# Objection shall be decided then and there

- Link: https://section1.in/objection-shall-be-decided-then-and-there/
- Published: 2023-02-07T05:01:11+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Further study](https://section1.in/objection-shall-be-decided-then-and-there/#further-study)

12. It was pointed out by learned amici that the practice adopted predominantly 
in all trials is guided by the decision of this court in **Bipin Shantilal Panchal
v. State of Gujarat – (2001) 3 SCC 1** with respect to objections regarding questions
to be put to witnesses. This court had termed the practice of deciding the objections,
immediately as “archaic” and indicated what it felt was an appropriate course:

> “It is an archaic practice that during the evidence collecting stage, whenever
> any objection is raised regarding admissibility of any material in evidence the
> court does not proceed further without passing order on such objection. But the
> fall out of the above practice is this: Suppose the **[trial court](http://localhost:8080/section1/reversal-of-acquittal-appellate-court-cannot-reverse-the-acquittal-on-fresh-appreciation-of-evidence-and-without-recording-any-illegality-error-of-law-or-of-fact-in-the-trial-court-judgment/)**,
> in a case, upholds a particular objection and excludes the material from being
> admitted in evidence and then proceeds with the trial and disposes of the case
> finally. If the appellate or revisional court, when the same question is re-canvassed,
> could take a different view on the admissibility of that material in such **[cases the appellate court](http://localhost:8080/section1/section-482-crpc-only-high-court-has-the-power-to-direct-to-run-sentences-in-two-different-cases-concurrently/)**
> would be deprived of the benefit of that evidence, because that was not put on
> record by the trial court. In such a situation the higher court may have to send
> the case back to the trial court for recording that evidence and then to dispose
> of the case afresh. Why should the trial prolong like that unnecessarily on account
> of practices created by ourselves. Such practices, when realised through the course
> of long period to be hindrances which impede steady and swift progress of trial
> proceedings, must be recast or re-moulded to give way for better substitutes which
> would help acceleration of trial proceedings.
> When so recast, the practice which can be a better substitute is this: Whenever
> an objection is raised during evidence taking stage regarding the admissibility
> of any material or item of oral evidence the trial court can make a **[note](http://localhost:8080/section1/understanding-the-police-report-investigation-and-magistrates-duties-in-criminal-cases/)**
> of such objection and mark the objected document tentatively as an exhibit in 
> the case (or record the objected part of the oral evidence) subject to such objections
> to be decided at the last stage in the final judgment. If the court finds at the**
> [final](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-cannot-return-final-report/) **stage
> that the objection so raised is sustainable the judge or magistrate can keep such
> evidence excluded from consideration. In our view there is no illegality in adopting
> such a course. (However, we make it clear that if the objection relates to deficiency
> of stamp duty of a document the court has to decide the objection before proceeding
> further. For all other objections the [**procedure suggested above can be followed**.](http://localhost:8080/section1/court-cannot-convert-complaint-into-a-1563-cr-p-c-petition-without-following-procedures/))
> The above procedure, if followed, will have two advantages. First is that the 
> time in the trial court, during evidence taking stage, would not be wasted on 
> account of raising such **[objections and the court can continue to examine the witnesses](http://localhost:8080/section1/when-chief-examination-of-prosecution-witness-is-being-recorded-presence-of-accused-advocate-is-required-to-object-to-a-leading-or-irrelevant-question-being-asked-to-the-witness/).**
> The witnesses need not wait for long hours, if not days. Second is that the superior
> court, when the same objection is re-canvassed and reconsidered in appeal or revision
> against the final judgment of the trial court, can determine the correctness of
> the view taken by the trial court regarding that objection, without bothering 
> to remit the case to the trial court again for fresh disposal. We may also point
> out that this measure would not cause any prejudice to the parties to the litigation
> and would not add to their misery or expenses.”

13. It was argued by _amici_ that the procedure, whereby the courts record answers
to all questions, regardless of objections, leads to prolonged and lengthy cross
examination, and more often than not, irrelevant facts having no bearing on the 
charge or the role of the accused, are brought on record, which often result in 
great prejudice. It is pointed out that due to the practice mandated in _Bipin Shantilal
Panchal (supra)_, such material not only enters the record, but even causes prejudice,
which is greatly multiplied when the appellate court has to decide the issue. Frequently,
given that trials are prolonged, the trial courts do not decide upon these objections
at the final stage, as neither counsel addresses arguments. Therefore, it is submitted
that the rule in _Bipin Shantilal Panchal (supra)_ requires reconsideration.

