# Murder Case: Acquittal: Prosecution failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt that the recovery of dead body and failure to do Test Identification Parade of articles

- Link: https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/
- Published: 2026-05-26T15:14:41+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#appeal)
    - [Appeal by complainant against the judgment of reversal of conviction](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#appeal-by-complainant-against-the-judgment-of-reversal-of-conviction)
 * [Brief facts](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#brief-facts)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#analysis)
    - [Question: Whether High Court is right in acquitting the accused?](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#question-whether-high-court-is-right-in-acquitting-the-accused)
    - [Analysing Article 136 Constitution](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#analysing-article-136-constitution)
    - [Prosecution case is totally rests upon the theory of last seen together](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#prosecution-case-is-totally-rests-upon-the-theory-of-last-seen-together)
    - [High Court rightly doubted the prosecution case based on arrest memo filed on the very same date](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#high-court-rightly-doubted-the-prosecution-case-based-on-arrest-memo-filed-on-the-very-same-date)
    - [Failure to produce the independent witness is nothing but withholding material witness](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#failure-to-produce-the-independent-witness-is-nothing-but-withholding-material-witness)
    - [Discovery of bolero jeep is doubtful and no reliance can be placed on that](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#discovery-of-bolero-jeep-is-doubtful-and-no-reliance-can-be-placed-on-that)
    - [Test Identification Parade of accused persons](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#test-identification-parade-of-accused-persons)
    - [Analysing burden of proof under section 106 IEA](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#analysing-burden-of-proof-under-section-106-iea)
    - [Appellant argues that it is the accused must explain what happened to the deceased as he was last seen in their company](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#appellant-argues-that-it-is-the-accused-must-explain-what-happened-to-the-deceased-as-he-was-last-seen-in-their-company)
    - [Judgment analysis](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#judgment-analysis)
    - [Absence of test identification parade of articles](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#absence-of-test-identification-parade-of-articles)
    - [Prosecution evidence is disjointed and not interlinked](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#prosecution-evidence-is-disjointed-and-not-interlinked)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#conclusion)
    - [Appreciation of circumstantial evidence](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#appreciation-of-circumstantial-evidence)
    - [Appeal dismissed](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#appeal-dismissed)
 * [Resources](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#resources)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-prosecution-failed-to-establish-beyond-reasonable-doubt-that-the-recovery-of-dead-body-and-failure-to-do-test-identification-parade-of-articles/#party)

#### **Appeal**

##### **Appeal by complainant against the judgment of reversal of conviction**

1. The present criminal appeals arise out of the judgment and order dated 30th January
2015 passed by the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur Bench, in D.
B. Criminal Appeal Nos. 923/2008, 844/2008, and 606/2010. By the impugned judgment
and order, the High Court allowed the appeals of the respondents/accused persons
and [set aside the order](https://section1.in/habeas-corpus-unexplained-delay-in-disposing-the-representation-made-by-the-detenu-is-sufficient-to-set-aside-the-order-of-detention/)
of conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court against respondents/accused
persons namely, Manoj Kumar, Manjeet Kumar @ Billu, Balraj @ Tiloo, and Vijay Singh@
Sunder under Sections 364 r/w 120B, 302 r/w 120 B, 396 and 201 of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 [hereinafter referred to as “IPC”].

#### **Brief facts**

2. For the sake of brevity and for maintaining continuity, the parties are referred
to as per their nomenclature before the Trial Court.

**Appellant [submitted a written report](https://section1.in/magistrate-shall-consider-both-the-final-reports-and-proceed-further-if-further-investigation-u-s-1738-cr-p-c-shows-the-accused-is-innocent/)
about the deceased as well as the vehicle went missing**: 3. The factual matrix 
of the case is that on 28.04.2007, the complainant, Pawan Kumar Sharma (P.W.1), 
submitted a written report before the [Police Station](https://section1.in/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)
Khetri stating that on 26.04.2007, around 5:00 PM, two boys came to his shop and
hired a Bolero Jeep, operated as a taxi by his brother Ashok Kumar Sharma [hereinafter
referred to as “deceased”], to go towards Lambi Road. The deceased was supposed 
to return on the same night, however both the deceased as well as the vehicle went
missing.

