# Mr. Arvind Kejriwal Interim Bail: Framing the questions of law on the arrest Hon’ble Supreme Court has referred to a larger bench further granted Interim bail to Kejriwal with the condition not to visit the CM office

- Link: https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/
- Published: 2024-07-12T21:42:04+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal against the rejection of writ petition filed questioning the validity of section 19 PMLA](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#appeal-against-the-rejection-of-writ-petition-filed-questioning-the-validity-of-section-19-pmla)
 * [Mr. Arvind Kejriwal is not an accused till the charge sheets (including two supplementary chargesheets) were filed by the CBI and cognizance taken by the special court on the allegation of excise policy framed for sale of liquor in Delhi](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#mr-arvind-kejriwal-is-not-an-accused-till-the-charge-sheets-including-two-supplementary-chargesheets-were-filed-by-the-cbi-and-cognizance-taken-by-the-special-court-on-the-allegation-of-excise-policy)
 * [Though the DOE (Directorate of Enforcement) has filed the first complaint as early on 26.11.2022 since then the DOE has filed seven supplementary complaints in which the Kejriwal was added as accused in the last complaint](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#though-the-doe-directorate-of-enforcement-has-filed-the-first-complaint-as-early-on-26112022-since-then-the-doe-has-filed-seven-supplementary-complaints-in-which-the-kejriwal-was-added-as-accused-in-t)
 * [Kejriwal argued that the summons and notices sent by the PMLA were illegal](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#kejriwal-argued-that-the-summons-and-notices-sent-by-the-pmla-were-illegal)
 * [Ground of appeal: Arrest was in violation of section 19(1) PMLA](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#ground-of-appeal-arrest-was-in-violation-of-section-191-pmla)
 * [ECIR is not a public document](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#ecir-is-not-a-public-document)
 * [Question of law: Under PMLA Is mere satisfaction of the formal parameters to arrest sufficient?](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#question-of-law-under-pmla-is-mere-satisfaction-of-the-formal-parameters-to-arrest-sufficient)
 * [Test of proportionality](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#test-of-proportionality)
 * [Interim bail is granted after referring to a larger bench](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#interim-bail-is-granted-after-referring-to-a-larger-bench)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/mr-arvind-kejriwal-interim-bail-framing-the-questions-of-law-on-the-arrest-honble-supreme-court-has-referred-to-a-larger-bench-further-granted-interim-bail-to-kejriwal-with-the-condition-no/#party)

##### **Appeal against the rejection of writ petition filed questioning the validity of section 19 PMLA**

This appeal filed by the appellant – Arvind Kejriwal assails the judgment and order
dated 09.04.2024 passed by the single Judge of the High Court of Delhi whereby the
Criminal Writ Petition filed by Arvind Kejriwal under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19731,
challenging his arrest by the Directorate of Enforcement2, vide the arrest order
dated 21.03.2024, on the ground of violation of Section 19 of the Prevention of 
Money Laundering Act, 20023, and the proceedings pursuant thereto including the 
order of remand dated 22.03.2024 to the custody of DoE passed by the Special Judge,
has been rejected.

2. At the outset, we must clarify that this is not an appeal against refusal or 
grant of bail. Instead, this appeal impugns the validity of arrest under Section
19 of the PML Act. It raises a pivotal question regarding the scope and ambit of
the trial court/courts to examine the legality of the arrest under Section 19. The
issue is legal in nature, and with the ratio being propounded in detail, the decision
becomes complex and legalistic.

##### **Mr. Arvind Kejriwal is not an accused till the charge sheets (including two supplementary chargesheets) were filed by the CBI and cognizance taken by the special court on the allegation of excise policy framed for sale of liquor in Delhi**

3. On 17.08.2022, the Central Bureau of Investigation registered RC No. 0032022A0053
for the offences punishable under Section 120B read with Section 477A of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860 and Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The registration
was based on a complaint dated 20.07.2022, made by the Lieutenant Governor of the
Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi, and on the directions of the 
competent authority conveyed by the Director, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government
of India.

4. Later, on 25.11.2022, the CBI filed a chargesheet. Thereafter, on 25.04.2023 
and 08.07.2023, two supplementary chargesheets were filed. On 15.12.2022, the **
[Special Court took cognisance of the offences](http://localhost:8080/section1/pmla-cognizance-under-pmla-special-court-can-take-cognizance-only-by-way-of-complaint-filed-by-the-authority-authorized-on-this-behalf/).**
The chargesheets inter alia allege that the excise policy, framed for the sale of
liquor in NCT of Delhi, was a product of **[criminal conspiracy](http://localhost:8080/section1/title-understanding-section-120b-of-the-indian-penal-code-ipc-criminal-conspiracy-and-its-implications/)**.
It was hatched by a cartel of liquor manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers and
it provided undue pecuniary gain to public servants and other accused in the conspiracy.
It resulted in huge losses to the government exchequer and ultimately to the public.
Arvind Kejriwal is not an accused in the said chargesheets.

