# Elicited portions through contradiction as per section 145 IEA from sections 161 & 164 Cr.P.C statements are not substantive evidence

- Link: https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/
- Published: 2025-01-31T08:14:36+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#appeal)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#facts)
    - [Hon’ble High court has converted the acquittal into conviction under the revisional jurisdiction that too on ex-parte](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#honble-high-court-has-converted-the-acquittal-into-conviction-under-the-revisional-jurisdiction-that-too-on-exparte)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#analysis)
    - [Question of law](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#question-of-law)
    - [Section 401 (3) Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#section-401-3-crpc)
    - [Section 401(5) Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#section-4015-crpc)
    - [Section 372 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#section-372-crpc)
    - [Article 22(1) Constitution and lawyer’s presence](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#article-221-constitution-and-lawyers-presence)
    - [High Court cannot reverse the acquittal into one conviction in revisional jurisdiction](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#high-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revisional-jurisdiction)
    - [Is the proviso to section 372 CrPC retrospective in operation?](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#is-the-proviso-to-section-372-crpc-retrospective-in-operation)
    - [Complainant argued that the High Court could have treated the revision application as appeal](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#complainant-argued-that-the-high-court-could-have-treated-the-revision-application-as-appeal)
    - [Unlike revision appeal is a statutory right](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#unlike-revision-appeal-is-a-statutory-right)
    - [Appeal by victim is added through Amending Act No.5 of 2009](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#appeal-by-victim-is-added-through-amending-act-no5-of-2009)
    - [Victim has right to prefer appeal](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#victim-has-right-to-prefer-appeal)
    - [Is proviso to section 372 an exception?](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#is-proviso-to-section-372-an-exception)
    - [Victim has no right of appeal during the year 2006](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#victim-has-no-right-of-appeal-during-the-year-2006)
    - [Other aspects erred by the High Court](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#other-aspects-erred-by-the-high-court)
    - [Hon’ble High court relied section 161 Cr.P.C instead of oral testimony](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#honble-high-court-relied-section-161-crpc-instead-of-oral-testimony)
    - [Section 162 Cr.P.C cannot be used for any purpose except for contradiction u/s 145 IEA](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#section-162-crpc-cannot-be-used-for-any-purpose-except-for-contradiction-us-145-iea)
 * [Role of Public Prosecutors in hostile witness](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#role-of-public-prosecutors-in-hostile-witness)
    - [Public Prosecutors should conduct details cross-examinations to reveal the truth](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#public-prosecutors-should-conduct-details-crossexaminations-to-reveal-the-truth)
    - [Material elicited as contradiction from s.161 crpc and s.164 crpc statements by use of section 145 of the IEA is not substantive evidence](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#material-elicited-as-contradiction-from-s161-crpc-and-s164-crpc-statements-by-use-of-section-145-of-the-iea-is-not-substantive-evidence)
    - [Unlawful detention of the appellants for a period of three months](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#unlawful-detention-of-the-appellants-for-a-period-of-three-months)
    - [Judgments cited/relied](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#judgments-citedrelied)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/high-court-cannot-reverse-acquittal-into-one-conviction-in-revision-that-too-ex-parte-a-must-carry-judgment-by-defense-counsel/#party)

#### **Appeal**

1. Since the issues raised in both the captioned appeals are the same and the challenge
is also to the self-same judgement and order passed by the High Court, those were
taken up for hearing analogously and are being disposed of by this common judgement
and order.

2. We may clarify that the Criminal Appeal No. 5560 of 2024 arises from the judgement
and order passed by the High Court, reversing the acquittal and holding the appellants
herein guilty of the offence of murder. Whereas Criminal Appeal No. 5561 of 2024
arises from the order of sentence, which ultimately came to be passed by the High
Court.

3. These appeals arise from the judgement and order passed by the High Court of 
Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh dated 27.08.2024 in Criminal Revision Application
No. 194 of 2006 by which the criminal revision filed by the original de facto complainant
against the judgment and order of acquittal passed by the trial court came to be
allowed and the appellants herein were held guilty of the offence of murder punishable
under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”) and sentenced 
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life and fine of Rs. 50,000/- each and further,
rigorous imprisonment for 3 months in default of payment of fine.

