# Monthly Digest February’ 2025

- Link: https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/
- Published: 2025-02-18T06:06:07+00:00
- Author: section1

Contents

 * [Electronic records objection: Though objection regarding absence of certificate under section 65B IEA not raised while marking but question put to the witness is treated as objection](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#electronic-records-objection-though-objection-regarding-absence-of-certificate-under-section-65b-iea-not-raised-while-marking-but-question-put-to-the-witness-is-treated-as-objection)
 * [No moral conviction: Unless the deceased was subjected to cruelty or harassment or in connection with demand of dowry soon before her death presumption under section 113A IEA cannot be invoked](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#no-moral-conviction-unless-the-deceased-was-subjected-to-cruelty-or-harassment-or-in-connection-with-demand-of-dowry-soon-before-her-death-presumption-under-section-113a-iea-cannot-be-invoked)
 * [SC/ST Act: As per FIR accused insulted the complainant inside his office hence does not come within public view](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#scst-act-as-per-fir-accused-insulted-the-complainant-inside-his-office-hence-does-not-come-within-public-view)
 * [Supreme court clarified the celebrated Uma devi judgment. State of Karnataka vs. Umadevi (2006 (4) SCC 1). (hereinafter umadevi judgment)](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#supreme-court-clarified-the-celebrated-uma-devi-judgment-state-of-karnataka-vs-umadevi-2006-4-scc-1-hereinafter-umadevi-judgment)
 * [Dock identification not relied since the Test Identification was not conducted](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#dock-identification-not-relied-since-the-test-identification-was-not-conducted)
 * [Transfer of malice: Act of accused was nothing but murder under section 302 IPC r/w section 301 IPC](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#transfer-of-malice-act-of-accused-was-nothing-but-murder-under-section-302-ipc-rw-section-301-ipc)
 * [No Original Documents No Registration of Deed?](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#no-original-documents-no-registration-of-deed)
 * [Murder case: Asphyxia can be caused by Chronic tuberculosis and the ligature marks on the neck might be due to long journey of dead body](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#murder-case-asphyxia-can-be-caused-by-chronic-tuberculosis-and-the-ligature-marks-on-the-neck-might-be-due-to-long-journey-of-dead-body)
 * [Firearm: Acquittal: Ballistic report opined that two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the test fired bullets](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#firearm-acquittal-ballistic-report-opined-that-two-bullets-found-in-the-bodies-were-not-sufficient-for-comparison-with-the-test-fired-bullets)
 * [Dowry death: Acquittal: Evidence on record is full of omissions amount to material contradiction to peril the prosecution story of demand of dowry](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#dowry-death-acquittal-evidence-on-record-is-full-of-omissions-amount-to-material-contradiction-to-peril-the-prosecution-story-of-demand-of-dowry)
 * [PMLA-Bail:  Mandatory requirements of Section 45 PMLA not considered while releasing the accused on bail hence matter remanded back for fresh consideration](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#pmlabail-%c2%a0mandatory-requirements-of-section-45-pmla-not-considered-while-releasing-the-accused-on-bail-hence-matter-remanded-back-for-fresh-consideration)
 * [Portions contradicted with the previous statement can be put in bracket and marked as Exhibit AA, BB, e.t.c](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#portions-contradicted-with-the-previous-statement-can-be-put-in-bracket-and-marked-as-exhibit-aa-bb-etc)
 * [Discharge: When specific remedy is available under section 397 Cr.P.C the CBI ought not to have filed petition under section 482 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#discharge-when-specific-remedy-is-available-under-section-397-crpc-the-cbi-ought-not-to-have-filed-petition-under-section-482-crpc)
 * [UAPA bail granted after five years in custody](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#uapa-bail-granted-after-five-years-in-custody)
 * [Directions issued to manage S. 138 NI Act cases effectively](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/#directions-issued-to-manage-s-138-ni-act-cases-effectively)

### 󠀁[Electronic records objection: Though objection regarding absence of certificate under section 65B IEA not raised while marking but question put to the witness is treated as objection](http://localhost:8080/section1/electronic-records-objection-though-objection-regarding-absence-of-certificate-under-section-65b-iea-not-raised-while-marking-but-question-put-to-the-witness-is-treated-as-objection/)󠁿