##### **Though the DOE (Directorate of Enforcement) has filed the first complaint as early on 26.11.2022 since then the DOE has filed seven supplementary complaints in which the Kejriwal was added as accused in the last complaint**

5. On 22.08.2022, the DoE recorded ECIR No. HIU-II/14/2022 based on offences detailed
under the RC registered by CBI. The offences under the RC are the predicate offence
for investigation/inquiry into the scheduled offences under the PML Act. On 26.11.2022,
the DoE **[filed the first prosecution complaint](http://localhost:8080/section1/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/).**
On 20.12.2022, the Special Court took cognisance. Since then, the DoE has filed 
seven supplementary prosecution complaints. In the last complaint, that is, the 
Seventh Supplementary Prosecution Complaint dated 17.05.2024, Arvind Kejriwal has
been named as an accused.

##### **Kejriwal argued that the summons and notices sent by the PMLA were illegal**

6. On 30.10.2023, Arvind Kejriwal was issued notice under **[Section 50 of the PML Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/)**
for his appearance and recording of statement. Thereafter, eight **[summons were issued till his arrest](http://localhost:8080/section1/pmla-section-88-cr-p-c-an-order-accepting-bonds-under-section-88-cr-p-c-from-the-accused-does-not-amount-to-a-grant-of-bail-a-detailed-discussion-on-arrest-summons-warrant-bail-and-bond-under/)**
on 21.03.2024. DoE states that Arvind Kejriwal failed to appear and join the investigation.
Arvind Kejriwal claims that the summons and notices under Section 50 were illegal,
bad in law and invalid.

##### **Ground of appeal: Arrest was in violation of section 19(1) PMLA**

7. The cardinal ground taken in the present appeal is that Arvind Kejriwal was arrested
in violation of Section 19(1) of the PML Act. It is contended that the arrest was
illegal, which makes the order of remand to custody of the DoE passed by the Special
Court dated 01.04.2024 also illegal. Therefore, it would be apt to begin by referring
to Section 19 and elucidating how the Courts have interpreted and applied the section.

9. A bare reading of the section reflects, that while the legislature has given 
power to the Director, Deputy Director, Assistant Director, or an authorised officer
to arrest a person, it is fenced with preconditions and requirements, which must
be satisfied prior to the arrest of a person. The conditions are –

 * The officer must have material in his possession.
 * On the basis of such material, the authorised officer should form and record 
   in writing, “reasons to believe” that the person to be arrested, is guilty of
   an offence punishable under the PML Act.
 * The person arrested, as soon as may be, must be **[informed of the grounds of arrest](http://localhost:8080/section1/ratio-decidendi-failing-to-inform-the-accused-of-the-grounds-of-arrest-denying-the-opportunity-to-defend-through-counsel-and-failing-to-provide-information-about-the-proposed-remand-is-unconstituti/).**

These preconditions act as stringent safeguards to protect life and liberty of individuals.
We shall subsequently interpret the words “material”, “reason to believe”, and “
guilty of the offence”. Before that, we will refer to some judgments of this Court
on the importance of Section 19(1) and the effect on the legality of the arrest 
upon failure to comply with the statutory requirements.

10. In **Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and others, [2023 SCC Online SC 1244]**
interpreting Section 19 of the PML Act with reference to Article 22(1) of the Constitution
of India,10 this Court has observed:

“32. In this regard, we may note that Article 22(1) of the Constitution provides,
inter alia, that no person who is arrested shall be detained in custody without 
being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds for such arrest. This being the
fundamental right guaranteed to the arrested person, the mode of conveying information
of the grounds of arrest must necessarily be meaningful so as to serve the intended
purpose. It may be noted that **[Section 45 of the Act of 2002 enables the person](http://localhost:8080/section1/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/)**
arrested under Section 19 thereof to seek release on bail but it postulates that
unless the twin conditions prescribed thereunder are satisfied, such a person would
not be entitled to grant of bail. The twin conditions set out in the provision are
that, firstly, the Court must be satisfied, after giving an opportunity to the public
prosecutor to oppose the application for release, that there are reasonable grounds
to believe that the arrested person is not guilty of the offence and, secondly, 
that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail. To meet this requirement,
it would be essential for the arrested person to be aware of the grounds on which
the authorized officer arrested him/her under Section 19 and the basis for the officer’s‘
reason to believe’ that he/she is guilty of an offence punishable under the Act 
of 2002. It is only if the arrested person has knowledge of these facts that he/
she would be in a position to plead and prove before the Special Court that there
are grounds to believe that he/she is not guilty of such offence, so as to avail
the relief of bail. Therefore, communication of the grounds of arrest, as mandated
by Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 19 of the Act of 2002, is meant
to serve this higher purpose and must be given due importance.”

