# Discharge: When specific remedy is available under section 397 Cr.P.C the CBI ought not to have filed petition under section 482 Cr.P.C

- Link: https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/
- Published: 2025-02-15T08:41:17+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against the order of setting aside discharge order of Trial court on the petition u/s.–482 crpc preferred by CBI](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#appeal-against-the-order-of-setting-aside-discharge-order-of-trial-court-on-the-petition-us482-crpc-preferred-by-cbi)
    - [CBI filed a charge sheet against the appellants under sections 420 and 120B IPC](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#cbi-filed-a-charge-sheet-against-the-appellants-under-sections-420-and-120b-ipc)
    - [Hon’ble High court quashed the proceedings but Apex court set aside the quash](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#honble-high-court-quashed-the-proceedings-but-apex-court-set-aside-the-quash)
    - [Appellants preferred discharge and the Trial court discharged them after one and half years CBI preferred application u/s 482 Cr.P.C and the High Court allowed the same](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#appellants-preferred-discharge-and-the-trial-court-discharged-them-after-one-and-half-years-cbi-preferred-application-us-482-crpc-and-the-high-court-allowed-the-same)
    - [Section 420 IPC on facts](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#section-420-ipc-on-facts)
    - [High Court denied the objection that the CBI ought to have preferred revision](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#high-court-denied-the-objection-that-the-cbi-ought-to-have-preferred-revision)
    - [If the party does not speak of being dishonestly induced to do or not do something it was not for others to insinuate the same](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#if-the-party-does-not-speak-of-being-dishonestly-induced-to-do-or-not-do-something-it-was-not-for-others-to-insinuate-the-same)
    - [Maintainability and Limitation of CBI’s petition under section 482 Cr.P.C instead of under section 397 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#maintainability-and-limitation-of-cbis-petition-under-section-482-crpc-instead-of-under-section-397-crpc)
    - [CBI cannot ignore the statutory remedy and file petition under section 482 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#cbi-cannot-ignore-the-statutory-remedy-and-file-petition-under-section-482-crpc)
    - [High Court can treat revision petition as filed under section 482 Cr.P.C but not vice versa](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#high-court-can-treat-revision-petition-as-filed-under-section-482-crpc-but-not-vice-versa)
 * [Appellant stands discharged](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#appellant-stands-discharged)
    - [List of Judgments Cited](https://section1.in/discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-cr-p-c-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-cr-p-c/#list-of-judgments-cited)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against the order of setting aside discharge order of Trial court on the petition u/s.–482 crpc preferred by CBI**

2. Exercising power under Section 239 Cr.P.C, the learned Special Judicial Magistrate,
CBI Court, Ghaziabad, discharged the appellants herein of a charge under Sections
420 and 120B IPC, vide order dated 31.08.2019 in Case No. 456 of 2012 arising out
of RC-219 2011 (E) 0016 registered on the file of Police Station CBI, EO-1, New 
Delhi. Aggrieved thereby, the Central Bureau of Investigation (for short, ‘CBI’)
approached the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, under Section 482 Cr.P.C, 
by way of Application U/S 482 No. 11426 of 2021. By order dated 20.01.2023 passed
therein, the High Court set aside the discharge order and directed the learned Magistrate
to proceed with the case against the appellants. Assailing the said order, they 
are before this Court.

##### **CBI filed a charge sheet against the appellants under sections 420 and 120B IPC**

6. However, on 30.11.2011, Case Crime No. 219 2011 (E) 0016 was registered on the
file of PS CBI, EO-1, New Delhi, under Sections 420 and 120B IPC along with Section
13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. This
FIR was registered against the appellants and unnamed officials of the AICTE, alleging
that the appellants had obtained approval by deceitful means from the AICTE, in 
violation of Section 4.2(iii) of the AICTE Approval Process 2006. As per this provision,
the land approved for starting an educational institution ought not to be encumbered.
After completion of the investigation, Charge Sheet No. 11 of 2012 was filed by 
the CBI for offences under Sections 420 and 120B IPC, naming only the appellants
as the accused. No official of the AICTE was charged with criminality in granting
approval to the Society’s institutions.

