# Multiple Dying Declarations – No stereotypical approach can be adopted by courts

- Link: https://section1.in/dying-declaration-no-stereotypical-approach-can-be-adopted-by-courts/
- Published: 2023-02-14T06:33:01+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

13. Section 32 of the Evidence Act, which is material for the purposes of this appeal,
reads as under:

“32. Cases in which statement of relevant fact by person who is dead or cannot be
found, etc., is relevant. — Statements, written or verbal, of relevant facts made
by a person who is dead, or who cannot be found, or who has become incapable of 
giving evidence, or whose attendance cannot be procured without an amount of delay
or expense which under the circumstances of the case appears to the Court unreasonable,
are themselves relevant facts in the following cases: —

(1) When it relates to cause of death. –When the statement is made by a person as
to the cause of his death, or as to any of the circumstances of the transaction 
which resulted in his death, in cases in which the cause of that person’s death 
comes into question.

Such statements are relevant whether the person who made them was or was not, at
the time when they were made, under expectation of death, and whatever may be the
nature of the proceeding in which the cause of his death comes into question.

(2) Or is made in course of business.–When the statement was made by such person
in the ordinary course of business, and in particular when it consists of any entry
or memorandum made by him in books kept in the ordinary course of business, or in
the discharge of professional duty; or of an acknowledgment written or signed by
him of the receipt of money, goods, securities or property of any kind; or of a 
document used in commerce written or signed by him; or of the date of a letter or
other document usually dated, written or signed by him.

(3) Or against interest of maker.–When the statement is against the pecuniary or
proprietary interest of the person making it, or when, if true, it would expose 
him or would have exposed him to a criminal prosecution or to a suit for damages.

(4) Or gives opinion as to public right or custom, or matters of general interest.–
When the statement gives the opinion of any such person, as to the existence of 
any public right or custom or matter of public or general interest, of the existence
of which, if it existed, he would have been likely to be aware, and when such statement
was made before any controversy as to such right, custom or matter had arisen.

(5) Or relates to existence of relationship.–When the statement relates to the existence
of any relationship [by blood, marriage or adoption] between persons as to whose
relationship [by blood, marriage or adoption] the person making the statement had
special means of knowledge, and when the statement was made before the question 
in dispute was raised.

(6) Or is made in will or deed relating to family affairs. –When the statement relates
to the existence of any relationship [by blood, marriage or adoption] between persons
deceased, and is made in any will or deed relating to the affairs of the family 
to which any such deceased person belonged, or in any family pedigree, or upon any
tombstone, family portrait or other thing on which such statements are usually made,
and when such statement was made before the question in dispute was raised.

(7) Or in document relating to transaction mentioned in Section 13, clause (a).–
When the statement is contained in any deed, will or other document which relates
to any such transaction as is mentioned in Section 13, clause (a).

(8) Or is made by several persons and expresses feelings relevant to matter in question.–
When the statement was made by a number of persons, and expressed feelings or impressions
on their part relevant to the matter in question.”

14. This court has considered the above provision in numerous decisions and held
that the weight and utility of a dying declaration depend upon the surrounding circumstances
and the credibility which the court attaches to it, having regard to the evidence
led before it. Therefore, whether it is essential to have medical certification 
before the statement is recorded, who records it, etc. are all fact dependent, and
no stereotypical approach can be adopted by courts. In Laxman vs. State of Maharashtra[
2002 (SUPP1) SCR 697]a five-member Bench of this court explained the position, in
law, as follows:

“A dying declaration can be oral or in writing and in any adequate method of communication
whether by words or by signs or otherwise will suffice provided the indication is
positive and definite. In most cases, however, such statements are made orally before
death ensues and is reduced to writing by someone like a magistrate or a doctor 
or a police officer. When it is recorded, no oath is necessary nor is the presence
of a magistrate is absolutely necessary, although to assure authenticity it is usual
to call a magistrate, if available for recording the statement of a man about to
die. There is no requirement of law that a dying declaration must necessarily be
made to a magistrate and when such statement is recorded by a magistrate there is
no specified statutory form for such recording. Consequently, what evidential value
or weight has to be attached to such statement necessarily depends on the facts 
and circumstances of each particular case. What is essentially required is that 
the person who records a dying declaration must be satisfied that the deceased was
in a fit state of mind.

Where it is proved by the testimony of the magistrate that the declarant was fit
to make the statement even without examination by the doctor the declaration can
be acted upon provided the court ultimately holds the same to be voluntary and truthful.
A certification by the doctor is essentially a rule of caution and therefore the
voluntary and truthful nature of the declaration can be established”.

xxx

19. The principles enunciated by the decision of this court, especially Laxman and
the decisions dealing with multiple dying declarations, adduced in the course of
a criminal trial, especially where the deceased had been a victim of burns and had
succumbed to burn injuries and had prior to death made more than one dying declaration
have indicated that test of credibility having regard to the overall facts on record,
has to be adopted.

20. This court notices that the present is a case where the second dying declaration
has been rejected completely by the High Court. In these circumstances, the cumulative
weight of evidence relied upon by the High Court needs to be examined to ascertain
whether the appellant is guilty of the offence he stands convicted for, i.e., Section
498A IPC. Ex. P-26, the second dying declaration is the only piece of evidence which
names the appellant as one of the perpetrators of cruelty on the deceased along 
with the other accused. Both the courts below have noticed that in Ex. P-11, the
first dying declaration, the appellant has not been named; rather he along with 
his father took the deceased in a critically injured state to the hospital. Undoubtedly,
the focus of the first dying declaration is only upon the incident involving pouring
of kerosene and setting the deceased on fire. The second dying declaration, Ex. 
P-26 alone elaborates acts of cruelty. That is the only piece of incriminating evidence
against the accused. As far as the recovery of articles and the smell of kerosene
in the report considered by the court are concerned, they are circumstances relating
to the incident of setting the deceased on fire. They do not further the prosecution’s
case under Section 498A as against the appellant.

21. Having regard to the above circumstances, especially the fact that the only 
evidence against the appellant, i.e., Ex. P-26 was discredited by the High Court,
there is no other material to sustain his conviction. For these reasons, the impugned
judgment and the appellant’s conviction and sentence are hereby set aside. The appellant
shall be released forthwith unless required in some other case. The appeal is allowed
but without any order as to costs.

**PARTY:** RAJARAM vs. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH & ORS – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S). 2311
OF 2022 [@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO(S). 6762 of 2022] – December 16, 2022.

[**Rajaram vs. State of M.P 16271_2022_15_1501_40642_Judgement_16-Dec-2022**](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Rajaram-vs.-State-of-M.P-16271_2022_15_1501_40642_Judgement_16-Dec-2022.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
