# Hostile witness: Trustworthy portions of complainant cannot be eschewed even though he affirmed every suggestion made by the defence

- Link: https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/
- Published: 2026-04-19T13:10:10+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#appeal)
    - [Appeal by state against the judgment of High court acquitting the accused in corruption case](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#appeal-by-state-against-the-judgment-of-high-court-acquitting-the-accused-in-corruption-case)
    - [Demand is for countersign by the TSO](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#demand-is-for-countersign-by-the-tso)
    - [Complaint and pre-trap proceedings](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#complaint-and-pretrap-proceedings)
    - [Trap proceedings](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#trap-proceedings)
    - [High Court’s finding](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#high-courts-finding)
 * [Analysing the judgments submitted by the bar with the facts of the case](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#analysing-the-judgments-submitted-by-the-bar-with-the-facts-of-the-case)
    - [Considering Jayaraj B judgment](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#considering-jayaraj-b-judgment)
    - [Considering Neeraj Dutta judgment](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#considering-neeraj-dutta-judgment)
    - [Complainant helping the accused by affirmed every suggestion made by the defense](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#complainant-helping-the-accused-by-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defense)
    - [Analysing hostile witness position with a judgment in the present case and appreciating the same](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#analysing-hostile-witness-position-with-a-judgment-in-the-present-case-and-appreciating-the-same)
    - [Accused though accepted that the bribe amount was a loan but he did not clearly explain that who is giving to who](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#accused-though-accepted-that-the-bribe-amount-was-a-loan-but-he-did-not-clearly-explain-that-who-is-giving-to-who)
    - [If complainant witness evidence contains inconsistent versions the court must scrutinize and find out is there any creditworthy proof of allegation raised](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#if-complainant-witness-evidence-contains-inconsistent-versions-the-court-must-scrutinize-and-find-out-is-there-any-creditworthy-proof-of-allegation-raised)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#conclusion)
    - [Independent witness got corroborated and hence trial court conviction restored](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#independent-witness-got-corroborated-and-hence-trial-court-conviction-restored)
 * [Resources](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#resources)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-trustworthy-portions-of-complainant-cannot-be-eschewed-even-though-he-affirmed-every-suggestion-made-by-the-defence/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal by state against the judgment of High court acquitting the accused in corruption case**

2. We have before us, divergent findings in a prosecution initiated under Section
7 and 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The [trial court](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
convicted the accused and imposed a sentence of two years both under Section 7 and
Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) to be suffered concurrently along with 
a fine of Rs.10,000 and default sentence under each of the two provisions. The High
Court found that the prevaricating deposition of the complainant who was examined
as PW1 failed to [establish the necessary ingredients to prove offences](https://section1.in/to-prove-dacoity-the-offence-of-robbery-must-first-be-established-in-the-case-on-hand-settlement-between-the-parties-dilutes-the-allegation-of-dishonest-intention-leading-to-dacoity/)
under both the sections; particularly the demand. Placing reliance on the Constitution
Bench decision of this Court in Neeraj Dutta v. State (NCT of Delhi) the accused
was acquitted and the [State is in appeal](https://section1.in/who-can-prefer-the-appeal-against-acquittal-in-the-case-initially-registered-by-state-police-later-transferred-to-cbi-investigation-is-left-open-to-decide-in-a-suitable-case/).

