# Moratorium Protections (IBC) in Section 138 Proceedings referred to Larger Bench

- Link: https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/
- Published: 2026-05-29T15:07:24+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#appeal)
 * [A. Factual matrix](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#a-factual-matrix)
 * [C. Issues for determination](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#c-issues-for-determination)
 * [E. Determination Of The Issues Identified](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#e-determination-of-the-issues-identified)
    - [I. Whether the proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act are in the nature of legal action for recovery of money?](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#i-whether-the-proceedings-under-section-138-of-the-ni-act-are-in-the-nature-of-legal-action-for-recovery-of-money)
    - [II. Whether the proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act are protected during the moratorium period provided under Part-III of the IBC?](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#ii-whether-the-proceedings-under-section-138-of-the-ni-act-are-protected-during-the-moratorium-period-provided-under-partiii-of-the-ibc)
    - [Whether director(s) liable under Section 141 of the NI Act would enjoy the benefit of moratorium in respect of Section 138 proceedings, while undergoing personal insolvency?](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#whether-directors-liable-under-section-141-of-the-ni-act-would-enjoy-the-benefit-of-moratorium-in-respect-of-section-138-proceedings-while-undergoing-personal-insolvency)
 * [F. Conclusion](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#f-conclusion)
    - [Matter was referred to larger (3 judge bench) by framing two questions](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#matter-was-referred-to-larger-3-judge-bench-by-framing-two-questions)
 * [References](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#references)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/moratorium-protections-ibc-in-section-138-proceedings-referred-to-larger-bench/#party)

#### **Appeal**

2. Since the issues raised in all the captioned appeals are the same, those were
taken up for hearing analogously and are being disposed of by this common judgment
and order.

3. This appeal arises from the [judgment and order dated 18.10.2023 passed by the High Court](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
of Judicature at Madras, dismissing the Criminal OP SR No. 40230 of 2023 and Criminal
MP No. 13854 of 2023 respectively filed by the appellant herein seeking to get the
complaint quashed, which was filed by the respondent herein under Section 138 of
the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (the “NI Act”), essentially on the ground that
the appellant was undergoing [personal insolvency proceedings and that the complaint](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act were stayed during the interim moratorium
period under Section 96 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (the “IBC”).

#### **A. Factual matrix**

**Appellant is the former MD of SPL: **4. The appellant is the former Managing Director
of M/s. Surana Power Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “SPL”), a company incorporated
under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956. The company is engaged in the business
of generation, production and sale of electricity. Presently, SPL undergoing liquidation
as per the [order dated 19.02.2018 passed by the National Companies Law Tribunal](https://section1.in/court-martial-murder-case-armed-forces-tribunal-order-of-acquittal-enhances-the-presumption-of-innocence/),
Chennai.

**Appellant availed a loan from the respondent for 5 crores**: 5. It appears from
the materials on [record that the appellant herein availed](https://section1.in/digitization-of-records-records-not-available-in-the-appeal-conviction-set-aside/)
various financial and credit facilities from the respondent bank which included 
the opening of Irrevocable Letters of Credit Facility on 26.12.2014 for the purchase
of Indonesian Coal from M/s. Natural Coal Private Ltd. for a sum of Rs. 5,03,21,250/-.
The respondent bank acceded to the appellant’s request to open an Inland Letter 
of Credit in favour of SPL for the said purpose.

**Appellant provided a blank [cheque as security](https://section1.in/security-cheque-if-the-signature-is-not-in-dispute-then-the-court-cannot-set-aside-the-summoning-order/)**:
6. The appellant had to provide a blank cheque by way of security to the respondent
for the issuance of the Inland Letter of Credit with an understanding that the respondent
would be at liberty to encash the same if ultimately the liability of paying the
sum of Rs. 5,03,21,250/- fell onto the respondent due to non-payment thereof by 
the appellant and SPL respectively within 90 days of the invoice raised by M/s. 
Natural Coal Private [Limited](https://section1.in/limitation-section-468-cr-p-c-applies-for-both-cases-instituted-upon-a-complaint-or-by-a-police-report-what-matters-is-the-date-of-initiation-of-criminal-proceedings/).

**Cheque got dishonoured as ‘funds insufficient’**: 7. In view of the devolvement
of the Letter of Credit to SPL, the respondent became liable to pay the bills amounting
to Rs. 5,03,21,250/- which were originally payable by SPL. In such circumstances,
the appellant [issued a cheque dated](https://section1.in/high-court-can-quash-cheating-charges-if-there-was-no-dishonest-intention-of-false-promise-while-making-it-and-since-the-making-of-movie-is-not-false-as-issuing-post-dated-cheques-is-not-a-false-promi/)
26.03.2015 drawn on Punjab National Bank in order to clear the aforesaid dues payable
to the respondent by the SPL. However, the said cheque got dishonoured on 18.06.2015
with an endorsement of “Funds Insufficient”.

