# Murder case acquittal: How to appreciate Circumstantial evidence is explained

- Link: https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/
- Published: 2024-11-30T16:39:33+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appeal)
    - [Appeal against the modification of conviction from section 302 IPC to section 304 part 1](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appeal-against-the-modification-of-conviction-from-section-302-ipc-to-section-304-part-1)
 * [Factual matrix](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#factual-matrix)
    - [FIR was lodged and investigation stared as a dead body was lying in the verandah of shop](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#fir-was-lodged-and-investigation-stared-as-a-dead-body-was-lying-in-the-verandah-of-shop)
    - [Autopsy reveals death was due to head injury](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#autopsy-reveals-death-was-due-to-head-injury)
    - [Appellants were arrested on suspicion](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appellants-were-arrested-on-suspicion)
    - [Statement of witnesses revealed that they had seen the deceased with the company of accused](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#statement-of-witnesses-revealed-that-they-had-seen-the-deceased-with-the-company-of-accused)
    - [Trial commenced after the charges were framing under sections 302 / 201 r/w 34 IPC](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#trial-commenced-after-the-charges-were-framing-under-sections-302-201-rw-34-ipc)
    - [After trial procedure: Statement under section 313 Cr.PC: Appellant no.1 either outright denied the allegations or pretended not to know about the incriminating circumstances put to him](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#after-trial-procedure-statement-under-section-313-crpc-appellant-no1-either-outright-denied-the-allegations-or-pretended-not-to-know-about-the-incriminating-circumstances-put-to-him)
    - [Recovery of blood stained not put to appellant no.2](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#recovery-of-blood-stained-not-put-to-appellant-no2)
 * [Trial & High courts findings](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#trial-amp-high-courts-findings)
    - [Trial court findings: Convicted the accusedappellants for offences punishable under Sections 302/34 and 201/34 of IPC](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#trial-court-findings-convicted-the-accusedappellants-for-offences-punishable-under-sections-30234-and-20134-of-ipc)
    - [High Court findings: Reduced under Section 304 Part I of IPC](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#high-court-findings-reduced-under-section-304-part-i-of-ipc)
 * [Appeal Analysis](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appeal-analysis)
    - [Exercise of powers under Article 136 of constitution](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#exercise-of-powers-under-article-136-of-constitution)
 * [Appreciation of circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appreciation-of-circumstantial-evidence)
    - [Legal principles qua circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#legal-principles-qua-circumstantial-evidence)
    - [Two view theory on circumstantial evidence is in favour of accused](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#two-view-theory-on-circumstantial-evidence-is-in-favour-of-accused)
    - [Conviction shall be based on must be and not may be](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#conviction-shall-be-based-on-must-be-and-not-may-be)
    - [Circumstances relied by the prosecution](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#circumstances-relied-by-the-prosecution)
    - [Motive: Proving the appellant and deceased were opposing candidates in election is not material bearing in the case](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#motive-proving-the-appellant-and-deceased-were-opposing-candidates-in-election-is-not-material-bearing-in-the-case)
    - [Last seen circumstance: Time gap period explained](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#last-seen-circumstance-time-gap-period-explained)
    - [In the instant case there is a large gap between the deceased last seen alive with accused hence possibility of third party hand in the crime cannot be ruled out](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#in-the-instant-case-there-is-a-large-gap-between-the-deceased-last-seen-alive-with-accused-hence-possibility-of-third-party-hand-in-the-crime-cannot-be-ruled-out)
    - [Appellant(s) looking for the deceased: There may be multiple reasons for a person looking another](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appellants-looking-for-the-deceased-there-may-be-multiple-reasons-for-a-person-looking-another)
    - [Disclosure / Discovery](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#disclosure-discovery)
    - [Recovery of stone was shown as open pathway](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#recovery-of-stone-was-shown-as-open-pathway)
    - [Accused on the way to police station pointed out the place of assault](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#accused-on-the-way-to-police-station-pointed-out-the-place-of-assault)
    - [Hon’ble Supreme court says even accept the recovery of stone at the instance of the appellants is proved the same is inconsequential](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#honble-supreme-court-says-even-accept-the-recovery-of-stone-at-the-instance-of-the-appellants-is-proved-the-same-is-inconsequential)
    - [The stone (weapon in this case) was not shown to the doctor and obtain his opinion about the injury](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#the-stone-weapon-in-this-case-was-not-shown-to-the-doctor-and-obtain-his-opinion-about-the-injury)
    - [Recovery was made not based on disclosure statement but pointed out by the accused enroute to the police station hence recovery inadmissible](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#recovery-was-made-not-based-on-disclosure-statement-but-pointed-out-by-the-accused-enroute-to-the-police-station-hence-recovery-inadmissible)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#conclusion)
    - [Appel allowed and appellants are acquitted](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#appel-allowed-and-appellants-are-acquitted)
    - [Apex court found mistake on modification since multiple injuries on the deceased shows the intention to kill](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#apex-court-found-mistake-on-modification-since-multiple-injuries-on-the-deceased-shows-the-intention-to-kill)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-how-to-appreciate-circumstantial-evidence-is-explained/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal against the modification of conviction from section 302 IPC to section 304 part 1**

