# Mere contradictions would not make the entire story of prosecution false [Falsus in uno falsus in omnibus explained]

- Link: https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/
- Published: 2025-01-09T14:33:06+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#appeal)
 * [Facts](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#facts)
    - [A meeting lead to clashes between members of communist party and RSS](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#a-meeting-lead-to-clashes-between-members-of-communist-party-and-rss)
    - [High Court convicted A1 to A# and A.11 & 12 while acquitting other accused](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#high-court-convicted-a1-to-a-and-a11-amp-12-while-acquitting-other-accused)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#analysis)
    - [Impact of crime enlightened](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#impact-of-crime-enlightened)
    - [Due to hartal accused persons led a deadly attack on 11 members hiding themselves wherein two persons lost their lives](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#due-to-hartal-accused-persons-led-a-deadly-attack-on-11-members-hiding-themselves-wherein-two-persons-lost-their-lives)
    - [Postmortem reports establish death of both victims was homicidal](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#postmortem-reports-establish-death-of-both-victims-was-homicidal)
    - [Analysis: Whether contradictions are material enough for benefit of doubt?](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#analysis-whether-contradictions-are-material-enough-for-benefit-of-doubt)
    - [Judgments on material contradiction in witness testimony](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#judgments-on-material-contradiction-in-witness-testimony)
    - [Cross-examination of PW-1 goes against defence](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#crossexamination-of-pw1-goes-against-defence)
    - [Principle of Falsus in uno falsus in omnibus discussed](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#principle-of-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-discussed)
    - [Eye-witnesses testimony revealed the murder and hence dead body found at different place cannot be a decisive factor to discard prosecution case](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#eyewitnesses-testimony-revealed-the-murder-and-hence-dead-body-found-at-different-place-cannot-be-a-decisive-factor-to-discard-prosecution-case)
    - [Apex court finds that the proper and disciplined investigation could have strengthened the case](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#apex-court-finds-that-the-proper-and-disciplined-investigation-could-have-strengthened-the-case)
    - [Accused cannot escape on the defective investigation ground alone](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#accused-cannot-escape-on-the-defective-investigation-ground-alone)
    - [Interested witness statements would not raise any suspicion](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#interested-witness-statements-would-not-raise-any-suspicion)
    - [Mere act of throwing the bomb is an offence under section 5 of Explosive Substances Act, 1968](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#mere-act-of-throwing-the-bomb-is-an-offence-under-section-5-of-explosive-substances-act-1968)
    - [Mere contradictions would not make the entire story of prosecution false](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/mere-contradictions-would-not-make-the-entire-story-of-prosecution-false-falsus-in-uno-falsus-in-omnibus-explained/#party)

#### **Appeal**

1. The present criminal appeal arises out of judgment and order dated 12th April
2011 passed by High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, in Cri. Appeal No. 1040/2006. 
By the impugned judgment and order, the Appellants/Accused- A4 to A10 and A13 to
A15 have been acquitted under Sections 302 r/w 149 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860(
hereinafter ‘IPC’) while conviction and sentence against A1 to A3 and A11 and A12
was confirmed. Additionally, A3 was convicted and sentenced under Section 5 of the
Explosive Substance Act,1908.

#### **Facts**

2. For the sake of brevity and for maintaining continuity the accused persons are
referred as per their sequence in the trial.