**Accused were arrested during the course of investigation**: 4. The report came
to be lodged at the instance of P.W. 1 Pawan Kumar Sharma/complainant. On lodgment
of report i.e., the First Information Report Case no. 122/2007, the criminal machinery
was set into motion and the investigating agency proceeded. In the course of investigation,
four [accused persons](https://section1.in/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)
namely, Manoj Kumar, Manjeet Kumar @ Billu, Balraj @ Tiloo, Vijay Singh @ Sunder
and Surendra Kumar were arrested. As per prosecution accused Balraj @ Tiloo was 
arrested on 28.04.2007 and on the basis of his [disclosure statement](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/)
dead body of deceased was discovered in a dry well on the same day.

**[Charge sheet filed under section 302 IPC](https://section1.in/section-420-ipc-the-contention-that-since-charge-sheet-has-been-filed-the-present-appeal-is-to-be-dismissed-was-rejected/)**:
5. The investigation concluded by filing charge sheet against the [accused persons for commission of offences under Sections](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
364, 302, 396 and 201 read with Section 120B IPC.

**Trial started and separate trial for one [accused before Juvenile Justice](https://section1.in/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)
Board**: 6. The learned [Trial Court](https://section1.in/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)
framed charges against the four accused persons whereas one of the accused person
namely, Surender Kumar being juvenile was put to separate trial before the Juvenile
Justice Board.

**Trial**: 7. Criminal Sessions Case No. 131/07 was registered against Balraj @ 
Tiloo, Manjeet Kumar @ Billu, Vijay Singh @ Sunder, and Manoj Kumar [hereinafter
collectively referred to as ‘respondents/ accused persons’]. In order to prove its
case, the [prosecution presented 18 witnesses](https://section1.in/when-chief-examination-of-prosecution-witness-is-being-recorded-presence-of-accused-advocate-is-required-to-object-to-a-leading-or-irrelevant-question-being-asked-to-the-witness/)
and submitted 65 documents. The respondents/accused persons, however, did not examine
any witnesses but presented four documents in its support.

**Trial [court convicted all the accused](https://section1.in/in-exceptional-circumstances-the-court-may-grant-anticipatory-bail-to-an-absconder-but-a-co-accuseds-acquittal-does-not-ipso-facto-entitle-him-to-a-b-relief/)
under section 302 IPC:** 8. The Trial Court on its appreciation of evidence holds
all four respondents/accused persons guilty and vide its judgment and order dated
26.07.2008 convicted them for [committing offences](https://section1.in/homicide-not-amounting-to-murder-though-the-accused-shot-the-deceased-but-the-weapon-firearm-was-not-brought-for-the-purpose-of-committing-an-offence-in-the-liquor-party/)
under Sections 364/120B, 302/120B, 396, and 201 of IPC and awarded sentences as 
follows:

“……..”

**Appeal before High court**: 9. Being aggrieved by the judgment and order of the
Trial Court all the respondent/ [accused persons](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
challenged the judgment and order of the Trial Court by way of three separate appeals,
D.B. Criminal Appeal Nos. 923/2008, 844/2008, and 606/2010 before the High Court
of Rajasthan at Jaipur.

**High [Court acquitted all the accused](https://section1.in/madras-high-court-settled-that-confession-could-be-used-in-favour-of-the-accused-to-reduce-the-sentence-is-sudalaimani-overruled/)
by reversing the conviction**: 10. The High Court on its reappreciation and scrutiny
of the evidence found that the evidence led by the prosecution failed to complete
the chain of circumstances so as to hold them guilty for recording the conviction
and [awarding the sentence](https://section1.in/section-304a-ipc-awarding-sentence-under-section-304-a-ipc-is-not-mandatory/).
The High Court also found that the evidence insofar as the identification is concerned
against one of the accused Vijay Singh @ Sunder is too weak. Consequently, the High
Court set aside the judgment and order of conviction and sentence passed by the 
Trial Court. Resultantly all the four respondents/ [accused persons](https://section1.in/i-o-has-the-power-to-delete-accused-persons-in-the-final-report-but-i-o-is-expected-to-serve-a-notice-upon-the-complainant/)
were acquitted.