5. The complainant was an Authorized Ration Dealer (ARD) whose activities were subject
to the control and supervision of the Civil Service Department through the Taluk
Supply Office. The ARDs are required to produce the weekly accounts before the Revenue
Inspector (RI) in the Taluk Supply Office and get verified the ‘Abstract’ of the
changes in the ration cards, every three months. The ‘Abstract’ is a copy of a register
maintained at the Taluk Supply Office, kept in the ration shop, which is required
to be verified by the RI and then countersigned by the Taluk Supply Officer (TSO).
The accused was the TSO responsible for the ARD run by the complainant who consistently
refused to countersign the ‘Abstract’ and as per the prosecution case demanded a
[bribe](https://section1.in/defence-of-omission-to-produce-the-currency-notes-in-the-court-was-not-raised-before-the-trial-court-or-in-the-appellate-court-but-only-in-the-slp/)
of Rs.500/- which was handed over pursuant to a trap laid. The High Court found 
that the demand was not established by the [evidence](https://section1.in/no-court-should-allow-a-witness-to-be-contradicted-by-reference-to-the-previous-statement-in-writing-or-reduced-to-writing-unless-the-procedure-set-out-in-section-145-of-the-evidence-act-has-been-foll/)
of PW1 and one of the independent witnesses who had accompanied the complainant 
into the cabin of the TSO, wherein the handing over of the note took place, had 
not been examined; thus creating a lacuna insofar as no direct evidence of a demand
having been adduced. There was also no proof of an offer made by the complainant
to the accused at the time of handing over, which, in the absence of a demand is
a necessary ingredient under Section 7. The demand though alleged to have been made,
the complainant turned hostile at the trial. These were the grounds on which the
[acquittal](https://section1.in/ec-act-on-the-date-of-prosecution-both-the-laws-regarding-cement-were-not-in-operation-hence-unauthorised-storage-of-cement-by-the-accused-is-not-illegal/)
was ordered by the High Court.

##### **Demand is for countersign by the TSO**

6. The deposition of the complainant PW1 in the translation has been read over to
us and that produced by the respondents/accused in the vernacular was read by one
of us (KVC, J.), who is conversant with the language. As per the deposition of PW1
when the ‘Abstract’ was produced before the TSO, who is the accused, identified 
from the dock, he refused to so to do. Again, the TSO refused to countersign the‘
Abstract’ in the next week also when the complainant was informed by other ration
dealers that the TSO would countersign only if he is given a bribe which was specified
to be Rs.500/-. The statement made before the [Vigilance](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-directed-vigilance-to-inquire-about-a-senior-counsel-receiving-rs-50-lakh-as-fees-to-give-judge-to-get-order/)
that there was a demand of Rs.500/- from the accused, when confronted to PW1, though
not denied, the answer was that the complainant was informed that the refusal to
countersign was since he had not given a bribe. There were [inconsistent statements](https://section1.in/contradiction-and-impeaching-the-witness/)
made which we will come to a little later.

##### **Complaint and pre-trap proceedings**

7. The fact that the complainant had approached the vigilance department was not
denied. It was also the statement of PW1 that he had approached the vigilance department
only because he was not willing to bribe the TSO to get the counter signature. The
complaint having been made orally, it was taken down in hand by PW17, who read over
the same to the complainant and the independent witnesses present, which stood confirmed
as correct by PW1, as deposed by PW1. The pre-trap proceedings were in the presence
of the independent witnesses; one an Assistant Engineer of the PWD Special Building
Section and the other a Special Tahsildar, the former of whom was examined as PW2.
PW1 admitted having entrusted a note of Rs.500/- with the Dy.S.P (PW17) for laying
the trap, the details of which were noted in a Mahazar after which the Dy.S.P put
his initials on it. The note was then covered with a powder after which, the effect
of the powder coating on the test solution was demonstrated. The First Information
Statement, which was the complaint taken down by PW17, was marked as Ext.P1 and 
the marked note was marked as M.O 1, before Court.