##### **A meeting lead to clashes between members of communist party and RSS**

3. The factual matrix of the case are that on 01.03.2002, Rashtriya Swayam Sevak
Sangh/Vishva Hindu Parishad (in short ‘RSS/VHP’) had called for a hartal. The Hartal
led to clashes between members of the Communist Party of India (M) (in short ‘CPI(
M)’) and RSS. A group of 11 persons, afraid of the mob led by CPI(M), hid and stayed
near a shed situated near the Meloor river. At midnight, they saw 11 persons coming
from the eastern side and 5 persons coming from the northern side carrying deadly
weapons like, axe, dagger and chopper. All the 11 but for the deceased persons were
alerted and rushed towards the river to save themselves. The two deceased namely
Sunil and Sujeesh, were asleep and thus, the mob inflicted fatal injuries on them.
The body of Sujeesh was taken to a hospital in Thalassery where he was pronounced
dead and based on the statement of PW-1, FIR No. 53/2002 dated 02.03.2002 was registered
under Section 43, 147, 3 148, 341, 506(ii), 307, 302 r/w 149 IPC & Section 3, 5 
of Explosive Substances Act, 1908 at P.S. Dharmadam on receipt of the report investigating
agency was set in motion. PW-19 conducted the investigation and on 02.03.2002 body
of the 2nd deceased person Sunil was found at a marshy land near the spot of occurrence
in the morning. The inquest of both the dead bodies was conducted and inquest reports
were prepared. Subsequently, post-mortem was done on the same day. A1, A9 and A11
were arrested on 06.03.2002. Pursuant to the disclosure statement of A11 made under
Section 27 of The Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter ‘IEA’), recovery of the
axe used in the murder was made from the bushes near the spot of occurrence. A2,
A4, A10, A15 were arrested on 10.03.2002 and, based on the disclosure statement 
of A12, a chopper was recovered. A3, A5 to A8 and A12 were arrested on 16.03.2002.
It is pertinent to note here that though one Ashraf was named in the FIR as A13,
subsequently on 10.03.2002 a report for deletion of his name was moved by PW19 before
the Ld. Magistrate stating that Ashraf was undergoing treatment at Mangalore on 
the date of incident. On completion of investigation, Chargesheet was filed against
all the accused persons (A1 to A15). The Trial Court vide its judgment dated 24.04.2006
found all accused persons guilty under Section 143, 147, 506 (ii), and 302 r/w. 
149 of IPC. A2,3,11,12 were also found guilty under Section 148 of IPC and under
Section 5 of the Explosive Substance Act and A15 was completely acquitted of all
charges.

##### **High Court convicted A1 to A# and A.11 & 12 while acquitting other accused**

4. On appreciation of evidence on record, the High Court in its elaborate judgment
dated 12th April 2011 convicted A1 to A3 and A.11 & 12 while acquitting A4 to10,
A13 & A14 and confirmed the acquittal of A15.

5. Aggrieved by the said judgment of the High Court, A1 to A3 and A11 and 12 are
before us. For the sake of convenience, we will refer to the parties by their respective
nomenclature before the Trial Court.

#### **Analysis**

##### **Impact of crime enlightened**

10. Crime creates a sense of societal fear and it affects adversely the societal
conscience. It is inequitable and unjust if such a situation is allowed to perpetuate
and continue in the society. In every civilized society, the purpose of criminal
administrative system is to protect individual dignity and to restore societal stability
and order and to create faith and cohesion in the society. The courts in the discharge
of their duties are tasked with balancing of interests of the accused on one hand
and the state/society on the other.

##### **Due to hartal accused persons led a deadly attack on 11 members hiding themselves wherein two persons lost their lives**

12. Admittedly, there was a long-standing political rivalry between RSS and CPI.
As has been stated by PW1, he and 11 others were earlier a part of CPI and they 
had defected and joined RSS and hence there were estranged relations between the
two groups. Admittedly, a call of Hartal was given by one organization and the same
was opposed by another political party, leading to a clash between the followers
of these two parties. The version of witnesses discloses that the group of 11 members
rushed to a shed near river Meloor to save their lives from the violent mob. This
group of 11 members were hiding themselves near the river and in the night the accused
persons led a deadly attack on them and ultimately, two persons lost their lives
as a result of this incident.

##### **Postmortem reports establish death of both victims was homicidal**

13. In the postmortem report issued by PW7, it was opined that the death of Sunil
was due to injuries caused to vital organs like liver, lung, heart and shock resulting
from loss of blood. Similarly, the postmortem report pertaining to Sujeesh submitted
by PW8 concluded that the death of Sujeesh was due to injuries to vital organs like
liver, lung, spleen, hemorrhage, and shock. A cumulative reading of both the reports
sufficiently establish that death of both the victims was homicidal.

##### **Analysis: Whether contradictions are material enough for benefit of doubt?**

14. It was urged by the counsel for the appellants that there are material contradictions
in the testimonies given by the prosecution witnesses, particularly the eyewitnesses.
In this context, the question arises, whether these contradictions are material 
enough for the benefit of doubt to be given to the appellants so as to set aside
their conviction.

##### **Judgments on material contradiction in witness testimony**

15. The law relating to material contradiction in witness testimony has been discussed
by this Court in the judgment of **Rammi vs State of MP (1999 8 SCC 649)**. It was
held that:

(25) “It is common practice in trial court to make out contradictions from the previous
statements. Merely Because there is inconsistency in evidence it is not sufficient
to impair the credit of the witness. No Doubt Section 155 of the Evidence Act provides
scope for impeaching the credit of a witness by proof of an inconsistent former 
statement. But a reading of the section would indicate that all inconsistent statements
are not sufficient to impeach the credit of the witness. Only such of the inconsistent
statement which is capable to be “contradicted” would affect the credit of the witness’’.

