# No provision for interim bail under law and is not permissible for the purposes of contesting elections much less for campaigning

- Link: https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/
- Published: 2025-01-23T14:45:23+00:00
- Author: lawsection

Contents

    - [Petition is in custody](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#petition-is-in-custody)
    - [Petitioner is participating bail remaining behind the bars](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#petitioner-is-participating-bail-remaining-behind-the-bars)
    - [Interim bail moved was disallowed by Hon’ble High Court but granted conditional custody parole](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#interim-bail-moved-was-disallowed-by-honble-high-court-but-granted-conditional-custody-parole)
    - [Appeal against custody parole granted](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#appeal-against-custody-parole-granted)
    - [Right to campaign or canvass is neither a fundamental right nor a constitutional right](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#right-to-campaign-or-canvass-is-neither-a-fundamental-right-nor-a-constitutional-right)
    - [No provision for interim bail under law](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law)
    - [Reasons for granting interim bail discussed](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#reasons-for-granting-interim-bail-discussed)
    - [Allowing accused in interim bail to canvas or to contest in election would be in conflict with provision section 62(5) Representation of People Act, 1951](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#allowing-accused-in-interim-bail-to-canvas-or-to-contest-in-election-would-be-in-conflict-with-provision-section-625-representation-of-people-act-1951)
    - [There are many ways to canvassing election without appearing](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#there-are-many-ways-to-canvassing-election-without-appearing)
    - [Accused who are in custody and undertrial even granted bail be restricted](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#accused-who-are-in-custody-and-undertrial-even-granted-bail-be-restricted)
    - [His Lordship Mr. Justice AHSANUDDIN AMANULLAH, J](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#his-lordship-mr-justice-ahsanuddin-amanullah-j)
 * [Analysis, reasoning and conclusion](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#analysis-reasoning-and-conclusion)
    - [Sequel](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#sequel)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/no-provision-for-interim-bail-under-law-and-is-not-permissible-for-the-purposes-of-contesting-elections-much-less-for-campaigning/#party)

**His Lordship Mr. Justice PANKAJ MITHAL, J.**

##### **Petition is in custody**

2. The petitioner is in custody in connection with FIR No. 65 of 2020 dated 26.02.2020
registered at Police Station Dayalpur, District North East, Delhi in connection 
with rioting and murder of one Ankit Sharma, an official of the Intelligence Bureau,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. Apart from the aforesaid case, several
other cases relating to riots in Delhi which took place in the month of February,
2020 and one under PMLA are pending consideration and the petitioner is allegedly
involved in all of them.

##### **Petitioner is participating bail remaining behind the bars**

3. The petitioner so far has not been successful in getting bail in the above case
and some other cases, so he applied to the High Court for grant of interim bail 
from 14.01.2025 to 09.02.2025 simply to participate and contest Delhi Assembly Election,
2025 from Mustafabad Constituency, Delhi. It may be remembered that the petitioner
was earlier a councilor from the ticket of the Aam Aadmi Party. However, subsequently
he left the said party and was given ticket to contest the Assembly Elections by
the All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM). He took the ticket to contest
the Assembly Elections fully knowing that he is in jail in connection with several
cases in some of which he may have been granted bail but continues to languish therein
and so he has to participate in the election remaining behind the bars.

##### **Interim bail moved was disallowed by Hon’ble High Court but granted conditional custody parole**

4. The interim bail application moved by the petitioner was considered by the High
Court and was ultimately disallowed by the order impugned dated 14.01.2025 but he
was granted conditional custody parole for subscribing oath and to complete formalities
in respect of filing his nomination papers to contest the Assembly Elections. In
this way, though the petitioner has no fundamental right to contest the elections
but his statutory right to that effect was duly protected.

##### **Appeal against custody parole granted**

5. The petitioner is not satisfied by the grant of custody parole for filing his
nomination enabling him to participate in the election and has thus preferred this
Special Leave Petition contending inter alia that permitting filing of nomination
is meaningless if he is not allowed to campaign and canvass.

##### **Right to campaign or canvass is neither a fundamental right nor a constitutional right**

6. It is important to note here that right to campaign or canvass is neither a fundamental
right nor a constitutional or a human right. It is not even a right recognized under
any statute. However, the petitioner is an Indian citizen and we are conscious that
his rights as a citizen are to be protected. Nonetheless, the involvement of the
petitioner in as many as eleven cases including the present one, one pertaining 
to PMLA and nine in relation to Delhi riots of 2020, dilutes and erodes his position
as a law-abiding citizen.