#### **Facts**

##### **Hon’ble High court has converted the acquittal into conviction under the revisional jurisdiction that too on ex-parte**

6. We need not delve much into the facts of the present case as our order dated 
13.12.2024 gives more than a fair idea as to how these appeals have come up before
us. The order reads thus:

“3. The three appellants herein along with three other co-accused were put to trial
for the offence of murder punishable under Section 302 read with Section 148 and
149 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. On conclusion of the trial, the Trial Court 
held two co-accused guilty of the alleged crime, whereas the other four, including
three appellants herein, came to be acquitted.

4. The State did not deem fit to challenge the acquittal of the three appellants
herein. One of the convicts went in appeal before the High Court and the father 
of the deceased in turn invoked the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court under
Section 401 read with Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 seeking
to challenge the acquittal of the three appellants herein. It appears that the appeal
filed by one of the convicts against his order of conviction came to be dismissed
despite the fact that the convict had already passed away.

5. In the revision application, which was filed by the father of the deceased, the
High Court held all the three appellants herein guilty of the alleged offence of
murder and sentenced them to undergo life imprisonment. We are informed that they
were taken into custody on the very same day the judgment was pronounced by the 
High Court and now they are serving the sentence as imposed by the High Court.

6. We are not able to understand, on what basis the High Court in exercise of its
revisional jurisdiction under Section 401 read with Section 397 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure could have converted the finding of acquittal into one of conviction. 
Sub Section (3) of Section 401 reads thus: “(3) Nothing in this section shall be
deemed to authorize a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction.”

7. There is one another feature which has disturbed us. According to the learned
counsel the High Court proceeded ex-parte without issuing notice to the three appellants
herein in the revision petition, who had already been acquitted by the Trial Court.

8. We are also informed that the father of the deceased, who had filed the revision
application before the High Court had also passed away much before the judgment 
of the High Court.

9. Issue notice to the State of Haryana, returnable on 19th December, 2024.

10. In such circumstances referred to above, all the three appellants are ordered
to be released on bail. The substantive order of sentence passed by the High Court
is suspended till further orders. Accordingly, IA No. 285726/2024 stands disposed
of.

11. Registry to call for the records and proceedings of the Sessions Case No. 4 
of 1988/2005, disposed of by Additional Sessions Judge, Rewari, from the High Court
of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh.”

#### **Analysis**

##### **Question of law**

31. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through
the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether
the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment and order of
conviction in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction under Section 401 read with
Section 397 of the CrPC.

##### **Section 401 (3) Cr.P.C [section 442 (3) BNSS]**

34. Section 401(3) says – “Nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorize 
a High Court to convert a finding of appeal into one of conviction.”

i. Thus, the bar is categorical and express.

##### **Section 401(5) Cr.P.C [section 442 (5) BNSS]**

35. Section 401(5) says – “Where under this Code an appeal lies but an application
for revision has been made to the High Court by any person and the High Court is
satisfied that such application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal
lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of justice so to do so, the
High Court may treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal and deal
with the same accordingly.”

i. For the High Court to treat the revision as an appeal, all of the above conditions
were required to be fulfilled.

ii. And a reasoned, speaking order was required to be passed recording that they
were fulfilled. iii. However, no such procedure was adopted.

##### **Section 372 Cr.P.C [section 413 BNSS]**

36. The general provision on appeals is Section 372 Cr PC which says – No appeal
to lie unless otherwise provided. – No appeal shall lie from any judgment or order
of a Criminal Court except as provided for by this Code or by any other law for 
the time being in force. i. Thus, no appeal was permissible other than provided 
for, in law.

37. The Proviso to the above had not yet come into effect as on 19.01.2006 when 
the revision petition was filed, for it was added only w.e.f. 31.12.2009. The Proviso
says – [Provided that the victim shall have a right to prefer an appeal against 
any order passed by the Court acquitting the accused or convicting for a lesser 
offence or imposing inadequate compensation, and such appeal shall lie to the Court
to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of such Court.]

> i. Thus, the statutory right of appeal by a victim against such acquittal arose
> only from the date of the amendment w.e.f. 31.12.2009. As the said revision was
> filed by the father of the deceased on 19.01.2006 well before the above amendment,
> such right was not available at the relevant point of time.
> ii. Therefore, the very first condition under Section 401(5) itself would not 
> have been possible to be fulfilled, i.e. the right of the victim to appeal did
> not lie under the Code at the time of filing the revision petition.