The abovementioned settled position of law was again reiterated by this Court in
the judgment of **Birbal Nath vs State of Rajasthan (2023 INSC 957) [http://localhost:
8080/section1/how-not-to-contradict-a-witness/]** wherein it was held as under:

“(19) No doubt statement given before police during investigation under section 
161 are “previous statements” under section 145 of the Evidence Act and therefore
can be used to cross examine a witness. But this only for a limited purpose, to “
contradict” such a witness. Even if the defense is successful in contradicting a
witness, it would not always mean that the contradiction in her two statements would
result in totally discrediting this witness. It is ere that we feel that the learned
judges of the High Court have gone wrong.

(21) In the landmark case of **Tehshildar Singh v State of UP (AIR 1959 SC 1012)**
this Court has held that to contradict a witness would mean to “discredit” a witness.
Therefore, unless and until the former statement of this witness is capable of “
discrediting” a witness, it would have little relevance. A mere variation in the
two statements would not be enough to discredit a witness. This has been followed
consistently by this Court in its later judgement, including Rammi (Supra)”.

> Bearing in mind the abovementioned settled position of law, this court is of the
> considered opinion that though there is a variance in the statements of the witnesses,
> it is minor and not of such a nature which would drive their testimony untrustworthy.
> This court finds the deposition of witnesses PW1, 2 and 4 to be honest, truthful,
> and trustworthy. Hence, the observations made by the High Court in this regard
> are well reasoned.

##### **Cross-examination of PW-1 goes against defence**

16. It is worthwhile to mention that in his examination in chief, PW1- V K Jithesh
had mentioned that Sunil was not seen. In his cross examination, PW1 had stated 
that he had told the police at the picket post that Sunil was missing. This was 
apparently in contradiction to the stand of the defence that death of Sunil was 
mentioned in the FIR at 3 am itself while his body was found only at 7:30 am in 
the morning. The statement of PW1 to the police mentioning that Sunil is “missing”
cannot be seen in an abstract. “Noscitur a sociis” is a well-recognized principle
used for interpretation of statutes. It means that the meaning of a word can be 
determined by the context of the sentence; it is to be judged by the company it 
keeps. Though this principle Is used for interpretation of words in a statute, the
inherent principle can very well be applied to the facts of the present case which
have be seen in the context of the entire set of events that had transpired that
night. The High Court has also, in its well-reasoned judgment considered the fact
that while struggling for his life, injured Sunil might have made some movements
and while so he might have fallen into the slushy area and happened to be amidst
the bushes which is the reason for him being allegedly “missing”.

##### **Principle of Falsus in uno falsus in omnibus discussed**

18. Either a partial, untrue version of one of the witnesses or an exaggerated version
of a witness may not be a sole reason to discard the entire prosecution case which
is otherwise supported by clinching evidence such as truthful version of the witnesses,
medical evidence, recovery of the weapons etc. At this stage, it may not be out 
of place to refer to the principle called as ‘falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus’.

19. It is a settled position that ‘falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus’ (false in one
thing, false in everything) that the above principle is foreign to our criminal 
law jurisprudence. This aspect has been considered by this Court in a plethora of
judgements. In the case of **Ram Vijay Singh vs State of UP (2021 SCC Online SC 
142)**, a Three Judge bench of this Hon’ble Court had held that:

“..(20) We do not find any merit in the arguments raised by the learned counsel 
for the Appellant. A part statement of a witness can be believed even though some
part of the statement may not be relied upon by the Court. The maxim falsus in uno,
falsus in omnibus is not the rile applied by the courts in India. This Court recently
in a judgement IIangovan vs State of T.N. held that Indian Courts have always been
reluctant to apply the principle as it is only a rile of caution. It was held as
under: (SCC Pg 536, Para 11)”

“..(11) The Counsel for the Appellant lastly argued that once the witnesses had 
been disbelieved with respect to the co accused, their testimonies with respect 
to the present accused must also be discarded. The Counsel is, in effect, relying
on the legal maxim “falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus”, which Indian Courts have 
always been reluctant to apply. A three Judge bench of this Court, as far back as
in 1957, in Nisar Ali v. State of UP, held on this point as follows (AIR p 368, 
Para 9-10)

“(9) This maxim has not received general acceptance in different jurisdictions in
India nor has this maxim come to occupy the status of a rule of law. It is merely
a rule of Caution. All that it amounts to is that in such cases the testimony may
be disregarded and not that it must be disregarded.