##### **No provision for interim bail under law**

9. There is no provision for interim bail under the law but lately it has become
an acceptable mode of grant of bail in certain special contingencies.

10. In **Arvind Kejriwal vs. Directorate of Enforcement [(2024) 9 SCC 577]** this
Court quoted with approval from **Athar Pervez [2016 SCC OnLine Del 6662] case which
reads as under:**

“20. The expression “interim” bail is not defined in the Code. It is an innovation
by legal neologism which has gained acceptance and recognition. The terms, “interim”
bail/”interim” suspension of sentence, have been used and accepted as part of legal
vocabulary and are well- known expressions. The said terms are used in contradistinction
and to distinguish release on regular bail during pendency of trial or appeal till
final adjudication. Applications for “interim” suspension or bail are primarily 
moved and prayed for, when the accused or convict is not entitled to or cannot be
granted regular bail or suspension of sentence, or the application for grant of 
regular bail is pending consideration and is yet to be decided. “Interim” bail entailing
temporary release can be granted under compelling circumstances and grounds, even
when regular bail would not be justified. Intolerable grief and suffering in the
given facts, may justify temporary release, even when regular bail is not warranted.
Such situations are not difficult to recount, though making a catalogue would be
an unnecessary exercise.”

##### **Reasons for granting interim bail discussed**

11. The reasons and factors whereunder interim bail may be permitted may include
cases where there is death in the family of the accused and the cremation has to
take place; to attend the wedding of son/daughter or of any close relative of the
accused but such a right has not been recognized on the plea of contesting or canvassing
for the election.

##### **Allowing accused in interim bail to canvas or to contest in election would be in conflict with provision section 62(5) Representation of People Act, 1951**

12. In the event interim bail is made permissible on the ground of contesting elections,
it will open a Pandora’s box inasmuch as in this country election in some form takes
place throughout the year and the accused persons in jail may take undue benefit
of it and even if they are not serious in contesting elections, they would move 
interim bail application for the purposes of participating in the election knowing
fully well they are likely to lose or are not serious contenders. This will open
a flood gate of litigation which ought not to be permitted so as to widen the scope
of grant of interim bail, more particularly when the regular bail application is
pending consideration.

13. Secondly, if right to participate, canvassing and contesting in election is 
allowed to be treated as a ground for interim bail, then the necessary sequel of
the same would be that the accused person ought to be allowed to vote in the election
as well. Such a sequel would be in conflict with the provision Section 62(5) of 
the Representation of People Act, 1951 which circumscribe the right to vote by laying
down that no person shall vote in any election, if he is confined in a prison or
is in lawful custody of the police. The grant of interim bail for contesting elections
would mean permitting the accused to cast his/her vote, which would be antithesis
to the provisions of Section 62(5) of the Representation of People Act, 1951.

##### **There are many ways to canvassing election without appearing**

16. Canvassing in an election can be done in many ways such as through newspapers,
social media, pamphlets, writing letters and it is not necessary that it should 
be in the physical form such as by holding meetings and by personal contact. Permitting
the petitioner to be released on interim bail for the purpose of canvassing would
amount to permitting the petitioner to hold meetings and to undertake door to door
canvassing. This would necessarily involve interaction of the petitioner with the
people of the locality on personal basis. Since, the incident mentioned in the FIR
took place in the locality from where the petitioner is contesting, if the petitioner
is permitted to move around freely, there is a very high possibility of his tampering
with the witnesses who are or local people living in that locality alone.

##### **Accused who are in custody and undertrial even granted bail be restricted**

21. It is high time that the citizens of India deserve a clean India, which means
clean politics as well and for the said purpose, it is necessary that people with
tainted image, especially those who are in custody and had not been granted bail
and those who are undertrial, even if out of jail, be restricted in some way or 
the other from participating in the election. The people of India should be given
a choice to elect people with clean image and antecedents.

22. In the case at hand, as stated earlier, the Court is confined as to whether 
interim bail for the purposes of election ought to be allowed or not. The petitioner,
on the ground of his long custody or the trial not being completed for long, may
argue for regular bail but that is not the subject-matter for consideration before
this Court today. We do not intend to usurp the jurisdiction of the High Court, 
where the regular bail of the petitioner is pending consideration.

24. In simple words, interim bail is not permissible for the purposes of contesting
elections, much less for campaigning.

25. In this view of the matter no case is made out for any indulgence in exercise
of discretionary power of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of India
and the Special Leave Petition is dismissed with liberty to the petitioner to pursue
his regular bail application before the High Court where he may seek an advancement
of the date of hearing fixed in the matter concerned, if so advised. 26. The Special
Leave Petition is dismissed as aforesaid.