1. This criminal appeal impugns the judgment and order of the High Court of Uttarakhand
at Nainital dated 24.5.2012 passed in Criminal Appeal No. 82 of 2003, whereby the
appeal of the appellants against the judgment and order of the Sessions Judge, Pithoragarh
passed in Session Trial No. 36 of 1997 was partly allowed and the conviction of 
the appellants was altered from Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 to
Section 304 Part I of IPC, and the sentence, inter alia, was reduced from imprisonment
for life to 7 years R.I.

#### **Factual matrix**

##### **FIR was lodged and investigation stared as a dead body was lying in the verandah of shop**

2. On 3.2.1997, at about 10 AM, PW-7, a cousin of the deceased, lodged a first information
report (Exb. Ka[1]2) at PS Lohaghat, District Pithoragarh, inter alia, alleging 
that on 3.2.1997, at about 9.30 AM, he came to know that dead body of the deceased
was lying in the verandah of Mohan Singh’s shop. Pursuant to the aforesaid report,
the police proceeded to the spot, carried out inquest and prepared an inquest report(
Exb. Ka-8). It also lifted blood-stained and plain earth/ floor from the spot and
prepared a seizure memo (Exb. Ka-4) thereof. Belongings of the deceased lying near
the spot were also seized and a seizure memo (Exb. Ka-5) was prepared. Besides that,
a black polythene bag containing goat meat was also recovered from near the spot
and another seizure memo (Exb. Ka-3) was prepared.

##### **Autopsy reveals death was due to head injury**

3. Autopsy of the cadaver was conducted by PW-1 on 3.2.1997 at about 2.45 PM. Autopsy
report (Exb. Ka-1) indicated that the deceased died due to shock because of head
injury. The estimated time of death, as per autopsy report, was about a day before
autopsy. Ante[1]mortem injuries noticed at the time of autopsy were:

“ ……………. “

##### **Appellants were arrested on suspicion**

4. On 6.2.1997, the police arrested the appellants on suspicion and, according to
the police, at the pointing out of the appellants, the place where the deceased 
was allegedly assaulted was discovered. From that place, allegedly, some bloodstained
stones and mud were lifted and a seizure memo (Exb. Ka-6) was prepared.

##### **Statement of witnesses revealed that they had seen the deceased with the company of accused**

5. During investigation, inter alia, statements of witnesses who had seen the deceased
in the company of the accused on 2.2.1997 during daytime and who had seen the two
accused in the company of each other, late in the night of 2.2.1997, on the pathway,
near the place from where the dead body of the deceased was recovered were recorded.
Based on that, a charge sheet was submitted against the appellants.

##### **Trial commenced after the charges were framing under sections 302 / 201 r/w 34 IPC**

6. After taking cognizance on the charge sheet, the case was committed to the Court
of Session. The Sessions Court framed charges against the appellants for offences
punishable under Sections 302 /201 read with Section 34 IPC. The accused appellants
denied the charges and claimed for trial.