(10) The Doctrine merely involves the question of weight of evidence which a Court
may apply in a given set of circumstances, but it is not what may be called “a mandatory
rule of Evidence”

(21) Therefore, merely because a prosecution witness was not believed in respect
of another accused, the testimony if the said witness cannot be disregarded qua 
the present Appellant. Still, further it is not necessary for the prosecution to
examine all the witnesses who might have witnessed the occurrence. It is the quality
if evidence which is relevant in criminal trial and not the quantity.”

Hence, as can be seen from above, it has being a consistent stand of this Hon’ble
Court that the principle ‘falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus’ is not a rule of evidence
and if the court inspires confidence from the rest of the testimony of such a witness,
it can very well rely on such a part of the testimony and base a conviction upon
it.

##### **Eye-witnesses testimony revealed the murder and hence dead body found at different place cannot be a decisive factor to discard prosecution case**

20. Though the learned defence counsel vehemently submitted that the dead body of
Sujeesh was found at a different place away from the dead body of the other victim
Sunil and as such, on this count alone, the prosecution case is to be discarded.
We are unable to accept the submissions of the learned counsel for the reason that
the evidence of eye witnesses clearly reveal that this mob of persons being apprehensive
of their life rushed towards the river. It is further disclosed in the version of
witnesses that members of this group took shelter near a shed in bushy area. In 
this process, it is quite natural that all the members may not find a suitable place
for hiding at a particular spot or one spot. This being the situation, it was also
natural and possible that Sujeesh might have rushed to another spot to hide and 
save himself and as such his body is found away from the dead body of another victim
Sunil. The violent mob of accused persons led a deadly attack on the members of 
the mob and was successful in killing two members of the mob.

Thus in our opinion, merely because the dead body of Sujeesh was found at a place
little away from the place of body of other victim Sunil, it cannot be the sole 
and decisive factor to discard the entire case of prosecution.

##### **Apex court finds that the proper and disciplined investigation could have strengthened the case**

21. One more thrust of argument from the appellants was that the prosecution has
not conducted the investigation in a fair and impartial manner as they have tried
to rope in innocent persons who were not present at the spot. There was an attempt
to rope in one Ashraf and there was a consistency in the statements of the eyewitnesses
that they had seen Ashraf when the crime was taking place. Admittedly, there is 
a rivalry between the two groups so the possibility of exaggeration cannot be ruled
out. When the fact that Ashraf was not at all present during the crime and that 
he was present in the hospital came to light of the prosecution, they had moved 
a report and sought deletion of his name.

22. A cumulative reading of the entire evidence on record suggests that the investigation
has not taken place in a proper and disciplined manner. There are various areas 
where a properly investigation could have strengthened its case. In the case of **
Paras Yadav & ors. vs. State of Bihar ([1999 (2) SCC 126])**, the Apex Court observed
as under:

“Para 8 – ..the lapse on the part of the Investigating Officer should not be taken
in favour of the accused, may be that such lapse is committed designedly or because
of negligence. Hence, the prosecution evidence is required to be examined de hors
such omissions to find out whether the said evidence is reliable or not. For this
purpose, it would be worthwhile to quote the following observations of this Court
from the case of Ram Bihari Yadav v. State of Bihar and others, J.T. (1998) 3 SC
290.

“In such cases, the story of the prosecution will have to be examined de hors such
omissions and contaminated conduct of the officials otherwise the mischief which
was deliberately done would be perpetuated and justice would be denied to the complainant
party and this would obviously shake the confidence of the people not merely in 
the law enforcing agency but also in the administration of justice.”