**SLP**: 11. Aggrieved by the judgment and [order passed by the High Court](https://section1.in/section-362-cr-p-c-section-362-cr-p-c-would-not-prohibit-the-court-to-modify-the-bail-order/),
complainant/Pawan Kumar Sharma and State of Rajasthan have preferred separate appeals
before us.

#### **Analysis**

22. We have heard learned counsels for the parties at length and also perused the
material placed on record.

23. As referred to above, it is not in dispute that the case of prosecution entirely
rests on circumstantial evidence. It is also not in dispute that in series of judgments
of this Court principles are laid down by this Court so as to appreciate the substantial
evidence. Admittedly, in the [present case](https://section1.in/how-sanctioning-authority-shall-examine-the-case-presented/),
the Trial Court though passed the judgment and order of conviction and awarded sentence
to the accused, the High Court on reappreciation of the evidence overturned the 
judgment and order of the Trial Court and acquitted the accused of the offences 
charged against them.

##### **Question: Whether High Court is right in acquitting the accused?**

24. Thus, the question before us is whether the High Court was justified in reversing
the order of conviction by granting the benefit of doubt to the respondents/ accused
persons.

##### **Analysing Article 136 Constitution**

25. Before we undertook this exercise, it will not be out of place to refer to certain
judgments of this [Court wherein the test for exercising power](https://section1.in/cr-p-c-1973-notes-no-6-general-introduction-to-inquiries-and-trials-part-4-criminal-courts-powers-administration/)
under Article 136 of the Constitution of India is discussed.  

27. On the touchstone of these tests laid by this [Court in above referred judgments, we are of the opinion that the High Court committed no error in reversing the judgment](https://section1.in/as-per-section-323-of-cr-p-c-the-magistrate-before-signing-judgment-may-commit-the-case-if-the-same-has-to-try-by-court-of-sessions/)
of conviction and acquitting all the accused. We may state our reasons supporting
the conclusion arrived at by us as follows

##### **Prosecution case is totally rests upon the theory of last seen together**

28. The [prosecution case](https://section1.in/in-dowry-death-cases-prosecution-has-to-prove-the-initial-burden/),
insofar as accused Balraj @ Tiloo, Manjeet Kumar @ Billu and Manoj Kumar are concerned,
rests entirely on circumstantial evidence. In the case of accused Vijay Singh @ 
Sunder, the prosecution case substantially rests upon the [theory of last seen](https://section1.in/murder-acquittal-deceased-informing-the-witness-that-he-is-going-to-meet-the-accused-in-the-evening-is-not-proof-of-last-seen-theory/)
together. The other incriminating circumstances relied upon by the prosecution include
the alleged recovery of the dead body at the instance of accused Balraj @ Tiloo,
the identification of accused Vijay Singh @ Sunder by PW1 Pawan Kumar Sharma and
PW8 Rajendra Kumar, and the recovery of certain articles/objects from the different
accused persons.