##### **Trap proceedings**

8. The independent witnesses along with the vigilance team proceeded to the Taluk
Supply Office in two vehicles. The complainant along with the Special Tahsildar,
the independent witness went to the cabin of the TSO and handed over the money. 
The TSO is said to have received the note by his left hand and placed it on the 
right upper drawer of his table. The complainant and the independent witness walked
out, and the complainant raised his hand, which was the pre-arranged signal to the
trap team who rushed into the room led by PW17 and accompanied by PW2, the other
independent witness. The [complainant also followed the trap](https://section1.in/acquittal-trap-case-witness-entered-the-room-only-after-the-complainants-signal-meaning-they-did-not-witness-the-actual-transaction-also-the-amount-was-scattered-in-the-floor-next-to-the-accused/)
team into the cabin of the TSO where he saw the Dy.S.P. securing the hands of the
TSO/the accused. The Dy.S.P. then introduced the independent [witnesses to the accused and asked](https://section1.in/when-chief-examination-of-prosecution-witness-is-being-recorded-presence-of-accused-advocate-is-required-to-object-to-a-leading-or-irrelevant-question-being-asked-to-the-witness/)
the complainant as to where the marked note was placed by the accused. On the complainant
pointing out the drawer in which the note was placed, the independent witnesses 
opened the drawer but found no currency note inside that. On further search, from
the shirt pocket of the accused certain [currency notes were recovered](https://section1.in/investigation-officer-cannot-release-the-case-property-without-any-courts-order-also-currency-recovered-was-not-produced-before-the-court-and-the-court-convicted-without-the-case-property/),
one of which was the marked note handed over by the complainant to the accused. 
The right hand of the accused was immersed in the test solution which did not evoke
any result, but the left hand when immersed into the test solution, it turned pink.
The shirt pocket also, on being sprinkled with the solution, turned pink which the
complainant said he did not remember. There was further currency notes recovered
from the trouser pockets of the accused in excess of that declared by him; which
however is explained as the [proceeds of the sale](https://section1.in/prosecution-has-to-prove-to-whom-a1-has-sold-the-stolen-article-and-obtained-sale-proceeds-of-rs-8000/)
of tickets in connection with a boat race as deposed by PW3, the RI attached to 
the Taluk Supply Office, with which we are not concerned.

##### **High Court’s finding**

9. The acceptance of the marked currency note from the complainant PW1 by the accused,
stands established unequivocally. The pre and post-trap proceedings also were spoken
of by PW1 corroborated by both PW2 and PW17, the independent witness and the lead
trap officer. The finding of the High Court was that the independent [witness](https://section1.in/suggestions-put-to-the-witnesses-are-part-of-the-evidence-based-on-that-suggestions-court-can-convict-the-accused/)
who accompanied the complainant to the cabin of the accused was not examined before
Court. If at all there was an offer or demand of bribe for the purpose of counter
signature at the time of handing over of the bribe it was he who could have deposed
on that fact. The prosecution, in any event did not have a case that there was any
offer made by PW1 pursuant to which the note was handed over. Thus, there was no
case of any offer made by the bribe giver which along with the proof of acceptance
of money could have enabled a presumption under [Section](https://section1.in/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/)
20 of the Act, to bring in the guilt of the accused under Section 7 of the Act. 
As far as the demand is concerned, there were prevaricating statements made by the
witness, which absolved the accused, was the finding of the High Court. Before looking
at the deposition of the witness, we would look at the decisions relied on.

#### **Analysing the judgments submitted by the bar with the facts of the case**

##### **Considering Jayaraj B judgment**

10. Jayaraj B as relied on by the learned Senior Counsel for the accused was a [case in which the complainant disowned the very complaint](https://section1.in/pmla-section-88-cr-p-c-an-order-accepting-bonds-under-section-88-cr-p-c-from-the-accused-does-not-amount-to-a-grant-of-bail-a-detailed-discussion-on-arrest-summons-warrant-bail-and-bond-under/)
and stated in his deposition that the amount paid to the accused was with a request
to deposit it with the bank as a fee for renewal of his license. The complainant
having disowned the very complaint made by him and there being no other evidence
available, the [prosecution failed to bring home the offence under Section](https://section1.in/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/)
7, by the mere possession and recovery of the currency notes from the accused. The
use of an illegal means and abuse of public office to obtain a pecuniary advantage
also was held to be not established which is required to [prove the offence under Section](https://section1.in/how-to-prove-section-7-p-c-act-explained/)
13(1)(d)(i)&(ii) of the Act. **Immediately, we have to observe that the facts here
are quite distinct since the complaint is admitted, the pre and post trap proceedings
are spoken to by the complainant and corroborated by one of the independent witnesses**.
Section 161 statement made by PW1, of the TSO having enquired as to whether the 
money was brought, confronted to PW1 by the prosecution in [cross examination](https://section1.in/pocso-since-section-29-of-the-act-necessitates-the-accused-to-rebut-the-case-it-is-just-to-recall-the-witness-for-cross-examination/)
was denied. Probably the [examination of the other independent witness](https://section1.in/witness-did-not-name-any-person-from-the-locality-who-had-seen-the-incident-and-not-a-single-witness-from-the-locality-was-examined-who-had-seen-the-incident/),
who accompanied PW1 to the cabin of the accused, would have led to credible evidence
regarding the demand at the time the money was handed over. But that is not to say
that the demand could not have been inferred otherwise from the deposition of PW1.

