# Life sentence reduced: No separate sentence for POCSO is imposed while maintaining conviction under section 376 AB IPC

- Link: https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/
- Published: 2024-02-05T16:53:51+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Death sentence reduced into imprisonment for life in High Court](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#death-sentence-reduced-into-imprisonment-for-life-in-high-court)
 * [Challenge is on the question of sentence alone](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#challenge-is-on-the-question-of-sentence-alone)
 * [Trial and sentence](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#trial-and-sentence)
 * [Alternative for life punishment is rigorous imprisonment not less than 20 years with fine](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#alternative-for-life-punishment-is-rigorous-imprisonment-not-less-than-20-years-with-fine)
 * [The act of appellant is only barbaric and not brutal](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#the-act-of-appellant-is-only-barbaric-and-not-brutal)
 * [Reason for referring the act as barbaric](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#reason-for-referring-the-act-as-barbaric)
 * [In capital punishment only constitutional courts can modify or fixed the term for life sentence](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#in-capital-punishment-only-constitutional-courts-can-modify-or-fixed-the-term-for-life-sentence)
 * [Life sentence modified for 30 years includes the period already undergone](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#life-sentence-modified-for-30-years-includes-the-period-already-undergone)
 * [Alternative punishment under section 42 of the POCSO Act](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#alternative-punishment-under-section-42-of-the-pocso-act)
 * [No separate sentence for POCSO is imposed while maintaining conviction under section 376 AB IPC](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/life-sentence-reduced-no-separate-sentence-for-pocso-is-imposed-while-maintaining-conviction-under-section-376-ab-ipc/#party)

##### Death sentence reduced into imprisonment for life in High Court

2) In troth, it is a common judgment in Criminal Reference No.6/2018 submitted by
the Trial Court under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.PC)
for confirmation of the conviction under Section 376 AB of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (IPC) as amended by Act No.22 of 2018 and in Criminal Appeal No.5725 of 2018
filed by the petitioner-convict herein aggrieved by the conviction and sentence 
imposed against him for certain other offences under the IPC, as also against the
conviction under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (for 
short, ‘POCSO Act’). As per the impugned judgment, the capital punishment awarded
for the conviction under Section 376 AB, IPC was not confirmed and it was commuted
to imprisonment for life, which, going by the provisions thereunder, means imprisonment
for the remainder of the convict’s natural life.

3) Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner convict and the learned
Additional Advocate General for the State of Madhya Pradesh.

##### Challenge is on the question of sentence alone

4) It is to be noted that in the instant case, after condoning the delay, limited
notice on the question of sentence alone was issued on 24.02.2023. Since we do not
find any reason to enlarge the scope, the parties confined their arguments within
the permissible scope.

##### Trial and sentence

5) We are of the considered view that for considering the aforesaid question it 
is apposite to refer succinctly to the facts of the case. On 21.05.2018, the complainant
Munni Bai (PW-8) who is the grandmother of the victim lodged a report that her granddaughter
X, who was examined as PW-1, aged 7 years was kidnapped and raped by the petitioner-
convict. After the trial, the Trial Court found that the prosecution had succeeded
in bringing damning evidence to establish that the victim, aged 7 years was taken
to Rajaram Baba Thakur Mandir by the petitioner-convict and there upon making her
and himself nude he committed rape. Upon her screaming, the prosecution witnesses
who went there found the convict, belonging to the same village, laying over and
violating the victim and at their sight running away from there. The oral testimonies
of the prosecution witnesses (PWs-1, 2 and 14) on the culpability of the convict
got credence from the medical evidence unerringly pointing to his guilt. The consequential
conviction inter alia, under Section 376 AB, IPC as amended by Act No.22 of 2018,
originally, brought him capital sentence. Though, the petitioner was also convicted
under Section 376 (2) (i) and under Sections 3/4, Sections 5(d)/6 of the POCSO Act
taking note of his conviction under Section 376 AB, IPC, no separate sentences were
awarded for the aforesaid offences by the trial Court. In view of the commutation
of capital punishment awarded for the conviction under Section 376 AB, IPC it is
also a matter to be considered if we interfere with the sentence of life imprisonment
for the offence under Section 376 AB, IPC as amended under the Act No.22 of 2018.

##### Alternative for life punishment is rigorous imprisonment not less than 20 years with fine

6) As noticed hereinbefore, on appreciating the evidence on record and coming to
the conclusion that the guilt of the petitioner under Section 376 AB, IPC has been
conclusively proved, but capital punishment imposed therefor, is to be commuted 
while confirming the conviction under Section 376 AB, IPC. The High Court commuted
it to imprisonment for life though another alternative punishment was also possible
viz. rigorous imprisonment for a term not less than 20 years with fine.

7) In the decision in Mulla v. State of U.P ((2010) 3 SCC 508), this Court held:-

> “85………It is open to the sentencing court to prescribe the length of incarceration.
> This is especially true in cases where death sentence has been replaced by life
> imprisonment……”

##### The act of appellant is only barbaric and not brutal

10) We have taken note of the observation of the High Court made after referring
to the manner of commission of the crime concerned that it was not barbaric and 
brutal. We are of the concerned view that when the words ‘barbaric’ and ‘brutal’
are used simultaneously they are not to take the character of synonym, but to take
distinctive meanings. In view of the manner in which the offence was committed by
the petitioner-convict, as observed by the High Court under the above extracted 
recital, according to us, one can only say that the action of the petitioner-convict
is barbaric though he had not acted in a brutal manner. We will take the meanings
of the words ‘barbaric’, ‘barbarians’ and ‘brutal’ to know the distinctive meanings
of the words ‘barbaric’ and ‘brutal’.

