# Sanction: How sanctioning authority shall examine the case presented before him?

- Link: https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/
- Published: 2023-06-13T05:14:21+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Facts](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/#facts)
 * [Section 18 (c) of Drugs and Cosmetics Act 1940](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/#section-18-c-of-drugs-and-cosmetics-act-1940)
 * [Sanction](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/#sanction)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/#party)

##### **Facts**

2. The Appellant before this Court is a registered medical practitioner who is presently
working as an Associate Professor and the Head of Dermatology Department, in the
Government Omandurar Medical College, Chennai. In the past, she has held the post
of Assistant Professor and Civil Surgeon at Royapettah Medical College. It is permissible
for her under the law to practice medicine when she is not performing her official
duties. The Appellant, in her individual and independent capacity was carrying on
her medical practice at a premises which is No. 87, Red Hills Road (North), Villivakkam,
at Chennai. It is here that she could be consulted and where she meets and examines
her patients.

3. An inspection was made on the above premises by the Drugs Inspector, Villivakkam
Range on 16.03.2016. As per inspection report, the Drugs Inspector found some medicines
in the inner room of her premises.

4. The Drugs Inspector thereafter moved an application for obtaining **[sanction](http://localhost:8080/section1/sanction-manufacturing-or-fabrication-of-public-documents-and-records-cannot-be-a-part-of-the-official-duty-of-a-public-servant-hence-sanction-not-required/)**
from the office of the Director of Drugs Control, Tamil Nadu, Chennai on 22.09.2016
which was given to him on 23.01.2018. Consequently, the Drugs Inspector filed a 
complaint before the Court of X Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, for prosecuting
the Appellant under Section 18(c) of the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 punishable
under Section 27(b)(ii) of the Act.

5. Aggrieved by these proceedings, the Appellant filed an application under Section
482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 before the High **[Court of Madras for quashing the criminal](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-cannot-return-final-report/)**
proceedings. Her petition was dismissed by the Ld. Single Judge on 21.06.2022. Aggrieved
by this, the Appellant has filed **[Special Leave Petition before this Court](http://localhost:8080/section1/s-c-quashed-g-o-of-tamilnadu-for-anti-land-grabbing-cell-and-adviced-to-enact-appropriate-legislation-for-land-grabbing-cases/)**
against the order of the Single Judge.

##### **Section 18 (c) of Drugs and Cosmetics Act 1940**

7. As we can see the prohibition under Section 18(c) is on the manufacturing, distribution,
stocking or exhibition of medicines for the purposes of sale. The charge in the 
present case is that the Appellant had “stocked” medicines for “sale”. The entire
emphasis is on “sale” of these medicines. This is evident from the sanction being
sought by the Drug Inspector from the office of the Director, Drugs Control, Tamil
Nadu wherein as per the sanction letter dated 23.01.2018, he had said that the Appellant
be prosecuted for the contravention of:

“Section 18(c) of Drugs and Cosmetics Act 1940 for having ∙stocked drugs for sale
and sold the drugs without having a valid drug license, which is punishable under
section 27(b)(ii) of the said Act”.

Thus, as per the prosecution she had stocked the drugs and sold them. What the Director
of Drugs Control and the High Court lost sight of is the fact that the Appellant
is a registered medical practitioner, her area of specialization being dermatology.
She has an M.D. (DVL) degree in this specialisation. It is not a case that she had
opened a shop in her premises from where she was selling drugs and cosmetics across
the counter! It is possible that she was distributing these drugs to her patients
for emergency uses and thus she is protected by the Act itself. Schedule (K) which
is a part of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945 provides an exemption which we 
shall examine hereafter.

xxx

8. Under Section 33 of the Act, the Central Government can make rules which have
to be laid before the Parliament for its ratification under Section 38 of the Act.
These rules have been framed which is known as Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1940. 
Rule 123 of the rules exempts certain drugs from the provisions of Chapter IV of
the Act (which includes both Section 18 and Section 27 referred above, which are
penal provisions), under certain conditions Rule 123 reads as under:

“123. The drugs specified in Schedule K shall be exempted from the provisions of
Chapter IV of the Act and the rules made thereunder to the extent and subject to
the conditions specified in that Schedule.”

Entry No. 5 under Schedule (K) are the drugs which are supplied by a registered 
medical practitioner with which we are presently concerned.

…

It is not the **[case of the prosecution](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-dowry-death-cases-prosecution-has-to-prove-the-initial-burden/)**
that the Appellant was selling drugs from an open shop across the counter. She is
a senior doctor who is engaged as an Associate Professor and Head of Department,
Dermatology in a Government Medical College, and being a medical practitioner, under
certain conditions, she is also protected under the law which has been referred 
to above.

