# Judgment: Court cannot convict one accused and acquit the other for the similar or identical evidence in a case

- Link: https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/
- Published: 2024-09-24T18:45:18+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appellant against the conviction on Passport Act and IPC](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#appellant-against-the-conviction-on-passport-act-and-ipc)
 * [Appellant had wrongfully and illegally facilitated and obtained a second passport for accused no.1](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#appellant-had-wrongfully-and-illegally-facilitated-and-obtained-a-second-passport-for-accused-no1)
 * [Discussion And Finding](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#discussion-and-finding)
 * [Conviction based on three witnesses](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#conviction-based-on-three-witnesses)
 * [For lack of direct evidence accused 3 and 4 were acquitted](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#for-lack-of-direct-evidence-accused-3-and-4-were-acquitted)
 * [Court cannot convict one accused and acquit the other for the similar or identical evidence in a case](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case)
 * [Section 12(2) of Passports Act](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#section-122-of-passports-act)
 * [Prosecution failed to prove that the appellant had knowingly furnished false information to the passport authorities](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#prosecution-failed-to-prove-that-the-appellant-had-knowingly-furnished-false-information-to-the-passport-authorities)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/judgment-court-cannot-convict-one-accused-and-acquit-the-other-for-the-similar-or-identical-evidence-in-a-case/#further-study)

##### **Appellant against the conviction on Passport Act and IPC**

1. The appellant who has been arraigned as accused No.2 has challenged the concurrent
conviction and sentence ordered under Section 420 Indian Penal Code (for short ‘
IPC’) read with Section 12(2) of the Passports Act, 1967 (herein after referred 
as ‘Passports Act’) and sentenced to one-year rigorous imprisonment for each of 
the offences which are to run concurrently.

##### **Appellant had wrongfully and illegally facilitated and obtained a second passport for accused no.1**

2. The short and long of prosecution story is that appellant had wrongfully and 
illegally facilitated accused No. 1, for obtaining a second passport, who was already
holding an Indian passport. It was further alleged that accused No.1 having deposited
his passport with his employer at Dubai had applied for second passport in order
to have better employment opportunities and said application was forwarded / routed
through the appellant. The prosecution alleged that second passport which was issued
and dispatched to Accused No.1 had been returned undelivered to the Passport Office
Trichy and was kept in safe custody and later it was delivered to the appellant 
by accused No.3 who was in charge of safe custody of the passports through accused
No.4 who was working as a casual labourer in the Passport Office. It was also alleged
that appellant had demanded payment of Rs.5,000/- from accused No.1 for handing 
over the passport and he having refused resulted in appellant returning the second
passport to the Passport Office by registered post.

3. Along with the appellant other accused persons namely Mr. J.Joseph (Accused No.
1), Smt. Sasikala (Accused No.3) – in charge of safe custody of passports, Mr. P.
Manisekar (Accused No.4) working as a casual labour in the Passport Office, Trichy
and Mr. S. Raghupathy (Accused No.5) then working as an Upper Division Clerk in 
Passport Office, Trichy who had made an endorsement that no passport had earlier
been issued in favour of Accused No.1 were also tried for the **[offences punishable under Section120B read with Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)**
420 of IPC, Section 12(1)(b), 12(2) of Passports Act and Section 13(2) and Section
13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 before the Special Judge for CBI 
cases, Madurai, which resulted in acquittal of all the accused persons in respect
of charge of conspiracy. Accused Nos.3 and 4 were acquitted of all other charges
also. The CBI did not prefer any appeal against acquittal of accused Nos.3 and 4.
However, accused Nos.1 and 2 were convicted for offences punishable under Section
420 IPC and Section 12(1)(b) and Section 12(2) of Passports Act respectively. Accused
No.5 was convicted under Section 12(2) of Passports Act and Section 13(2) and 13(
1)(d) of the **[Prevention of Corruption Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/terrorist-act-bail-is-a-fundamental-right-under-article-21-of-the-constitution-even-for-unlawful-activities-prevention-act-1967-shoma-kanti-sen/)**,
1988. Accused Nos.1, 2 and 5 preferred criminal appeals challenging their conviction
and sentence and by impugned common judgment the High Court allowed the appeals 
filed by accused Nos.1 and 5 and acquitted them and said judgment has attained finality
as it has not been challenged by the CBI. However, the appeal filed by accused No.
2 came to be dismissed and as such she is before this Court.