38. As regards appeals against acquittals, the relevant provision for appeals, and
specifically for appeal to the High Court, are detailed out below:

a. Section 378. Appeal in case of acquittal – Section 378 (1) says – Save as otherwise
provided in sub-section (2), and subject to the provisions of sub-sections (3) and(
5), –

b. The relevant section pertaining to an appeal to the High Court is Section 378(
1)(b) which says – The State Government may, in any case, direct the Public Prosecutor
to present an appeal to the High Court from an original or appellate order of an
acquittal passed by any Court other than a High Court [not being an order under 
clause (a)] or an order of acquittal passed by the Court of Session in revision.].

> i. Thus, only the State had the statutory right to appeal against the order of
> acquittal in 2006, and
> ii. Indisputably, the State did not file appeal challenging the said order of 
> acquittal.

Hon’ble Supreme Court has cited several precedents explaining the above said propositions[
listed below].

44. The decision in Manharibhai Muljibhai (supra) was referred to and relied upon
in Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan & Anr. reported in (2014) 9 SCC 640, wherein
it was inter alia, held that “The appellant who is an accused person cannot be deprived
of hearing on the face of the express provision contained in Section 401(2) of the
Code and on this ground, the impugned order of the High Court is liable to be set
aside…”.

##### **Article 22(1) Constitution and lawyer’s presence**

45. This Court in Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani & Anr. reported in (1978) 2 SCC 
424 held that the right to consult an advocate of choice shall not be denied to 
any person who is arrested. This does not mean that persons who are not under arrest
or custody can be denied such right. The spirit and ethos of Article 22(1) is that
it is fundamental to the rule of law that the service of a lawyer shall be available
for consultation to the accused person under circumstances of near custodial interrogation.
Moreover, the right against self-incrimination is best practiced & best promoted
by conceding to the accused, the right to consult a legal practitioner of his choice.
Lawyers’ presence is a constitutional claim in some circumstances of our country,
and in the context of Article 20(3), is an assurance of awareness and observance
of the right to silence.

##### **High Court cannot reverse the acquittal into one conviction in revisional jurisdiction**

46. Thus, it is as clear as a noonday that the High Court committed an egregious
error in reversing the acquittal and passing an order of conviction in exercise 
of its revisional jurisdiction and that too without affording any opportunity of
hearing to the appellants herein.

47. We could have closed this matter at this stage; however, we would like to explain
the position of law in so far as the applicability of sub section (5) to Section
401 of the CrPC read with the provision to sub section 372 of the CrPC is concerned.

##### **Is the proviso to section 372 CrPC [section 413 BNSS] retrospective in operation?**

##### **Complainant argued that the High Court could have treated the revision application as appeal**

48. A very fabulous argument was canvassed on behalf of the State that the proviso
to Section 372 of the CrPC is retrospective in operation. Therefore, although the
revision was filed in 2006, yet as it came to be decided in 2014, the proviso to
Section 372 CrPC was applicable. The High Court could have treated the revision 
application as an appeal under Section 372 at the instance of the complainant. If
the High Court would have treated it as an appeal, then it would have been within
its jurisdiction to reverse the acquittal and passed an order of conviction.

49. It seems one and all are under a serious misconception of law.

##### **Unlike revision appeal is a statutory right**

50. Insofar as the statutes regulating appeal are concerned, the law is well settled
that the right to file an appeal is a statutory right and it can be circumscribed
by the conditions of the statute granting it. As was observed by this Court in Government
of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. P. Laxmi Devi reported in (2008) 4 SCC 720 and Super
Cassettes Industries Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. reported in (2009) 10
SCC 531, it is not a natural or inherent right and cannot be assumed to exist, unless
provided by a statute.

51. Therefore, the scheme of right of appeal under Chapter XXXIX of the CrPC, which
provides the right to file appeals including abatement of appeals, should be understood
on the basis of the above golden rules of statutory interpretation.

