# NDPS Act: Confession statement: Statement recorded under section 67 of NDPS Act is hit under Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India

- Link: https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/
- Published: 2024-05-10T20:29:47+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Challenge against the confirmation of conviction by the Hon’ble High Court under NDPS Act](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#challenge-against-the-confirmation-of-conviction-by-the-honble-high-court-under-ndps-act)
 * [Information based on secret information and secret informer](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#information-based-on-secret-information-and-secret-informer)
 * [Charges, Trial and conviction](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#charges-trial-and-conviction)
 * [Appeal rejected by High court](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#appeal-rejected-by-high-court)
 * [Panch witness was serving in the Income tax department and hence independent panch witness was associated in the search and seizure procedure](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#panch-witness-was-serving-in-the-income-tax-department-and-hence-independent-panch-witness-was-associated-in-the-search-and-seizure-procedure)
 * [Section 43 NDPS Act would apply only when the search and seizure effected from a public place](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#section-43-ndps-act-would-apply-only-when-the-search-and-seizure-effected-from-a-public-place)
 * [No requirement to act under section 50 of NDPS Act since the polythene bag was held by the appellant](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#no-requirement-to-act-under-section-50-of-ndps-act-since-the-polythene-bag-was-held-by-the-appellant)
 * [CRCL report is admissible under section 293 crpc](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#crcl-report-is-admissible-under-section-293-crpc)
 * [Statement recorded under section 67 of NDPS Act is hit under Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india)
 * [Confessional statement is not admissible in evidence as per Tofan Singh](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#confessional-statement-is-not-admissible-in-evidence-as-per-tofan-singh)
 * [First time identification of witness is dubitable and not corroborated with any independent evidence](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#first-time-identification-of-witness-is-dubitable-and-not-corroborated-with-any-independent-evidence)
 * [Order](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#order)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#party)
 * [Further study](https://section1.in/ndps-act-confession-statement-statement-recorded-under-section-67-of-ndps-act-is-hit-under-article-203-of-the-constitution-of-india/#further-study)

 

##### **Challenge against the confirmation of conviction by the Hon’ble High Court under NDPS Act**

1. These two appeals arise out of a common judgment dated 30^(th) November, 2009
rendered by the Division Bench of the High Court of Gujarat whereby Criminal Appeal
Nos. 1865 of 2006 and 1866 of 2006 preferred by the appellants herein i.e. Anwarkhan
Jahilkhan Pathan and Firdoskhan Khurshidkhan Pathan, respectively were dismissed.
By way of the said appeals, the appellants herein had assailed the judgment dated
6th June, 2006 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court,
Nadiad(hereinafter being referred to as the ‘trial Court’) in Special Case (NDPS)
No. 5 of 2003 convicting the appellants for the **[offences punishable under Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/custody-death-or-station-death-if-the-death-takes-place-inside-the-police-station-the-accused-persons-should-be-punished-for-the-offence-under-section-302-ipc/)**
21 read with Section 8(c) and Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic 
Substances Act, 1985(hereinafter being referred to as ‘NDPS Act’) and sentencing
them to undergo rigorous imprisonment for ten years and fine of Rs. 1 lakh each 
in default of payment of fine to undergo simple imprisonment for two years.

##### **Information based on secret information and secret informer**

2. Shri Deepak Pareek(PW-2) received a secret information at his office in the morning
of 30th January, 2003. The informer divulged that two persons would be delivering
contraband/illicit substance at the ST Bus Stand, Kheda between 4:30 pm and 5:00
pm. The secret information also contained the description of features of the suspects
and the clothes which they would be probably wearing. The information also provided
that the contraband substance had been received from one Adilkhan and that the miscreants
would be delivering it to a third person. Deepak Pareek(PW-2) jotted down the secret
information, translated and converted it into a typewritten script and forwarded
a copy thereof to his immediate superior officer.