##### **High Court rightly doubted the prosecution case based on arrest memo filed on the very same date**

29. The High Court has, in our considered opinion, rightly doubted the prosecution
case insofar as the alleged recovery of the dead body at the instance of accused
Balraj @ Tiloo is concerned. The reasons assigned by the High Court are cogent and
borne out from the record. Firstly, because at the time of arrest of accused Balraj@
Tiloo police was not aware that the deceased had been killed as PW1 merely filed
a missing report, then how come on the arrest memo filed on the very same date it
was mentioned that the [accused was arrested for offence under Sections](https://section1.in/even-in-a-case-where-the-final-report-of-the-police-under-section-173-is-accepted-and-the-accused-persons-are-discharged-the-magistrate-has-the-power-to-take-cognizance-of-the-offence-on-a-complaint/)
302, 394 and 201 of IPC. Secondly, the testimony of P.W.5 Basant Singh, an [independent witness](https://section1.in/independent-witness/),
materially undermines the prosecution case. PW5 in his testimony stated that police
had already visited and examined well from where the dead body was discovered on
28.04.2007 itself, however since the boring machine was not available, the dead 
body was recovered on 29.04.2007. Further P.W.5 stated that none of the accused 
people were present on the spot when the recovery was being made. High Court observed
that the Trial Court has totally ignored the testimony of PW5, which is a crucial
piece of evidence as the said testimony challenges the position of the prosecution.
Thirdly, the requirement of [independent witnesses](https://section1.in/official-witnesses-can-nay-be-discarded-simply-because-independent-witnesses-were-not-examined/),
more particularly, as per Section 100(4) of Cr.P.C. is to provide credibility to
the investigation. In the present case, admittedly, the dead body was recovered 
in the presence of one witness i.e. P.W. 2 who happens to be uncle of deceased and
another person namely, Ramawtar who has not been produced by the prosecution for
his examination before the Court.

##### **Failure to produce the independent witness is nothing but withholding material witness**

30. On the backdrop of these facts, the High Court observed that Ramawtar who was
an independent witness and failure to produce him before the Court is nothing but
withholding the material witness and this creates a doubt about the recovery of 
the dead body alleged at the instance of accused Balraj @ Tiloo. Therefore, the 
High Court was justified in holding that the prosecution failed to establish beyond
reasonable doubt that the recovery of dead body was made pursuant to the [disclosure statement of accused](https://section1.in/section-27-iea-i-o-did-not-narrate-the-exact-words-spoken-by-the-accused-while-making-a-disclosure-statement/)
Balraj @ Tiloo.

31. It is consistently held by this Court that the suspicion however strong it may
be, cannot take place of the legal evidence so as to convict an accused person. 
Considering this position of law, the High Court was justified in not recording 
the conviction against the accused persons on a weak piece of evidence i.e. recovery
of dead body.

##### **Discovery of bolero jeep is doubtful and no reliance can be placed on that**

32. Furthermore, the discovery of bolero jeep, vehicle belonging to the deceased
at the instance of accused Balraj @ Tiloo has been rightly doubted by the High Court.
As per the testimony of PW 14, the recovery was made from the road and not from 
the accused’s possession. In Jaikam Khan v. State of U.P it was observed: –

“One of the alleged recoveries is from the room where deceased Asgari used to sleep.
The other two recoveries are from open field, just behind the house of deceased 
Shaukeen Khan i.e. the place of incident. It could thus be seen that the recoveries
were made from the places, which were accessible to one and all and as such, no 
[reliance could be placed](https://section1.in/section-311-cr-p-c-though-the-accused-has-right-to-keep-his-defence-closed-till-cross-examination-but-the-accused-cannot-reserve-a-few-questions-for-a-later-point-of-time-placing/)
on such recoveries.”

Thus, relying on the abovementioned position of law it is clear that no reliance
can be placed on the recovery of the Bolero Jeep.

##### **Test Identification Parade of accused persons**

33. As far as the evidence against Accused Vijay Singh @ Sunder is concerned, PW1
Pawan Kumar and PW8 Rajendra Kumar have identified him in the [Test Identification Parade](https://section1.in/test-identification-parade-not-proved/)(
Ex P5, P6, P25, P26) and these both the witnesses have stated before the Court that
they saw the accused Vijay Singh @ Sunder and Juvenile Surendra had taken deceased
with bolero vehicle on hire basis in the presence of PW1 and PW8. High Court considering
the testimonies of PW1 and PW8 observed as follows:

“……”

##### **Analysing burden of proof under section 106 IEA**

##### **Appellant argues that it is the accused must explain what happened to the deceased as he was last seen in their company**

34. An attempt was made by the Learned Counsel for the appellant to submit that 
it was for the respondents/ accused persons to explain as to what happened to the
deceased, as deceased was last seen in their company and thus burden shifted upon
respondents/ [accused persons under section 106 of the Evidence Act](https://section1.in/case-diary-section-1723-cr-p-c-the-accused-has-a-right-to-cross-examine-police-officer-as-per-section-145-evidence-act-whenever-the-police-officer-uses-it-to-refresh-his-memory/).