##### **Hon’ble High court quashed the proceedings but Apex court set aside the quash**

7. Aggrieved by their arraignment, the appellants approached the High Court at Allahabad
under Section 482 Cr.P.C, vide Application U/S 482 No. 37398 of 2012, seeking quashing
of the criminal proceedings against them. By order dated 14.02.2013, the High Court
accepted their plea and quashed the said proceedings. However, upon the CBI approaching
this Court in Criminal Appeal No. 239 of 2015, by order dated 05.02.2018 passed 
therein, this Court set aside the order dated 14.02.2013 but made it clear that 
the Trial Court would be at liberty to go into the merits of the issue raised at
the stage of framing of charges. Thereafter, on 02.07.2018, the Trial Court granted
bail to the appellants.

##### **Appellants preferred discharge and the Trial court discharged them after one and half years CBI preferred application u/s 482 Cr.P.C and the High Court allowed the same**

8. On 25.09.2018, the appellants moved an application for discharge before the learned
Special Judicial Magistrate, CBI Court, Ghaziabad, but the learned Magistrate rejected
their plea by order dated 15.02.2019 and directed the matter to be listed for framing
of charges. The appellants, thereupon, preferred Criminal Revision No. 101 of 2019
before the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Ghaziabad, under Section 397 Cr.P.
C. The revision was allowed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, vide order
dated 29.05.2019, whereby the order passed by the learned Magistrate was set aside
and the matter was remanded for hearing afresh, in the light of the observations
made in the revisional order. In consequence, the learned Magistrate reheard the
case and passed order dated 31.08.2019, discharging the appellants from the alleged
offence under Sections 420 and 120B IPC. Nearly one and a half years after the passing
of this discharge order, i.e., on 21.02.2021, the CBI filed a petition under Section
482 Cr.P.C assailing it before the High Court at Allahabad. The petition was taken
on file as Application U/S 482 No. 11426 of 2021 and the High Court allowed the 
same by way of the impugned order, leading to the present appeal.

##### **Section 420 IPC on facts**

10. The sine qua non to make out an offence under Section 420 IPC, insofar as the
present case is concerned, is an act on the part of the appellants to ‘cheat and
thereby dishonestly induce the person so deceived, viz., the AICTE, to deliver any
property’. Therefore, the appellants, while applying for and on behalf of the Society,
should have either suppressed material information or projected incorrect information
so as to induce the AICTE, by such dishonest means, to grant approval for its educational
institutions. Further, as no official of the AICTE has been implicated in the offence,
as per the charge sheet, the alleged ‘criminal conspiracy’ under Section 120B IPC
would also be attributable to the appellants only.

15. At this stage we may note that, though the appellants were initially successful
in getting the proceedings quashed by the High Court, this Court reversed the said
order but left it open to the Trial Court to examine the issue raised, on merits,
at the time of framing of charges. It is pursuant to the liberty granted by this
Court that the learned Special Judicial Magistrate, CBI Court, chose to exercise
power under Section 239 Cr.P.C and discharged the appellants. The validity of that
exercise was called in question before the High Court, which ultimately held against
the appellants.

##### **High Court denied the objection that the CBI ought to have preferred revision**

16. Significantly, the High Court was not inclined to accept the preliminary objection
raised by the appellants to the effect that the CBI ought to have filed a revision
under Section 397 Cr.P.C against the discharge order and could not maintain a petition
under Section 482 Cr.P.C. In this regard, the High Court observed that it could 
always treat a petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C as a revision under Section
397 Cr.P.C and, therefore, the appellants’ objection had no substance. On merits,
the High Court opined that the appellants had deliberately withheld relevant information
knowing fully well that if the land was encumbered in any manner, approval for setting
up the educational institutions there would be declined. Holding so, the High Court
set aside the discharge order.

##### **If the party does not speak of being dishonestly induced to do or not do something it was not for others to insinuate the same**

18. That apart, it was not even the case of the AICTE that it was under any illusions,
whereby it was dishonestly induced to grant approval for establishment of the colleges
in question. The only party who can speak of being ‘dishonestly induced to do or
not do something’ is that party itself and when the AICTE made no such complaint,
it was not for others to insinuate that the AICTE was dishonestly induced to do 
something.