##### Reason for referring the act as barbaric

In the light of the evidence on record and rightly noted by the High Court in the
above-extracted paragraph 34 of the impugned judgment it may be true to say that
the petitioner-convict had committed the offence of rape brutally, but then, certainly
his action was barbaric. In the instant case, the petitioner-convict was aged 40
years on the date of occurrence and the victim was then only a girl, aged 7 years.
Thus, the position is that he used a lass aged 7 years to satisfy his lust. For 
that the petitioner-convict took the victim to a temple, unmindful of the holiness
of the place disrobed her and himself and then committed the crime. We have no hesitation
to hold that the fact he had not done it brutally will not make its commission non-
barbaric.

##### In capital punishment only constitutional courts can modify or fixed the term for life sentence

13) After referring to the relevant paragraphs from the said decisions in Shiva 
Kumar (Shiva Kumar @ Shiva @ Shivamurthy v. State of Karnataka – (2023) 9 SCC 817)
this Court held as follows: –

> “13. Hence, we have no manner of doubt that even in a case where capital punishment
> is not imposed or is not proposed, the Constitutional Courts can always exercise
> the power of imposing a modified or fixed-term sentence by directing that a life
> sentence, as contemplated by “secondly” in Section 53 of the IPC, shall be of 
> a fixed period of more than fourteen years, for example, of twenty years, thirty
> years and so on. The fixed punishment cannot be for a period less than 14 years
> in view of the mandate of Section 433A of Cr.P.C.”

##### Life sentence modified for 30 years includes the period already undergone

16) Then, we are also to take into account the present age of the petitioner and
the fact that he has already undergone the incarceration. On consideration of all
such aspects, we are of the considered view that a fixed term of sentence of 30 
years, which shall include the period already undergone, must be the modified sentence
of imprisonment.

##### Alternative punishment under section 42 of the POCSO Act

19) We fully endorse the said contention as paragraph 1 of the impugned judgment
itself would reveal that the High Court had actually taken into consideration the
fact that the petitioner-convict was convicted only under Section 376 AB, IPC as
amended by Act No.22 of 2018 and under Section 363 IPC. In such circumstances, the
conviction and sentence imposed on the petitioner-convict is confirmed. We have 
taken note of the fact that though the petitioner-convict was convicted for the 
offence under Section 3/4 and 5 (m)/6 of the POCSO Act, no separate sentence was
imposed on the petitioner-convict by the Trial Court taking note of the provision
under Section 42 of the POCSO Act. The said provision reads thus:-

> “**42. Alternate punishment**.—Where an act or omission constitutes an offence
> punishable under this Act and also under sections 166A, 354A, 354B, 354C, 354D,
> 370, 370A, 375, 376, [376A, 376AB, 376B, 376C, 376D, 376DA, 376DB], [376E, section
> 509 of the Indian Penal Code or section 67B of the Information Technology Act,
> 2000 (21 of 2000)], then, notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the
> time being in force, the offender found guilty of such offence shall be liable
> to punishment only under this Act or under the Indian Penal Code as provides for
> punishment which is greater in degree.”

##### No separate sentence for POCSO is imposed while maintaining conviction under section 376 AB IPC

20) Since, even after the interference with the sentence imposed for the conviction
of the petitioner-convict under Section 376 AB, IPC and modified sentence imposed
on commutation by the High Court, we have awarded 30 years of rigorous imprisonment
with a fine of Rupees One Lakh, no separate sentence for the aforesaid offence under
POCSO Act is to be imposed on the convict. While maintaining the conviction of the
petitioner-convict under Section 376 AB, IPC, the sentence imposed thereunder is
modified to a sentence of rigorous imprisonment for a term of 30 years, making it
clear that this will also include the period of sentence already undergone and the
period, if any ordered by the Trial Court for set off. The imprisonment awarded 
for the conviction under Section 363, IPC shall run concurrently. The amount of 
fine imposed thereunder shall be added to the fine imposed by us viz., Rupees One
Lakh.

##### Party

**Bhaggi @ Bhagirath @ Naran …Petitioner versus The State of Madhya Pradesh …Respondents–
Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No.2888 of 2023 – February 05, 2024 – 2024 INSC 82**

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/42693/42693_2022_13_1501_50074_Judgement_05-Feb-2024.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/42693/42693_2022_13_1501_50074_Judgement_05-Feb-2024.pdf)**

**[Bhaggi-@-Bhagirath-@-Naran-vs.-The-State-of-M.P-42693_2022_13_1501_50074_Judgement_05-Feb-2024](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Bhaggi-@-Bhagirath-@-Naran-vs.-The-State-of-M.P-42693_2022_13_1501_50074_Judgement_05-Feb-2024-1.pdf)**

 

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