##### **Considering Neeraj Dutta judgment**

11. Neeraj Dutta in fact arose from a reference made with respect to divergent opinions
of three Judge Benches, one of which as per the reference order was in Jayaraj B.
Jayaraj B was eventually approved, but on [distinct facts](https://section1.in/there-cannot-be-a-discovery-of-an-already-discovered-fact-discovery-should-be-of-a-distinct-fact-from-the-facts-already-discovered/)
as we found earlier. Neeraj Dutta having considered the various decisions found 
that in establishing illegal gratification by a public servant, an offence under
Section 7 is made out if there is an offer to pay, by the bribe giver, without there
being any demand by the public servant who is proved to have accepted and received
the illegal gratification**. This ingredient on facts is absent in the [present case](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/)
and so was the demand at the time of handing over denied by PW1. Neeraj Dutta held
that proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification by a public servant
as a fact in issue is a sine qua non in order to establish the guilt of the public
servant under Section 7 and 13(1)(d) of the Act. Hence our enquiry is confined as
to whether the demand has been made, since the complaint, laying of the trap and
what transpired at the trap including the acceptance of the bribe is proved beyond
reasonable doubt**.

##### **Complainant helping the accused by affirmed every suggestion made by the defense**

12. As far as the demand is concerned, true, PW1 prevaricated in his deposition 
though the complaint was that a specific demand of Rs.500/- was made for the purpose
of counter signing the ‘Abstract’. PW1, the complainant, deposed that it was his
inference that twice when the TSO, the accused, failed to countersign the ‘Abstract’,
it was for the purpose of taking a bribe which was said to be spoken of by the other
ration dealers also. **As is noticed by the High Court, in cross-examination the
complainant affirmed every suggestion made by the defense. This is clearly with 
the purpose of helping the accused, especially looking at the contents of the chief-
examination**.

##### **Analysing hostile witness position with a judgment in the present case and appreciating the same**

13. We pause here to notice that the Constitution Bench in Neeraj Dutta had specifically
dealt with the efficacy of the deposition of hostile witnesses. It referred with
approval to Sat Paul v. Delhi Administration wherein it was held:

> “52. From the above conspectus, it emerges clear that even in a [criminal prosecution](https://section1.in/anticipatory-bail-civil-claims-being-settled-by-pressurising-through-criminal-prosecution-discouraged/)
> when a witness is cross-examined and contradicted with the leave of the court,
> by the party calling him, his evidence cannot, as a matter of law, be treated 
> as washed off the record altogether. It is for the Judge of fact to consider in
> each case whether as a result of such crossexamination and contradiction, the 
> witness stands thoroughly discredited or can still be believed in regard to a 
> part of his testimony. **If the Judge finds that in the process, the credit of
> the witness has not been completely shaken, he may, after reading and considering
> the evidence of the witness, as a whole, with due caution and care, accept, in
> the light of the other evidence on the record, that part of his testimony which
> he finds to be creditworthy and act upon it**. If in a given case, the whole of
> the testimony of the witness is impugned, and in the process, the witness stands
> squarely and totally discredited, the Judge should as a matter of prudence, discard
> his evidence in toto.” [underlining supplied for emphasis]