##### **After trial procedure: Statement under section 313 Cr.PC: Appellant no.1 either outright denied the allegations or pretended not to know about the incriminating circumstances put to him**

9. In his statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19736, 
Suresh Chandra Tiwari (appellant no.1) either denied, or feigned ignorance of, the
incriminating circumstances put to him. But admitted (a) that the body of the deceased
was found in front of the shop of Mohan Singh; (b) that the autopsy report was prepared
by PW-1; (c) that panchayat elections were held in the year 1996; and (d) that he
was interrogated on 6.2.1997, though he disclosed nothing incriminating. Notably,
the incriminating circumstance qua discovery of blood-stained stone, etc. at his
instance on 6.2.1997, vide seizure memo Exb. Ka-6, was not put to him. At last, 
he stated that owing to enmity he has been falsely implicated.

##### **Recovery of blood stained not put to appellant no.2**

10. Identical is the statement of Bhuwan Chandra Punetha (appellant no.2). Notably,
the incriminating circumstance of recovery of blood-stained stone etc. on 6.2.1997,
of which seizure memo Exb. Ka-6 was prepared, was not put to him.

#### **Trial & High courts findings**

##### **Trial court findings: Convicted the accused[1]appellants for offences punishable under Sections 302/34 and 201/34 of IPC**

11. Trial court found the following circumstances proved: (i) the deceased was last
seen alive in the company of the accused on 2.2.1997 at about 4.30 PM; (ii) the 
accused, in the night of 2.2.1997, were seen on the pathway going towards Madhkhetla(
where articles of the deceased were found) and were also noticed coming back from
the same route on which shop of Mohan Singh falls; (iii) Suresh Chandra Tiwari had
purchased a kilogram of meat on 2.2.1997 from PW-6, and there was recovery of a 
polythene bag, containing meat, from the place where other articles of the deceased
were found; (iv) the accused were looking for Suresh Upreti (the deceased) in the
evening of 2.2.1997, as was evident from their talks, while they were present at
the shop of Mohan Singh (PW-3); (v) autopsy report and medical evidence confirmed
a homicidal death of the deceased as also the fact that ante-mortem head injury 
could have been caused by a sharp-edged stone; (vi) blood-stained stone was found
at the place pointed out by the accused appellants, and forensic report confirmed
presence of human blood on it, therefore, the chain of circumstances stood complete,
which pointed that sometime in the night of 2.2.1997 the accused appellants killed
the deceased due to past enmity and kept his body in front of Mohan Singh’s shop.
Consequently, the trial court convicted the accused[1]appellants for offences punishable
under Sections 302/34 and 201/34 of IPC.

##### **High Court findings: Reduced under Section 304 Part I of IPC**

12. Aggrieved by the judgment and order of the trial court, the appellants filed
an appeal before the High Court. The High Court affirmed the findings of the trial
court on strength of the circumstances narrated above and held that recovery of 
blood-stained stone(s) at the instance of the accused, of which seizure memo (Exb.
Ka-6) was prepared, corroborated the prosecution case to dispel any doubt about 
their guilt. In addition, the High Court relied on the disclosure statement (Exb.
Ka[1]18) which, according to the High Court, led to discovery of the place and consequential
recovery. However, the High Court, upon finding that the accused had no previous
criminal record and except injuries 1 and 2 none were dangerous to life and those
two could be a result of a solitary blow, thought fit to alter the conviction from
offence of murder, punishable under Section 302 of IPC, to offence of culpable homicide
not amounting to murder, punishable under Section 304 Part I of IPC, and thereby
reduced the sentence, accordingly.

13. Aggrieved by their conviction, the appellants are before us.

#### **Appeal Analysis**

17. We have considered the rival submissions and have perused the materials on record.

##### **Exercise of powers under Article 136 of constitution**

18. At the outset, we may put on record that if finding of guilt is returned without
properly evaluating and testing the evidence by applying the requisite legal principles,
it can always be corrected by this Court in exercise of its powers under Article
136 of the Constitution of India.

#### **Appreciation of circumstantial evidence**

##### **Legal principles qua circumstantial evidence**

19. Before we proceed to test the correctness of the findings returned by the trial
court as well as the High Court, we must bear in mind that the prosecution case 
rests on evidence circumstantial in nature. As to when on strength of such evidence
an accused can be convicted, the legal principles, as propounded in a series of 
decisions of this Court [**See: Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra(
1984) 4 SCC 116; Hanumat Govind Nargundkar v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1952 SC
343; Santosh @ Bhure versus State (G.N.C.T) of Delhi, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 538 8 (
2019) 19 SCC 447**], may be summarized thus:

> (i) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should
> be fully established;
> (ii) the circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards
> the guilt of the accused;
> (iii) the circumstances taken cumulatively should form a chain so far complete
> that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability 
> the crime was committed by the accused;
> (iv) the circumstances should be consistent only with the hypothesis regarding
> the guilt of the accused; and
> (v) they must exclude every possible hypothesis except the one which is sought
> to be proved.

