# Official witnesses can nay be discarded simply because independent witnesses were not examined

- Link: https://section1.in/official-witnesses-can-nay-be-discarded-simply-because-independent-witnesses-were-not-examined/
- Published: 2023-08-17T14:23:43+00:00
- Author: Ramprakash Rajagopal

Contents

 * [Background of the appeal](https://section1.in/official-witnesses-can-nay-be-discarded-simply-because-independent-witnesses-were-not-examined/#background-of-the-appeal)
 * [Grounds on challenge](https://section1.in/official-witnesses-can-nay-be-discarded-simply-because-independent-witnesses-were-not-examined/#grounds-on-challenge)
 * [There is no bar to investigate the offence by the same officer who received the information](https://section1.in/official-witnesses-can-nay-be-discarded-simply-because-independent-witnesses-were-not-examined/#there-is-no-bar-to-investigate-the-offence-by-the-same-officer-who-received-the-information)
 * [Party](https://section1.in/official-witnesses-can-nay-be-discarded-simply-because-independent-witnesses-were-not-examined/#party)

##### **Background of the appeal**

1. This appeal is at the instance of the Accused-Appellant namely, Sathyan against
the order and judgement dated 5th September, 2019 passed by the High Court of Kerala
at Ernakulam in Criminal Appeal No. 2822 of 20081, wherein his prayer to set aside
the conviction in S.C. No. 1140 of 2006 under Section 8 of the Abkari Act, was denied
and the findings returned by 1 Hereinafter referred to as the “impugned judgement”
2 Additional District & Sessions Judge, Fast Track (Ad Hoc-11), Kozhikode, in judgment
dated 3rd November, 2008, were endorsed.

##### **Grounds on challenge**

12. The grounds of challenge, as urged by the Appellant are that in the absence 
of independent witnesses, the investigation cannot be sustained since the detecting
officer and investigator were both official witnesses; there is interpolation in
the Mahazar with respect to the quantity of the sample initially being written as
375 ML but then subsequently been corrected to 180 ML; there is unexplained delay
in production of the contraband before the trial court; the evidence of PW-2(C.K
Manoharan) clearly shows that he was not aware of the seizure and also that he was
not present at this spot; members of the patrol team were not made into witnesses;
independent witnesses who signed the Mahazar were not examined, et cetera.

13. The question that we must consider is whether the conviction, solely on the 
basis of official witnesses is sustainable in the present facts? And, whether the
delay of nearly 3 years in filing the challan can be said to be materially affecting
the correctness of the judgement of the lower court as also the judgement impugned
before us?

14. The trial court, when faced with this question of the conviction being based
solely on the testimony of official witnesses, referred to two judgements of this
court in Tahir v. State (Delhi) – (1996) 3 SCC 338 and Karamjiti Singh v. State (
Delhi Administration) – (2003) 5 SCC 291 to observe that, there is no bar on convictions
being based solely on the testimony of the police officials.

##### **There is no bar to investigate the offence by the same officer who received the information**

16. Therefore, it can no longer be said to be res integra that the person receiving
the information of the crime or detecting the occurrence thereof, can investigate
the same. Questioning such investigation on the basis of bias or such like factor,
would depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. It is not amenable to 
a general unqualified rule that lends itself to uniform application.

21. From the above discussion, it is clear that simply because the person who detected
the commission of the offence, is the one who filed the report or investigated, 
such an investigation cannot be said to be bad in law. That particular submission
therefore must necessarily be negatived. We also notice that, the judgement of the
trial court categorically records that the person conducting the investigation was
PW-4 and neither PW-1 nor PW-2, on whose testimonies the court has relied to hand
down a verdict of conviction. On that ground also, the submission of the Appellant,
must be negatived.
 22. Conviction being based solely on the evidence of police 
officials is no longer an issue on which the jury is out. In other words, the law
is well settled that if the evidence of such a police officer is found to be reliable,
trustworthy then basing the conviction thereupon, cannot be questioned, and the 
same shall stand on firm ground.

25. Recently, this Court in Mohd. Naushad v. State (NCT of Delhi13) had observed
that the testimonies of police witnesses, as well as pointing out memos do not stand
vitiated due to the absence of independent witnesses.

26. It is clear from the above propositions of law, as reproduced and referred to,
that the testimonies of official witnesses can nay be discarded simply because independent
witnesses were not examined. The correctness or authenticity is only to be doubted
on “any good reason” which, quite apparently is missing from the present case. No
reason is forthcoming on behalf of the Appellant to challenge the veracity of the
testimonies of PW – 1 and PW – 2, which the courts below have found absolutely to
be inspiring in confidence. Therefore, basing the conviction on the basis of testimony
of the police witnesses as undertaken by the trial court and is confirmed by the
High Court vide the impugned judgement, cannot be faulted with.

##### **Party**

Sathyan vs State of Kerala – Crl. Apl No: 2363 OF 2023 arising out of SLP (Crl.)
No. 9710/2023 – AUGUST 11, 2023;

[**https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/16317/16317_2022_11_1502_46028_Judgement_11-Aug-2023.pdf**](https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2022/16317/16317_2022_11_1502_46028_Judgement_11-Aug-2023.pdf)

**[Sathyan vs State of Kerala](http://localhost:8080/section1/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Sathyan-vs-State-of-Kerala.pdf)**

### Further Study

 No Related Posts Found.