14. During a trial, in terms of Section 132, every witness is bound to answer the
questions she or he is asked; however, that is subject to the caveat that he or 
she is entitled to claim silence, if the answers incriminate him or her, by virtue
of Article 20 (3) of the Constitution. Every judge who presides over a criminal 
trial, has the authority and duty to decide on the validity or relevance of questions
asked of witnesses. This is to be found in Section 148 Cr. PC, which reads as follows:

> “148. Court to decide when question shall be asked and when witness compelled 
> to answer. –– If any such question relates to a matter not relevant to the suit
> or proceeding, except in so far as it affects the credit of the witness by injuring
> his character, the Court shall decide whether or not the witness shall be compelled
> to answer it, and may, if it thinks fit, warn the witness that he is not obliged
> to answer it.
> In exercising its discretion, the Court shall have regard to the following considerations:––
> (1) such questions are proper if they are of such a nature that the truth of the
> imputation conveyed by them would seriously affect the opinion of the Court as
> to the credibility of the witness on the matter to which he testifies;
> (2) such questions are improper if the imputation which they convey relates to
> matters so remote in time, or of such a character, that the truth of the imputation
> would not affect, or would affect in a slight degree, the opinion of the Court
> as to the credibility of the witness on the matter to which he testifies;
> (3) such questions are improper if there is a great disproportion between the 
> importance of the imputation made against the witness’s character and the importance
> of his evidence;
> (4) the Court may, if it sees fit, draw, from the witness’s refusal to answer,
> the inference that the answer if given would be unfavourable”.

15. Apart from Section 148, there are other provisions of the **[Evidence Act](http://localhost:8080/section1/in-npds-cases-confession-is-hit-under-section-25-indian-evidence-act/)**(
Sections 149-154) which define the ground rules for cross examination. During questioning,
no doubt, the counsel for the party seeking cross examination has considerable leeway;
cross examination is not confined to matters in issue, but extends to all relevant
facts. However, if the court is not empowered to rule, during the proceeding, whether
a line of questioning is relevant, the danger lies in irrelevant, vague and speculative
answers entering the record. Further, based on the answers to what (subsequently
turn out to be irrelevant, vague or otherwise impermissible questions) more questions
might be asked and answered. If this process were to be repeated in case of most
witnesses, the record would be cluttered with a jumble of irrelevant details, which
at best can be distracting, and at worst, prejudicial to the accused. Therefore,
this court is of opinion that the view in Bipin Shantilal Panchal should not be 
considered as binding. The presiding officer therefore, should decide objections
to questions, during the course of the proceeding, or failing it at the end of the
deposition of the concerned witness. This will result in decluttering the record,
and, what is more, also have a salutary effect of preventing frivolous objections.
In given cases, if the court is of the opinion that repeated objections have been
taken, the remedy of costs, depending on the nature of obstruction, and the proclivity
of the line of questioning, may be resorted to. **Accordingly, the practice mandated
in Bipin Shantilal Panchal shall stand modified in the above terms.**

**PARTY**: IN RE: TO ISSUE CERTAIN **[GUIDELINES REGARDING INADEQUACIES AND DEFICIENCIES IN CRIMINAL TRIALS](http://localhost:8080/section1/suo-moto-guidelines-common-practice-and-procedure-in-criminal-trials-all-over-india/)**
vs THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH & ORS – April 20, 2021 (3 judge bench).

**[https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/9999/9999_2017_31_1504_27750_Judgement_20-Apr-2021.pdf](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2017/9999/9999_2017_31_1504_27750_Judgement_20-Apr-2021.pdf)**

**[In-re-To-issue-certain-guidelines-regarding-inadequacies-and-deficiencies-in-criminal-trials-vs.-The-state-of-Andra-Pradesh](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/In-re-To-issue-certain-guidelines-regarding-inadequacies-and-deficiencies-in-criminal-trials-vs.-The-state-of-Andra-Pradesh.pdf)**

##### Further study

 * **[Apex court’s direction as to amendment in criminal rules of practice, 2019 and subsequent compliance by the Madras High court](http://localhost:8080/section1/suo-moto-guidelines-common-practice-and-procedure-in-criminal-trials-all-over-india/)**
 * **[When chief-examination of Prosecution witness is being recorded presence of accused advocate is required to object to a leading or irrelevant question being asked to the witness](http://localhost:8080/section1/when-chief-examination-of-prosecution-witness-is-being-recorded-presence-of-accused-advocate-is-required-to-object-to-a-leading-or-irrelevant-question-being-asked-to-the-witness/)**
 * **[Protest petition & cognizance: Cognizance taken on the further investigation petition filed under section 173(8) Cr.P.C as protest petition is correct](http://localhost:8080/section1/cognizance-taken-on-the-further-investigation-petition-filed-u-s-1738-cr-p-c-as-protest-petition-is-correct/)**
 * **[SUCCESSFUL PROSECUTIONS – A FEW IDEAS ](http://localhost:8080/section1/successful-prosecutions-a-few-ideas/)**
 * **[Class – Cr.P.C – Criminal Revision](http://localhost:8080/section1/class-cr-p-c-criminal-revision/)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