**[Cheque case was filed](https://section1.in/complainants-are-victim-in-cheque-cases-and-they-may-file-appeal-against-acquittal-under-section-372-cr-p-c-itself-without-seeking-special-leave-under-section-3784-cr-p-c/)
after the legal compliance**: 8. In view of the aforesaid, the respondent issued
a statutory notice dated 23.06.2015 under Section 138 of the [NI Act](https://section1.in/directions-issued-to-manage-s-138-ni-act-cases-effectively/),
to the SPL, the appellant and the other accused calling upon them to make good the
amount in respect of which the cheque was dishonoured. After 15 days from the issuance
of the statutory notice, the respondent filed the C.C. No. 3645 of 2015 before the
XIV Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai (the “MM, Egmore”).

**[Quash dismissed by the High court](https://section1.in/s-c-quashed-g-o-of-tamilnadu-for-anti-land-grabbing-cell-and-adviced-to-enact-appropriate-legislation-for-land-grabbing-cases/)**:
9. On 24.10.2018, the appellant [filed Criminal](https://section1.in/sica-does-not-create-any-legal-bar-to-file-criminal-case-against-a-sick-company-or-its-directors-as-per-s-138-n-i-act/)
OP No. 24740 of 2019 before the High [Court praying for quashing of the complaint filed](https://section1.in/pmla-cognizance-under-pmla-special-court-can-take-cognizance-only-by-way-of-complaint-filed-by-the-authority-authorized-on-this-behalf/)
by the respondent before the MM, Egmore. However, the High Court dismissed the petition
vide its order dated 24.10.2018.

**NCLT admitted section 95 IBC insolvency application**: 10. After about three years,
the National Company Law Tribunal, Chennai (the “NCLT”) vide its order dated 15.02.2022,
admitted an insolvency application against the appellant under Section 95 of the
IBC, during the pendency of the [complaint filed](https://section1.in/protest-petition-when-the-magistrate-does-not-treat-the-protest-petition-as-a-complaint-and-rejects-it-then-the-complainant-can-file-a-fresh-complaint/)
before the MM, Egmore.

**Petition for quash based on section 96 IBC**: 11. On 09.08.2023, the appellant
filed Criminal OP SR No. 40230 of 2023 and Criminal MP No. 13854 of 2023 respectively
before the High [Court for quashing of the complaint under Section](https://section1.in/section-482-crpc-only-high-court-has-the-power-to-direct-to-run-sentences-in-two-different-cases-concurrently/)
138 of the NI Act pending before the MM, Egmore and stay of the proceedings thereunder,
respectively. The appellant prayed for stay of the proceedings under Section 138
of the NI Act on the ground that as per Section 96 of the IBC, the interim moratorium
would operate as regards a legal proceeding in respect of any debt. Therefore, the
proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act would be covered by such interim moratorium.

**Quash [dismissed stating that since section](https://section1.in/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)
138 NI Act is not a proceeding for recovery of money and hence section 96 IBC is
not applicable**: 12. The High Court vide its order dated 18.10.2023 dismissed the
said applications on the premise that [Section 138 of NI Act is not a proceeding](https://section1.in/initiation-of-criminal-proceeding-under-sections-138-141-n-i-act-is-covered-under-moratorium-provision-u-s-14-ibc/)
for recovery of money from a debtor and thus, the moratorium under Section 96 of
the IBC is not applicable. The High [Court opined that Section 138 of the NI Act](https://section1.in/no-court-should-allow-a-witness-to-be-contradicted-by-reference-to-the-previous-statement-in-writing-or-reduced-to-writing-unless-the-procedure-set-out-in-section-145-of-the-evidence-act-has-been-foll/)
is a criminal enactment which provides for sentence of imprisonment and fine. Therefore,
the proceedings under [Section 138 of the NI Act](https://section1.in/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/)
could be said to be criminal in nature and not merely intended to be recovery proceedings
against a debtor.

**NCLT admitted the appellant’s personal insolvency application**: 13. Later, on
30.08.2024, the NCLT admitted the personal insolvency application against the appellant
and triggered the operation of the moratorium under Section 101 of the IBC.

14. Upon completion of the insolvency proceedings, the NCLT, on 03.01.2025, closed
the matter thereby granting liberty to the appellant under Section 122 of the IBC
and the creditor under Section 123 of the IBC who, in the [present case](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/),
moved the insolvency application, to file a bankruptcy application. The same was
preferred by the said creditor and a bankruptcy order was passed on 12.11.2025 by
the NCLT. In view thereof, the moratorium under Section 128 of the IBC is currently
operating qua the appellant.