3. Two panchas i.e. Manubhai(PW-1) and Amit R. Dantani were summoned to the NCB 
office, Ahmedabad where a preliminary panchnama taking their consent to participate
in the proceedings was drawn. Deepak Pareek(PW-2) accompanied with other NCB officials
and the panchas proceeded to ST Bus Stand, Kheda. The raiding party was divided 
into two groups. Upon reaching the bus stand at around 4:30 pm, they saw two persons,
whose description was matching with the secret information, sitting near the public
urinals of the bus stand. The officials observed that a bag was being held by one
of the two suspects who handed the same over to the other and proceeded towards 
the exit gate of the bus stand. One group of the raiding team cornered the person
who was holding the bag whereas, the second group followed the other person who 
was seen proceeding towards the exit gate of the bus stand. The first group after
disclosing their identity to the suspect who was holding the bag, made enquiry about
his identity and he gave out his name to be Anwarkhan(A-1). The second suspect, 
however, escaped from the spot and could not be apprehended by the group of officials
who went in his pursuit. The bag held by 4 Anwarkhan(A-1) was opened and two polythene
bags containing suspected contraband material were found therein. The contraband
substance was weighed at the bus stand and gross weight of the two polythene bags
came out to be 2kg and 30 grams. As the spot where the suspect and the contraband
were found was a busy public place, the NCB officers in order to avoid security 
issues thought it fit to move to the PWD Guest House adjacent to the bus stand for
carrying out the seizure, **[sampling and sealing procedure](http://localhost:8080/section1/procedure-sample-collection-assistant-director-has-no-power-to-seize-the-sample-of-meat-under-prevention-of-cow-slaughter-and-cattle-preservation-act-1964/).**
Accordingly, the team members along with the panchas, the suspect and the packet
of contraband, moved to the PWD Guest House. Three samples were collected from each
polythene bag and were sealed under the signatures of the panchas and the Intelligence
Officer(PW-2) of the NCB. The second/final part of the panchnama was drawn up and
completed at the PWD Guest House, Kheda. Summon under **[Section 67 of the NDPS Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/scope-of-section-52a-of-the-ndps-act-1985/)**
was issued to Anwarkhan(A-1) by Deepak Pareek(PW-2) which was duly received by him.
Statement of Anwarkhan(A-1) was recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act by Deepak
Pareek(PW-2) and thereafter, he was arrested.

4. Further, **[investigation was assigned to Intelligence Officer](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-cross-case-or-case-in-counter-the-i-o-has-to-file-both-the-final-reports-before-the-jurisdictional-magistrate/)**
Vikram Ratnu(PW-3). During investigation, information was received that the second
suspect who had escaped from the ST Bus Stand had been tracked down by the Madya
Pradesh Police. The Intelligence Officer Deepak Pareek(PW-2) claims to have proceeded
to Shah Jahan Pur Police Station, Madhya Pradesh where the second suspect was found
and identified to be Firdoskhan(A-2) who volunteered to come down to the Office 
of NCB, Ahmedabad for participating in investigation. Accordingly, Firdoskhan(A-
2) was brought to NCB Office, Ahmedabad by Deepak Pareek(PW-2) on 9th February, 
2003 where summon under Section 67 of the NDPS Act was served to him. Deepak Pareek(
PW-2) recorded the statement of Firdoskhan(A-2) under Section 67 of the NDPS Act
during the intervening night of 9th and 10th February, 2003 whereafter, Firdoskhan(
A-2) was also arrested in the present case.

##### **Charges, Trial and conviction**

7. Charges were framed against both the accused for the offences mentioned above
who abjured their guilt and claimed trial. The prosecution examined 4 witnesses 
and exhibited 38 documents to prove its case. The accused were questioned under 
Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973(hereinafter being referred to
as ‘CrPC’) upon which, they denied the allegations as appearing against them in 
the prosecution evidence and claimed to be innocent. After deliberating upon the
submissions advanced on behalf of the parties and upon analysing the evidence available
on record, the trial Court vide judgment dated 6th June, 2006 proceeded to convict
and sentence the appellants in the manner stated above.

##### **Appeal rejected by High court**

8. The appeals preferred by the appellants were rejected by the High Court of Gujarat
vide impugned judgment dated 30th November, 2009.

9. Since both the appeals arise out of a common judgment, they have been heard analogously
and are being decided together.

##### **Panch witness was serving in the Income tax department and hence independent panch witness was associated in the search and seizure procedure**

16. At the outset, we may note that the contention of learned counsel for the appellants
that the search and seizure was undertaken without associating an independent witness
is untenable on the face of record. Manubhai(PW-1), the _panch _witness associated
in the search and seizure proceedings was serving in the Income Tax Department and
hence by no stretch of imagination, can it be accepted that the witness was a stock
witness of the NCB or was an interested witness. Manubhai(PW-1) in his sworn testimony
proved the recovery _panchnama _(Exhibit P-30) and also fully supported the prosecution
case regarding the search and seizure of contraband effected from Anwarkhan(A-1).
Nothing significant could be elicited by the defence in the prolonged cross-examination
undertaken from Manubhai(PW-1) and hence, we have no hesitation in holding that 
the evidence of Manubhai(PW-1) being the _panch _witness associated in the search
and seizure effected from Anwarkhan(A-1) is reliable and trustworthy. Thus, it is
well established that independent _panch _witness was associated in the search and
seizure procedure.