##### **Judgment analysis**

35. This Court in Manoj @ Munna v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2025 INSC 1466 has observed
as follows:

> “30. It is a settled principle that [Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act](https://section1.in/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/),
> 1872 clearly provides that when a fact lies especially within the knowledge of
> a person, the burden of proving that fact rests upon him. Accordingly, when an
> accused is shown to have been last seen in the company of the deceased, it becomes
> incumbent upon him to explain how and when they parted ways. The explanation furnished
> must be reasonable, probable, and satisfactory in the opinion of the Court. If
> such an explanation is offered, the burden cast by [Section 106 of the Evidence Act](https://section1.in/no-court-should-allow-a-witness-to-be-contradicted-by-reference-to-the-previous-statement-in-writing-or-reduced-to-writing-unless-the-procedure-set-out-in-section-145-of-the-evidence-act-has-been-foll/)
> stands discharged.
> **However, if the accused fails to present a credible explanation regarding facts
> within his special knowledge, this failure constitutes an additional link in the
> chain of circumstantial evidence established against him. At the same time, it
> must be emphasized that [Section 106 of the Evidence Act](https://section1.in/no-court-should-allow-a-witness-to-be-contradicted-by-reference-to-the-previous-statement-in-writing-or-reduced-to-writing-unless-the-procedure-set-out-in-section-145-of-the-evidence-act-has-been-foll/)
> does not shift the primary burden of proof, which in a criminal trial always remains
> on the prosecution**.
>  31. Thus, any adverse inference under Section 106 of the Evidence [Act is to be drawn against the accused person](https://section1.in/pmla-pc-act-prosecuting-the-person-accused-of-an-offence-under-section-131e-of-the-pc-act-as-well-as-for-an-offence-under-section-3-of-pmla-would-not-amount-to-double-jeopardy/)
> when the prosecution has been able to establish the case beyond a reasonable doubt.”

36. Further this Court in Manoj @ Munna v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2025 INSC 1466
while reiterating principle laid down in Kanhaiya Lal vs. State of Rajasthan6 observed
as follows:

> “28. In Kanhaiya Lal vs. State of Rajasthan this Court held that evidence on last
> seen together is a weak evidence and conviction only on the basis of last seen
> together without there being any other corroborative evidence against the accused
> will not be sufficient to convict the accused for an [offence under Sections](https://section1.in/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)
> 302 and 201 of the IPC.”

37. Considering the aforesaid position of law and the observations of High Court,
it would be appropriate to hold that the High Court, rightly held that it would 
be wholly unsafe and unjust to [convict accused](https://section1.in/section-427-cr-p-c-two-different-cases-same-accused-not-entitled-for-the-benefit-2/)
Vijay Singh @ Sunder merely on the basis of a strong suspicion arising from the 
evidence of last seen together and identification by PW1 and PW8. We find no infirmity
in the view taken by the High Court in extending the benefit of doubt to the accused.

##### **Absence of test identification parade of articles**

38. As far as the recoveries from the accused Manjeet Kumar @ Billu is concerned,
though learned counsel for the appellant heavily relied on the recoveries of the
articles, we are unable to accept the submission of learned counsel to that effect,
in view of the just and proper appreciation of the recoveries by the High Court 
in following words:

“Most pertinently, neither the tape recorder, nor the wrist watch has ever been 
subjected to the T.I. Parade. Even if Rajendra Kumar (P. W .8) had identified the
tape recorder and the wrist watch as belonging to Ashok, even then such. identification
is absolutely meaningless In the eyes of law. For, according to Rajasthan Police
Rules, 1965, an object which is recovered has to be subjected to a test identification
parade in order to assess its objective identification by a witness. Since neither
the tape recorder, nor the wrist watch was subjected to a test identification parade,
it would be too conjectural to presume that the tape recorder came from the Jeep
and the wrist watch belonged to Ashok. Therefore, the recovery is insignificant.
It does not connect Manjeet to the alleged crime. If he were to be convicted on 
the basis of this flimsy recovery, he would be convicted on the basis of conjectures
and surmises. But under [criminal jurisprudence](https://section1.in/basics-of-criminal-law-part-3-criminal-jurisprudence/),
a moral conviction is impermissible. The conviction has to be a legal one.”