##### **Discussion And Finding**

7. The case of the prosecution as noted herein above is that appellant had illegally
facilitated the issuance of second passport in favour of accused No.1 or in other
words accused No.1 who held an Indian Passport had deposited the same with his employer
at Dubai and in search of better employment opportunities had clandestinely applied
for second passport through the appellant and other accused persons had connived
with the appellant in procuring second passport to Accused No.1.

##### **Conviction based on three witnesses**

8. The conviction of appellant is based on the deposition of three witnesses namely
PW-3 (Selvi Sakila Begum), PW-15(Mr. Selvaraj), and PW-16 (Mr. Ravi). PW-3 is an
employee of the proprietorship firm of appellant i.e. Kamatchi Travels and in her
examination-in-chief she has deposed that she was working in the said travels which
was offering various services including facilitating and obtaining the passports.
She has further deposed that as the firm in which she was working could not render
such services directly and the applications of their customers for issuance of passports
were routed through Eagle Travels run by PW-15. She has also deposed that the application
of accused No.1 was filled by her. However, she had turned hostile and nothing worthwhile
was elicited in her cross-examination except to the extent of her admission that
appellant was sitting next to her while she was filling the application form of 
accused No.1. She does not depose that appellant had any knowledge of Accused No.
1 was already possessing a passport or appellant having informed her about the passport
already held by Accused No.1.

##### **For lack of direct evidence accused 3 and 4 were acquitted**

9. PW-15 (Mr. Selvaraj) who is the proprietor of Eagle Travels has deposed that 
the application Ex.P-7 for issuance of passport in favour of accused No.1 was submitted
through his firm and it was received from the appellant and appellant had paid the
registration fee. PW-16 (Mr. Ravi), the Principal Scientific Advisor of Central 
Forensic Sciences Laboratory who has been examined by prosecution to drive home 
the fact that hand writing found on the returned postal cover is that of the appellant,
though had deposed that there are similarities in the writings has also admitted
that it is not possible for him to express any opinion in that regard on the basis
of material on hand. It is pertinent to note at this juncture that prosecution had
contended that accused No.3 who was in charge of safe custody of returned passports
in the Passport Office had illegally removed the returned passport of accused No.
1 from safe custody and had handed over the same to the appellant through accused
No.4. However, trial court has not accepted this version of the prosecution and 
had acquitted accused Nos.3 and 4. The prosecution had failed to place on record
any evidence to establish as to the how the passport kept in the safe custody had
gone missing and in what manner it was handed over to the appellant or appellant
in turn having returned the same back to Passport Office by post. Thus, for lack
of direct **[evidence the accused](http://localhost:8080/section1/case-diary-section-1723-cr-p-c-the-accused-has-a-right-to-cross-examine-police-officer-as-per-section-145-evidence-act-whenever-the-police-officer-uses-it-to-refresh-his-memory/)**
No.3 and 4 have been acquitted.

##### **Court cannot convict one accused and acquit the other for the similar or identical evidence in a case**

10. The Court cannot convict one accused and acquit the other when there is** [similar or identical evidence pitted against two accused persons](http://localhost:8080/section1/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)**.
In the case of Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi v State of Gujarat reported in 2023 INSC
829, this court has held that:

> “15. When there is similar or identical evidence of eyewitnesses against two accused
> by ascribing them the same or similar role, the [**Court cannot convict one accused and acquit**](http://localhost:8080/section1/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)
> the other. In such a case, the cases of both the accused will be governed by the
> principle of parity. This principle means that the **[Criminal Court should decide like cases](http://localhost:8080/section1/understanding-the-police-report-investigation-and-magistrates-duties-in-criminal-cases/)**
> alike, and in such cases, the Court cannot make a distinction between the two 
> accused, which will amount to discrimination.’’