14. **With this in mind, as a matter of prudence, every court considering the deposition
of a hostile witness has to look at the extent of the deposition, which is creditworthy
to provide proof, of the [case set](https://section1.in/quash-sc-st-and-section-307-ipc-case-set-up-by-the-prosecution-does-not-reveal-the-offences/)
up**. PW1 in his evidence spoke of the refusal of the TSO to countersign the ‘Abstract’,
which the ARD is liable to maintain in his shop. PW1 was specifically confronted
with a statement that the demand of Rs.500/- was made by the accused for the purpose
of passing the card register which was the statement made by him before the Vigilance
Department; which though not denied, he stated he did not remember. He was then 
specifically confronted with a statement from his complaint that on and 20.07.2009,
the accused had demanded an amount of Rs.500/-, which he affirmed and followed up
with the statement that he had gone to the vigilance office to hand over the money.
He spoke of the complaint having been given before PW17, Dy.S.P, and at that time,
there were three to five people present there. He confirmed that the two independent
witnesses, the Special Tahsildar and the Assistant Engineer were present at that
time. The prosecution put a specific question as to [whether the statements made](https://section1.in/whether-statement-or-letter-made-to-the-investigation-officer-i-o-during-the-investigation-is-admissible-no/),
taken down and read over to him were confirmed as truthful before the witnesses,
which was affirmed by him before Court. His specific answer was that he was asked
whether the statements made were correct and he confirmed it. Ext. P1 complaint 
was confronted to him and he gave an evasive answer that whatever was in his memory
he had stated to be correct. Yet another question was put to him that Ext. P1 speaks
about the accused having twice demanded money from him. He confirmed that he had
stated so to the independent witnesses. A further statement made in Ext. P1 that
he endorsed the complaint fully to the independent witnesses as truthful was also
affirmed by him.

**Trustworthy portions of complainant cannot be eschewed even though he affirmed
every suggestion made by the defence**

15. PW2 who was the independent witness spoke of he being summoned to the vigilance
office by 9:30 in the morning. On reaching there he found the Special Tahsildar 
also present there along with the Dy.S.P. and the complainant who were introduced.
PW1 made an oral complaint which was taken down by the Dy.S.P. and PW1 confirmed
to the independent witnesses that what has been stated by him and later read over
were correct. The further trap proceedings regarding the marking of note and so 
on were spoken of as deposed by PW1 itself. PW17 also spoke of the complaint having
been made by PW1 in the presence of the independent witness, orally, which he had
taken down and read over to the complainant in the presence of the witnesses. Ext.
P1 confronted to PW17 was further proved to be the FIS as recorded by PW17 on the
oral recital by PW1. The statements made in Ext. P1 having been affirmed by PW1,
his further statements regarding his inference, personal feelings and the denial
of various statements in the Section 161 statement regarding the demand, pales into
insignificance**. ****So much of the evidence of PW1 is creditworthy and despite
PW1 having accepted every suggestion made by the defense in the cross examination,
the credible portion cannot be eschewed. True, PW1 prevaricated, but so much of 
the facts brought out by the prosecution on his examination brings forth a demand
having been made by the accused to the complainant. The earlier demand, hence, stands
established despite the non-examination of the other independent witness who could
have only spoken of what transpired in the course of the trap.**

##### **Accused though accepted that the bribe amount was a loan but he did not clearly explain that who is giving to who**

16. **We also have to emphasize that the acceptance of the Rs.500/- note is not 
only established but also [admitted by the accused.](https://section1.in/acquittal-section-306-114-ipc-unless-the-accused-admitted-the-handwriting-report-the-expert-should-be-examined-to-prove-the-handwriting-opinion-report/)**
In the cross-examination of PW1, a suggestion was made that PW1 was returning the
amount taken as a loan from the accused through one Swayam Prakash; denied by PW1.
However, under Section 313 the response as extracted by the [trial court](https://section1.in/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-6-general-introduction-to-inquiries-and-trials-part-4-criminal-courts-powers-administration/)
indicates that the complainant had entrusted Rs.500/- to the TSO for handing it 
over to one Swayam Prakash, working in the same office as Office Attendant. Swayam
Prakash examined as PW8 turned hostile and did not have a consistent case and his
evidence was that he had borrowed money from PW1 and there was no reason for PW1
to borrow money from him.** Though the accused is entitled to take inconsistent 
stances in defense, the explanation offered for accepting the amount cannot validly
lead to a rebuttal, if the suggestion made and explanation offered are contrary 
and the subject of the alleged loan itself having spoken yet otherwise in his evidence.
The false explanation given by the [accused insofar as the acceptance](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
is another compelling circumstance pointing to the guilt of the accused**.