#### **C. Issues for determination**

45. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through
the materials on record, the following questions fall for our consideration:

> i. Whether the [proceedings under Section](https://section1.in/the-statement-of-the-complainant-recorded-in-the-abscondence-proceedings-is-a-substantive-piece-of-evidence-as-per-section-299-cr-p-c-read-with-section-33-of-iea/)
> 138 of the NI Act are initiated with the object to recover the money from the 
> debtor?
> ii. Whether the proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act are protected during
> the moratorium period provided under Part-III of the IBC, i.e., under Sections
> 96 and 101 respectively during the insolvency proceedings as well as Sections 
> 124 and 128 respectively during the bankruptcy proceedings?
> iii. Whether the proceedings under [Section 138 of the NI Act against the individual](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/)
> directors and other persons vicariously liable under Sections 141 of the NI Act
> for the actions of the corporate debtor would benefit from the moratorium provisions
> in Part-III of the IBC in cases of personal insolvency or bankruptcy?

#### **E. Determination Of The Issues Identified**

##### **I. Whether the proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act are in the nature of legal action for recovery of money?**

194. The answer to this question must be an emphatic ‘No’. We are of the considered
view that the discussion on the predominantly criminal nature and objective of [Section 138 of the NI Act](https://section1.in/no-court-should-allow-a-witness-to-be-contradicted-by-reference-to-the-previous-statement-in-writing-or-reduced-to-writing-unless-the-procedure-set-out-in-section-145-of-the-evidence-act-has-been-foll/)
was not brought to the attention of the three-Judge Bench of this Court in P. Mohanraj(
supra). We have held that though [proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act are quasi- criminal](https://section1.in/under-section-195-cr-p-c-honble-high-court-can-commence-criminal-proceeding/),
yet the predominant nature of such proceedings is criminal. We have said so after
a perusal of the reasons on the strength of which the judgment in P. Mohanraj (supra)
described Section 138 as a “civil sheep in criminal wolf’s clothing”. In our considered
opinion the three-Judge Bench described Section 138 proceeding inherently civil 
in nature primarily on the basis of the procedure stipulated under Chapter XVII 
of the NI Act.

196. On a plain reading of Section 138 of the NI Act, it is limpid that the offence
is the act of cheque dishonour which has been saddled with criminal consequences.
The non-payment of the debt to the extent of the cheque amount is the injury caused
due to commission of the offence. The principal object of Section 138 is to deter
persons from using cheques when they have insufficient balance. The provision of
punishment is a measure of deterrence. Therefore, the provision was not intended
to be used as a recovery of debt mechanism.

##### **II. Whether the proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act are protected during the moratorium period provided under Part-III of the IBC?**

202. We have also dealt with the compensatory aspect of Section 138 proceedings 
and have taken the view that the same is in the nature of a civil remedy that would
result in the depletion of the assets of the individual debtor if not stayed. Therefore,
we are of the view that the moratorium provisions under Part III of the IBC must
be made applicable in respect of recovery of [compensation](https://section1.in/husband-died-but-pw-1-wife-survived-by-sustained-injuries-high-court-by-reasoned-judgment-reduced-the-sentence-and-directed-to-pay-compensation/)
in Section 138 proceedings.

203. Therefore, operation of moratorium [depends upon](https://section1.in/sentencing-policy-depend-upon-facts-and-circumstances/)
the stage of the Section 138 proceeding.

##### **Whether director(s) liable under Section 141 of the NI Act would enjoy the benefit of moratorium in respect of Section 138 proceedings, while undergoing personal insolvency?**

204. We have answered the aforesaid question in the affirmative. We find it apposite
to reiterate that the benefit of moratorium is available only in respect of the 
compensatory aspect of Section 138 proceedings.

209. In our considered opinion, moratorium under Sections 96 and 101 of the IBC 
respectively is applicable on the director(s) who are saddled with the liability
to discharge the compensatory obligation of the company by virtue of the use of 
the words “any debt” therein. Further, the moratorium under Sections 124 and 128
of the IBC respectively would also stay any suit or legal proceedings against the
properties of the debtor, instituted with the purpose of [enforcement of the bankruptcy debt](https://section1.in/provisions-of-sec-138-n-i-act-attracts-only-when-it-has-been-issued-to-discharge-a-legally-enforceable-debt/).

#### **F. Conclusion**

##### **Matter was referred to larger (3 judge bench) by framing two questions**

210. In view of what has been pointed out hereinabove, we are of the opinion that,
for a comprehensive consideration and an authoritative pronouncement after taking
into account all aspects, including those dealt with hereinabove, the matter needs
to be placed before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India to constitute an appropriate
three-Judge Bench.