##### **Two view theory on circumstantial evidence is in favour of accused**

20. Adding on to the aforesaid legal principles, in **Devi Lal vs. State of Rajasthan****[(
2019) 19 SCC 447]**, a three-judge bench of this Court held that in a case based
on circumstantial evidence where two views are possible, one pointing to the guilt
and the other to his innocence, the accused is entitled to the benefit of one which
is favorable to him.

##### **Conviction shall be based on must be and not may be**

21. Besides that, before recording conviction, the court must be satisfied that 
the accused ‘must be’ and not merely ‘may be’ guilty. In **Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade
vs. State of Maharashtra ****[(1973) 2 SCC 793]****,** this Court, elaborating upon
the above principle, observed that the mental distance between ‘may be’ and ‘must
be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions. Therefore, even
if the prosecution evidence generates strong suspicion against the accused, it cannot
be a substitute for proof.

22. Bearing in mind the aforesaid legal principles, we would examine and consider–(
a) whether the circumstances relied by the prosecution have been proved beyond reasonable
doubt; (b) whether those circumstances are of a definite tendency unerringly pointing
towards the guilt of the accused; (c) whether those circumstances taken cumulatively
form a chain so far complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within
all human probability the crime was committed by the accused; (d) whether they are
consistent only with the hypothesis of the accused being guilty; and (e) whether
they exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved.

##### **Circumstances relied by the prosecution**

23. The prosecution case rests on the following circumstances:

> (i) Accused-appellant no.1 and the deceased had supported rival candidates in 
> the last panchayat elections held in 1996, and on 19.01.1997 accused – appellant
> no.1 had threatened the deceased in a Gram Sabha meet, therefore there existed
> motive for the crime.
> (ii) The deceased was last seen alive on 2.2.1997, at about 4.30 PM, with the 
> accused-appellants by PW[1]4.
> (iii) According to PW-3, whilst accused-appellants were at his shop on 2.2.1997,
> at about 6.30 PM, they were looking for the deceased.
> (iv) In the night hours of 2.2.1997, the accused[1]appellants were noticed walking
> on the pathway in front of Mohan Singh’s shop from where deceased’s body with 
> multiple ante-mortem injuries, confirming a homicidal death, was recovered next
> day morning.
> (v) A polythene bag containing meat was recovered from the place where belongings
> of the deceased were littered. Testimony of PW-6 proved that accused-appellant
> no.1 had purchased 1 kg of meat on 2.2.1997 at about 3.30 PM.
> (vi) On the disclosure made by the accused[1]appellants, as well as at their pointing
> out, on 6.2.1997 blood-stained stone(s) were recovered which might have been used
> to inflict head injury to the deceased, resulting in his death.

**Apex court dealing with each circumstances**

24. We shall now deal with each of the above circumstances separately.

##### **Motive: Proving the appellant and deceased were opposing candidates in election is not material bearing in the case**

25. Though prosecution has been successful in establishing that in 1996 panchayat
elections the deceased and accused-appellant no.1 had supported rival candidates,
but it could lead no concrete evidence as regards any untoward incident precipitating
the crime in question. No doubt, evidence about extension of death threat in a public
meet of the Gram Sabha, held in January 1997, has come, but, admittedly, no such
incident was reported to the police. Hence, motive proved is not such as may have
a material bearing on the prosecution case. Otherwise also, motive on its own cannot
make or break the prosecution case.