20. In **V.P. Shrivastava vs. Indian** Explosives Limited and others, this Court
observed that in order to constitute an offence of cheating, it must be shown that
the accused had a fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making the representation
or promise and such a culpable intention should be there at the time of entering
into the agreement. On facts, it was found that the party alleged to have been cheated
was fully conscious of the situation at the time it decided to enter into the contract
and there was no dishonest inducement.

21. In the case on hand, there was disclosure of the fact that the subject land 
was mortgaged to secure the bank loan but despite the same, the AICTE granted approval
for the ‘Business School of Delhi’ and it never complained that it was under any
misinformation in that regard. Thus, the essential requisite to make out an offence
of cheating is lacking. Mere carelessness on the part of the appellants in filling
up the second and third applications and a part of the first application also cannot
be taken to be motivated by deliberate deception, on the admitted factual position,
so as to invite criminal charges.

##### **Maintainability and Limitation of CBI’s petition under section 482 Cr.P.C instead of under section 397 Cr.P.C**

23. As regards the objection raised by the appellants as to the maintainability 
of the CBI’s petition filed before the High Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C., we 
may note that, as per Article 131 in the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963, the
limitation period for filing a criminal revision under Section 397 Cr.P.C, be it
before the High Court or the Sessions Court, is 90 days. However, there is no limitation
prescribed for invocation of the inherent powers of the High Court under Section
482 Cr.P.C. and it can be at any time. It is a matter of record that when the learned
Special Magistrate, CBI Court, dismissed the appellants’ discharge petition in the
first instance, they had filed a revision before the Sessions Court under Section
397 Cr.P.C. and the matter was remanded for hearing afresh. However, the CBI did
not choose to adopt this course when the appellants’ discharge petition was allowed
by the learned Special Magistrate in the second round. Long after the expiry of 
the limitation period of 90 days, the CBI filed a petition before the High Court
at Allahabad under Section 482 Cr.P.C. This was obviously to get over the hurdle
of the limitation for filing of a revision under Section 397 Cr.P.C. In this regard,
useful reference may be made to the decision of this Court in **Mohit alias Sonu
and another vs. State of U.P. and another**, wherein it was observed thus:

‘28. So far as the inherent power of the High Court as contained in Section 482 
CrPC is concerned, the law in this regard is set at rest by this Court in a catena
of decisions. However, we would like to reiterate that when an order, not interlocutory
in nature, can be assailed in the High Court in revisional jurisdiction, then there
should be a bar in invoking the inherent jurisdiction of the High Court. In other
words, inherent power of the Court can be exercised when there is no remedy provided
in the Code of Criminal Procedure for redressal of the grievance. It is well settled
that the inherent power of the Court can ordinarily be exercised when there is no
express provision in the Code under which order impugned can be challenged.

29. Courts possess inherent power in other statute also like the Code of Civil Procedure(
CPC), Section 151 whereof deals with such power. Section 151 CPC reads:

“151. Saving of inherent powers of court.—Nothing in this Code shall be deemed to
limit or otherwise affect the inherent power of the court to make such orders as
may be necessary for the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the
court.”

30. This Court in **Padam Sen v. State of U.P. [AIR 1961 SC 218 : (1961) 1 Cri LJ
322]** regarding inherent power of the Court under Section 151 CPC observed: (AIR
p. 219, para 8)

“8. … The inherent powers of the court are in addition to the powers specifically
conferred on the court by the Code. They are complementary to those powers and therefore
it must be held that the Court is free to exercise them for the purposes mentioned
in Section 151 of the Code when the exercise of those powers is not in any way in
conflict with what has been expressly provided in the Code or against the intentions
of the legislature. It is also well recognised that the inherent power is not to
be exercised in a manner which will be contrary to or different from the procedure
expressly provided in the Code.”