##### **Section 43 NDPS Act would apply only when the search and seizure effected from a public place**

18. Section 42 of the NDPS Act deals with search and seizure from a building, conveyance
or enclosed place. When the search and seizure is effected from a public place, 
the provisions of **[Section 43 of the NDPS Act would apply and hence](http://localhost:8080/section1/kidnapping-except-kidnapping-prosecution-did-not-prove-the-demand-and-threat-hence-section-364a-ipc-would-not-attract/)**,
there is no merit in the contention of learned counsel for the appellants that non-
compliance of the requirement of Section 42(2) vitiates the search and seizure. 
Hence, the said contention is noted to be rejected.

##### **No requirement to act under section 50 of NDPS Act since the polythene bag was held by the appellant**

19. So far as the contention of learned counsel for the appellants that the search
and seizure proceedings are vitiated on account of the non-compliance of **[Section](http://localhost:8080/section1/initiation-of-criminal-proceeding-under-sections-138-141-n-i-act-is-covered-under-moratorium-provision-u-s-14-ibc/)**
50 of the NDPS Act is concerned, the same is also noted to be rejected because admittedly,
the seizure in this case was not effected during personal search of the appellant
Anwar Khan(A-1). Admittedly, the contraband was being carried in a polythene bag
held by the appellant Anwar Khan(A-1) in his hand and hence, there was no requirement
for the Seizure Officer to have acted under the provisions of Section 50 of the 
NDPS Act before conducting the search and seizure proceedings.

##### **CRCL report is admissible under section 293 crpc**

20. The CRCL report (Exhibit-62) admissible under Section 293 CrPC concludes that
sample packets A2 and B2 gave positive tests for presence of 8.4% and 7.9% of Diacetyl
Morphine, respectively. Thus, the fact regarding the seizure of contraband narcotic
drug, i.e., 14 heroin/brown sugar weighing 2 kgs and 30 grams from the possession
of Anwarkhan(A-1) has been duly established by the **[prosecution beyond all manner of doubt](http://localhost:8080/section1/appreciation-of-evidence-it-is-only-after-the-prosecution-discharges-its-initial-burden-beyond-all-reasonable-doubt-the-false-explanation-or-non-explanation-could-be-taken-into-consideration/)**.
The link evidence required to prove the sanctity of the sampling and transmission
of the samples to the Chemical Analyst is also sacrosanct. The search and seizure
procedure is free from all doubts

##### **Statement recorded under section 67 of NDPS Act is hit under Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India**

24. It is not in dispute that the appellant Firdoskhan(A-2) was not apprehended 
on the spot or at the time of seizure. On a perusal of the panchnama(Exhibit-30),
it is evident that Firdoskhan is not named therein. We find that even though Anwarkhan(
A-1) was present with the raiding team from 4.30 p.m onwards, no effort was made
by any of the NCB officials to make an inquiry from him regarding the identity of
his companion who allegedly fled away from the spot.

25. The name of Firdoskhan(A-2) cropped up for the first time in the statement of
Anwarkhan(A-1) recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act. However, we are duly satisfied
that the sequence in which the said statement came to be recorded completely discredits
the reliability thereof. Anwarkhan(A-1) was apprehended at the bus stand with the
packet of narcotic drug at around 4:30 p.m. His signatures had been taken on the
panchnama(Exhibit-30) prepared at 9:00 p.m. and thus, it does not stand to reason
that the Intelligence Officer would defer arresting Anwarkhan(A-1) to a later point
of time because, as per the arrest memo(Exhibit-43) his arrest is shown at 11:45
p.m. It seems that this deferment in formal arrest of Anwarkhan(A-1) was only shown
in papers so that the Intelligence Officer could record 16 the statement of Anwarkhan(
A-1) under Section 67 of the NDPS Act and avoid the same being hit by the rigours
of Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India.

##### **Confessional statement is not admissible in evidence as per Tofan Singh**

26. The admissibility of a confessional statement of the accused recorded under 
Section 67 of the NDPS Act was examined by this Court in the case of Tofan Singh(
supra) and it was laid down that such confessional statements are not admissible
in evidence.

27. Hence, the statement(Exhibit-42) of Anwarkhan(A-1) wherein he allegedly identified
the appellant Firdoskhan(A-2) as the person who had escaped from the spot cannot
be read in evidence against the appellant Firdoskhan(A-2) because the manner in 
which the said statement was recorded leaves much to be desired and creates a grave
doubt on the sanctity thereof, in addition to the same having rendered inadmissible
by virtue of Tofan Singh(supra).