##### **Appeal by victim is added through Amending Act No.5 of 2009**

52. Comparing Section 404 of CrPC 1898 with Section 372 of CrPC, would indicate 
that the main provision is intact, insofar it provides that no appeal shall lie 
from any judgment or order of a criminal court, except as provided by this Code 
or by any other law for the time being in force. The significant development that
has taken place in this provision is that a ‘proviso’ was added by the Amending 
Act No. 5 of 2009, which provides that ‘the victim shall have a right to prefer 
an appeal against any order passed by the Court acquitting the accused or convicting
for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation, and such appeal shall 
lie to the Court to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction
passed by such Court’.

##### **Victim has right to prefer appeal**

53. Therefore, by the aforesaid provision a right has been created in favour of 
the victim, which was not existing earlier in the Code, i.e., that a victim shall
have a right to prefer an appeal against any order passed by the court acquitting
the accused or convicting for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation.
The plain reading of the statement of objects and reasons for introducing the proviso
to Section 372 CrPC makes it clear that it wanted to confer certain rights on the
victims. It has been noted therein that the victims are the worst sufferers in a
crime, and they don’t have much role in the court proceedings. They need to be given
certain “rights” and compensation, so that there is no distortion of the criminal
justice system. This, by itself, is clear that the object of adding this proviso
is to create a right in favour of the victim to prefer an appeal as a matter of 
right. It not only extends to challenge the order of acquittal, but such appeal 
can also be filed by the victim if the accused is convicted for a lessor offence
or if the inadequate compensation has been imposed.

54. Thus, it is clear as per the golden rule of interpretation, that the ‘proviso’
is a substantive enactment, and is not merely excepting something out of or qualifying
what was excepting or goes before. Therefore, by adding the ‘proviso’ in Section
372 of CrPC by this amendment, a right has been created in favour of the victim.

##### **Is proviso to section 372 an exception?**

67. In the present context, given the text of Section 372 and the scheme of the 
Act, it is clear that the proviso establishes an independent right, and must be 
interpreted within that framework. Section 372 forbids appeals unless otherwise 
authorized by the Code, or by another law. The proviso, however, states that the
victim shall have the right to appeal under certain circumstances. Given the rule
enacted in Section 372, it cannot be said that the proviso to that provision carves
out an exception to the rule. According to the rule in Section 372, appeals must
be in accordance with the Code; according to the proviso – which is itself part 
of the Code – victims have the right to appeal under certain circumstances. At various
other places in the CrPC, appeal procedures are specified. For instance, Section
378 stipulates the procedure in case of appeals from acquittal, and Section 378(
3) specifies that “no appeal under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) shall be entertained
except with leave of the High Court.” The proviso to Section 372 dispenses with 
the requirement of leave in case it is the victim who is appealing. From the scheme
of the Act, therefore, it seems clear that the proviso is better understood to be
one of the many provisions governing appeals under Chapter 29 of the CrPC. While
Section 372 enacts that no appeal shall lie except as provided for by the Code, 
it refers to the various provisions of Chapter 29, including the proviso, each of
which prescribe the requirements and procedures for appeals under different circumstances.
The proviso, therefore, is not an exception to Section 372, but a stand-alone legal
provision.

##### **Victim has no right of appeal during the year 2006**

72. In view of the aforesaid, it is very much clear that the amendment so made in
Section 372 CrPC by adding a proviso in the year 2009 creating a substantive right
of appeal is not retrospective in nature. A statute which creates new rights shall
be construed to be prospective in operation unless otherwise provided, either expressly
or by necessary implication. It is, therefore, clear that in the year 2006 when 
the judgement of acquittal was passed, the de facto complainant had no right to 
challenge the impugned order passed in 2006 by way of filing the appeal. In such
circumstances sub section (5) of Section 401 CrPC has no application in the present
case.

##### **Other aspects erred by the High Court**

73.There is yet one another shocking aspect of the matter, we need to take cognizance
of.

##### **Hon’ble High court relied section 161 Cr.P.C instead of oral testimony**

74. It appears that the High Court relied upon the police statement of PW-7 recorded
under Section 161 of the CrPC instead of his oral testimony before the trial court.

##### **Section 162 Cr.P.C cannot be used for any purpose except for contradiction u/s 145 IEA**

76. Whereas Section 162 of the CrPC expressly provides that the statements recorded
under Section 161 of the CrPC shall not be used for any purpose save as provided
in Section 162, and the Proviso to Section 162 clearly says that, any part of the
statement, if duly proved, may be used by the accused, to contradict such witness
in the manner provide in Section 145 of the Evidence Act. And when any part of such
statement is so used, any part thereof may also be used in the re-examination of
such witness, but only for the purpose of explaining any matter referred to in the
cross-examination.