##### **Last seen circumstance: Time gap period explained **

26. The circumstance of deceased being last seen alive in the company of the deceased
is a vital link in the chain of other circumstances but on its own strength it is
insufficient to sustain conviction unless the time-gap between the deceased being
last seen alive with the accused and recovery of dead body of the deceased is so
small that possibility of any other person being the author of the crime is just
about impossible. Where the time-gap is large, intervening circumstances including
act by some third person cannot be ruled out **[See Nizam v. State of Rajasthan,(
2016) 1 SCC 550; Navaneethakrishnan v. State, (2018) 16 SCC 161; Kanhaiya Lal v.
State of Rajasthan, (2014) 4 SCC 715; State of U.P. v. Satish, (2005) 3 SCC 114;
Ramreddy Rajesh Khanna Reddy & Anr. V. State of A.P., (2006) 10 SCC 172; and Bodhraj
v. State of J & K, (2002) 8 SCC 45]**. In such a case, adverse inference cannot 
be drawn against the accused merely because he has failed to prove as to when he
parted company of the deceased.

##### **In the instant case there is a large gap between the deceased last seen alive with accused hence possibility of third party hand in the crime cannot be ruled out**

27. In the instant case, PW-4 allegedly saw the deceased walking on a street with
accused-appellant no.1 on 2.2.1997, at about 4.30 PM, near Gadhera Degree College.
PW-4 further stated that accused / appellant no.2 was walking 50-55 paces behind
them. No evidence was led by the prosecution to demonstrate that the place where
the deceased was last seen alive with the accused was near the place from where 
deceased’s body was recovered. Further, the time gap between 4.30 PM of 2.2.1997
and 8.30 AM of 3.2.1997 (i.e., when the dead body was recovered) is so large that
third party hand in the crime cannot be ruled out. Otherwise also, if two or more
persons are seen walking on a public street, either side by side, or behind one 
another, it is not such a circumstance from which it may be inferred with a degree
of certainty that those were together or in company of each other. Quite often on
a public path a person may happen to walk side by side a stranger for a considerable
distance without even talking to him. Likewise, a person may exchange pleasantries
with another person walking on the path, but that by 10 itself is not sufficient
to infer that the two are in company of each other. Importantly, the prosecution
case is not that the deceased was picked up from his house by the accused-appellant(
s). Had it been so, in absence of evidence as to when they parted company of each
other, adverse inference against the accused might be permissible, if the other 
circumstances so warrant. But here there is no evidence of that kind. Therefore,
taking into account (a) the place where the accused appellants and the deceased 
were allegedly seen together; and (b) lack of proximity of the time and place when
the three were seen together with the time and place when, and from where, the body
of the deceased was recovered, we are of the considered view that the last seen 
circumstance as canvassed by the prosecution is not of a definite tendency unerringly
pointing towards the guilt of the accused-appellants.

##### **Appellant(s) looking for the deceased: There may be multiple reasons for a person looking another**

28. PW-3 speaks of accused-appellants’ presence at his shop on 2.2.1997, at about
6.30 PM, as also of they being looking for the deceased. This circumstance has been
considered incriminating by the courts below because it throws a possibility of 
accused being looking for the deceased with an intent to finish him off. In our 
view, this circumstance is not of a definite tendency in unerringly pointing towards
the guilt of the accused, inasmuch as there may be multiple reasons for a person
to look for another. Importantly, there is no evidence that the accused appellants
were heard conspiring against the deceased or expressing their animosity towards
him. Rather, this circumstance runs contrary to the last seen circumstance because
if the accused were in the company of the deceased, why would they be looking for
the deceased.

##### **Disclosure / Discovery**

32. Exb. Ka-18 is the disclosure statement recorded vide GD Entry no.27 at 19:20
hrs. on 6.2.1997. Exb. Ka[1]6, which is also dated 6.2.1997, is the memorandum of
seizure of blood-stained stones, plain stones, and plain earth from the spot where,
according to the disclosure made by the two accused, the deceased was assaulted 
and killed. PW-8 is witness of that seizure, whereas PW[1]10 is the investigating
officer who got the disclosure statement recorded. The articles seized vide Exb.
Ka-6 were initially produced as material exhibits 1 to 5 by PW[1]9 (i.e., the first
investigating officer) and were later identified by PW-10 (i.e., the second investigating
officer).

##### **Recovery of stone was shown as open pathway**

33. Exb. Ka-21 is the site plan prepared by the investigating officer (PW-10) on
9.2.1997 showing the place from where that seizure was made. A perusal thereof would
reveal that the place from where recovery of stone, etc. was shown was an open pathway.