28. The prosecution witness Deepak Pareek(PW-2) claimed that Firdoskhan(A-2) was
apprehended from Shah Jahan Pur Police Station, Madhya Pradesh. However, no document
pertaining to the apprehension/detention of appellant Firdoskhan(A-2) at the Shah
Jahan Pur Police Station was placed on record by the prosecution. Thus, the very
manner in which the said accused was apprehended and brought to the NCB Office at
Ahmedabad in the purported exercise of recording his statement under Section 67 
of the NDPS Act is full of doubt and creates grave suspicion. Even otherwise, the
confession of the accused recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act cannot be admitted
in evidence as a confession as had been held in the case of Tofan Singh(supra). 
Hence the confessional statement(Exhibit-42) does not lend any succour to the prosecution
in its quest to **[prove the charges against the accused](http://localhost:8080/section1/juvenile-justice-act-2015-though-offences-pocso-and-murder-have-been-proved-accused-acquitted-based-on-procedural-illegalities/)**
Firdoskhan(A-2).

##### **First time identification of witness is dubitable and not corroborated with any independent evidence**

30. In this background, we feel that the first time identification of Firdoskhan(
A-2) by Vikram Ratnu(PW-3) during his evidence in the Court recorded on 14th February,
2005 i.e. more than two years from the date of incident, is dubitable. The evidence
of Vikram Ratnu(PW-3) to the extent he claimed to have identified Firdoskhan(A-2)
is neither reliable nor it gets corroborated by any other independent evidence and
hence, his evidence deserves to be discarded to this extent.

31. There is no dispute that no contraband substance was recovered from the possession
of appellant Firdoskhan(A-2).

32. Resultantly, the conviction of Firdoskhan(A-2) as recorded by the trial Court
and affirmed by the High Court cannot be sustained and he deserves to be acquitted
by giving him the benefit of doubt.

##### **Order**

33. As a conse**quence of the above discussion, the following order is passed: –**

> **(a) Cri**minal Appeal No. 2045 of 2010 filed by appellant Anwarkhan(A-1) lacks
> merit and is hereby dismissed. He is on bail. His bail bonds are cancelled. He
> shall **[surrender before the trial](http://localhost:8080/section1/guidelines-if-surrender-of-proof-not-provided-then-the-registry-may-call-for-report-from-the-trial-judge/)**
> Court within 30 days to serve the remaining part of sentence failing which the
> trial Court shall take steps to apprehend the accused and make him serve out the
> remaining sentence.
> (b) Criminal Appeal No. 2044 of 2010 preferred by appellant Firdoskhan(A-2) is
> allowed. His conviction as recorded by the trial Court vide judgment dated 6th
> June, 2006 and affirmed by the High Court vide judgment dated 30th November, 2009
> is quashed and set aside. He is acquitted of all the charges. He is on bail and
> need not surrender. His bail bonds stand discharged. 34. Pending application(s),
> if any, shall stand disposed of

##### **Party**

Firdoskhan Khurshidkhan  -Versus- The State Of Gujarat & Anr – Criminal Appeal No(
S). 2044 Of 2010 With Criminal Appeal No(S). 2045 Of 2010 – Dated On 30th April,
2024.

**[https://webapi.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2010/13961/13961_2010_3_1503_52759_Judgement_30-Apr-2024.pdf](https://webapi.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2010/13961/13961_2010_3_1503_52759_Judgement_30-Apr-2024.pdf)**

**[Firdoskhan-VS-The-State-Of-Gujarat-2024-Apr](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Firdoskhan-VS-The-State-Of-Gujarat-2024-Apr.pdf)**

##### Further study

 * **[SECTION 308 IPC MODIFIED INTO SECTION 338 IPC](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-308-ipc-modified-into-section-338-ipc/)**
 * **[NDPS: Confession: Explained](http://localhost:8080/section1/ndps-confession-explained/)**
 * **[IN NPDS CASES CONFESSION IS HIT UNDER SECTION 25 INDIAN EVIDENCE ACT.](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/)**
 * **[Section 451 / 457 Cr.P.C: Return of Property: There is no bar to release the property in NDPS Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-451-457-cr-p-c-return-of-property-there-is-no-bar-to-release-the-property-in-ndps-act/)**
 * **[OMISSION TO TAKE PHOTOGRAPH OF VEHICLE BY THE I.O IS NOT FATAL IN TNPPDL ACT](http://localhost:8080/section1/omission-to-take-photograph-of-vehicle-by-the-i-o-is-not-fatal-in-tnppdl-act/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
