# Natural justice must be followed before impounding passport under section 10(3) Passports Act, 1967

- Link: https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/
- Published: 2025-02-25T13:24:24+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Appeal](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#appeal)
 * [Factual aspects](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#factual-aspects)
    - [FIR registered and passport impounded](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#fir-registered-and-passport-impounded)
    - [Petition under section 26 DV filed, appellant failed to appear, hence extradition process initiated against him](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#petition-under-section-26-dv-filed-appellant-failed-to-appear-hence-extradition-process-initiated-against-him)
    - [Hon’ble High Court dismissed appellant’s petitioner and hence preferred this appeal](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#honble-high-court-dismissed-appellants-petitioner-and-hence-preferred-this-appeal)
 * [Analysis](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#analysis)
    - [Whether initiation of extradition process is justified?](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#whether-initiation-of-extradition-process-is-justified)
    - [Mother-in-law of respondent filed a complaint under several section of IPC against respondent](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#motherinlaw-of-respondent-filed-a-complaint-under-several-section-of-ipc-against-respondent)
    - [Passport of appellant already impounded](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#passport-of-appellant-already-impounded)
    - [Without examining the circumstance of the appellant’s failure to appear in the court is liable to set aside](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#without-examining-the-circumstance-of-the-appellants-failure-to-appear-in-the-court-is-liable-to-set-aside)
    - [Filing of cases against appellant reflects her vindictive](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#filing-of-cases-against-appellant-reflects-her-vindictive)
    - [Position of law regard to the determination of permanent alimony](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#position-of-law-regard-to-the-determination-of-permanent-alimony)
    - [Natural justice must be followed before impounding passport under section 10(3) Passports Act, 1967](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967)
 * [Conclusion](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#conclusion)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/natural-justice-must-be-followed-before-impounding-passport-under-section-103-passports-act-1967/#party)

#### **Appeal**

2. Very important issues arise in the appeal. The first issue is about the conduct
of the advocate-on-record who filed the Special Leave Petition (for short, ‘SLP’)
out of which the present appeal arises. The second issue concerns the conduct of
the advocate who appeared in this case as a counsel and was later designated as 
a senior advocate. Two consequential issues arise. The first consequential issue
is about the need to formulate a code of conduct for the advocates-on-record. The
second one is whether the decisions of this Court in the case of Indira Jaising 
v Supreme Court of India (hereafter referred to as ‘Indira Jaising-I’) and Indira
Singh v Supreme Court of India (hereafter referred as ‘Indira Jaising-II’) need 
reconsideration. The question of taking action against the appellant for making 
false statements will be considered in a separate IA on which a notice has been 
issued.

#### **Factual aspects**

3. First, we are setting out a few factual aspects. The trial court convicted the
appellant for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 307 of the Indian Penal
Code (for short, ‘the IPC’) by the judgment dated 1st July 2013. He was sentenced
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life with a direction that his case for a grant
of remission shall not be considered until he undergoes a sentence of thirty years.
The appellant preferred an appeal before the High Court. While confirming the conviction,
the High Court was of the view that the punishment imposed on the appellant was 
excessive and modified the same by removing the cap of thirty years. The appellant
was let off on a sentence of 16 years, 10 months already undergone. By the judgment
dated 25th October 2018, in Jitendra @ Kalla v. State of Govt. of NCT of Delhi, 
this Court interfered with the view taken by the High Court and restored the order
of sentence of the trial court. This Court held that the appellant’s sentence shall
be thirty years of rigorous imprisonment and that the appellant shall have no right
to seek remission till he completes the full sentence of thirty years.

##### **FIR registered and passport impounded**

6. In view of the aforesaid cases registered against the appellant, his passport
was impounded by the concerned authorities on 3rd October, 2018. Between 2018 and
2020, the respondent resided in the same house with her mother-in-law, i.e., the
appellant’s mother. As per the appellant, during this period, the respondent had
subjected his mother to severe physical and mental torture, ultimately forcing her
to leave the house and seek shelter at her daughter’s residence on 14th September,
2020. Consequently, a Complaint Case No. 446C of 2020 was filed by the mother of
the appellant against the respondent for the offences punishable under Sections 
323, 341, 342, 379, 403, 504, 506, and 120B IPC.

##### **Petition under section 26 DV filed, appellant failed to appear, hence extradition process initiated against him**

7. As a counterblast, the respondent also filed an application under Section 26 
of the DV Act against the appellant, his mother, and five other close relatives,
which came to be registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 440 of 2022 in Complaint Case
No. 446C of 2020. The application filed by the respondent was proceeded with, and
vide order dated 11th August 2022, the appellant was directed to personally appear
before the Court on the scheduled date, i.e., 15th September 2022. However, when
the appellant failed to appear before the trial court on the notified date, the 
competent authorities were instructed to initiate the extradition process against
him.