##### **His Lordship Mr. Justice AHSANUDDIN AMANULLAH, J [dissenting]**

1. With great reverence for the erudite opinion expressed by learned Brother Pankaj
Mithal, J., I express my inability to concur therewith.

2. The factual matrix has been noted by Brother Mithal. I see no need to repeat 
the same, except to refer thereto where required.

7. I consciously refrain from discussing in detail the evidence or my view thereon,
following, inter alia, Niranjan Singh v Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, (1980) 2 SCC 
559; Vilas Pandurang Pawar v State of Maharashtra, (2012) 8 SCC 795, and; Manik 
Madhukar Sarve v Vitthal Damuji Meher, (2024) 10 SCC 753. However, in view of the
elaborate submissions advanced at the Bar, reference somewhat to the materials on
record is necessitated.

#### **Analysis, reasoning and conclusion**

26. The law, as it stands today, is that merely because a statute imposes limitations
on grant of bail, the same would not per se oust the jurisdiction of a Constitutional
Court to grant bail, as held in Union of India v K A Najeeb, (2021) 3 SCC 713. Pertinently,
Najeeb (supra), rendered by a Bench of 3-Judges, was distinguished by a 2-Judge 
Bench in Gurwinder Singh v State of Punjab, (2024) 5 SCC 403. However, in the Review
Petition preferred thereagainst viz. Gurwinder Singh v State of Punjab, 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 1777, the 2-Judge Bench clarified, while dismissing the Review Petition,
that ‘our decision is to be construed on the facts dealt with by us.’ This apart,
the exposition in Najeeb (supra) has been reiterated by another 2-Judge Bench in
Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh v State of Maharashtra, (2024) 9 SCC 813 and Sheikh Javed
Iqbal v State of Uttar Pradesh, (2024) 8 SCC 293.

##### **Sequel**

33. The grant of interim bail vide the present Judgment is not to be treated as 
a conclusive opinion on the merits of the underlying bail application or the main
case before the Trial Court, lest it prejudice either side.

34. Learned Brother Mithal has rightly opined that a Pandora’s Box cannot be permitted
to be opened by letting a horde of convicts and/or undertrial prisoners seek release
for the purpose of trying their luck at the electoral hustings. Likewise, the learned
ASG’s apprehension that others, whether similarly situated or not, may seek to (
mis)use this Judgment, is not unjustified.

35. I would therefore, necessarily, insert the caveat that this Judgment has been
passed in facts and circumstances specific to this case. Were any litigant, in futuro,
to cite this in a later case, I am sure the Court concerned would examine such case
on its merits and on its own factual prism. When any court is called upon to apply
and/or follow precedent, it is for that court to examine whether or not the precedent
is attracted in that particular case. It would not be out of place to recall the
following passage from **Sanjay Dubey v State of Madhya Pradesh, 2023 SCC OnLine
SC 610**:

‘18. … Yet, as our discussions in the preceding paragraphs display, the same are
inapplicable to the extant factual matrix. It is too well-settled that judgments
are not to be read as Euclid’s theorems; they are not to be construed as statutes,
and; specific cases are authorities only for what they actually decide. We do not
want to be verbose in reproducing the relevant paragraphs but deem it proper to 
indicate some authorities on this point – Sreenivasa General Traders v. State of
Andhra Pradesh, (1983) 4 SCC 353 and Amar Nath Om Prakash v. State of Punjab, (1985)
1 SCC 345 – which have been reiterated, inter alia, in BGS SGS Soma JV v. NHPC Limited,(
2020) 4 SCC 234 , and Chintels India Limited v. Bhayana Builders Private Limited,(
2021) 4 SCC 602.’ (emphasis supplied)

#### **Party**

Mohd. Tahir Hussain Petitioner(S) versus State of Nct of Delhi Respondent(S) – Extra
Ordinary Jurisdiction Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 856/2025 – 2025 INSC
100 – JANUARY 22, 2025 – PANKAJ MITHAL J. AHSANUDDIN AMANULLAH [Bench dissents].

[Mohd. Tahir Hussain vs. State of NCT of Delhi 27912025_2025-01-22](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Mohd.-Tahir-Hussain-vs.-State-of-NCT-of-Delhi-27912025_2025-01-22.pdf)
[Download](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Mohd.-Tahir-Hussain-vs.-State-of-NCT-of-Delhi-27912025_2025-01-22.pdf)

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