In the Court’s view, Section 19 includes inbuilt checks that designated officers
must adhere to. First, the “reasons to believe” of the alleged involvement of the
arrestee have to be recorded in writing. Secondly, while affecting the arrest, the
reasons shall be furnished to the arrestee. Lastly, a copy of the order of arrest
along with the material in possession have to be forwarded to the safe custody of
the adjudicating authority. This ensures fairness, objectivity and accountability
of the designated officer while forming their opinion, regarding the involvement
of the arrestee in the offence of money laundering.

##### **ECIR is not a public document**

11. Arrest under Section 19(1) of the PML Act may occur prior to the filing of the
prosecution complaint and before the Special Judge takes cognizance. Till the prosecution
complaint is filed, there is no requirement to provide the accused with a copy of
the ECIR. The ECIR is not a **[public document](http://localhost:8080/section1/charge-sheet-rti-whether-a-public-document/)**.
Thus, to introduce checks and balances, Section 19(1) imposes safeguards to protect
the rights and liberty of the arrestee. This is in compliance with the mandate of
Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India.

12. **V. Senthil Balaji v. State and others ((2024) 3 SCC 51)** similarly states
that the designated officer can only arrest once they record “reasons to believe”
in writing, that the person being arrested is guilty of the offence punishable under
the PML Act. It is mandatory to record the “reasons to believe” to arrive at the
opinion that the arrestee is guilty of the offence, and to furnish the reasons to
the arrestee. This ensures an element of fairness and accountability.

73. In Prabir Purkayastha (supra), this Court went beyond the rigours of the PML
Act/UAPA. Drawing a distinction between “reasons to arrest” and “grounds for arrest”,
it held that while the former refers to the formal parameters, the latter would 
require all such details in the hands of the **[investigating officer](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)**
necessitating the arrest. Thus, the grounds of arrest would be personal to the accused.

##### **Question of law: Under PMLA Is mere satisfaction of the formal parameters to arrest sufficient?**

74. Therefore, the issue which arises for consideration is whether the court while
examining the validity of arrest in terms of Section 19(1) of the PML Act will also
go into and examine the necessity and need to arrest. In other words, is the mere
satisfaction of the formal parameters to arrest sufficient? Or is the satisfaction
of necessity and need to arrest, beyond mere formal parameters, required? We would
concede that such review might be conflated with stipulations in Section 41 of the
Code which lays down certain conditions for the police to arrest without warrant:

 * Section 41(1)(ii)(a) – preventing a person from committing further offence.
 * Section 41(1)(ii)(b) – proper investigation of the offence.
 * Section 41(1)(ii)(c) – preventing a person from disappearing or tampering with
   evidence in any manner.
 * Section 41(1)(ii)(d) – preventing the person from making any inducement or threat
   or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade
   him from disclosing such facts to the court or police.
 * Section 41(1)(ii)(e) – to ensure presence of the person in the Court, whenever
   required, which without arresting cannot be ensured.

However, Section 19(1) of the PML Act does not permit arrest only to conduct investigation.
Conditions of Section 19(1) have to be satisfied. Clauses (a), (c), (d) and (e) 
to Section 41(1)(ii) of the Code, apart from other considerations, may be relevant.

75. In **Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (supra),** this Court has held that when a person
applies for **[bail or anticipatory](http://localhost:8080/section1/anticipatory-bail-civil-claims-being-settled-by-pressurising-through-criminal-prosecution-discouraged/)**
bail under the PML Act, the conditions stipulated in Section 437 or 438 or 439 of
the Code would equally apply, in addition to Section 45 of the PML Act. Therefore,
it is urged that necessity to arrest, in the case of arrest under Section 19(1) 
would be an additional factor required to be considered beyond the conditions and
factors stipulated in Section 19(1) of the PML Act.

76. DoE submits that the test of “necessity to arrest” is satisfied in view of Arvind
Kejriwal failing to appear despite the issuance of 9 summons dated 30.10.2023, 18.12.2023,
22.12.2023, 12.01.2024, 31.01.2024, 14.02.2024, 21.02.2024, 26.02.2024, and 16.03.2024.
It is also submitted that arrest is a part and parcel of investigation intended 
to secure evidence, leading to discovery of material facts and relevant information
as held in **P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement [(2019) 9 SCC 24].**

##### **Test of proportionality**

81. The proportionality test is more precise and sophisticated than other traditional
grounds of review. The court is required to assess the balance struck by the decision
maker, not merely whether it is within the range of rational or reasonable decisions.
In this manner, proportionality goes further than the traditional grounds of review
as it requires attention to the relative weight according to interest and considerations.**
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Lal [(2006) 3 SCC 276]** which refers to several other
cases, states that the proportionality test safeguards fundamental rights of citizens
to ensure a fair balance between individual rights and public interest. It requires
the court to judge whether the action taken was really needed and whether it was
within the range of courses of action which could be reasonably followed. Proportionality
is more concerned with the aims and intentions of the decision maker and whether
the decision maker has achieved more or less the correct balance or equilibrium.