##### **If complainant witness evidence contains inconsistent versions the court must scrutinize and find out is there any creditworthy proof of allegation raised**

17. In fact, the High Court has noticed various portions in the deposition of PW1
where he admits the demand, especially certain portions of Ext. P1. The demeanor
of the witness in the box, as discernible from the evidence recorded, especially
his hesitance to make an answer immediately on a question being asked was also noticed
by the High Court. The evidence of PW2, it was observed by the High Court, was not
[impeached](https://section1.in/impeachment-proceedings-and-role-of-lawyers/) by
a shred in the cross-examination by the defense. Despite these observations, the
High Court chose to find no demand having been established; according to us erroneously.
The [evidence of PW1 was pock marked](https://section1.in/literature-on-secondary-evidence-judgment-explaining-statutory-procedure-to-introduce-mark-and-appreciate-secondary-evidence/)
with inconsistent versions, but it is for the court to scrutinize the same and find
out whether there is anything creditworthy enabling proof of the allegation raised,
which was done by the trial court.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Independent witness got corroborated and hence trial court conviction restored**

18. Herein the demand was raised as a complaint before the vigilance and the statements
to that extent made in the complainant before the Vigilance Officer in the presence
of independent witnesses were affirmed by the complainant when he was examined as
PW1, which PW2 the independent witness fully corroborated. This was further corroborated
by the Vigilance Officer, the lead trap officer PW17, who wrote down the allegations
on the oral complaint of PW1. He also spoke of the complaint having been read over
to the complainant who confirmed it to himself; the scribe, and the independent 
witnesses present. We allow the appeal [setting aside the order](https://section1.in/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/)
of the High Court and restoring the order of the trial court. Considering the fact
that the [sentence awarded](https://section1.in/section-304a-ipc-awarding-sentence-under-section-304-a-ipc-is-not-mandatory/)
is the statutory minimum for the offences we find no reason to tinker with the same.

#### **Resources**

**Judgments cited or involved**

 * Neeraj Dutta v. State (NCT of Delhi) [(2023) 4 SCC 731]: This Constitution Bench
   decision was centrally discussed to establish that proof of demand and acceptance
   of illegal gratification is a _sine qua non_ for conviction under the Prevention
   of Corruption Act. The [Court noted](https://section1.in/once-the-high-court-noted-multiple-injuries-on-the-deceaseds-body-there-was-no-reason-to-grant-bail-to-the-accused/)
   that under this precedent, demand can be proved by circumstantial evidence if
   direct evidence is unavailable.
 * Jayaraj B. v. State of Andhra Pradesh [(2014) 13 SCC 55]: The respondent relied
   on this case to argue that mere recovery of currency notes is insufficient for
   conviction without proof of demand. The Court distinguished this case because,
   unlike in _Jayaraj B._, the complainant here admitted to the [initial complaint and the trap proceedings](https://section1.in/limitation-section-468-cr-p-c-applies-for-both-cases-instituted-upon-a-complaint-or-by-a-police-report-what-matters-is-the-date-of-initiation-of-criminal-proceedings/)
   were corroborated.
 * Sat Paul v. Delhi Administration [(1976) 1 SCC 727]: Cited regarding the efficacy
   of testimony from a hostile witness. The Court reaffirmed that a witness’s evidence
   is not entirely “washed off the record” just because they are declared hostile;
   the judge can still believe and act upon parts of the testimony that appear creditworthy.
 * P. Satyanarayana Murthy v. District Inspector of Police [(2015) 10 SCC 152]: 
   Mentioned in the context of the _Neeraj Dutta_ reference as a precedent emphasizing
   the necessity of proving demand.
 * M. Narsinga Rao v. State of A.P. [(2001) 1 SCC 691]: Referenced as an earlier
   view on the circumstantial proof of demand that contributed to the legal conflict
   resolved in _Neeraj Dutta_.