The view taken by the High Court also finds support from the decision of this Court
in Thammaraya & Anr. v. The State Of Karnataka wherein this Court has reiterated
the law relating to Test Identification Parade of recovered articles. It observed
as follows:

> “27. Therefore, this material omission on part of the [Investigating Officer](https://section1.in/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)(
> PW-27) in not conducting a Test Identification Parade (TIP) of the recovered articles,
> more particularly when the case of prosecution is based solely upon recoveries
> of these articles, has created holes in the fabric of the prosecution story, which
> are impossible to mend.
> 28. Every piece of [relevant fact](https://section1.in/section-311-cr-p-c-recall-may-be-allowed-if-no-occasion-to-bring-relevant-facts-at-initial-deposition/)
> needs to be sewn via the golden thread of duly proved circumstances, in order 
> to ultimately formulate the fabric of guilt. Sadly, in the present case, the facta
> probantia fails to sustain and support the alleged factum probando, rendering 
> the prosecution’s case miserably weak. Hence, the evidence led by the prosecution
> against the accused person is woefully short of the mandate to prove the [case](https://section1.in/murder-case-based-on-injuries-in-the-evidence-it-is-doubtful-that-deceased-would-have-met-the-witnesses/)
> beyond reasonable doubt.”

##### **Prosecution evidence is disjointed and not interlinked**

40. A holistic appreciation of the evidence confirms the High Court’s observation
that the prosecution’s evidence is disjointed and not interlinked. Instead of placing
the Court on a firm footing, the prosecution has left it “groping in the dark”. 
We find that the High Court meticulously “separated grain from the chaff” and arrived
at a plausible conclusion that the chain of circumstances was incomplete.

#### **Conclusion**

##### **Appreciation of circumstantial evidence**

42. Thus, it is a settled position of law that to convict the accused on the basis
of circumstantial evidence, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt each
of the incriminating  circumstances on which it proposes to rely; the circumstance(
s) relied upon must be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the [accused’s guilt and must form a chain so far complete](https://section1.in/accused-completely-rebutted-in-the-cheque-case/)
that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability it
is the accused and no one else who had committed the crime and they (it) must exclude
all other hypothesis inconsistent with his guilt and consistent with his innocence.

##### **Appeal dismissed**

43. For all the reasons above, while keeping in mind that the view taken by the 
High Court is a plausible view, we do not find a good reason to interfere with the
order of acquittal passed by the High Court. The appeals are accordingly dismissed.

