# Madras High Court: 14% of the disproportionate assets is inconsistent with the known sources of income thus conviction upheld

- Link: https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/
- Published: 2026-08-08T07:36:58+00:00
- Author: Sathiyajyothi Sabapathi

Contents

 * [The Appeal](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/#the-appeal)
    - [Summary of the case of the prosecution](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/#summary-of-the-case-of-the-prosecution)
    - [Summary](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/#summary)
    - [Paragraphs from the judgments](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/#paragraphs-from-the-judgments)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-14-of-the-disproportionate-assets-is-inconsistent-with-the-known-sources-of-income-thus-conviction-upheld/#conclusion)

#### **The Appeal

This Criminal Appeal is filed against the Judgment of the XIII Additional Judge 
for CBI Cases, Chennai, dated 06/06/2014 in C.C. No.38 of 2010, thereby finding 
the appellant/sole accused guilty of the offence punishable under Section 13(2) 
read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and was sentenced to
undergo rigorous
imprisonment for two years and to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/- and
in default of payment of fine to undergo simple imprisonment for three months.

##### **Summary of the case of the prosecution**

The prosecution case arose during investigation of a larger case relating to customs
officials, where during a surprise check it was found that goods were released without
proper adjudication and illegal gratification was involved. While that case was 
pending, the [prosecution received information](https://section1.in/as-per-section-21-pocso-act-only-those-who-received-credible-information-directly-could-be-prosecuted-for-failure-to-report-and-not-all-the-teachers-or-office-bearers-of-the-institution-also-no-suppre/)
that the accused had amassed assets disproportionate to his known sources of income.
A separate [case was registered alleging](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
that during the check period the accused had acquired assets far exceeding his lawful
income. After investigation, a [final report was filed](https://section1.in/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)
alleging possession of disproportionate assets, and the case was taken on file by
the Trial Court.

##### Summary

In [appeal](https://section1.in/who-can-prefer-the-appeal-against-acquittal-in-the-case-initially-registered-by-state-police-later-transferred-to-cbi-investigation-is-left-open-to-decide-in-a-suitable-case/),
the main dispute was not with regard to the assets at the beginning of the check
period, but with regard to certain items included as assets at the end of the check
period. The accused contended that some immovable properties standing in the names
of his mother and relatives ought to have been excluded, as they were purchased 
from their independent sources of income, and that if those items were excluded,
no disproportionate assets would remain. The [accused also questioned inclusion of one property transaction](https://section1.in/acquittal-trap-case-witness-entered-the-room-only-after-the-complainants-signal-meaning-they-did-not-witness-the-actual-transaction-also-the-amount-was-scattered-in-the-floor-next-to-the-accused/)
which, according to him, had not been completed, and the inclusion of gold jewels.

The Court examined the evidence relating to each disputed item. With respect to 
the Tambaram property, the [Court noted](https://section1.in/once-the-high-court-noted-multiple-injuries-on-the-deceaseds-body-there-was-no-reason-to-grant-bail-to-the-accused/)
that though the property stood in the names of relatives, the evidence showed that
the accused was instrumental in the purchase, was present during registration, and
that the property ultimately came back to his son through settlement deeds. The 
explanations put forward regarding family arrangements were found to be unsupported
by any [document and contradicted by evidence](https://section1.in/secondary-evidence-document-that-are-not-properly-stamped-cannot-be-secondary-evidence/),
leading the Court to conclude that the purchasers were only name lenders and that
the property rightly belonged to the accused and was correctly included as his asset.

With regard to the Mahabalipuram plots, the Court considered the evidence of the
vendor who clearly deposed that the accused paid the consideration in cash, including
for the plot which was not finally registered. The seized [money was found to have been deposited](https://section1.in/section-167-cr-p-c-condition/)
in connection with the main case. The Court found no credible explanation to disbelieve
the vendor’s [evidence and held that these properties were also](https://section1.in/approver-since-direct-evidence-has-come-through-the-approver-pw-1-who-is-creditworthy-and-the-circumstantial-evidence-also-corroborated-him-led-to-conviction/)
rightly treated as assets of the accused. As far as the jewels were concerned, the
[Court agreed with the Trial](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
Court’s approach in limiting the value taken into account.