##### **Hon’ble High Court dismissed appellant’s petitioner and hence preferred this appeal**

8. Being aggrieved by the direction to commence the extradition process, the appellant,
through his authorized representative i.e., his sister, filed Criminal Revision 
being CRR No. 135 of 2023 before the High Court of Calcutta, which came to be dismissed
vide the judgment and order dated 25th January, 2023, which is impugned in this 
appeal by special leave.

#### **Analysis**

14. We have heard the learned counsels appearing for the parties and have given 
our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced and perused the pleadings.

##### **Whether initiation of extradition process is justified?**

15. Taking note of the facts and circumstances narrated above, the first question
that arises for consideration is whether the initiation of the extradition process
against the appellant vide order dated 15th September 2022 is justified in the eyes
of the law.

16. It is undisputed that the appellant returned to the USA on 19th May, 2018, and
his passport was impounded under Section 10 of the Passport Act, 1967, by the concerned
authorities on 3rd October, 2018 because of numerous matrimonial and other cases
filed against him by the respondent.

##### **Mother-in-law of respondent filed a complaint under several section of IPC against respondent**

17. The respondent and her mother-in-law had been residing under the same roof since
2018. The motherin-law had alleged that she was brutally assaulted, and her modesty
was outraged by the respondent, compelling her to file Complaint Case No. 446C of
2020 before the Ld. JMFC, Howrah, under Sections 323, 341, 342, 379, 403, 504, 506,
and 120B IPC against the respondent. It is further claimed that, despite her old
age, she was forced to leave her own home to ensure the safety of her property and
dignity from the vicious design of the respondent.

##### **Passport of appellant already impounded**

18. In the afore-mentioned complaint case, an application was filed by the respondent
under Section 26 of the DV Act against the appellant, her mother-inlaw, and their
five other relatives. A notice was issued to the appellant vide order dated 21st
July 2022. Subsequently, on 11th August 2022, the learned JMFC passed an interim
order in favour of the respondent, prohibiting her eviction from the matrimonial
home and directing the personal appearance of the appellant (respondent therein)
and other respondents on the next hearing date. However, when the matter was listed
again, the Court noticed that the appellant had not returned to India, and the concerned
authorities were directed to initiate the extradition process against him. We may
observe that as the proceedings under the DV Act are quasi-criminal in nature, thus,
there cannot be any justification to require the personal presence of the appellant
in these proceedings. Thus, the learned Magistrate grossly erred while directing
the appellant to remain personally present in the Court.

19. At this juncture, it is pertinent to note that while passing the order dated
15th September 2022, the learned JMFC took into account the fact that the passport
of the appellant was impounded by the concerned authorities on 3rd October, 2018
and when the appellant lay challenge to this act of impounding before the High Court
of Calcutta by filing a Writ Petition being WPA No. 4743 of 2020, the same was also
dismissed by the High Court vide judgment and order dated 15th January, 2021, while
affirming the revocation and barring the appellant herein from filing any appeal
under Section 11 of the Passport Act, 1967. The relevant observations from the order
passed by the JMFC dated 15th September, 2022 are as follows:-

“Finally, the Govt of India, on its motion, revoked/impounded his passport (J1863634)
on 03.10.2018 u/s 10 of the Passport Act, 1967, and this, the letter no. 17(1249)
18/PSK/RPO/KOL (CALA07137810) dr. 04.10.2018 suggests. Against such revocation, 
he had approached the Hon’ble Calcutta High Court through WPA 4743 of 2020. The 
order dated 15.01.2021 of that action suggests that the Hon’ble High Court not merely
dismissed his writ petition but has debarred him from any appeal u/s 11 of the said
Act of 1967 while affirming the revocation.” (emphasis supplied)

##### **Without examining the circumstance of the appellant’s failure to appear in the court is liable to set aside**

20. It is apparent that the appellant’s inability to travel to India and appear 
in Miscellaneous Case No. 440 of 2022, filed by the respondent under Section 26 
of the DV Act, stemmed from the impoundment of his passport, a circumstance beyond
his control. Consequently, the order of the learned JMFC directing the initiation
of extradition proceedings against the appellant as a consequence of his non-appearance,
despite being aware of the fact of impounding of the passport of the appellant, 
is untenable and unsustainable in the eyes of the law. Otherwise also, as noted 
above, there is no requirement for the personal presence of any party in the proceedings
under the DV Act, because they are quasi-criminal in nature and do not entail any
penal consequences except when there is a breach of a protection order, which is
the only offence provided under Section 31 of the DV Act.