##### **Section 12(2) of Passports Act**

In the case on hand, allegations against the appellant being the same as made against
Accused No.3 & 4, the Courts below could not have convicted the Appellant while 
acquitting the other two.

14. Appellant has also been charged for the offence punishable under Section 12(
2) of the Passports Act, 1967 which reads as under:

“………………….”

It is needless to state that burden is cast on the prosecution to prove that the
appellant had knowingly furnished false information or supressing known material
information with the intent of securing a passport or travel document to a **[person and thereby had abetted in the commission of offence](http://localhost:8080/section1/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/)**
punishable under Section 12(1) and thereby punishable under Section 12(2) of the
Passports Act.

##### **Prosecution failed to prove that the appellant had knowingly furnished false information to the passport authorities**

15. In the [**case on hand the prosecution failed to place any evidence**](http://localhost:8080/section1/case-diary-section-1723-cr-p-c-the-accused-has-a-right-to-cross-examine-police-officer-as-per-section-145-evidence-act-whenever-the-police-officer-uses-it-to-refresh-his-memory/)
to prove that the appellant had prior information of accused No.1 was already possessing
a passport or knowingly had furnished false information to the passport authorities
namely after knowing that accused No.1 had possessed or holding a passport was applying
for second passport or having known the fact of accused No.1 possessing the passport
was applying for the second passport and thereby there has been suppression of material
information. In other words, the prosecution had failed to place on record any evidence
to **[prove that appellant had any previous knowledge of accused](http://localhost:8080/section1/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)**
No.1 was already possessing a passport. In the absence of any cogent evidence placed
in this regard and accused Nos. 1 and 3 to 5 having been acquitted of the offences
alleged, the conviction and order of sentence imposed against the appellant alone
cannot be sustained or in other words it has to be held that prosecution had failed
to **[prove the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable](http://localhost:8080/section1/prosecution-not-proved-the-murder-case-beyond-reasonable-doubt/)**
doubt.

16. For the reasons afore-stated the appeal succeeds and appellantaccused No.2 is
acquitted of the offences alleged against her. The judgment of the **[Trial Court](http://localhost:8080/section1/suo-moto-guidelines-common-practice-and-procedure-in-criminal-trials-all-over-india/)**
passed in C.C. No.5 of 2007 as affirmed in C.A.(Md) No.203 of 2008 by the High Court
of Madras at Madurai Bench dated 18.08.2011 are hereby **[set aside](http://localhost:8080/section1/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/).**

17. The bail bonds of the appellant stands cancelled. The appeal stands allowed 
in the above terms.

##### **Party**

Yogarani … Appellant(s) versus State by the Inspector of Police …Respondent(S) –
Criminal Appeal No. 477 of 2017 – September 23 , 2024 – 2024 INSC 721

**[https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=298592011&type=j&order_date=2024-09-23&from=latest_judgements_order](https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=298592011&type=j&order_date=2024-09-23&from=latest_judgements_order)**

**[Yogarani vs. State by Inspector of Police 298592011_2024-09-23](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/Yogarani-vs.-State-by-Inspector-of-Police-298592011_2024-09-23.pdf)**

##### **Further study**

 * **[Cost: Hon’ble Supreme court imposed cost on the husband to file cheating case on his wife](http://localhost:8080/section1/cost-honble-supreme-court-imposed-cost-on-the-husband-to-file-cheating-case-on-his-wife/)**
 * **[Procedure to impound passport](http://localhost:8080/section1/procedure-to-impound-passport/)**
 * **[S. 201 IPC GOES OFF IF ACCUSED ACQUITTED u/s. 302 IPC.](http://localhost:8080/section1/s-201-ipc-goes-off-if-accused-acquitted-u-s-302-ipc/)**
 * **[Murder: Common intention (section 34 IPC) & Appreciation of eye-witness: Explained](http://localhost:8080/section1/common-intention-section-34-ipc-appreciation-of-eye-witness-explained/)**
 * **[In economic offences affecting large number of people court may impose strict and additional conditions for bail and Anticipatory bail](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-economic-offences-affecting-large-number-of-people-court-may-impose-strict-and-additional-conditions-for-bail-and-anticipatory-bail/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