211. The three-Judge [Bench constituted](https://section1.in/section-319-cr-p-c-summoning-of-accused-after-the-pronouncement-whether-valid/)
may refer to the following questions:

(i) Whether the provisions of Section 138 of the NI Act and the objective underlying
the enactment thereof indicate that it is quasicriminal in nature with a tilt towards
the criminal side?

(ii) Whether the moratorium provisions under Part III of the IBC should be [made](https://section1.in/s-138-n-i-act-would-not-attract-if-the-part-payment-made-before-encashment-of-the-cheque-issued-for-the-original-amount/)
applicable on the entire proceedings under Section 138 of the NI Act or only to 
the compensatory aspect thereof?

212. The registry is directed to place these matters before Hon’ble the Chief Justice
of India for [appropriate orders](https://section1.in/even-in-bail-matters-high-courts-can-travel-beyond-the-scope-and-pass-appropriate-orders-under-articles-226-and-227/).

#### **References**

Judgments involved or cited

1. The Current Judgment: Dineshchand Surana v. UCO Bank – Citation: SLP (Crl.) Nos.
12135-12136 of 2024 (Diary No. 37189/2024), [Supreme Court](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-public-prosecutor-while-explaining-the-principles-of-106-iea-in-criminal-cases-honble-supreme-court-has-addressed-the-government-to-appoint-skilled-lawyers-as-public-prosec/)
of India – Date: May 27, 2026.

 * Context: The 151-page ruling you are currently viewing. It analyzes the conflict
   between Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments (NI) Act and the Insolvency
   and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) moratorium, ultimately [referring the matter to a larger bench](https://section1.in/whether-sanction-is-necessary-at-the-stage-of-direction-under-section-1563-cr-p-c-case-referred-to-larger-bench/)
   for a comprehensive constitutional resolution.

2. Precedents Cited & Analysed

Rakesh Bhanot v. Gurdas Agro Pvt. Ltd. Citation: (2025) 6 SCC 781 | 2025 SCC OnLine
SC 728.

 * Context: Established that the interim moratorium under [Section](https://section1.in/prosecution-has-to-establish-the-existence-of-demand-as-well-as-acceptance-by-the-public-servant-to-prove-sections-7-131d-of-p-c-act/)
   96 of the IBC applies only to civil debt recovery and does not shield individuals
   from criminal prosecutions under Section 138 of the NI Act.

P. Mohanraj v. Shah Brothers Ispat Pvt. Ltd. Citation: (2021) 6 SCC 258 | 2021 SCC
OnLine SC 152.

 * Context: The foundational three-judge bench decision holding that the Section
   14 IBC moratorium applies to _corporate debtors_ in cheque dishonor proceedings.

Ajay Kumar Radheyshyam Goenka v. Tourism Finance Corpn. of India Ltd. Citation: (
2023) 10 SCC 545 | 2023 SCC OnLine SC 266.

 * Context: Reinforced that the personal penal liability of directors and signatories
   under Section 141 of the NI Act is not extinguished simply because a corporate
   insolvency resolution plan has been approved.

Narinder Garg v. Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. Citation: (2022) 2 SCC 576 | 2022 SCC 
OnLine SC 517.

 * Context: Ruled firmly that moratorium provisions under the IBC protect the corporate
   entity itself but do not absolve the personal penal consequences for the individuals
   who issued the dishonored cheques.

Vijay Kumar Ghai v. Pritpal Singh Babbar Citation: 2022 SCC OnLine P&H 1944 (Punjab
and Haryana High Court).

 * Context: A coordinate High Court judgment referenced in the litigation history
   concerning procedural attempts by accused individuals to use IBC provisions to
   stay NI [Act trial court proceedings](https://section1.in/pocso-victims-contradictory-statements-cannot-form-the-basis-for-quashing-criminal-proceedings-but-trial-court-must-careful-on-misusing-this-act/).

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    Dineshchand Surana v. UCO Bank - Criminal Appeal No. (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) Nos. 12135-12136 of 2024) - 2026 INSC 579 - May 27, 2026 – Hon’ble Mr. Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Hon’ble Mr. Justice K.V. Viswanathan.
    ```

[Dineshchand Surana vs. UCO Bank 371892024_2026-05-27](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Dineshchand-Surana-vs.-UCO-Bank-371892024_2026-05-27.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Dineshchand-Surana-vs.-UCO-Bank-371892024_2026-05-27.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [N.I ACT: Initiation of criminal proceeding under sections 138 &141 N.I Act is covered under moratorium provision [U/S 14 IBC]](https://section1.in/initiation-of-criminal-proceeding-under-sections-138-141-n-i-act-is-covered-under-moratorium-provision-u-s-14-ibc/)