##### **Accused on the way to police station pointed out the place of assault**

34. Exb. Ka-6 reveals that after arrest while the two accused were being brought
to the police station, in the presence of Jeevan Upreti (PW-8) and Mahesh Upreti,
they pointed out the place where the deceased was assaulted by them with the help
of a stone and thereafter dragged to a field at Madhkhetla where he was again assaulted
and killed. Exb. Ka-6, however, does not record that any of the accused had specifically
pointed out a particular stone or spot. Rather, it records that on way to the police
station the accused had showed the place of assault, therefore the police stopped
the vehicle to look for clues, and then the stone, etc. mentioned therein were collected.

##### **Hon’ble Supreme court says even accept the recovery of stone at the instance of the appellants is proved the same is inconsequential**

35. Importantly, PW-9 who investigated the case on 3.2.1997 (i.e., the first investigating
officer) produced these stones, etc. (i.e., one big stone, three small stones, wooden
plank, blood-stained and plain earth) as material exhibits 1 to 5 respectively. 
During cross[1]examination, PW-9 admitted that the large stone produced as material
exhibit no.1 bore no blood stain. PW-9 also stated, [during cross-examination](http://localhost:8080/section1/subject-study-on-examination-of-witness/),
that in the night of 2.2.1997 it had rained, and that rain shower converted into
a drizzle on 3.2.1997. He went on to state that the entire land terrain from Lohaghat
to Madhkhetla had turned slippery due to rain. Notably, the seizure memorandum (
Exb. Ka-6) records that blood on the stone appeared to have been washed away due
to rain. In these circumstances there was no chance of blood being found on the 
stone etc., which was lying in open, on 6.2.1997 (i.e., 4 days after the incident).
The forensic report Exb. Ka-22 seems to confirm that there was no blood found on
the stone. In fact, as per forensic report (Exb. Ka-22), three items were received
by the laboratory for chemical examination, namely, (1) stone/ blood-stained/ plain
earth, (2) cement plaster (blood[1]stained) and plain earth and (3) blood-stained
earth and plain earth. However, the chemical examination report clearly discloses
that in respect of items (1) and (2) above no blood was found. Though human blood
was found on item (3), it is not clear from the oral testimony of the witnesses 
as to from where item (3) was lifted. However, from the seizure memorandum (Exb.
Ka-4) it appears that item (3) was lifted on 3.2.1997 from that spot where body 
of the deceased was found in the morning of 3.2.1997. In these circumstances, we
are of the view that even if we accept the recovery of stone(s) at the instance 
of the accused-appellants on 6.2.1997, the same is inconsequential because it could
not be connected to the crime.

##### **The stone (weapon in this case) was not shown to the doctor and obtain his opinion about the injury**

36. Besides that, two incised wounds with clear cut margins were found on the head
of the deceased. Though doctor (PW-1) said that they could be caused by a sharp[
1]edged stone but whether the seized stone could have caused it is not proved. Importantly,
the stone was not shown to the doctor to have his opinion as to whether those head
injuries could be caused by use of it. For all the reasons above, we are of the 
considered view that the recovery allegedly made from the place discovered consequent
to the disclosure statement/pointing out by the accused is inconsequential as it
could not be connected to the crime. The High Court erred by placing reliance on
the same.

##### **Recovery was made not based on disclosure statement but pointed out by the accused enroute to the police station hence recovery inadmissible**

37. Otherwise also, the disclosure statement (Exb. Ka[1]18) was not admissible in
evidence because the alleged discovery was not made pursuant to that statement. 
Disclosure statement was recorded at the police station whereas recovery was made
from the place pointed out by the accused enroute to the police station. It was,
therefore, a case of recovery from the place allegedly pointed out by the accused
and not based on a disclosure statement. In **Geejaganda Somaiah vs. State of Karnataka****[(
2007) 9 SCC 315]**, this Court has cautioned the courts about misuse of provision
of Section 27 of the Evidence Act, 1872 while observing as under:

> “22. As the section is alleged to be frequently misused by the police, the courts
> are required to be vigilant about its application. The court must ensure the credibility
> of evidence by police because this provision is vulnerable to abuse. It does not,
> however, mean that any statement made in terms of the aforesaid section should
> be seen with suspicion and it cannot be discarded only on the ground that it was
> made to a police officer during investigation. The court has to be cautious that
> no effort is made by the prosecution to make out a statement of the accused with
> a simple case of recovery as a case of discovery of fact in order to attract the
> provisions of section 27 of the Evidence Act.” (Emphasis supplied)