82. The principle of proportionality has been followed by this Court in several 
decisions such as **Modern Dental College & Research Centre v. State of Madhya Pradesh**,[(
2016) 4 SCC 346] **K.S. Puttaswamy (Retired) and Anr. (Aadhar) v. Union of India
and Anr. (5J)** [(2019) 1 SCC 1] and **Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India and Others**[(
2020) 3 SCC 637].

83. Recently, the **[Constitution Bench](http://localhost:8080/section1/constitution-bench-on-p-c-act-question-of-law-on-absence-of-evidence-of-complainant-direct-or-primary-evidence/)**
applied the doctrine of proportionality to strike down the Electoral Bond Scheme
in **Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India** [(2024) 5 SCC 1]. In
a way, the present case also relates to funding of elections, an issue which was
examined in some depth in Association for Democratic Reforms (supra).

84. In view of the aforesaid discussion, and as Vijay Madanlal Choudhary (supra)
is a decision rendered by a three Judge Bench, we deem it appropriate to refer the
following questions of law for consideration by a larger Bench:

> (a) Whether the “need and necessity to arrest” is a separate ground to challenge
> the order of arrest passed in terms of Section 19(1) of the PML Act?
> (b) Whether the “need and necessity to arrest” refers to the satisfaction of formal
> parameters to arrest and take a person into custody, or it relates to other personal
> grounds and reasons regarding necessity to arrest a person in the facts and circumstances
> of the said case?
> (c) If questions (a) and (b) are answered in the affirmative, what are the parameters
> and facts that are to be taken into consideration by the court while examining
> the question of “need and necessity to arrest”?

##### **Interim bail is granted after referring to a larger bench**

85. As we are **[referring the matter to a larger Bench](http://localhost:8080/section1/whether-sanction-is-necessary-at-the-stage-of-direction-under-section-1563-cr-p-c-case-referred-to-larger-bench/)**,
we have to, despite our findings on “reasons to believe”, consider whether interim
bail should be granted to Arvind Kejriwal. Given the fact that right to life and
liberty is sacrosanct, and Arvind Kejriwal has suffered incarceration of over 90
days, and that the questions referred to above require in-depth consideration by
a larger Bench, we direct that Arvind Kejriwal may be released on interim bail in
connection with case ECIR No. HIU-II/14/2022 dated 22.08.2022, on the same terms
as imposed vide the order dated 10.05.2024 which reads:

> (a) he shall furnish bail bonds in the sum of Rs.50,000/- with one surety of the
> like amount to the satisfaction of the Jail Superintendent;
> (b) he shall not visit the Office of the Chief Minister and the Delhi Secretariat;
> (c) he shall be bound by the statement made on his behalf that he shall not sign
> official files unless it is required and necessary for obtaining clearance/approval
> of the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi;
> (d) he will not make any comment with regard to his role in the present case; 
> and
> (e) he will not interact with any of the witnesses and/or have access to any official
> files connected with the case.

> The interim bail may be extended, or recalled by the larger Bench.

87. Accordingly, the Registry is directed to place the matter before the Hon’ble
Chief Justice of India for constitution of an appropriate Bench, and if appropriate,
a Constitution Bench, for consideration of the aforesaid questions. The questions
framed above, if required, can be reformulated, substituted and added to.

88. The observations made in this judgment are for deciding the present appeal and
will not be construed as findings on merits of the case/allegations. Facts, as alleged,
have to be established and proved. Application for regular bail, if pending consideration
or required to be decided, shall be decided on its own merits.

##### **Party**

ARVIND KEJRIWAL ….. APPELLANT VERSUS DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT ….. RESPONDENT –
Criminal Appeal No. 2493 of 2024 – 2024 INSC 512 – JULY 12, 2024.

**[https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=163502024&type=j&order_date=2024-07-12&from=latest_judgements_order](https://www.sci.gov.in/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=get_court_pdf&diary_no=163502024&type=j&order_date=2024-07-12&from=latest_judgements_order)**

**[Arvind-Kejriwal-interim-bail-163502024_2024-07-12](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Arvind-Kejriwal-interim-bail-163502024_2024-07-12.pdf)**

 

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