#### **Resources**

**Judgments Cited and Involved**

 * Tulesh Kumar Sahu v. State of Chhattisgarh – Citation: Criminal Appeal No. 753
   of 2021. Brief: Relied upon by the respondents’ counsel to argue that piecemeal
   recovery of articles fails to establish guilt. It highlights that the solitary
   circumstance of unexplained recovery of articles only raises an inference that
   the individuals are receivers of stolen property or committed the theft, but 
   not necessarily murder.
 * Sunder Lal alia Sundera v. State of Madhya Pradesh Citation: AIR 1954 SC 28. 
   Brief: A decision relied upon within the _Tulesh Kumar Sahu_ judgment regarding
   circumstantial evidence.
 * Sanwant Khan vs. State of Rajasthan Citation: AIR 1956 SC 54. Brief: Relied upon
   within the _Tulesh Kumar Sahu_ judgment to establish that it is unsafe to infer
   that a person in possession of stolen property is the murderer, even if the theft
   and murder were committed at the same time.
 * Baiju v. State of Madhya Pradesh Citation: Not explicitly provided beyond the
   name. Brief: Cited to test the ability or otherwise of the accused to explain
   the possession of recovered articles.
 * State of M.P. v. Paltan Mallah Citation: (2005) 3 SCC 169. Brief: Cited to discuss
   the test for exercising power under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.
   It lays down that the [Supreme Court](https://section1.in/burden-of-proof-public-prosecutor-while-explaining-the-principles-of-106-iea-in-criminal-cases-honble-supreme-court-has-addressed-the-government-to-appoint-skilled-lawyers-as-public-prosec/)
   should be slow to interfere with High Court acquittals unless there is a perverse
   appreciation of evidence resulting in a serious miscarriage of justice.
 * State of Punjab v. Kewal Krishan Citation: (2023) 13 SCC 695. Brief: Reiterates
   the reluctance of the Court to interfere with an order of acquittal. It clarifies
   that interference is warranted if the High Court used a legally erroneous approach
   and ignored vital facts, leading to a substantial miscarriage of justice.
 * State of U.P. v. Sahai Citation: (1982) 1 SCC 352: 1982 SCC (Cri) 223. Brief:
   Cited within the _Kewal Krishan_ judgment concerning the rightful exercise of
   extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution.
 * Jaikam Khan v. State of U.P Citation: (2021) 13 SCC 716. Brief: Quoted to support
   the view that no reliance can be placed on [recoveries made](https://section1.in/co-accused-confession-to-the-police-may-have-relevance-only-on-the-recovery-made-in-furtherance-of-the-said-disclosure/)
   from open fields or places that are accessible to one and all.
 * Manoj @ Munna v. State of Chhattisgarh Citation: 2025 INSC 1466. Brief: Cited
   to explain the burden of proof under [Section 106 of the Evidence Act](https://section1.in/no-court-should-allow-a-witness-to-be-contradicted-by-reference-to-the-previous-statement-in-writing-or-reduced-to-writing-unless-the-procedure-set-out-in-section-145-of-the-evidence-act-has-been-foll/)
   when an accused is “last seen in the company of the deceased. It emphasizes that
   while the accused must provide a reasonable explanation, the primary burden of
   [proof remains on the prosecution](https://section1.in/prosecution-not-proved-the-murder-case-beyond-reasonable-doubt/).
 * Kanhaiya Lal vs. State of Rajasthan Citation: (2014) 4 SCC 715. Brief: Cited 
   within _Manoj @ Munna_ [holding that evidence of “last seen](https://section1.in/circumstantial-evidence-merely-appellants-were-seen-nearby-the-place-where-the-crime-occurred-holding-chopper-is-not-last-seen/)
   together” is weak. A conviction based solely on this, without other corroborative
   evidence, is insufficient.
 * Thammaraya & Anr. v. The State Of Karnataka Citation: (2025) 3 SCC 590. Brief:
   Cited to reiterate the law regarding Test Identification Parades (TIP) for recovered
   articles. It notes that a material omission in conducting a TIP creates holes
   in the prosecution’s story that are impossible to mend.
 * Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra Citation: (1984) 4 SCC 116. 
   Brief: Quoted to crystallize the law regarding circumstantial evidence. It outlines
   the nature, character, and essential proof required for convictions relying solely
   on circumstantial evidence.
 * Hanumant v. State of Madhya Pradesh Citation: (1952) 2 SCC 71: AIR 1952 SC 343:
   1952 SCR 1091: 1953 Cri LJ 129. Brief: Quoted extensively within the _Sharad 
   Birdhichand Sarda_ judgment as the fundamental and basic decision on circumstantial
   evidence. It mandates that the chain of evidence must be so complete that it 
   leaves no reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of
   the accused.
 * Tufail (Alias) Simmi v. State of Uttar Pradesh Citation: (1969) 3 SCC 198: 1970
   SCC (Cri) 55. Brief: Mentioned within the _Sharad Birdhichand Sarda_ quote as
   a case that has uniformly followed the principles laid down in _Hanumant_.
 * Ramgopal v. State of Maharashtra Citation: (1972) 4 SCC 625: AIR 1972 SC 656.
   Brief: Mentioned within the _Sharad Birdhichand Sarda_ quote as another case 
   that uniformly followed the _Hanumant_ decision regarding circumstantial evidence.