The judgment in the case of Chandrabhan Sudam Sanap vs. The State of Maharashtra
addresses the appeal against the conviction and death sentence imposed by the Trial
Court for multiple serious offenses, including murder (Section 302 IPC), kidnapping(
Sections 364 and 366 IPC), rape (Section 376 IPC), robbery (Chapter 392 read with
397 IPC), and destruction of evidence (Section 201 IPC). The High Court upheld the
conviction and death sentence after reviewing the evidence, including the appellant’s
extra-judicial confession and other circumstantial evidence linking him to the crime.
The sentencing of lower courts set aside. Accused are set at liberty.

### 󠀁[No moral conviction: Unless the deceased was subjected to cruelty or harassment or in connection with demand of dowry soon before her death presumption under section 113A IEA cannot be invoked](http://localhost:8080/section1/no-moral-conviction-unless-the-deceased-was-subjected-to-cruelty-or-harassment-or-in-connection-with-demand-of-dowry-soon-before-her-death-presumption-under-section-113a-iea-cannot-be-invoked/)󠁿

In this judgment, the appellant, along with his parents, was tried for offences 
punishable under Sections 304-B and 498-A of the Indian Penal Code, resulting in
his parents acquittal while appellant was convicted and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment
for seven years under Section 304-B and one year under Section 498-A, along with
a fine. The High Court upheld this conviction; however, upon further appeal, the
Supreme Court found that the prosecution failed to prove the essential ingredients
of cruelty or harassment beyond a reasonable doubt, ultimately quashing the conviction
and acquitting appellant of all charges.

### 󠀁[SC/ST Act: As per FIR accused insulted the complainant inside his office hence does not come within public view](http://localhost:8080/section1/sc-st-act-as-per-fir-accused-insulted-the-complainant-inside-his-office-hence-does-not-come-within-public-view/)󠁿

The judgment involves an appeal against the dismissal of petitions filed by the 
Appellant under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C by the Hon’ble Madras High Court. The 
Appellant was charged with offences under the Indian Penal Code and the SC/ST Act
concerning an incident registered in Crime No. 676 of 2021. The High Court had rejected
the Appellant’s petitions, stating that the allegations were sufficient for trial.
However, the Supreme Court found that the ingredients necessary to constitute an
offence under the SC-ST Act were not made out, leading to the quashing of the charge-
sheet and all related proceedings by the Supreme Court, thus offering relief to 
the Appellant. Following an incident where he allegedly insulted a Revenue Inspector
by using caste-based slurs. The Supreme Court, upon reviewing the allegations in
the FIR, concluded that the incident did not occur in a “place within public view,”
a necessary condition for the offences under the SC-ST Act to be applicable. Consequently,
the Court allowed the appeal, quashed the High Court’s judgment, and set aside the
charge sheet and all related proceedings against the appellant.

### 󠀁[Supreme court clarified the celebrated Uma devi judgment. State of Karnataka vs. Umadevi (2006 (4) SCC 1). (hereinafter umadevi judgment)](http://localhost:8080/section1/supreme-court-clarified-the-celebrated-uma-devi-judgment-state-of-karnataka-vs-umadevi-2006-4-scc-1-hereinafter-umadevi-judgment/)󠁿

“…Right to employment, if it is a part of right to life, would stand denuded by 
the preferring of those who have got in casually or those who have come through 
the back door. The obligation cast on the State under Article 39(a) of the Constitution
of India is to ensure that all citizens equally have the right to adequate means
of livelihood….

### 󠀁[Dock identification not relied since the Test Identification was not conducted](http://localhost:8080/section1/dock-identification-not-relied-since-the-test-identification-was-not-conducted/)󠁿

In the criminal appeal arising from the conviction of Wahid and Anshu, the court
found insufficient corroborative evidence regarding the recovery of looted articles,
thus granting the appellants the benefit of the doubt. Despite the prosecution’s
arguments and witness testimonies, the court determined that the evidence was not
compelling enough to uphold the lower court’s convictions. Consequently, the appeals
were allowed, the impugned judgment and order of the High Court were set aside, 
and the appellants were acquitted of all charges. They were reported to be on bail,
and their bail bonds were discharged.

