# Forgery: Who is the culprit [appellant or respondent] shall be decided only during the trial and using inherent powers under section 482 Cr.P.C and Apex Court advised Two wrongs do not make a right

- Link: https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/
- Published: 2024-08-27T17:14:51+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Brief facts](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#brief-facts)
 * [Final report filed as lack of evidence Magistrate directed further investigation again final report filed for same reason hence magistrate summoned the accused](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#final-report-filed-as-lack-of-evidence-magistrate-directed-further-investigation-again-final-report-filed-for-same-reason-hence-magistrate-summoned-the-accused)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#analysis)
 * [Hon’ble High Court observed that the appellant ha manipulated the documents by altering the experience certificate](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#honble-high-court-observed-that-the-appellant-ha-manipulated-the-documents-by-altering-the-experience-certificate)
 * [Respondent is the one who was successful in obtaining the tender on the basis of fabricated documents and the ultimate beneficiary](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#respondent-is-the-one-who-was-successful-in-obtaining-the-tender-on-the-basis-of-fabricated-documents-and-the-ultimate-beneficiary)
 * [Respondent No.2 completed the work and got paid by the government](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#respondent-no2-completed-the-work-and-got-paid-by-the-government)
 * [While exercising the power under section 482 Cr.P.C the High Court is not required to conduct the mini trial](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#while-exercising-the-power-under-section-482-crpc-the-high-court-is-not-required-to-conduct-the-mini-trial)
 * [A person who was involved in the forgery is a disputed question of fact shall de decided only during trial and not at the threshold](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#a-person-who-was-involved-in-the-forgery-is-a-disputed-question-of-fact-shall-de-decided-only-during-trial-and-not-at-the-threshold)
 * [At the stage of summons the High Court ought not to have recorded the finding on the aspect of forgery](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#at-the-stage-of-summons-the-high-court-ought-not-to-have-recorded-the-finding-on-the-aspect-of-forgery)
 * [Since appellant was an equal mischief player cannot absolve respondent from criminal liability](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#since-appellant-was-an-equal-mischief-player-cannot-absolve-respondent-from-criminal-liability)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/forgery-who-is-the-culprit-appellant-or-respondent-shall-be-decided-only-during-the-trial-and-using-inherent-powers-under-section-482-cr-p-c-and-apex-court-advised-two-wrongs-do-not-make-a-right/#further-study)

##### **Brief facts**

2. In both these appeals the appellant challenges the judgement and order dated 
05.12.2023 passed by the High Court of Jharkhand allowing the petition filed by 
the respondents under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and the High
Court of Jharkhand by impugned judgment quashed the summoning order dated 31.01.2022
as well criminal proceedings pending in the court of Judicial Magistrate in connection
with Case No. 30 of 2019 corresponding to proceedings pending in **[court of Judicial Magistrate](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-cannot-return-final-report/),**
1st Class Palamau.

3. The appellant challenging the order impugned is the original complainant to an
application under Section 156 (3) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 against M/
s SS Infrastructure Co and its Partners (Respondent No.2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha
in SLP (Crl.) No. 1500/2024; Respondent No. 2 – Sandhya Choudha and Respondent No.
3 – Rajeev Choudha – in SLP (Crl.) No. 1660/2024). Accordingly, the said **[FIR](http://localhost:8080/section1/fir-is-a-public-document-and-also-a-dying-declaration-and-hence-it-shall-be-treated-as-substantive-piece-of-evidence-and-admissible-u-s-321-evidence-act-1872/)**
No. 38 of 2019 came to be registered on 02.04.2019. In this said FIR it is alleged
that all the above mentioned respondents have **[committed offences under Sections](http://localhost:8080/section1/offence-committed-in-journey-or-voyage/)**
384, 389, 406 and 420 r/w Section 34 and 120B of Indian Penal Code, 1860. The accusation
was two-fold. Firstly: the complainant had worked as a sub-contractor and an amount
due to him was not paid by the main contractor i.e. Respondent no.2 – Santosh Kumar
Choudha. The second allegation is of more serious nature namely the Respondent No.
2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha, was successful in obtaining the contract fraudulently
by submitting forged and fabricated documents.