21. The appellant challenged the order dated 15th September, 2022, passed by the
learned JMFC by filing Criminal Revision being CRR No. 135 of 2023 before the High
Court of Calcutta. However, the High Court vide a non-speaking order dated 25th 
January, 2023, dismissed the revision petition, stating that no grounds for interference
were made out. This Court is of the considered opinion that the High Court could
have examined the record of the case, particularly the reasons for the appellant’s
failure to appear due to circumstances beyond his control, and hence, a reasoned
decision addressing the merits of the matter was expected in these circumstances.

22. In the wake of the above discussion, the order dated 15th September, 2022, passed
by the trial Court, and the order dated 25th January, 2023, passed by the High Court
of Calcutta, are liable to be quashed and set aside.

23. The next question that arises for our consideration is whether there is an irretrievable
breakdown of the marriage of the appellant and the respondent requiring this Court
to exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution
of India to do complete justice.

25. The Constitution Bench further laid down the factors to be considered for such
determination, which were also reiterated in the case of Kiran Jyot Maini v. Anish
Pramod Patel. This Court, in both these judgments, opined that the factors to be
examined inter alia include the period of cohabitation between the parties after
marriage; the last cohabitation among the parties; the period of separation; the
nature and the gravity of allegations made by the parties against each other and
their family members; the orders passed in the legal proceedings from time to time,
cumulative impact on the personal relationship; whether, and how many attempts were
made to settle the disputes by intervention of the court or through mediation, and
such other similar factors.

26. On the issue as to grant of divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown
of marriage in the exercise of jurisdiction under Article 142(1) of the Constitution
of India, this Court, in a very recent judgment of Rinku Baheti v Sandesh Sharda,
held that the factual analysis has to be undertaken in each case to determine as
to what constitutes an ‘irretrievable breakdown’ while keeping in mind the non-exhaustive
factors laid down in Shilpa Sailesh (supra). The relevant observations are as follows:-

“8.11 But what constitutes an irretrievable breakdown has to be determined in each
case by undertaking a factual analysis of the case and using judicial discretion
in light of several non-exhaustive factors laid down by this Court in the judgment
of Shilpa Sailesh. This Court has to reach the conclusion that the marriage has “
completely failed” of and there is no possibility of the parties cohabiting together
as husband and wife, and that the continuation of the formal legal relationship 
of marriage is unjustified lacking in substance and content.”

##### **Filing of cases against appellant reflects her vindictive**

31. The filing of the aforesaid cases by the respondent-wife reflects her vindictive
attitude towards the appellant and his family members and unambiguously reflects
the bitterness that has seeped into the marital relationship. The tumultuous state
of the marital relationship between the parties is quite evident, irrespective of
the fate of the criminal complaints and the imputations made by the parties against
each other. The passport of the appellant was also impounded by the concerned authorities,
pursuant to the pending cases filed by the respondent.

36. Apart from the irreconcilable status of the relationship between the parties,
in the present case, another factor that has weighed with this Court in favour of
the exercise of the power under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India is that
there is no child born from the wedlock and therefore, any direction to allow the
parties to part ways would only affect the parties themselves and not any innocent
child.

37. Thus, this is a fit case warranting the exercise of the discretion conferred
under Article 142(1) of the Constitution of India to dissolve the marriage between.
the parties on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown of marriage.

38. We have to now consider the question of assessing the alimony for the respondent
upon the dissolution of marriage between the parties. Learned senior counsel for
the appellant has fairly submitted that the appellant is willing to pay a reasonable
lump sum of money as permanent alimony to the respondent in order to assist her 
in starting her life afresh and to put an end to multiple protracted litigations.
The respondent blatantly declined the said offer, stating that she was not interested
in the money of the appellant as her sole intent was to have an opportunity to resume
her marital life.

##### **Position of law regard to the determination of permanent alimony**

39. Before going into the details of the financial position of the parties, it is
imperative that we highlight the position of law with regard to the determination
of permanent alimony. This Court, in the cases of Rajnesh v. Neha, Kiran Jyot Maini(
supra), and Parvin Kumar Jain v. Anju Jain, provided a comprehensive criterion and
a list of factors to be looked into while deciding the question of permanent alimony,
which are as follows:-

> i. Status of the parties, social and financial.
> ii. Reasonable needs of the wife and the dependent children.
> iii. Parties’ individual qualifications and employment statuses.
> iv. Independent income or assets owned by the party.
> v. Standard of life enjoyed by the wife in the matrimonial home.
> vi. Any employment sacrifices made for family responsibilities.
> vii. Reasonable litigation costs for a non-working wife.
> viii. Financial capacity of the husband, his income, maintenance obligations, 
> and liabilities.