**Acts and Sections**

1. Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)

 * Section 120B: Punishes criminal conspiracy; applied alongside the substantive
   offences.
 * Section 201: Relates to [causing disappearance of evidence](https://section1.in/appeal-against-conviction-of-gruesome-murder-of-children-and-causing-disappearance-of-evidence/)
   of an offence, or giving false information to screen the offender.
 * Section 302: Punishes murder.
 * Section 364: Relates to kidnapping or abducting in order to murder.
 * Section 394: Relates to voluntarily causing hurt in committing dacoity (mentioned
   regarding an entry in the arrest memo).
 * Section 396: Relates to dacoity with murder.

2. Indian [Evidence Act](https://section1.in/fact-discovered-and-recovery-mahazar-witnesses/),
1872

 * Section 9: Discusses facts necessary to explain or introduce relevant facts (
   cited regarding the tool of Test Identification Parade).
 * Section 27: Governs the admissibility of information received from an accused
   that leads to a discovery.
 * Section 106: States that the burden of proving a fact especially within the knowledge
   of any person lies upon that person (discussed regarding the [“last seen together” theory](https://section1.in/witness-saw-accused-with-blood-stained-shirt-but-did-not-see-him-together-with-the-deceased-cannot-be-a-proof-for-last-seen-theory/)).
 * Section 114 (Illustration A): Relates to court presumptions regarding the possession
   of stolen goods shortly after a theft.

3. [Code of Criminal Procedure](https://section1.in/bail-ability-of-section-3513-of-the-bharatiya-nyaya-sanhita-2023-do-colonial-era-notifications-survive-the-new-criminal-procedure-code/)(
Cr.P.C.)

 * Section 100(4): Mandates the calling of independent and respectable inhabitants
   of the locality to witness a search/recovery to provide credibility to the investigation.

4. Constitution of India

 * Article 136: Discusses the Supreme [Court’s extraordinary jurisdiction](https://section1.in/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)
   regarding special leave to appeal (cited concerning the scope of interfering 
   with High Court acquittals).

5. Other Statutory Rules

 * Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965: Noted regarding the mandatory protocol requiring
   recovered objects to be subjected to a test identification parade to assess objective
   identification.

#### **Party**

    ```wp-block-verse
    Pawan Kumar Sharma v. Manoj Kumar & Ors - Criminal Appeal Nos. 1353-1355 of 2017 (with Criminal Appeal Nos. 1356, 1357, and 1358 of 2017) - 2026 INSC 539 - May 25, 2026 – Hon’ble Mr.  Justice Pankaj Mithal and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Prasanna B. Varale.
    ```

[Pawan Kumar Sharma vs. Manoj Kumar 142032015_2026-05-25](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Pawan-Kumar-Sharma-vs.-Manoj-Kumar-142032015_2026-05-25.pdf)
[Download](https://section1.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Pawan-Kumar-Sharma-vs.-Manoj-Kumar-142032015_2026-05-25.pdf)

### Further Study

 * [Murder case acquittal: Strangulation established but failed to connect the accused with the crime](https://section1.in/murder-case-acquittal-strangulation-established-but-failed-to-connect-the-accused-with-the-crime/)
 * [Murder case acquittal](https://section1.in/in-murder-case/)
 * [Murder: Common intention (section 34 IPC) & Appreciation of eye-witness: Explained](https://section1.in/common-intention-section-34-ipc-appreciation-of-eye-witness-explained/)
 * [Murder: Whether s.302 or s.304 IPC? – Explained](https://section1.in/murder-case-whether-s-302-or-s-304-ipc-explained/)
 * [Murder case: Appreciation of evidence – Circumstantial evidence & recovery under section 27 Indian Evidence Act](https://section1.in/appreciation-of-evidence-circumstantial-evidence-recovery-u-s-27-iea/)
