# Expert witness – vs – Ocular witness

- Link: https://section1.in/expert-witness-vs-ocular-witness/
- Published: 2023-02-28T11:09:44+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Opinion of an expert, therefore, is a relevant fact. The court may, thus, took the
expert opinion into consideration. But appreciation of evidence is the court’s job.
It is, thus, for the court to arrive at an opinion as to which part of contradictory
expert opinion should be accepted or whether in a given situation ocular evidence
should be believed in preference to medical evidence or vice versa[1].

The expert is not a witness of fact. Opinionative evidence of the doctor is primarily
an evidence of opinion and not of fact. It is only a corroborative piece of evidence
as to the possibility that the injuries could have been caused in the manner alleged
by the prosecution. Unless the medical evidence rules out such possibility of injury
being caused in the manner alleged by the prosecution version, the testimony of 
the eye witness cannot be doubted on the ground of its inconsistency with medical
evidence[2].

Once there is a clear contradiction between the medical and the ocular evidence 
coupled with severe contradictions in the oral evidence, clear latches in investigation,
then the benefit of doubt has to go to the accused[3].

A medical witness who performs a post-mortem examination is a witness of fact though
he also gives an opinion on certain aspects of the case. The value of a medical 
witness is not merely a check upon the testimony of eyewitnesses; it is also independent
testimony because it may establish certain facts quite apart from the other oral
evidence. From the evidence on record, inferences are drawn as to the truth or otherwise
of the prosecution case in criminal matters and truth or otherwise of a claim in
civil matters. In this process, the medical evidence plays a very crucial role. 
If there is inconsistency or discrepancy between the medical evidence and the direct
evidence or between medical evidence of two doctors, one of whom examined the injured
person and the other conducted post mortem on the injured person after his death
or as to the injuries, then in criminal cases, the accused is given the benefit 
of doubt, and let off[4].

Medical evidence is only an evidence of opinion and it is not conclusion and when
oral evidence is found to the inconsistent with the medical opinion, the ocular 
evidence has to be given importance[5]. The position of law in such a case of contradiction
between medical and ocular evidence can be crystallized to the effect that even 
the ocular testimony of witness has greater evidentiary value vis-à-vis medical 
evidence, when medical evidence makes the ocular testimony improbable that becomes
a relevant factor in the process of the evaluation of evidence. However, where the
medical evidence goes so far that it completely rules out all possibility of the
ocular evidence being true, the ocular evidence may be disbelieved[6].

Supreme Court held that for the proposition that where the direct evidence was not
supported by the expert evidence, it would be difficult to convict the accused on
the basis of such evidence and also held that prosecution story was doubtful because
there was clear inconsistency between medical evidence and ocular evidence[7].

But Supreme Court also cautioned that though the ocular testimony of witness has
greater evidentiary value vis-vis medical evidence when medical evidence makes the
ocular testimony improbable, that becomes a relevant improbable, that becomes a 
relevant factor in the process of evaluation of evidence. However, where the medical
evidence goes so far that it completely rules out all possibility of the ocular 
evidence being true, the ocular evidence maybe disbelieved[8].

The real test of credibility of Tatoba’s version was the medical evidence. If his
version was corroborated by the medical evidence there could be no ground to discard
his sole evidence just because he happened to be a brother of the deceased. On the
other hand, if medical evidence contradicted the version of Tatoba, it was evident
that the prosecution case would not succeed[9].

Medical science is a difficult one. The court for the purpose of arriving at a decision
on the basis of the opinions of experts must take into consideration the difference
between an ‘expert witness’ and an ‘ordinary witness’. The opinion must be based
on a person having special skill or knowledge in medical science. It could be admitted
or denied. Whether such an evidence could be admitted or how much weight should 
be given therein lies within the domain of the court. The evidence of an expert 
should, however, be interpreted like any other evidence[10].

A medical witness who performs a post-mortem examination is a witness of fact though
he also gives an opinion on certain aspects of the case. The value of a medical 
witness is not merely a check upon the testimony of eyewitnesses; it is also independent
testimony because it may establish certain facts quite apart from the other oral
evidence. From the evidence on record, inferences are drawn as to the truth or otherwise
of the prosecution case in criminal matters and truth or otherwise of a claim in
civil matters. In this process, the medical evidence plays a very crucial role. 
If there is inconsistency or discrepancy between the medical evidence and the direct
evidence or between medical evidence of two doctors, one of whom examined the injured
person and the other conducted post mortem on the injured person after his death
or as to the injuries, then in criminal cases, the accused is given the benefit 
of doubt, and let off[11].

[1] BASO PRASAD AND OTHERS vs STATE OF BIHAR – (2006) 12 SCALE 354=(2006) 13 SCC
65=(2007) 2 SCC(Cri) 567=(2007) 1 Supreme 31.

[2] Mallikarjun and others vs. Staet of Karnataka – Crl.Apl No:1066 OF 2009 – 08.08.2019

[3] Krishnegowda & Others Versus State of Karnataka By Arkalgud Police – Criminal
Appeal Nos. 635 of 2006, 1067 of 2006 – 28-03-2017

[4] SANJAY KHANDERAO WADANE Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA – (2017) 8 Scale 479.

[5] (2008)2 MLJ (SC) 691 Mahmood & ors vs. State of U.P

[6] Abdul Sayeed vs. State of M.P – 2010(10) SCC 259; reiterated in Bajan Singh @
Harbajan Singh & others vs. State of Haryana – 2011 (2) MWN (Cri) 444 (SC).

[7] Mani Ram v. State of U.P – 1994 Supp(2) SCC 289=1994 SCC (Cri) 1242; State of
Punjab v. Rajinder Singh – (2009)15 SCC 612 relied in Sayed Darain Ahsan V. State
of W.B – 2012 (2) Supreme 571

[8] (2010) 10 SCC 259 – Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P

[9] Shamu Balu Chaugule v. State of Maharashtra –AIR 1976 SC 557=(1976)1 SCC 438
=1976 Cr.L.J 492 (SC)

[10] Malay Kumar Ganguly vs. Dr.Sukumar Mukherjee and others – AIR 2009 SC 1162=
JT 2009 (10) SC 256=2009(10) SCALE 673=(2009)9 SCC 221=(2010) SCC (Cri) 299=(2009)
13 SCR 1

[11] SANJAY KHANDERAO WADANE Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA – (2017) 8 Scale 479=AIR 2017
SC 3595=2017 (7) JT 503.

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