### 󠀁[Transfer of malice: Act of accused was nothing but murder under section 302 IPC r/w section 301 IPC](http://localhost:8080/section1/transfer-of-malice-act-of-accused-was-nothing-but-murder-under-section-302-ipc-r-w-section-301-ipc/)󠁿

In the judgment delivered on January 30, 2025, in this case, the Supreme Court revisited
the appellant’s conviction originally for murder under Section 302 of the IPC, which
was subsequently altered to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section
304 Part-I. The Court acknowledged the significance of the year of the incident (
1992) and the appellant’s age (74 years), resulting in a reduction of the sentence
to the period already undergone. The Court upheld the High Court’s acceptance of
two eyewitness testimonies that implicated the appellant, ultimately dismissing 
the appellant’s appeal and disposing of the case accordingly.

### 󠀁[No Original Documents No Registration of Deed?](http://localhost:8080/section1/no-original-documents-no-registration-of-deed/)󠁿

In this judgment, the Hon’ble High Court of Madras examined an appeal filed by P.
Pappu against the dismissal of his writ petition challenging a refusal check slip
issued by the Sub Registrar, Rasipuram, concerning a release deed. The Court noted
that the provisions of Rule 55-A were meant to prevent fraudulent transactions but
maintained that there should not be an absolute bar on registration without the 
original documents, as clarifications from the Inspector General allowed for exceptions.
Ultimately, the Court set aside the previous orders and directed the Sub Registrar
to register the release deed once re-presented by the appellant within four weeks,
without insisting on the production of originals within 15 days of presentation.
The writ petition was allowed with no costs.

### 󠀁[Murder case: Asphyxia can be caused by Chronic tuberculosis and the ligature marks on the neck might be due to long journey of dead body](http://localhost:8080/section1/murder-case-asphyxia-can-be-caused-by-chronic-tuberculosis-and-the-ligature-marks-on-the-neck-might-be-due-to-long-journey-of-dead-body/)󠁿

The document discusses the legal principles regarding the evaluation of circumstantial
evidence in criminal cases, focusing on the standards established in the case of
Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra. It elaborates on the need for 
a conclusive chain of evidence to establish guilt and the responsibilities of both
the prosecution and the accused, particularly in relation to Section 106 of the 
Evidence Act, which places a burden on the accused to explain circumstances when
the prosecution has met its initial burden. The case details also include instances
where key witnesses turned hostile, leaving the prosecution reliant on formal witnesses
and their testimonies for establishing the facts of the case. Accused acquitted.

### 󠀁[Firearm: Acquittal: Ballistic report opined that two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the test fired bullets](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/ Acquittal: Ballistic report opined that two bullets found in the bodies were not sufficient for comparison with the test fired bullets)󠁿

In the case of Siba Nial @ Trilochan vs. State of Odisha, the Supreme Court of India
overturned the conviction of the appellant for the murder of Dhaneswar Kata and 
his wife, Nirupama Kata, which had been affirmed by the High Court. The prosecution’s
case relied heavily on witness testimonies that were found to be inconsistent and
lacking in direct evidence linking the appellant to the crime, as key witnesses 
did not identify any culprits and there were significant gaps in the timeline of
events. Additionally, the forensic evidence, including the postmortem and ballistic
reports, did not conclusively support the prosecution’s claims. Given these deficiencies
and discrepancies, the Court concluded that the guilt of the appellant was not proven
beyond a reasonable doubt, leading to the allowance of the appeal and the appellant’s
immediate release from jail.