31. In a Constitution Bench decision rendered in **Manohar Lal Chopra v. Seth Hiralal[
AIR 1962 SC 527]**, this Court held that: (AIR p. 537, para 43)

“43. … The inherent jurisdiction of the court to make orders ex debito justitiae
is undoubtedly affirmed by Section 151 of the Code, but [inherent] jurisdiction 
cannot be exercised so as to nullify the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Where the Code of Civil Procedure deals expressly with a particular matter, the 
provision should normally be regarded as exhaustive.”

32. The intention of the legislature enacting the Code of Criminal Procedure and
the Code of Civil Procedure vis-à-vis the law laid down by this Court it can safely
be concluded that when there is a specific remedy provided by way of appeal or revision
the inherent power under Section 482 CrPC or Section 151 CPC cannot and should not
be resorted to.’

##### **CBI cannot ignore the statutory remedy and file petition under section 482 Cr.P.C**

24. In the light of the above edict, it was not open to the CBI to blithely ignore
the statutory remedy available to it under Section 397 Cr.P.C and thereafter resort
to filing of an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C.

##### **High Court can treat revision petition as filed under section 482 Cr.P.C but not vice versa**

25. We may also note that in the event a revision is lawfully instituted before 
the High Court but the same is thereafter found to be not maintainable on some other
ground, it would be open to the High Court to treat the same as a petition filed
under Section 482 Cr.P.C in order to do justice in that case. However, the reverse
analogy may not apply in all cases and it would not be open to the High Court to
blindly convert or treat a petition filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C as one filed 
under Section 397 Cr.P.C., without reference to other issues, including limitation.
When the specific remedy of revision was available to the CBI, it could not have
ignored the same and filed a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. We, therefore, find
in favour of the appellants even on this count.

#### **Appellant stands discharged**

26. On the above analysis we are of the opinion that the learned Magistrate was 
fully justified in exercising power under Section 239 Cr.P.C. and discharging the
appellants from criminal proceedings in relation to Case No. 456 of 2012. The High
Court adopted a rather technical approach and practically concluded that the appellants
were guilty of deliberately withholding relevant information so as to secure the
approvals by deceitful means. This finding of the High Court is not supported by
the admitted facts, which indicate disclosure of the mortgage at the outset when
the first application was made and, therefore, there is no possibility of inferring
that the appellants conspired in terms of Section 120A IPC to commit an illegal 
act of suppression so as to secure the approvals. Further, the AICTE itself never
claimed that it was dishonestly induced to grant such approvals and that essential
link is altogether missing, whereby any such criminal charge of cheating can be 
sustained against the appellants. The impugned order dated 20.01.2023 passed by 
the Allahabad High Court in Application U/S 482 Cr.P.C No. 11426 of 2021 is, therefore,
set aside and the order of discharge passed by the learned Special Judicial Magistrate,
CBI Court, Ghaziabad, in Case No. 456 of 2012 is restored. In consequence, the appellants
shall stand discharged of the alleged offence under Sections 420 and 120B IPC in
Case Crime No. 219 of 2011 (E) 0016.

##### **List of Judgments Cited**

 1. **Ram Jas v. State of U.P.** (1970) 2 SCC 740
 2. **V.P. Shrivastava vs. Indian Explosives Limited and others** (2010) 10 SCC 361
 3. **Mohit alias Sonu and another vs. State of U.P. and another** (2013) 7 SCC 789
 4. **Padam Sen v. State of U.P.** AIR 1961 SC 218 : (1961) 1 Cri LJ 322
 5. **Manohar Lal Chopra v. Seth Hiralal** AIR 1962 SC 527

**Party**

Vipin Sahni and another (Appellants) vs. Central Bureau of Investigation (Respondent)–
Case Number: Criminal Appeal No. 1980 of 2024 (@ Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No.
2772 of 2023) – 2024 INSC 284 – April 8, 2024

[Vipin Sahni and another vs. CBI – 7277_2023_5_1502_52046_Judgement_08-Apr-2024](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Vipin-Sahni-and-another-vs.-CBI-7277_2023_5_1502_52046_Judgement_08-Apr-2024.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Vipin-Sahni-and-another-vs.-CBI-7277_2023_5_1502_52046_Judgement_08-Apr-2024.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
