# Firearm: Acquittal: Ballistic report opined that two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the test fired bullets

- Link: https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/
- Published: 2025-02-13T10:38:28+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against the conviction under sections 302 & 109 IPC](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#appeal-against-the-conviction-under-sections-302-amp-109-ipc)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#facts)
    - [Deceased died of gunshot injuries in the terrace](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#deceased-died-of-gunshot-injuries-in-the-terrace)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#analysis)
    - [No particular person named as culprit in FIR and the witnesses have not deposed about any offence committed nor hear any gunshots](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#no-particular-person-named-as-culprit-in-fir-and-the-witnesses-have-not-deposed-about-any-offence-committed-nor-hear-any-gunshots)
    - [PW4 who was sleeping with the deceased in the terrace also not named the perpetrators](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#pw4-who-was-sleeping-with-the-deceased-in-the-terrace-also-not-named-the-perpetrators)
    - [Doctor deposed that the bullet was not fired from close range but PW5 & 7 deposed the bullets were fired from a close range](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#doctor-deposed-that-the-bullet-was-not-fired-from-close-range-but-pw5-amp-7-deposed-the-bullets-were-fired-from-a-close-range)
    - [Ballistic report opined that two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the test fired bullets](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets)
    - [Guilt of the appellant not stands proved and established beyond reasonable doubt](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#guilt-of-the-appellant-not-stands-proved-and-established-beyond-reasonable-doubt)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against the conviction under sections 302 & 109 IPC**

This appeal by Siba Nial @ Trilochan challenges the judgment of affirmation by the
High Court confirming his conviction under Sections 302 and 109 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860, for the murder of Dhaneswar Kata and his wife, Nirupama Kata, during
the intervening night of 31.05.2013 and 01.06.2013.

#### **Facts**

##### **Deceased died of gunshot injuries in the terrace**

The case of the prosecution, as reflected in First Information Report No. 72/2013
dated 01.06.2013 registered with Police Station – IIC, Boden, District – Nuapada,
Odisha, is that Dhaneswar Kata and Nirupama Kata were found dead on the terrace 
of the house on the morning of 01.06.2013, having suffered gunshot injuries. They
had gone to sleep on the previous night on the terrace of the house along with other
family members, namely, Dhananjaya Kata, who was examined as PW-4, and Kishor Bachha,
who was not examined.

#### **Analysis**

##### **No particular person named as culprit in FIR and the witnesses have not deposed about any offence committed nor hear any gunshots**

Dhananjaya Kata (PW-4), in his Court deposition, did not claim having seen the person(
s) who had shot dead Dhaneswar Kata and Nirupama Kata. This was also confirmed by
the informant, Hrushikesh Kata (PW-1), who did not name any particular person as
a culprit in the FIR (Exhibit 1). Dalimba Kata (PW-2), the wife of the informant,
Hrushikesh Kata (PW-1), deposed on similar lines and did not name the culprit. None
of these witnesses deposed about how the offence was committed and why they did 
not hear any gunshots.

##### **PW4 who was sleeping with the deceased in the terrace also not named the perpetrators**

What is intriguing and makes the versions of Manoranjan Behera (PW-5) and Krutibash
Chhatria (PW-7) doubtful and debatable is their silence from 01.06.2013 till 09.06.2013.
This is significant given the fact that the locality must have been shaken on coming
to know that Dhaneswar Kata and his wife, Nirupama Kata, had been shot dead. As 
noticed above, the FIR (Exhibit 1) does not name any culprit or perpetrator. We 
have already referred to the depositions of Hrushikesh Kata (PW-1) and Dalimba Kata(
PW-2), who had deposed on similar lines. Dhananjaya Kata (PW-4), who was sleeping
with both the deceased persons on the terrace of the house, has also not named the
perpetrators, though he is the person who would have seen the persons committing
the crime given the fact that both Manoranjan Behera (PW-5) and Krutibash Chhatria(
PW-7) have deposed that there was the sound of gunshots being fired, not once but
twice.

##### **Doctor deposed that the bullet was not fired from close range but PW5 & 7 deposed the bullets were fired from a close range**

The prosecution also relied upon the disclosure statement of the appellant, Siba
Nial @ Trilochan, which led to the recovery of the pistol marked as Exhibit M.O.
I along with the Magazine marked as Exhibit M.O.II which were seized vide seizure
memo, Exhibit 4. These recoveries were made on 09.06.2013. The postmortem report,
marked as Exhibit 10, and the deposition of Dr. Jitender Kumar Soren (PW-16) as 
well as the ballistic report (Exhibit 17), however, are ambiguous and do not support
the prosecution’s version. In fact, the postmortem report (Exhibit 10) and the deposition
of Dr. Jitendra Kumar Soren (PW-16) indicate that the external injury on the head
could have been due to a rifle firearm bullet that was not fired from close range.
However, as per the depositions of Manoranjan Behera (PW-5) and Krutibash Chhatria(
PW7), the bullets were fired from a close range after Prabhulal had climbed onto
the terrace to commit the offence.

##### **Ballistic report opined that two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the test fired bullets**

The ballistic report (Exhibit 17) records that a country-made semi-automatic pistol,
four rounds of cartridges and two magazines were sent for examination on 22.07.2013.
As recorded above, the pistol along with cartridges, etc., as per the police version
and the testimony of Salya Naik (PW-17), the investigating officer, were recovered
on 09.06.2013. Thereafter, another sealed packet was received by the forensic laboratory
from the Biology and Serology Division on 13.11.2014. The result of the examination,
as per the ballistic report (Exhibit 17), was that the body wall of the cases were
found bulged indicating that they were fired from a country made firearm. However,
the percussion caps of both the cartridge cases were missing. Thus, it was not possible
to compare the firing pin marks on the cartridge cases found at the spot with the
test-fired cartridge cases. With reference to the deformed, jacketed bullets, on
examination, the report opined that individual characteristics of striation marks
on the two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the
test-fired bullets.

##### **Guilt of the appellant not stands proved and established beyond reasonable doubt**

In view of the aforesaid discussion highlighting the deficiencies and discrepancies
in the prosecution’s case, the guilt of the appellant, Siba Nial @ Trilochan, does
not stand proved and established beyond reasonable doubt. The impugned judgment,
confirming the conviction of the appellant, Siba Nial @ Trilochan, is accordingly
set aside. The appeal is allowed.

The appellant, Siba Nial @ Trilochan, shall be released from jail forthwith, unless
he is required to be detained in connection with any other case.

#### **Party**

Siba Nial @ Trilochan (Appellant) and The State of Odisha (Respondent) – Crl.A. 
674 of 2025 @ SLP(Crl.) No. 9244/2024 – 2025 INSC 206 – February 11, 2025.

[https://www.sci.gov.in/view-pdf/?diary_no=232592024&type=j&order_date=2025-02-11&from=latest_judgements_order](https://www.sci.gov.in/view-pdf/?diary_no=232592024&type=j&order_date=2025-02-11&from=latest_judgements_order)

[Siba Nial @ Trilochan vs. State of Odisha 232592024_2025-02-11](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Siba-Nial-@-Trilochan-vs.-State-of-Odisha-232592024_2025-02-11.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Siba-Nial-@-Trilochan-vs.-State-of-Odisha-232592024_2025-02-11.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