##### **Accused cannot escape on the defective investigation ground alone**

Hence, the principle of law is crystal clear that on the account of defective investigation
the benefit will not inure to the accused persons on that ground alone. It is well
within the domain of the courts to consider the rest of the evidence which the prosecution
has gathered such as statement of the eyewitnesses, medical report etc. It has been
a consistent stand of this court that the accused cannot claim acquittal on the 
ground of faulty investigation done by the prosecuting agency. As the version of
eyewitnesses in specifically naming the appellants have been consistent throughout
the trial, we find that there is enough corroboration to drive home the guilt of
the accused persons. When the testimony of PW1 Jitesh, PW 2 and PW4 is seen cumulatively,
their versions can be seen to be corroborating each other. All of them being eyewitnesses,
what is material to be seen is their stand is consistent when they said that it 
was A2 who was responsible for inflicting blows on both the deceased. It may not
be out of place to mention that though the unfortunate incident took place at midnight
around 1 am, it was a full moon night and as such, it was not pitch dark. This has
also not been vehemently disputed by the defence counsel. Hence, the version put
forth by the prosecution witnesses inspires confidence of this Court. The specific
role attributed by the prosecution witnesses cannot be challenged on extraneous 
grounds which have been raised by the defense. There is no contradiction when it
comes to assigning specific role to the above accused. Admittedly, there was an 
enmity between the witnesses as they were from different political groups. 17 Moreover,
it can be seen from the record that the Accused and the witnesses were well acquainted
with each other as PW1, PW 2 and PW4 had defected from the CPI and had joined RSS.
The witnesses could have tried to implicate anyone had they wished to take advantage
of their past acquaintance and recent rivalry.

##### **Interested witness statements would not raise any suspicion**

23. It has been held by this court in the case of **Raju alias Balachandran and 
ors. vs. State of Tamil Nadu (6 (2012) 12 SCC 701)**:

“… 29 The sum and substance is that the evidence of a related or interested witness
should be meticulous and carefully examined. In a case where the related and interested
witness may have some enmity with the assailant, the bar would need to be raised
and the evidence of the witness would have to be examined by applying a standard
of discerning scrutiny. However, this is only a rule of prudence and not one of 
law, as held in Dalip Singh [AIR 1963 SC 364] and pithily reiterated in Sarwan Singh[(
1976) 4 SCC 369] in the following words: (Sarwan Singh case [ (1976) 4SCC 369, p.
3376, para 10)

“10 ……The evidence of an interested witness does not suffer from any infirmity as
such, but the courts require as a rule of prudence, to as a rule of law, that the
evidence of such witnesses should be scrutinized with little care. Once that approach
is made and the court is satisfied that the evidence of the witnesses has a ring
of truth such evidence could be relied upon even without corroboration.”

> Bearing in mind the above legal position of the interested witnesses the testimonies
> of PW1, PW2 and PW4 is the only piece of evidence available of the eye- witnesses.
> Even if it is assumed that they are interested witnesses there is no such inconsistency
> in their statements which would raise a reasonable suspicion about their evidence
> being concocted and untruthful. They were present at the spot where the incident
> took place and they have delivered a version which is palpable one. Their versions
> about seeing and hearing the appellants inflicting injuries on the bodies of the
> deceased Sunil and Sujeesh are in harmony with each other.

##### **Mere act of throwing the bomb is an offence under section 5 of Explosive Substances Act, 1968**

24. As regards the conviction of A3 under Explosive Substances Act, 1908 is concerned,
this court is of the opinion that the mere act of throwing the bomb by A3 would 
give rise to reasonable suspicion that he did not have the bomb in his control for
a lawful object. The High Court has rightly upheld the conviction of A3 for Section
5 of Explosive Substances Act, 1908.

##### **Mere contradictions would not make the entire story of prosecution false**

25. The entire submissions of the appellants were that since there are contradictions,
the entire story of the prosecution is false. As we have already mentioned above,
the principle of ‘falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus’ does not apply to the Indian
criminal jurisprudence and only because there are some contradictions which in the
opinion of this Court are not even that material, the entire story of the prosecution
cannot be discarded as false. It is the duty of the Court to separate the grain 
from the chaff. In a given case, it is also open to the Court to differentiate the
accused who had been acquitted from those who were convicted where there are a number
of accused persons, like in the present case.

26. On appreciation of the evidence, we are unable to find any fault with the judgment
and order dated 12.04.2011 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in Criminal
Appeal No.1040/2006. Accordingly, we arrive at the conclusion that the present appeal
deserves to be dismissed. 27. The present appeal is accordingly dismissed. Pending
application(s), if any, shall be disposed of accordingly.

#### **Party**

Edakkandi Dineshan @ P. Dineshan & Ors. Appellant(S)…… versus State of Kerela Respondent(
S) – Criminal Appeal No. 118 Of 2013 – 2025 INSC 28 – JANUARY 6, 2025.

[Edakkandi Dineshan vs. State of Kerala 312472011_2025-01-06](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Edakkandi-Dineshan-vs.-State-of-Kerala-312472011_2025-01-06.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Edakkandi-Dineshan-vs.-State-of-Kerala-312472011_2025-01-06.pdf)