#### **Role of Public Prosecutors in hostile witness**

##### **Public Prosecutors should conduct details cross-examinations to reveal the truth**

78. Thus, this Court took a serious notice of lack of thorough cross-examination
by Public Prosecutors in criminal appeals, specifically with hostile witnesses. 
The prosecutors often only confront them with their police statement, aiming to 
highlight contradictions but not fully explore the witness’s testimony. The Court
emphasized that the purpose of cross-examination is to challenge the accuracy and
credibility of the witness’s statement, uncover hidden facts, and establish if the
witness is lying. Public Prosecutors should conduct detailed cross examinations 
to reveal the truth and establish the witness’s first hand knowledge of the incident
described in their police statement.

79. In the decision referred to above the Court noted that after the witness was
declared hostile, all that the Public Prosecutor had done was to put few suggestions
to her for the purposes of cross-examination. Even proper contradictions were not
brought on record.

80. This Court explained that the trial courts cannot independently use statements
made to the police that have not been proven, nor can it base its questions on such
statements if they conflict with the witness’s testimony in court. The phrase ‘if
duly proved’ in Section 162 of the CrPC indicates that the statements of witnesses
recorded by the police cannot be immediately admitted as evidence or examined. They
must first be proven through eliciting admissions from the witness during cross-
examination and also during the cross-examination of the Investigating Officer. 
While statements made to the Investigating Officer can be used for contradiction,
this can only be done after strict compliance with Section 145 of the Evidence Act.
This requires drawing attention to the specific parts of the statement intended 
for contradiction. This is what is required under Section 145 of the Evidence Act
but even where a witness is confronted by his previous statement and given an opportunity
to explain that part of the statement that is put to him does not constitute substantive
evidence.

##### **Material elicited as contradiction from s.161 crpc and s.164 crpc statements by use of section 145 of the IEA is not substantive evidence**

81. There is a catena of decisions laying down the principle in law that the material
elicited as contradiction by use of Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act is not
substantive evidence. Even in regard to the statement recorded under Section 164
of the CrPC by authorised Magistrate, it has been held accordingly. Therefore, the
fact that the contradictions are proved through the investigating officers though
the witnesses have denied having made such statements, does not translate the contradictions
into substantive evidence. Unless there is substantive evidence, it cannot be acted
upon legally particularly to base a conviction.

##### **Unlawful detention of the appellants for a period of three months**

84. The principle as aforesaid is now well established that in cases where there
can be no dispute of facts, the constitutional courts have the power to award compensation
in case a person has been deprived of his life and liberty without following the
procedure established by law.

87. From the above, it is quite vivid that emphasis has been laid on mental agony
when a person is confined within the four walls of the police station or lock up.

91. The Public Prosecutor instead of assisting the learned Judges in the right direction
by pointing out the correct position of law went to the extent of praying before
the Court that the appellants herein deserved capital punishment. It is a different
thing that the High Court rejected the prayer of the Public Prosecutor.

93. Time and again this Court has observed in so many of its decisions that such
appointments be it in the High Court or in the district judiciary should be only
taking into consideration the merit of the candidate and no other consideration 
should weigh in such appointments.

96. A Public Prosecutor is not expected to show a thirst to reach the case in the
conviction of the accused somehow or the other irrespective of the true facts of
the case. The expected attitude of the Public Prosecutor while conducting prosecution
must be couched in fairness not only to the Court to the investigation agencies 
but to the accused as well. If an accused is entitled to any legitimate benefit 
during trial, the Public Prosecutor should not scuttle/conceal it. On the contrary,
it is the duty of the Public Prosecutor to winch it to the fore and make it available
to the accused. Even if the court or defence counsel overlooked it, the Public Prosecutor
has the added responsibility to bring it to the notice of the Court, if it comes
to his knowledge.

98. Judges are human beings and at times they do commit mistakes. The sheer pressure
of work at times may lead to such errors. At the same time, the defence counsel 
as well as the Public Prosecutor owes a duty to correct the Court if the Court is
falling in some error and for all this, we hold the State Government responsible.
It is the State Government who appointed the concerned Public Prosecutor. The State
Government should be asked to pay compensation to the three appellants herein.