##### **Natural justice must be followed before impounding passport under section 10(3) Passports Act, 1967**

43. The law regarding the impounding of a passport of an individual has been settled
by this Court in the case of Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India and Anr., wherein it
was held that the rules of natural justice must be followed before impounding a 
passport under Section 10(3) of the Passports Act, 1967. Justice Bhagwati, speaking
for the majority, held as follows: –

> “40. …………. Now it is obvious that on a plain natural construction of Section 10(
> 3)(c), it is left to the Passport Authority to determine whether it is necessary
> to impound a passport in the interests of the general public. But an order made
> by the Passport Authority impounding a passport is subject to judicial review 
> on the ground that the order is mala fide, or that the reasons for making the 
> order are extraneous, or they have no relevance to the interests of the general
> public or they cannot possibly support the making of the order in the interests
> of the general public. It was not disputed on behalf of the Union, and indeed,
> it could not be in view of Section 10 sub-section (5) that, save in certain exceptional
> cases, of which this was admittedly not one, the Passport Authority is bound to
> give reasons for making an order impounding a passport……”
> 45. “……..We, however, wish to utter a word of caution to the Passport Authority
> while exercising the power of refusing or impounding, or cancelling a passport.
> The Passport Authority would do well to remember that it is a basic human right
> recognised in Article 13 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights with which
> the Passport Authority is interfering when it refuses or impounds, or cancels 
> a passport. It is a highly valuable right which is a part of personal liberty,
> an aspect of the spiritual dimension of man, and it should not be lightly interfered
> with. Cases are not unknown where people have not been allowed to go abroad because
> of the views held, opinions expressed, or political beliefs, or economic ideologies
> entertained by them. It is hoped that such cases will not recur under a Government
> constitutionally committed to uphold freedom and liberty but it is well to remember,
> at all times, that eternal vigilance is the price of liberty, for history shows
> that it is always subtle and insidious encroachments made ostensibly for a good
> cause that imperceptibly but surely corrode the foundations of liberty.” (emphasis
> supplied)

46. Applying the afore-mentioned legal principles to the present case, we find that
the act of impounding the appellant’s passport under Section 10 of the Passport 
Act, 1967, was carried out without granting the appellant an opportunity to be heard.
This clear violation of the principles of natural justice renders the act of impounding
the passport ex-facie illegal. Consequently, we hold that the concerned authorities
should release the appellant’s passport within a period of one week from today.

#### **Conclusion**

47. Resultantly, we conclude as below: –

> a. The judgments/orders dated 15th September, 2022 passed by the learned Judicial
> Magistrate, Howrah and 25th January, 2023 passed by the High Court are quashed
> and set aside.
> b. The application filed by the appellant/husband, under Article 142(1) of the
> Constitution of India, is allowed and the marriage between the appellant and the
> respondent is dissolved on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. –
> The Registry to draw a decree accordingly.
> c. Consequently, all the criminal cases/DV Act complaints and civil cases pending
> between the respondent and the appellant and his family members shall stand closed.
> d. The appellant shall deposit a sum of Rs.25,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty-Five Lakhs
> only) in the Registry of this Court as the amount of permanent alimony payable
> to the respondent within two months from today. This amount shall be disbursed
> to the respondent within a period of two weeks thereafter. An undertaking to that
> effect shall be filed before this Court within two weeks from today. We also make
> it clear that if the respondent refuses to accept the aforesaid amount and fails
> to draw the same from the Registry within the aforesaid period, the same shall
> be repaid to the appellant.
> e. The passport of the appellant shall be released by the authorities concerned
> within a period of one week from today.

**List of Judgments Cited or Relied Upon**

1.Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan – 2023 SCC OnLine SC 544

2. Kiran Jyot Maini v. Anish Pramod Patel – 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1724

3. Rinku Baheti v. Sandesh Sharda – 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3801

4. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India and Anr – (1978) 1 SCC 248

5. Rajesh Sharma v. State of U.P – (2018) 10 SCC 472

#### **Party**

Vishal Shah – Monalisha Gupta & Others – Criminal Appeal No. 870 of 2025 (Arising
out of SLP(Crl.) No. 4297 of 2023) – 2025 INSC 254 – February 20, 2025.

[Vishal Shah vs. Monalisha Gupta 121722023_2025-02-20](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Vishal-Shah-vs.-Monalisha-Gupta-121722023_2025-02-20.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Vishal-Shah-vs.-Monalisha-Gupta-121722023_2025-02-20.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
