important facet of law of conspiracy is that apart from it being a distinct
offence, all conspirators are liable for the acts of each other of the crime or 
crimes which have been committed as a result of conspiracy. A careful scanning of
the provisions under Sections 120A and 120B, IPC, would reveal that the sine qua
non for an offence of criminal conspiracy is an agreement to commit an offence. 
It consists of agreement between two or more persons to commit the criminal offence,
irrespective of the further consideration whether or not the offence is actually
committed as the very fact of conspiracy constitutes the offence (See the decision
in **K.S. Narayanan & Ors. v. G Gopinathan – 1982 Cri.L.J 1611 (Madras))**.

##### **A few bits on which prosecution may rely are not sufficient to prove the conspiracy**

27. There can be no doubt that conspiracy is hatched in privacy and not in secrecy,
and such it would rarely be possible to establish conspiracy by direct evidence.
A few bits here and a few bits there, on which the prosecution may rely, are not
sufficient to connect an accused with the commission of the crime of criminal conspiracy.
To constitute even an accusation of criminal conspiracy, first and foremost, there
must at least be an accusation of meeting of minds of two or more persons for doing
an illegal act or an act, which is not illegal in itself, by illegal means.

##### **Agreement to conspiracy may be expressed or implied**

28. In **Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India & Ors [(1993) 3 SCC 609]**, this Court 
characterized the offence of criminal conspiracy as an agreement between two or 
more persons to do an illegal act or a legal through illegal means. Furthermore,
it was held that commission of the offence would be complete as soon as, there is
consensus ad idem and it would be immaterial whether or not the offence is actually
committed. It is also held therein that necessarily there must be agreement between
the conspirators on the design or object of the conspiracy. As held in R. Venkatakrishnan
case (supra), the quintessential ingredient to attract the offence of criminal conspiracy
is agreement between two or more persons. Therefore, the question is whether it 
spelt in the final report dated 21.02.2000 or in any of the records of the case 
and documents submitted therewith, so as to find a prima facie case of commission
of criminal conspiracy against the appellant. True that an agreement referred to
in Section 120A, IPC may be expressed or implied or in part express and in part 
implied. However, no record of the case or documents submitted therewith carry such
an allegation/accusation against the appellant.

29. What is the common plan or the **[common intention](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-34-ipc-to-attract-common-intention-co-accused-need-not-have-engaged-in-discussion-or-agreement-for-consipiracy/)**?
This aspect is also conspicuously absent in the materials produced by the prosecution.
In regard to all such aspects, referred above, none of the witnesses has spoken 
while **[giving statements under Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-27-iea-mere-exhibiting-the-disclosure-statement-to-the-io-is-not-sufficient-but-the-io-must-give-description-about-the-conversation-while-recording-disclosure-statements-in-evidence/)**
161, Cr.PC. In this context it is also to be noted that according to the Trial Court,
a very strong suspicion lingers on account of twin circumstances. In the order dated
19.04.2007, the Trial Court in this regard observed and held thus: –  

“………………….”

##### **Complainant himself added as an accused is not probable**

32. We are at a loss to understand, how in the absence of ground for a prima facie
case revealed from the materials produced by the prosecution a person who lost his
money and lodged a complaint based on the information furnished by his employee 
can be implicated in an offence, that too a grave allegation of commission of an
offence of custodial death amounting to murder, merely because he caused the presence
of the person concerned before the Police Station unless the ingredients to attract
criminal conspiracy to commit any specific offence in relation to Ram Kishore is
available. If the case of the prosecution and the materials produced along with 
the charge are taken as true, they would only suggest that Ram Kishore was under
the control of the police in the Police Station. In fact, that exactly is the prosecution
case revealed from the final report dated 21.02.2000 filed in Crime No.371/1993.

35. For the reasons given as above, this appeal is allowed. Consequently, the order
and judgment dated 21.04.2023 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
in application No.21739 of 2007 filed under Section 482, Cr.PC, and the order dated
19.04.2007 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge (CBI) are set aside.
As a necessary sequel, the application filed by the appellant under Section 227,
Cr.PC, dated 04.04.2007 for discharge in Crime No.351/1993 filed in Sessions Trial
No.1532/2005 before Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge (CBI), Prevention of
Corruption Act U.P., East Ghaziabad is allowed and the appellant stands discharged.

##### **Party**

Ram Prakash Chadha …Appellant Versus The State of Uttar Pradesh …Respondent – Criminal
Appeal No. 2395 of 2023 (@ SLP (Crl.) No. 6687 of 2023 – 2024 INSC 522 – July 15,
2024

**[https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=203962023&type=j&order_date=2024-07-15&from=latest_judgements_order](https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=203962023&type=j&order_date=2024-07-15&from=latest_judgements_order)**

[**Ram prakash chadha vs. The State of U.P 203962023_2024-07-15**](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Ram-prakash-chadha-vs.-The-State-of-U.P-203962023_2024-07-15.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