After reworking the calculations, the Court found that one plot value required deduction,
but even after such deduction, the accused was still in possession of assets disproportionate
to his known sources of income. Thus, the core [issue before the Court](https://section1.in/honble-madras-high-court-issued-guidelines-to-family-courts-to-cirumvent-the-procedural-wrangles-that-are-being-faced-by-the-parties-before-the-family-court/),
namely whether the accused had satisfactorily explained the assets held in excess
of income, was answered against him, and the finding of guilt was confirmed.

##### Paragraphs from the judgments

**Doubt raised with respect of the money**: 4.7 As a matter of fact, doubt was raised
with respect to the money that was seized from PW-16 during the course of arguments
in this appeal. Accordingly this court called for particulars and it is seen that
the amount is deposited in the main case that is being faced by the accused along
with others in C.C. No.1 of 2013, on the file of the XIII Additional Court for CBI
Cases and amount was originally deposited to credit of RC 60A/2009 and is lying 
term deposit vide TDR No. TE/MTDN 0571856 dated 17/12/2009 in FD A/c. No.867591972
at Indian Bank, Nungambakkam Branch, Chennai. There was no necessity for PW- 16 
to part away with such huge money unless paid by the accused. The only cross-examination
is that, under pressure from CBI authorities, the money was paid, and the full money
would not have been paid. They could not elicit any favourable answer. Thus, there
is absolutely no explanation regarding item No. 5. It only demonstrates that the
money is not hard-earned and was to be stealthily invested. Documentation was not
even comfortable.

**Accused paid the money**: 4.9 However, there is no evidence suggesting payment
by PW-18 or PW-28. On the contrary, it is the specific deposition of PW-16, vendor
that it is only the accused who paid the money. In order to doubt the same, no credible
evidence is let in. As a matter of fact, it can be seen that yet another property
was also purchased in the name of PW-18 and immediately a power of attorney is obtained
in the name of the son of the accused. If the transactions are taken cumulatively,
the design of the accused to take the properties in the name of the relatives and
thereafter, changing over the same in the name of his son is evident. In the instant
case, before he could make documentation to item No.5 and further transactions in
respect of item No.4, the CBI intervened. Thus, there is no iota of doubt whatsoever
that these items 4 & 5 also belonged to the accused and have rightly been included
by the trial court.

4.10 As far as the arguments relating to jewels are concerned, the trial court itself
had considered the same and had taken into account only Rs. 67,250/-, which this
Court also agrees.

**14% assests are disproportionate/uneven to the known sources of income and confirmation
of the trial court judgment**: 4.11 In view of the above findings, there is no change
in Statement A i.e., Assets at the beginning of the check period, as found by the
Trial Court, which is Rs.28,02,343/-. As far as Statement B i.e. Assets at the end
of the check period is concerned, it was found by the trial Court to be as Rs.1,11,32,376/-,
In respect of one plot situated at Mahabalipuram, a sum of Rs. 11,54,540/- has to
be deducted in Statement B. After deducting the value, Statement B is as follows
Rs.1,11,32,376/- – Rs.11,54,540/- = Rs.99,77.836/-. Statement C i.e. the income 
during the check period is Rs.93,69,796/-. Statement D ie. the expenditure during
the check period as found by the trial court is Rs.35,49,733/-. Therefore the disproportionate
assets (B-A) –(C-D) is Rs.13,55,430/-. Thus, still the accused has got 14.4% of 
assets disproportionate to the known sources of income and therefore the finding
of trial Court Regarding the guilt has to be confirmed.

#### **Conclusion**

While partly allowing the appeal, the Court held that the conviction under Section
13(2) read with [Section 13(1)(e](https://section1.in/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/))
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 was correct and confirmed, but considering
the age of the accused and the circumstances, modified the sentence by reducing 
the imprisonment to one-year simple imprisonment while confirming the fine and granting
time to surrender.

    ```ql-align-justify
    Party: B. Pugazhenthi Vs. State represented by Inspector of Police ACB, CBI, Chennai -[Criminal Appeal No.323 of 2014] - Date of Judgment: 08.10.2025.
    ```

[B.Pugazhenthi vs. State](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/B.Pugazhenthi-vs.-State.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/B.Pugazhenthi-vs.-State.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