38. Above apart, there is another reason to doubt the alleged discovery (i.e., based
on disclosure made by the accused-appellants) or recovery (i.e., at their pointing
out), as the case may be. This we say so, because in all seizure memorandums including
that of torch, prepared on three dates i.e., 3.2.1997, 6.2.1997 and 9.2.1997, there
is one common witness, namely, PW-8. Recovery made on 6.2.1997 is a chance recovery
because by then there was no disclosure statement on record. Notably, as per evidence
on record, accused appellants were on their way to the police station when they 
allegedly pointed out the place where they had assaulted the deceased before dragging
him to the field. In such circumstances, it is quite unlikely that PW-8 would be
present at the spot to be available as a witness of the recovery. For this very 
reason, during cross[1]examination, suggestion was given to the investigating officer(
PW-10) that recoveries were bogus, and documents were prepared at one go while sitting
at the police station. Similarly, PW-8 was cross-examined about his presence at 
the time of recovery. PW-8, initially, responded by stating that he had not accompanied
the police, though he happened to be present at that time. On further query, PW-
8 stated that the police must have arrived between 11 and 12. Later, PW-8 stated
that the accused were arrested in the evening of 6.2.1997. This indicates that he
is not sure as to when the recovery took place. Further, distance of PW-8’s village
from Madhkhetla is 2 km. All these circumstances create a serious doubt about the
presence of the witness at the time and place of the alleged recovery. Besides that,
the site plan of the place from where recovery was made on 6.2.1997 was not prepared
until 9.2.1997. This makes us wonder whether papers in connection therewith were
prepared at one go as suggested by the defense. Unfortunately, the High Court did
not at all advert to these circumstances and relied on the disclosure statement/
discovery/recovery without carefully weighing the evidence on record.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Appel allowed and appellants are acquitted**

39. In view of the discussion above, we conclude as under:

> (a)The trial court and the High Court failed to test the evidence on record to
> find out whether the incriminating circumstances were proved beyond reasonable
> doubt and whether they were of definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the
> guilt of the accused-appellants.
> (b) The circumstance of (i) last seen; (ii) recovery of a meat bag from near the
> spot; (iii) accused[1]appellants walking on the pathway near Mohan Singh’s shop
> in the night; and (iv) accused[1]appellants inquiring about the deceased in the
> evening of 2.2.1997 are not of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards
> the guilt of the Criminal Appeal No. 1902/2013 Page 32 of 33 accused-appellants.
> Circumstance (iii) above, was not even proved beyond reasonable doubt.
> (c) The disclosure statement was not admissible as it did not lead to discovery.
> The stone, etc. were allegedly recovered even before the disclosure statement 
> was recorded. That apart, neither Doctor’s (PW-1’s) statement nor forensic report
> could connect them with the crime.
> (d) In consequence, no case was made out to
> hold the appellants guilty. Hence, the appeal deserves to be allowed.

##### **Apex court found mistake on modification since multiple injuries on the deceased shows the intention to kill**

40. Before parting, we would like to put on record that the High Court also erred
in converting the conviction from one punishable under Section 302 to Section 304
Part I of IPC only because, according to it, the fatal injury could be a result 
of a solitary blow. What it overlooked was that there were multiple injuries on 
the body of the deceased apart from two incised wounds on the head with underlying
fracture of occipital bone of the skull. In such a scenario, whosoever committed
the crime had clear intention to kill the deceased. Once that is the position, in
a case based on circumstantial evidence, when no effort is made on the part of the
accused either to take a plea, or lead evidence to show, that their act would fall
in any of the exceptions to Section 300 IPC, there was no justification at all to
alter the conviction.

#### **Party**

Suresh Chandra Tiwari & Anr. …Appellant(S) Versus State Of Uttarakhand …Respondent(
S) – Criminal Appeal No.1902 Of 2013 – 2024 INSC 907 – November 28, 2024

[Suresh Chandra Tiwari vs. State of Uttarakhand 208622012_2024-11-28](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Suresh-Chandra-Tiwari-vs.-State-of-Uttarakhand-208622012_2024-11-28.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Suresh-Chandra-Tiwari-vs.-State-of-Uttarakhand-208622012_2024-11-28.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