4. The said contract was in respect of a project namely Namna Ankiat Project and
the work under this project was of extension, restoration and modernisation under
the Jinjoyi Irrigation Scheme in district Palamau, Jharkhand. The estimated cost
of the work was of Rs.35,18,11,422/-. In response to the offer, the respondent firm
M/s SS Infrastructure Co and its Partners submitted its bid along with the documents.
The requisite condition was to have past experience of construction 3 to the tune
of Rs.18,40,00,000/-. It was alleged that though the respondent firm had an experience
of construction of Anikat (Check Dam) over Mandi River and the work contract was
only for a sum of Rs.3,40,00,000/- but by submitting forged and fabricated documents,
the respondent firm claimed that the work undertaken by the firm under tender no.
1797 was of Rs.18,40,00,000/-.

##### **Final report filed as lack of evidence Magistrate directed further investigation again final report filed for same reason hence magistrate summoned the accused**

7. The **[investigating agency initially submitted its first final report](http://localhost:8080/section1/closure-report-and-further-investigation-entire-settled-propositions-explained/)**
on 31.10.2020. The investigation agency submitted final report on the grounds of
lack of evidence. The appellant being aggrieved and not satisfied by this final 
report **[filed protest petition](http://localhost:8080/section1/protest-petition-cannot-be-filed-against-the-order-of-the-magistrate-taking-cognizance/)**.
The learned Magistrate in his detailed order dated 12.02.2021 observed that there
are serious lapses and defects in the investigation and further investigation is
necessary to meet the ends of justice. The investigating agency again citing the
same reason that no sufficient evidence is available against the accused, submitted
the second final report. The learned Magistrate was pleased to observe that the 
statements of the witnesses clearly revealed that the documents were fabricated.
The Magistrate also observed that the **[informant](http://localhost:8080/section1/questioning-whence-right-or-wrong/)**
himself had fabricated the documents and the Respondent No. 2 -Santosh Kumar Choudha,
though was not entitled for grant of the tender on the basis of false and fabricated
documents, the tender was still allotted to the respondents. It is also observed
by the Magistrate that the respondents were the beneficiaries and the aspect of 
fabrication of the documents is a matter of trial. Consequently, summoning order
dated 31.01.2022 was issued. As stated above, being aggrieved by the summoning order,
the respondents filed an application for quashing the summoning order and **[criminal proceedings](http://localhost:8080/section1/initiation-of-criminal-proceeding-under-sections-138-141-n-i-act-is-covered-under-moratorium-provision-u-s-14-ibc/)**
pending before the Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class Palamau.

##### **Analysis**

11. We have heard the arguments and perused the Judgments passed by the High Court
as well as other relevant documents on record.

##### **Hon’ble High Court observed that the appellant ha manipulated the documents by altering the experience certificate**

12. Admittedly, in the present case the documents which were presented by the appellant
were forged and fabricated documents. There are cross allegations by the appellant
as well as Respondent No. 2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha, about the complicity of the
forged documents. The High Court after perusing Para 140, 141 & 142 of the **[case diary](http://localhost:8080/section1/case-diary-section-1723-cr-p-c-the-accused-has-a-right-to-cross-examine-police-officer-as-per-section-145-evidence-act-whenever-the-police-officer-uses-it-to-refresh-his-memory/)**
observed that it was the appellant herein who had manipulated the documents by altering
the experience certificate along with the tender and Respondent No. 2 – Santosh 
Kumar Choudha, was not involved in submitting the forged documents. The High Court
laid much emphasis on the statements which are referred in the case diary and observed
that it was the appellant before this Court who had manipulated the documents by
altering the Experience Certificate along with the tender.

##### **Respondent is the one who was successful in obtaining the tender on the basis of fabricated documents**** and the ultimate beneficiary**

13. In our opinion, the High Court failed to appreciate the aspect that admittedly
at the relevant time, the appellant was an employee and working for Respondent No.
2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha. The High Court also failed to appreciate the fact that
Respondent No.2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha, was successful in obtaining the tender 
on the basis of fabricated documents. Though Respondent No. 2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha,
was not fulfilling the requisite condition of the experience but by using forged
and fabricated documents, he has shown himself before the competent authority to
be fulfilling the pre-requisite condition of experience. Thus, Respondent No.2 –
Santosh Kumar Choudha was the ultimate beneficiary of the allotment of the said 
tender.

##### **Respondent No.2 completed the work and got paid by the government**

14. Learned counsel for Respondent No.2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha also submitted that
admittedly the project was complete, the work allotted to him under the said project
was complete and there was no objection raised by the Government in respect of the
work. Since no objection was recorded against the work, the Government paid the 
amount to the Respondent No. 2 – Santosh Kumar Choudha, due and payable to him under
the contract.