### 󠀁[Dowry death: Acquittal: Evidence on record is full of omissions amount to material contradiction to peril the prosecution story of demand of dowry](http://localhost:8080/section1/dowry-death-acquittal-evidence-on-record-is-full-of-omissions-amount-to-material-contradiction-to-peril-the-prosecution-story-of-demand-of-dowry/)󠁿

This judgment pertains to the case where the accused was initially found guilty 
of the offence under Section 304B of the Indian Penal Code (I.P.C.) for causing 
the death of his wife under circumstances suggesting dowry-related cruelty. However,
upon appeal, the High Court scrutinized the evidence and determined that the prosecution
failed to substantiate the claim of a dowry demand of ₹4,00,000/-, concluding that
the financial and social circumstances of the parties made such a demand improbable.
Consequently, the court upheld the presumption of innocence and reversed the decision
of acquittal, reinforcing the principle that appellate courts are reluctant to overturn
an acquittal unless there is compelling evidence of guilt.

### 󠀁[PMLA-Bail:  Mandatory requirements of Section 45 PMLA not considered while releasing the accused on bail hence matter remanded back for fresh consideration](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/)󠁿

In this judgment, the Supreme Court of India addressed the appeal filed by the Union
of India through the Enforcement Directorate, challenging the High Court’s decision
to grant bail to Kanhaiya Prasad under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA).
The Supreme Court found the High Court’s order to be unsustainable and untenable,
highlighting that it failed to consider the mandatory requirements of Section 45
of the PMLA, which outlines strict conditions for granting bail in such cases. The
Supreme Court remanded the matter back to the High Court for fresh consideration
and directed that Kanhaiya Prasad surrender before the Special Court within one 
week, ultimately allowing the appeal.

### 󠀁[Portions contradicted with the previous statement can be put in bracket and marked as Exhibit AA, BB, e.t.c](http://localhost:8080/section1/portions-contradicted-with-the-previous-statement-can-be-put-in-bracket-and-marked-as-aa-bb-e-t-c/)󠁿

The law is well settled. The portion of the prior statement shown to the witness
for contradicting the witness must be proved through the investigating officer. 
Unless the said portion of the prior statement used for contradiction is duly proved,
it cannot be reproduced in the deposition of the witnesses. The correct procedure
is that the Trial Judge should mark the portions of the prior statements used for
contradicting the witness. The said portions can be put in bracket and marked as
AA, BB, etc. The marked portions cannot form a part of the deposition unless the
same are proved.

### 󠀁[Discharge: When specific remedy is available under section 397 Cr.P.C the CBI ought not to have filed petition under section 482 Cr.P.C](https://section1.in/monthly-digest-february-2025/ When specific remedy is available under section 397 Cr.P.C the CBI ought not to have filed petition under section 482 Cr.P.C)󠁿

In the present case, the Apex Court overturned a High Court order that had set aside
a discharge order by a Special Judicial Magistrate, which had previously cleared
the appellants of charges under Sections 420 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code. 
The Court found that the appellants had initially disclosed relevant information
regarding a bank loan and mortgage in their first application to the AICTE when 
seeking approval for educational institutions. The subsequent applications contained
inaccuracies regarding the mortgage, but the AICTE had not claimed to be misled 
or dishonestly induced to grant approvals. The Court concluded that the essential
elements of cheating were not established, as the AICTE officials were not implicated
in any wrongdoing, and thus restored the discharge order, allowing the appellants
to stand discharged from the alleged offences.

### 󠀁[UAPA bail granted after five years in custody](http://localhost:8080/section1/uapa-bail-granted-after-five-years-in-custody/)󠁿

In this case, allowed the appellant’s appeal for bail after he had been in custody
for nearly five years without a conclusion in trial. The Court acknowledged the 
seriousness of the charges under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) and
the Indian Penal Code (IPC) but emphasized the appellant’s fundamental right to 
a speedy trial as enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution. It criticized the
prosecution for planning to examine an excessive number of witnesses, which contributed
to trial delays, and highlighted the need for efficient trial management. The Court
granted bail with specific conditions, including restrictions on entering certain
areas and requirements for online appearances, while warning that any breach of 
these conditions would lead to automatic cancellation of bail.

### 󠀁[Directions issued to manage S. 138 NI Act cases effectively](http://localhost:8080/section1/directions-issued-to-manage-s-138-ni-act-cases-effectively/)󠁿

Directions issued to manage S. 138 NI Act cases effectively.