**Acts and Sections**

 * [Prevention of Corruption Act](https://section1.in/terrorist-act-bail-is-a-fundamental-right-under-article-21-of-the-constitution-even-for-unlawful-activities-prevention-act-1967-shoma-kanti-sen/),
   1988: This is the primary legislation under which the prosecution was initiated.
 * Section 7, Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988: Concerns [public servants](https://section1.in/records-maintained-by-the-private-school-is-public-documents-and-the-head-master-principal-is-not-public-servant/)
   taking gratification other than legal remuneration in respect of an official 
   act.
 * Section 13(1)(d), Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988: [Relates to criminal misconduct by a public servant](https://section1.in/pc-act-mere-registration-of-disproportionate-assets-in-the-name-of-public-servants-relative-or-friend-does-not-make-that-person-guilty-of-abetment-dissenting-version-in-judgment/)
   through the use of corrupt or illegal means.
 * Section 13(2), Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988: Specifies the punishment for
   any public servant who commits criminal misconduct.
 * Section 20, Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988: Deals with the presumption where
   [public servants accept](https://section1.in/prosecution-has-to-establish-the-existence-of-demand-as-well-as-acceptance-by-the-public-servant-to-prove-sections-7-131d-of-p-c-act/)
   gratification other than legal remuneration.
 * Section 161, [Code of Criminal Procedure](https://section1.in/bail-ability-of-section-3513-of-the-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-2023-do-colonial-era-notifications-survive-the-new-criminal-procedure-code/),
   1973: Referenced regarding the examination of witnesses by police and the use
   of their prior statements during the trial.
 * Section 313, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973: Relates to the power of the [court to examine the accused to explain any circumstances](https://section1.in/in-exceptional-circumstances-the-court-may-grant-anticipatory-bail-to-an-absconder-but-a-co-accuseds-acquittal-does-not-ipso-facto-entitle-him-to-a-b-relief/)
   appearing in the evidence against them.

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    The State of Kerala vs. K.A. Abdul Rasheed - Criminal Appeal No. 1956 of 2026 (@Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 1808 of 2026) - 2026 INSC 365 - April 15, 2026 - Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar and Hon'ble Mr. Justice K. Vinod Chandran.
    ```

[The State of Kerala vs. K.A.Abdul Rasheed – 182_2026_12_1501_70123_Judgement_15-Apr-2026](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/The-State-of-Kerala-vs.-K.A.Abdul-Rasheed-182_2026_12_1501_70123_Judgement_15-Apr-2026.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/The-State-of-Kerala-vs.-K.A.Abdul-Rasheed-182_2026_12_1501_70123_Judgement_15-Apr-2026.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [Permission to cross-examine (hostile) the witness by the party calling should be given only in special cases](https://section1.in/permission-to-cross-examine-hostile-the-witness-by-the-party-calling-should-be-given-only-in-special-cases/)
 * [Part departure in chief-examination is not necessary to declare the entire witness as hostile](https://section1.in/part-departure-in-chief-examination-is-not-necessary-to-declare-the-entire-witness-as-hostile/)
 * [Appreciation of hostile witness explained [A must carry judgment by prosecutors]](https://section1.in/appreciation-of-hostile-witness-explained-a-must-carry-judgment-by-prosecutors/)
 * [Hostile witness contradiction: Public Prosecutor has to confront relevant portions to the witness and contradict as required by section 145 IEA](https://section1.in/hostile-witness-contradiction-public-prosecutor-has-to-confront-relevant-portions-to-the-witness-and-contradict-as-required-by-section-145-iea/)
 * [Hostile & won over: Since there is a long gap between the Chief and cross-examination it appears that the witnesses were won over and confirmed the conviction](https://section1.in/hostile-won-over-since-there-is-a-long-gap-between-the-chief-and-cross-examination-it-appears-that-the-witnesses-were-won-over-and-confirmed-the-conviction/)