##### **While exercising the power under section 482 Cr.P.C the High Court is not required to conduct the mini trial**

15. This Court in a series of judgements has held that while exercising inherent
jurisdiction under Section 482 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, the High Court 
is not supposed to hold a mini trial. A profitable reference can be made to the **
[judgment](http://localhost:8080/section1/writing-judgment-is-an-art/)** in the 
case of CBI vs Aryan Singh (2023 SCC Online SC 379). Relevant paragraph from the
judgment is extracted here under:

> “Para 10…As per the cardinal principle of law, at the stage of discharge and/or
> quashing of the criminal proceedings, while exercising the powers under Section
> 482 Cr. P.C., the Court is not required to conduct the mini trial.
> At the stage of **[discharge and/or while exercising the powers under Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)**
> 482 Cr. P.C., the Court has a very limited jurisdiction and is required to consider“
> whether any sufficient material is available to proceed further against the accused
> for which the accused is required to be tried or not”.

##### **A person who was involved in the forgery is a disputed question of fact shall de decided only during trial and not at the threshold**

16. In the instant case, the High Court has delved into an aspect which was absolutely
not warranted and has exceeded its jurisdiction. The aspect about complicity of 
a person who was involved in the forgery is a disputed question of fact and the 
same will have to be addressed after a **[proper appreciation of evidence](http://localhost:8080/section1/secondary-evidence-document-that-are-not-properly-stamped-cannot-be-secondary-evidence/)**
which can be done only during trial and not at such a nascent stage when summons
is served. The Magistrate while considering the fact that the Respondent No. 2 –
Santosh Kumar Choudha, was a beneficiary and after considering the scope of summons
order had rightly observed that a prima facie case is made out and the same required
an adjudication through a trial.

##### **At the stage of summons the High Court ought not to have recorded the finding on the aspect of forgery**

17. The High Court ought to have considered the complicity of the accused in case
of forgery, which will have to be addressed after a proper appreciation of evidence
and such appreciation of evidence can be done only by undertaking the initial process
i.e. by conducting the trial on the aspect of forgery. The summons order was only
at an initial stage and at such a nascent stage, the High Court ought not to have
recorded the finding on the aspect of forgery.

##### **Since appellant was an equal mischief player cannot absolve respondent from criminal liability**

18. At the cost of repetition, we state that admittedly respondents are the beneficiaries
and merely because the appellant was an equal mischief player and/or a person having
criminal antecedents at his credit by itself will not absolve respondents from the
criminal liability as alleged against them. Least to say, “ Two wrongs do not make
a right.”

##### **Party**

Dharambeer Kumar Singh Appellant(S) versus The State Of Jharkhand & Anr. Respondent(
S) – Criminal Appeal No  __________ OF 2024 ( @ SLP (CRL.) NO. 1500 OF 2024) – AUGUST
6, 2024 – 2024 INSC 583

[**https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=38092024&type=j&order_date=2024-08-06&from=latest_judgements_order**](https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=38092024&type=j&order_date=2024-08-06&from=latest_judgements_order)

**[Dharambeer Kumar Singh vs. The State of Jharkhand 38092024_2024-08-06](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Dharambeer-Kumar-Singh-vs.-The-State-of-Jharkhand-38092024_2024-08-06.pdf)**

 

##### **Further study**

 * **[Twist the Throttle: Legal Wrangles in Motorcycle Touring](http://localhost:8080/section1/twist-the-throttle-legal-wrangles-in-motorcycle-touring/)**
 * **[All about sanction and approver](http://localhost:8080/section1/all-about-sanction-and-approver/)**
 * **[Section 138 NI Act: Cheque filled by the complainant is not forgery](http://localhost:8080/section1/cheque-filled-by-the-complainant-is-not-forgery/)**
 * **[Cost: Hon’ble Supreme court imposed cost on the husband to file cheating case on his wife](http://localhost:8080/section1/cost-honble-supreme-court-imposed-cost-on-the-husband-to-file-cheating-case-on-his-wife/)**
 * **[Sanction: Manufacturing or fabrication of public documents and records cannot be a part of the official duty of a public servant hence sanction not required](http://localhost:8080/section1/sanction-manufacturing-or-fabrication-of-public-documents-and-records-cannot-be-a-part-of-the-official-duty-of-a-public-servant-hence-sanction-not-required/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