99. For all the foregoing reasons, the appeals succeed and are hereby allowed. The
impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is hereby set aside. The State
Government shall pay Rs. 5,00,000/- each to the three appellants towards compensation
within a period of four weeks from today failing which we shall take appropriate
action against the responsible officer.

100. The bail bonds furnished by the appellants herein stand discharged.

101. Registry shall notify this matter once again before this Bench after four weeks
to report compliance of payment of compensation as awarded.

##### **Judgments cited/relied**

 1.  **Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar – (2002) 6 SCC 650**
 2.  **Joseph Stephen & Ors. v. Santhanasamy & Ors. – (2022) 13 SCC 115**
 3.  **Ganesha v. Sharanappa & Anr. – (2014) 1 SCC 87**
 4.  **Santhakumari & Ors. v. State of Tamil Nadu & Ors. – (2023) 15 SCC 440**
 5.  **Anees v. State Government of NCT – 2024 SCC OnLine SC 757**
 6.  **Kiran Bedi v. Committee of Inquiry & Anr. – (1989) 1 SCC 494**
 7.  **Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa & Ors. – (1993) 2 SCC 746**
 8.  **Mallikarjun Kodagali (Dead) represented through Legal Representatives v. State
     of Karnataka & Ors. – (2019) 2 SCC 752**
 9.  **Hitendra Vishnu Thakur & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. – (1994) 4 SCC 
     602**
 10. **D. Stephens v. Nosibolla – AIR 1951 SC 196**
 11. **K. Chinnaswamy Reddy v. State of A.P. – AIR 1962 SC 1788**
 12. **Akalu Ahir v. Ramdeo Ram – (1973) 2 SCC 583**
 13. **Pakalapati Narayana Gajapathi Raju v. Bonapalli Peda Appadu – (1975) 4 SCC 477**
 14. **Mahendra Pratap Singh v. Sarju Singh – AIR 1968 SC 707**
 15. **Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia & Anr. v. Shaileshbhai Mohanbhai Patel & Ors. –(
     2012) 10 SCC 517**
 16. **Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan – (2014) 9 SCC 640**
 17. **Government of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. P. Laxmi Devi – (2008) 4 SCC 720**
 18. **Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. – (2009) 10
     SCC 531**
 19. **A.N. Sehgal & Ors. v. Raje Ram Sheoran & Ors. – AIR 1991 SC 1406**
 20. **S. Sundaram Pillai & Ors. v. V.R. Pattabiraman & Ors. – AIR 1985 SC 582**
 21. **State of Bombay & Anr. v. United Motors (India) Limited & Ors. – (1953) 1 SCC
     514**
 22. **State of Kerala & Anr. v. B. Six Holiday Resorts Private Ltd. & Ors. – (2010)
     5 SCC 186**
 23. **Sudhir G. Angur & Ors. v. M. Sanjeev & Ors. – (2006) 1 SCC 141**
 24. **Ramesh Kumar Soni v. State of Madhya Pradesh – (2013) 14 SCC 696**
 25. **D.F. Marion v. Davis – 55 ALR 171; 217 Ala 176 (1927)**
 26. **Vishwanath Agrawal v. Sarla Vishwanath Agrawal – (2012) 7 SCC 288**
 27. **Anees v. State Government of NCT – 2024 SCC OnLine SC 757**
 28. **D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal – (1997) 1 SCC 416**

#### **Party**

Mahabir & Ors – State of Haryana – Criminal Appeal Nos. 5560 – 5561 of 2024 – 2025
INSC 120 – January 29, 2025.

[https://www.sci.gov.in/view-pdf/?diary_no=551212024&type=j&order_date=2025-01-29&from=latest_judgements_order](https://www.sci.gov.in/view-pdf/?diary_no=551212024&type=j&order_date=2025-01-29&from=latest_judgements_order)

[Mahabir & ors vs. State of Haryana – 551212024_2025-01-29](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Mahabir-ors-vs.-State-of-Haryana-551212024_2025-01-29.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Mahabir-ors-vs.-State-of-Haryana-551212024_2025-01-29.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