9. Considering the small quantity of medicines, most of which are in the category
of lotions and ointments, it cannot be said by any stretch of imagination that such
medicines could be ‘stocked’ for sale and would come in the category of stocking
of medicines for the purpose of sale. When small quantity of medicine has been found
in the premises of a registered medical practitioner, it would not amount to selling
their medicines across the counter in an open shop. In fact, this is not even the
allegation against the Appellant. Undoubtedly, the provisions of Section 18 and 
27 are relevant provisions under the law, which have a social purpose, which is 
to protect ordinary citizens from being exploited inter alia, by unethical medical
practitioners, and for this reason the punishment under Section 27 can extend up
to 5 years under the law, and has a minimum punishment of 3 years. But given the
facts and circumstances of the case and considering that the Appellant is a registered
medical practitioner, along with the fact that the quantity of medicines which have
been seized is extremely small, a quantity which can be easily found in the house
or a consultation room of a doctor, in our considered view no offence is made out
in the present case. In fact, an exception has been created under Schedule ‘K’ read
with Rule 123 to the rules, the appellant ought to have been given the benefit of
these provisions and such a registered medical practitioner should not have been
allowed to face a trial where in all likelihood the prosecution would have failed
to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.

10. But what the High Court failed to consider, however, is the provisions contained
in Rule 123 read with Schedule ‘K’ to the 1945 Rules and when admittedly it is not
the case of the prosecution that the drugs which were seized were being sold in 
an open shop across the counter. Since this was not being done as visualized above,
and an exception is created under the law in favour of the medical practitioner 
where the drugs given in Schedule ‘K’ would be exempted from the purview of Chapter
4 of the Act, we are of the considered view that prosecution against the Appellant
is unwarranted.

xxx

##### **Sanction**

13. Another factor which must be considered is that the search was carried out on
16.03.2016 and sanction for prosecution was sought on 22.09.2016 and the sanction
ultimately was given on 23.01.2018. There is no explanation which has been given
for this delay in getting the approval. In the recently decided case of Hasmukhlal
D. Vohra and Anr. v. State of Tamil Nadu [2022 SCC OnLine SC 1732], criminal proceedings
were quashed against a Petitioner on the grounds that the substance in question 
was not a drug under Indian Pharmacopoeia.

14. The sanction for prosecution given in the present case appears, **[prima facie](http://localhost:8080/section1/high-court-has-granted-bail-without-contemplating-statements-recorded-u-s-161-and-164-cr-p-c-for-considering-prima-facie-in-grave-offences/),**
to suffer from the vice of nonapplication of mind. There is no reference to any 
of the documents, evidence or the submissions submitted by either of the parties,
no reasons assigned or even an explanation pertaining to the delay which indicates
it has been passed in a mechanical manner. This Court in the case of Mansukhlal 
Vithaldas Chauhan v. State of Gujarat [(1997) 7 SCC 622], highlighted the importance
of a prior sanction granted under Section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 while quashing the criminal proceedings instituted against a Divisional Accountant
engaged with the Medium Irrigation Project Division, Gujarat.
 15. The possession
of the drugs is not disputed in this case by either side. However, this Court in
the case of Mohd. Shabir v. State of Maharashtra[(1979) 1 SCC 568] while allowing
an appeal in part and directing the release of an Appellant who had been prosecuted
under the provision 18(c) of the 1940 Act, this Court observed that possession simpliciter
would not itself be an offence but the **[prosecution had to prove the essential ingredient under Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/prosecution-has-to-establish-the-existence-of-demand-as-well-as-acceptance-by-the-public-servant-to-prove-sections-7-131d-of-p-c-act/)**
27 which was that even a ‘stock’ of the medicine was for sale. It was observed as
follows:

‘4. …We, therefore, hold that before a person can be liable for prosecution or conviction
under Section 27(a)(i)(ii) read with Section 18(c) of the Act, it must be proved
by the prosecution affirmatively that he was manufacturing the drugs for sale or
was selling the same or had stocked them or exhibited the articles for sale. The
possession simpliciter of the articles does not appear to be punishable under any
of the provisions of the Act. If, therefore, the essential ingredients of Section
27 are not satisfied the plea of guilty cannot lead the Court to convict the appellant.’

16. The sanctioning authority had not **[examined at all whether a practising doctor](http://localhost:8080/section1/dying-declaration-witness-who-recorded-the-dying-declaration-must-state-in-his-chief-examination-that-the-doctor-examined-the-deceased-before-giving-fitness-certificate/)**
could be prosecuted under the facts of the case, considering the small quantity 
of the drugs and the exception created in favour of medical practitioner under Rule
123, read with the Schedule “K”. All these factors ought to have been considered
by the sanctioning authority. Under these circumstances we allow this appeal and
set aside the order of the learned Single Judge of the Madras High Court and quash
the criminal proceedings in Criminal Case No. 7135 of 2018 on the file of X Metropolitan
Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai.

##### **Party**

**S. ATHILAKSHMI vs THE STATE REP. BY THE DRUGS INSPECTOR – CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 
OF 2023 (@ SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) No.9978 OF 2022) -March 15, 2023**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/29229/29229_2022_11_1501_42840_Judgement_15-Mar-2023.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/29229/29229_2022_11_1501_42840_Judgement_15-Mar-2023.pdf)**

**[athilakshmi vs. the state – doctor case](https://demonew.section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/athilakshmi-vs.-the-state-doctor-case.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
